Research at the Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences at the University of Amsterdam address societal and human behaviour related themes, like the impact of new media on society, health care, urbanisation, human and child development, mental health, inequalities, democracy, diversity and social cohesion. We share our knowledge and present our researchers in various videos.
A key difference between the traditional roles of men and women is that men had the freedom and power to promote the idea that their role must be more important than that of women. Consequently, women were influenced to believe that their role were inferior and that they were being denied the opportunity to have the same prestigious and significant role as men. Paradoxically, this has led to a situation where women, in some ways, have contributed to the devaluation of their own traditional role while simultaneously elevating the traditional role of men. By doing so, women have inadvertently participated in helping men denigrate the importance and contribution of the traditional female role. As a result, many women have come to believe that the traditional male roles are indeed more important; women have let themselves be propagandized into betraying themselves.
There’s nothing with being a traditional wife….if she wants to do so. I support certain gender roles but not all. No matter your gender, if you can do the job without ruining the integrity of the standards, then go for it. The propaganda in this video is ridiculous. Apparently, those who feel comfortable being a traditional wife somehow affects those who wish not to be for some reason. I am not far right - whatever that means - but I am a traditional Conservative. However, I WANT to work and my husband doesn’t care. People can be whatever makes them happy. Stop making it something it’s not.
No science on here, even use prank/satire site as example of #tradife. Just opinion, opinion, opinion....and here's how it is dangerous. No one ever seems to discuss the challenges to men who CHOOSE to be the sole provider for their wife and children.
Don't take advice from an economist of a country whose economy is in shambles. Italy and many European countries have been degrowthing for decades. Their citizens are poorer than most poor US states. They voluntarily shut down their nuclear reactors while importing oil and gas even today. Their ideas are poison. They have not gotten over their depression post WW2.
@@uva-socialsciencesbehaviour I have watched a few of these as I'm always interested in different perspective on these topics. What data is being used to substantiate some of the information. On Violence Through Video Observations, I'm curious if there was any investigation into the family background of any of the people in the video observations?
What on earth. You're trying to make this a racial thing? Give me a break. How about it's simply healthiest to look after your own children. Or how about looking at the Bible?
I always find it so endearing when women discuss topics that they do not understand. They really do brainstorm to their maximum capacity about these things, yet, somehow, they mostly end up wrong anyway. Aside from that, have you guys noticed how it is often ugly women who have problems against femininity and masculinity?
I'm with the tradwives. My wife and I have lived this way for 16 years (13 with a son) and we're both very glad we did. As for misogyny, traditional husbands are expected to provide for, protect, love and honor their wives. And I would encourage people to court rather than just date. Ask the important questions right away, don't let yourself "fall in love" with someone who doesn't share your values or preferred lifestyle. If he adheres to traditional gender roles and norms as she does, there's no problem.
😂 this is so tone deaf. I am educated. My Father strongly encouraged his daughters to be educated and work. He was "far right". He was also a hardworking taxpayer. So i was shocked after hi ing birth and holding my new born baby that i didn't want to go back to work. I didnt want to leave my baby. I had been lied to. It was also overwhelming to be a mother, a worker, and a student. SHAME ON YOU. REPORTED.
Would never go study at this university after seeing this... They are saying far right Europe wants more white babies...?? Trad wife racial? What a scientific conclusions...(opinions)
Honestly can't decide if I hate this kind of stereotyping of women who stay home to raise their family, or the anti-women people who demand women stay home. Additionally, does ANYONE want to discuss the role of traditional family and childrens' outcomes?
very insightful and important research property ownership is a huge part of the rapidly increasing inequality - and resulting mass poverty, as well as state capture by the rich - and has to be studied and highlighted as such
I don't get it why people are so mad about this tradwife trend, if not for the fact that they cannot afford themselves to be one because for most people two-earner household is the norm. Both haters and promoters are kinda wrong here, haters because who are they to tell women how to live their life and decide what makes them happy, some women prefer being a tradwife. Promoters are in the wrong too because there is an inherent assumptions that all women used to be tradwifes which historically just isn't true, most women also had to work in traditional lifestyles too.
People are mad because what the tradwives influencers promote is a fantasy, not a reality for most homemakers. Some are straight dishonest about the their husbands being the sole breadwinners while they monetize their videos or how they do it all effortlessly by themselves while looking like they jumped out of a 50's movie. And what you say about the haters can also be said about the promoters. If you take a closer look, a lot of them have a "better than the rest" attitude or push some religious agenda.
Hella bias. Lacking understanding on how payment processors and basic legal information about credit cards. Read your blog. Clearly lacking basic knowledge of how social media platforms and automated moderation works. Everything I've read and heard about this research project is ill informed. What a mess.
there is nothing wrong with staying home and taking care of your family. I read somewhere that 40% of women in the United States do not return to work after having children because they prefer to stay home with their babies. trad wives was never a problem before…its just a problem when you see people becoming influencers over it. which honestly its not a problem….no one is talking about the phenomenon of makeup influencers or, gaming channels or those pranksters…honestly the pranking and challenges stuff is the real issue to society. not women making money off of social media baking and showing how they take care of their children.
1:50 The religious right have muddled the waters (typical m.o.) and effectively spread the narrative that feminists are mad that the women chose that lifestyle so you've missed a huge part of the push back. 1)It's how they are lying and pushing this propaganda about women being submissive and letting their man make the income as they are making money as an influencer. 2) They are well off and essentially supervise most of the stuff the average mother has to do. 3)They are using the Mormon baby voice. (many mormons have explained it). It's propaganda of the christo-facism worsening in America. It's interesting how what they do is effective in obfuscating the genuine issues especially to those who are on the outside looking in on America's dtysfunctioning systems.
@@everettbr @lovreM makes a legitimate point. These are just opinions of women whose values don't coincide with what they call "traditional gender roles." There is nothing scientific about it.
So I'm racist because my own country has a negative birth rate, and I understand that's a problem? Sense when it is racist to say that Western countries won't be around in 100, 200 years if we don't get our birth rates up. What the actual fuck. I have never seen something so politically charged as this. How about I just want a large family, Karen. And I hate litterly everyone in my life say that 3 children is alot. 🙄
Humanity is struggling so hard with practicality, oh man... !!!!... Why are people so obsessed with ideologies, why is everyone so busy looking for "the right thing to do"??? JUST BE PRACTICAL OMG !!!! Your lifestyle depends on soooo many aspects and factors, you all should simply observe your situation, talk about things and organize everything with yor family (nuclear and extended) and figure out your options, prospects and best possibilities, and take decisions, divide responsabilities and create systems to secure your lives... IT'S NOT THAT DIFFICULT FGS !!!!! (well, actually it is difficult sometimes but whatever, life is what it is)
It's not a rebellion against equality! If anything it is rebellion of "career woman" and trying to shake the SHAME women put on other women who don't put career over children. It is a normal response to harsh economic times when daycare breaks the bank. . .it isn't about serving men. It is about putting children first! It has also become a problem when women out earn men and men no longer feel they have a purpose. Letting the man be the breadwinner while a woman takes the setbacks of birth and breastfeeding is a natural occurrence for heterosexual couples even if a woman enjoys working. Isn't feminism about choice? So women should support other women who want to raise children. . . When you bring race into this you are ONLY looking at white people and disregarding trad wives of latin, indian, muslim traditions . . Wow this whole discussion is racist to disregard women of color who already assume the roles of home maker and childcare and don't advertise it on the internet because of traditions of modesty. You are saying only the right cares about raising their own children? And the left either don't have children or give their children to the state to raise? Yay girl boss? Neglect your children!
It definitely is a movement against equality coming from a place of privilege and naivity. A woman who is against financial independence is either a fraud or never needed a paycheck, both uncommon positions. It really is about men and their egos. Children are better adjusted with two parents and better funded on two incomes, they could benefit from 2 providers *and* 2 caregivers. Why refuse to grow and give your life a new meaning if not for egoistical reasons such as self-image, comfort zone, laziness? Natural occurence is families working together. Did you really think those sad factory children on old photos and in fields on oil paintings did work but their moms did not? Feminists know mothers are in crisis, but instead of increasing the pressure by leaving them dependent they think of shared payed parental leave, availability of part time job contracts for new parents and affordable daycare. If the family wants the one income model, financial investition from the husband to his wife's retirement and a family financial reserve in case of his inability to work is a must. That is a projection. It's right wing men who would rather have a person be permanently with their kids than to share childcare.
on your point about women of color…I am muslim and in the muslim community its actually uncommon for a woman to work after kids. or sometimes even after getting married. most muslim cultures prefer women to stay home and take care of the kids. being a homemaker is not a modern phenomenon. its as old as antiquity. women only worked outside of the home when they needed to and unfortunately in western cultures during victorian times that usually meant the husband was dead, and her and her kids ended up homeless and she took a job along with her kids in a workhouse. even before that if women did work it was like farm work…that was still considered home related work.
It definitely is a movement against equality coming from a place of privilege and naivity. A woman who is against financial independence is either a sellout or a kept human which only few can stomach. It really is about men and their egos because children are better adjusted with two parents and better funded on two incomes. But instead of being flexible like women in the roles of provider *and* caretaker, men refuse it for egoistical reasons such as self-image, comfort and laziness. Natural occurence is families working together. Did you think factory children on photos and on fields on oil paintings did work but their moms did not? Feminists are well aware that mothers are in crisis, but instead of a financial dependence at home they think shared payed parental leave, availability of part time job contracts for new parents and affordable daycare. If the family wants the one income model, financial investition from the husband to his wife's retirement and a family financial reserve in case of his inability to work is a must. That is a projection. It's right leaning men who would rather have their spouse be penniless and permanently at home than to share childcare.
@@hydratejsn wow i avoid men like that at all costs. Women who want to raise children can still work. . . No one said they don't work just because they put child rearing before career. In fact all the "trad wives" on social media who people are getting mad at, are in fact earning money via social media. This movement is coming from women not from alpha male podcasts (those men repel women). What year are you living in that men want women to not work? Or what extremely religious sect are you a part of? I agree with my muslim sister who said women STILL work farms, gardens, handcrafts. No one said they don't work. This culture HATES children and it is obvious by how this is turned into a battle of the sexes while we ignore child enrichment. . . That is why the world is messed up. People are so selfish.
Being feminine is awesome, caring about traditions is awesome, having equal rights is awesome. The problem comes from the online world which is full of lies/deceit and toxicity, bringing out the worst in humans, the narcissistic side under the pretext of "helping or teaching others". Wether it's online tradwifes or online feminist wifes, they're all living a life to impress others, which is quite sad and miserable.
Exactly. It is the internet echo chambers designed to make everyone angry and keep the eyeballs on the content, so that content creators can generate income for themselves, that cause the problem.
.... So... as a traditional house wife.. I can honestly say.. there are *zero* 'white babies' living under my roof... but I would also not automatically jump to 'they're trying to over populate and racially crush us' if my white neighbour had a kid... because that's literally crazy talk. 🤪
@@tonyanzalone384 that's a terrible sum up. they did not state trad roles are far right, just that they tend to overlap more with rightwing conservatism than with progressive thought. they also literally named the ambiguity between tradwife and feminism, that it can be explained multiple ways.
High dose of oral contraceptive pill for six months led to the formation of two golf ball sized DVTs (blood clots). One clot was in the left side of my neck and the other clot was in the left underarm area. My left arm was swollen twice the size when I woke up one morning. Hospital gave me subcutaneous (injection into fatty tissue) blood thinners. I was taking the blood thinner injection everyday for 2 years until the clots dissipated. I’m also a smoker and blood clots, heart attacks and strokes before age 30 are common on my mom’s side of my family. Now I know I can never go on hormonal birth control again without it likely causing another DVT.
The video starts of with a lie that is typical of feminists. We are not seeing a backlash against gender equality. What we are seeing is a backlash against feminist lies, gaslighting, and bigotry. Framing it as a backlash against bigotry is a typical feminist gaslighting tactic that has been used again and again and again.
Hello! I didn't quite understand why housewives are a new thing? It's a very interesting thing to hear for me as a westerner. Cuz for me it's a basic role for woman in families in most of cultures and any time🤔 Thank you for your content. I hope to see more! *subscribed*
The idea of women being confined solely to home duties is a recent development. Historically, only wealthy families could afford to have wives dedicated exclusively to household chores and childcare. Across the globe, women have traditionally engaged in physical labor alongside their husbands, such as working in fields and doing strenuous work. From where I come from, in less developed areas, women often work in fields alongside their husbands well into their senior years, in addition to managing domestic responsibilities.
