list of inaccuracies/things i personally disagree with 0:00 no intro? :devastated: 2:57 i wanna say something about it, but i cant really describe why it feels slightly off to me 7:18 feel like the stutter couldve been a bit more jarring 7:28 the "WRONG WRONG WRONG" is barely audible 😔 7:30 i feel the entire piano is supposed to be doing the "Condemn him to the infirmary" bit, no chords or other things happening 8:30 "Struck by lightning" is supposed to go "G G G G" while the instruments/rest of the song goes up with its "G A A# B", creating dissonance 8:36 "I AM ME" is supposed to be "G# B C", not "A# B C" 😭 8:44 i feel like it shouldve been a low drum intro in a way i do not have the confidence to describe- but this also works tbf from 10:04 onwards its just missing most of the vocals/top hand :devastated: also i think the chords from 10:23 are slightly short? general things: tempo, not including it is fair, but its p easy to do considering you already have most of the song itself, you can just port the audio source file in and then alter the tempo automation thingies until it lines up, p convenient positive notes: i feel Heart Acoustic is slightly weak, but i love most of Mind Electric, and i also really love some of the parts in Soul Eclectic- its just a banger glad you did not cut out the Soul Eclectic intro, loads of other people seem to do that, even for just lyrics videos of the song :devastated: again, love the majority of this, very lovely to listen to, banger at times, and very cool that you went and made the entire thing, even if some parts are off/missing a bit
Appreciate the feedback! Yeah tbh I was lazy with The Heart Acoustic because I didn't really intend on making all 3 songs at first, I was just kinda messing around with time signatures in FL and I realized THA was in 3/4 lol. Also, when I was making this there were no MIDIs for THA or TSE [at least that I knew of] so I used a MIDI and the chords of the original TME for most of this, putting my own spin on it. For the parts added by Chonny, I pretty much winged it and that probably why it's off in some places. This whole thing was basically just me messing around, but I'm kinda proud of how it turned out and I'm glad that so many ppl enjoy it! I'm planning on **maybe** making a few more piano covers of songs, I will try and focus on the stuff you pointed out!
Oh my goodness. I don’t say this with a lot of instrumental songs on RU-vid, but this is something I would GENUINELY listen to. This is so good… I love how this sounds, and the lyrics you put are really interesting. Like, genuinely. This is so impressive!
this is very cool and i am very glad you released the FLP, going through it makes me tempted to try making it myself, might use this as a basis for some parts while some parts are slightly off, as a whole its p good and i really like some parts of it, very well done also not sure how you made this but it def seems to miss some small parts and general timings, i recommend bringing in the audio file itself as cross reference
i saw a vid of all 3 played overtop eachother, and i called it "The Whole Acloulctric", what would it be called in this context? The ??? Cleclectircal???
