What’s interesting to me is Beyonce emotes better with runs than words. She evokes an emotion, paints the drama, and tells a story with the runs alone just like all Arabic singers/music. To me, Beyonce is the melisma queen not Mariah. Mariah’s runs aren’t as dramatic or emotional as Beyoncés. Beyonce definitely must have been from there in another life or maybe she has some distant Arabic ancestor via Spain/Iberian Peninsula . I hear her mother is from New Iberia Louisiana which is interesting
Whitney Houston é incomparável. Ninguém deveria cantar as músicas dela. Beyoncé que me desculpe mais Whitney canta muitoooooo mais do que qualquer uma.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
It irks to see comments here mentioning mariah and whitney like why’d u always have to bring other artists up when Beyonce is literally UP there. People always want to humble her for whatever irrelevant reasons. Like go somewhere and comment mariah somewhere nobody asked. BEYONCE IS A STAR RATED VOCALIST. PERIOD.
Beyonce stage presence , along with never finished, remains relevant with the Kulture , Hairstyles , Outfits , Body , Energetic, You must stay in the Game , Keep giving us more , Concert 3 hours long without long Periods of waiting !
This video made me actually like Beyonce less. I don't know... she doesn't do it for me. I get that she's well trained but when you are in the singing world... there are so many better. Whitney just has IT.
@@TheAvgWoman that’s not true. Those are versed in vocal pedagogy would that Beyonce has one of the best technique in the music industry. And there are plenty things she can do that others can’t do.
Beyonce deserves her recognition as one of the greatest vocalists of all time. People need to remember that when Beyonce is singing, she is usually dancing and energetically moving around the stage at the same. That is very difficult to do. Aretha, Whitney, Celine, Mariah, Adele etc are all usually standing still when they produce their best vocals. That's an easier thing to do. So, i think people need to give Beyonce her due. She's a fantastic vocalist. HOWEVER, if i was forced at gunpoint to choose who i rate as the best singer of all time..it would be Aretha, closely followed by Whitney. But Beyonce now deserves to be mentioned in that conversation
I honestly believe Beyoncé has a (far) superior technique to both Aretha and Whitney and I just truly hope as time goes on that she gets the respect she deserves!
exactly! Beyoncé has by a significant margin the superior technique between the two... a bigger range, way more agility, better breath support. the only thing (and it is subjective) that Whitney has over Bey is tone, and I still prefer Beyoncé's. (she might be a little louder too haha but that is hardly a good thing)
idk about all THAT. Whitney is better in my opinion. Beyonce uses a lot of reverb and actually lacks the agility and range of Whitney. Beyonce wouldn’t be able to pull off 12:25 as cleanly.
Impossible de comparer une Déesse comme Whitney H avec une élève studieuse comme Beyonce. C'est juste indécent. A croire que l'objectif est d'humilier cette femme agréable mais somme toute commune qu'est Beyonce. Une laborieuse mais pas unique. Je ne comprends même pas qu'on mette WH en parallèle, pas en comparaison car ce n'est même pas envisageable avec Bey. IMPOSSIBLE.
Most comments agree that Beyoncé was magnificent and the comparison was fair. It's you who is humiliating anyway with your ridiculous comment. Beyoncé is considered the eighth greatest vocalist in history. Who are you?
Whitney’s tone and emotion is what makes her so great. Beyoncé is amazing in her own right and technically, may be better than Whitney in some areas or at very least, equal. And she does this while dancing and performing….but where is something to be said for a voice that can stand flat footed and move your soul with tone and emotion alone. That goes to Whitney.
Whitney was train by the best her mother you get that kind of training in church you feel what your singing. Please stop comparing her voice to others. Whitney was the voice. R.I.P
