What if Saki Arima is arrested and imprisoned instead of dead? (AU) Time: A year after Kaori Miyazono's death. [Kōsei visits his mother Saki's prison cell.] Saki: What took you so long? I was dying to see you. Kōsei: Me, too. I really wanted to see you like this. Locked up in here. Completely and totally alone. Without a single friend remaining. No one to love you. Saki: You… really think I'll be here long? Kōsei: Of course I do. Even if you get out, you'll be so old… Saki: YOU BRAT! Guard #1: 3886, be quiet! Kōsei: After all this is done, whether I'm in the ground or not, I want your world to always have me in it. I want you to regret your life so much you can feel it. Deep in your bones. Saki: I'm sorry… that I didn't get away with it. Regret? You know… I should be asking you the same thing. Why would I? What do I have to regret? What then? Say it! *_WHAT DO I HAVE TO FUCKING REGRET???!!!_* Guard #1: 3886! Your visit's over! Kōsei: I regret everything that's happened. Just look. God has never been on my side. And all you get is prison? I have no choice but to hope this prison's your hell. All I can do is pray that you live a very long life in this hell, never knowing the truth about why you're here. Saki: What is it? Tell me, what don't I know?! Hey! Kōsei! [Guards start to drag her away] Saki (screaming at the top of her lungs): *_YOU BASTARD, I'M GONNA KILL YOU!!! I'M GONNA KILL YOU, YOU FUCKING BRAT!!! LET GO!!! LET GO!!! MOTHERFUCKER!!! I'M GONNA FIND YOU AND RIP YOUR FUCKING HEAD OFF!!!_* [Based on a dialogue from the Korean drama "The Glory".]
Let’s be real. When the mother it was the kids happiest moments. He may not have reacted like that but you can tell on how hurt he is by his mom’s abuse that she dying was the best thing that could happen to him. I don’t care that you were dying, I don’t care if you have mental illness, I don’t care if you were abused as a child as well. There’s no excuse for what you did, you scarred your son for life for no reasons, he was a piano genius and the best of the best, what more do you want? That “I wish you could die” was not from anger in the moments, it was the voice from his heart. And he did the right thing telling his mom that so she could die knowing her only child hated her. And what else to hate her for? Oh yeah, she never allowed him to socialize, all kids don’t like to socialize but he wanted to. Sh got mad at him for no reasons. She clearly took out her own grief of dying on him. She pushed her dreams on her son, what about your son’s dreams? It’s not his responsibility to pick up where you failed. It’s not his fault you failed in life and continues to fail, you are a terrible person, no one loves you and no one should, when you died so many people probably celebrated your death. I hope you regret all the things you done in the afterlife because that’s something you can never take back.
I remember a video called "Alternative Happy Ending - Your Lie in April" in which 50 years after Kaori's death, Arima got hit by a truck when he tried to save a black cat. He then goes to Heaven and sees both Kaori and his mom there. Considering the abuse she inflicted on him, I don't agree with it. I'm not saying the mother should be in Hell or shouldn't be in Heaven, I'm just saying in the afterlife she could do the least of never seeing him ever again.
Ngl i know what im about to say isn’t related to this scene but i hate it when abuse or s’a is used for comedy in anime and other shows/movies bc these topics are topics that aren’t supposed to be used as comedy
You already failed as a mother when all you care about is if he can use his “talent” to support himself one day when you’re already out of time. You failed, utterly, when all you did was place a curse on him with the precious time that you had left when what he needed the most was the memory that he was loved.
Saki was a horrible person. Her rationale is beating her son will make him better at the piano so he’ll be able to take care of himself once she’s gone? That is horseshit. That just means she had no faith in him to support himself through any other means. I bet she really just wanted to have someone else join in her suffering, and she used Kousei not playing piano well enough as an excuse to hurt him
Our class valedictorian got yelled at by her mom for not reaching nationals for tennis in front of the principals office only because she was sandwiched by both responsibilities as the editor in chief of the school papers while also competing for the schools quiz bee during finals week (the only time she's not excused for). You havent been in an asian household if you've never been treated like that. Its basically the most realistic part of the anime. Its raw and heartbreaking but its a reality for a lot of asian children which is the sad truth.
@@iridimus nah man I live in Bangladesh, a country in south asia Our parents are also greatly disappointed and they always tries to compare us to other children on a daily basis, they also beat us when we Don something wrong but when we reach home then she can abuse me to her will but humiliating and hitting infront of so many people its just disgusting and shouldn’t be seen as a realistic scene
@@__a-yn9ny just because it doesnt happen to you in public does not discredit the experience of other kids that happens to get abused out in the public
Dysfunctional family, his father also deal the same amount of misery in the family because he never present in Kousei's life whatsoever. If keeping a family is just about making money, drug dealer, mafia, corruptors are also a family man then..
I resonate a lot with Kousei. Only physically disciplined, but verbally abused all the time throughout my childhood. Even now, although my relationship with my mother has improved a lot, since I moved out. It's really a shame that parents like this have turned out like that, but it's a result of their own upbringing and experiences. Best we can do is to learn from it, and make sure to do better, when it comes to our own future children.
The cost of excellence is misery. If given a choice, almost no one would choose it. The best artists and those who do the best have, in general, had to put up with the worst circumstances.
No matter her reasoning, no matter her reasoning, it does not justify her actions. Even if she intended to push him so he can make it in the long term, removing the love only a mother can give a child and replacing it with abuse both physical and mental, whilst also stopping your child from having a healthy social life with other children is unforgivable. The right thing for the wrong reason or wrong thing for the right reason.
You know what worst than the mother? Its that alot of people who watched this JUSTIFY the mother because "She just wants the best for him" NOTHING justify beating especially YOUR OWN Child Even if the woman "feels bad", what she did has scars him for life and no much 'sorry' Will be able to heal that wound
Glad she perished….had no right to be a mother just to berate and beat your own child over some stupid piano. Nothing worse than a parent trying to force their child to be an exact copy of themselves or just as skilled as them as if they had a child for the full purpose of continuing their own dreams instead of letting their child follow their own!
Her son got beaten up to the pulp everyday for making a minor mistake yet still smiling hoping his piano play will cure his mom Imagine how shocked deep down for kousei's mom when he finally snapped and told her to just die, his mom had a good intention but she forced him too hard
This hit hard for me than the death of kaori, this scene resonated to me because, this is exactly what happen in my life, the difference is that it isn't about the piano, it's about my grades in school, the truth is I'm not an intelligent person, but I tried so hard to prove that i can reached higher grades, to get higher honors this includes doing some shady stuff such as cheating, initiating a massive silent cooperation, connection to intelligent students, infiltrating teachers office and many more, i did it because I wanted to proveto her that i am that kid, unfortunately throughout the duration of my school, I could only get at top 5 to 3 honor, those honors are nothing compared to being the top 1, but there was one moment where I was no honor at all, a failure as many may call it. And then this exact scene of this anime happen to me in real life, I was at grade 8 at that time, I failed mathematics, it was at home and then she throw the report card and bag at me and remove all notebooks. And then the exact dialogue was shared to each other, the only difference with our dialogue is that i didn't say i wanted her to die, i cried, she never see me cry, the only time she see me cry was probably when i was just a kid. I hide my emotions and feelings throughout my life because of a belief that no one would actually care, especially if boys cried, but when i was on my breaking point. I lash out like a crazy motherfucker who have lost all manners. And then just turns away as if I were a some kind of born out villain out of nowhere.
