How did you have SO MUCH TIME to shoot him? I have the same deadeye level as you. I don't get it. The dueling mechanic is so frustratingly half assed. You either hold down the trigger until the circle fills and the guns already pointed at his head when you draw, making it so the game is essentially playing itself for you or the gun starts out either pointed to his left or at his gut giving you a split second to disarm.
Hello you like the game Tomb Raider then I could have something interesting you I make trailer of many different games and the characters look at it would be happy if you like it you can subscribe to it and press the bell or leave comment