Silman and dyas didn’t crash on Felucia but the moon orbiting obah dia pyke world. They brought dyas body to felucia to stage an accidental fatality there where the natives burned his body and silman who was told to dooku to have died was kept by pykes sad leverage
Nala the scientist isn’t working with the separatists she works for the republic but does not know dooku and Tyranus (as mentioned by kaminoans in attack of the clones), are the same person. She thinks it’s a Jedi with secretive orders initiated first by Siri days before he died to continue with syfos fail safe of inhibitor chips that were implanted based on an idea by Sifo dyas in case there were any Jedi rebels as he feared his visions
I do really not agree with any of your points of why TPM would have any relevance for the machete order. Star Wars is built on Tell, don't Show. Look at the original '77 movie What is the Kessel Run? Who is the Emperor? Who is Jabba? What is the Senate, how does it relate to the Empire? Why does Luke live with his uncle and aunt. And so on, and so on. Not over showing is what is called the ice berg technique. It makes the world bigger than the story. There are enough unsolved references in Star Wars to build a univere. That is why Star Wars became so big! The only thing missing without TPM would be the prophesy. The rest you understand anyways. And TPM doesn't really give a good introduction to the prophect anyways. And you can always watch it as a stand alone after the machete order, just like the rest. See machete order as a fan edit. It shapes the pacing and enhances the main narrative. The you can see the "deleted scenes" of TPM, rogue one and the rest of the movies and series. (And books and comics and.....)
I don't think you're giving first-time viewers enough credit. I've tried the machete order with first-timers and yes, a couple of those questions came up, but not how you described. "Who is that alien, and how do they know each other?" was not asked about Watto, but WAS asked about Dexter Jetster. "Who is that jedi master they mentioned but never showed?" was not asked about Qui-gon (because Yoda says who he was), but WAS asked about Sifo-Dyas. You miss part of Palpatine's machinations, but there's nothing in Ep1 that isn't sufficiently shown or explained in 2. It does need to be watched before Clone Wars, however, and is worth it for that.
There are 5 changes I would do: 1) Have Savage Opress take Darth Maul's place and characteristics of TCW with the emphasis of his talkative nature instead of being reduced to the second banana. 2) Ahsoka should have a different Jedi Master that gives her brutal disciplinary measures. 3) Zillo Beast should be an in-universe holofilm character based on the title shown rather than as a character in the show. 4) Nightbrothers are removed and referring to Iridonian Zabraks, not "Dathomirian Zabraks." 5) The battle events should be TCW original, rather than crossed with repeats, with the exception of Umbara. Honorable mentions: • Cad Bane is also an in-universe holofilm character with a different name changed to "Cadd Bain." • Kalifa exists, but she is not dead and survived. • Jinx takes the Jedi Temple bombing bit of BINO (Barriss in-name-only) and applies it to the Republic homeworld. • Grievous had a cyborg trainee who took the traits of TCW counterpart and runs with the idea that it is wwy over its head. • Steela survives, and among other things.
4, 1, 2, 5, 3, 6 -- Hear me out, so we start with introducing Luke, where we learn that Anakin was his father and was "killed" by Darth Vader, then we do a bit of a flashback to the first 2 episodes where we learn the story of Anakin Skywalker. Next, we have the famous TESB where we learn the truth of what really happened to Luke's father (the surprise will be even greater having already known young Anakin). Then comes Episode 3, showing Anakin's descent to the Dark Side (with another huge surprise at the very end where we learn that Amidala is having twins and she reveals their names). Finally, we have RoTJ where things are all wrapped up.
Good video there were a few ships that you forgot to mention. The Imperator Star Destroyer, Tector Star Destroyer, The Dreadnaught Heavy Cruiser, The Carreck Light Cruiser, The Maelstrom Battlecruiser, The Prosecutor Battlecruiser, The Secutor Battlecruiser, The Praetor Battlecruiser, The Mandator 1 Star Dreadnaught and Mandator 2 Star Dreadnaught. Also the Consular was a Frigate not a Cruiser.
i hate how plagueis backstory ties to the sequels by mentioning that plagueis try to make a force dyad with sidious and the explanation that palpatine learned from plagueis how to transfer his essence to a clone body.the sequels don´t make sense in the same universe as george six movies
