Surprisingly husband's counsel hardly countered allegations made by the opponent lawyer during these arguments.

It is highly inappropriate for a judge, sitting in such a high position, to make sweeping and dismissive remarks about the RTI Act and its applicants. This kind of behavior is uncalled for. Accusing the lawyer of being part of a "setup" only raises questions about the judge's own impartiality, especially after showing such disregard for the RTI Act of 2005. It now appears as though the judge herself may be aligned with corrupt bodies attempting to withhold information from citizens. The judge's initial demand for the lawyer to provide reasons for filing the RTI application was not only inappropriate but also a clear violation of Section 6(2) of the RTI Act, 2005. This section clearly states that an applicant “shall not be required to give any reason for requesting the information.” Furthermore, most of the information the lawyer sought under the RTI was already covered under Section 4(1)(b) of the Act, which mandates that such information should be disclosed proactively on public authority websites. In this case, the lawyer shouldn't have had to file an RTI at all, had the authorities fulfilled their obligations. The arrogance with which the judge has handled such a crucial issue, especially when the RTI Act is struggling to survive in this country, undermines the very essence of transparency and accountability. It is deeply troubling, particularly at a time when the right to information is more vital than ever.

Section 8(1) of the RTI may have such clarification on the subject

Good sir 🙏🇮🇳👌 JAI HIND 🇮🇳🇮🇳👌🙏

14/9/2024 5 : 25 pm सरन्यायाधीश धनंजय चंद्रचूड साहेब जी सहीत बेंच का फैसला स्वागतार्ह ! धन्यवाद

Next part

Hats off to the great justice BV Nagarathna the Lioness of all Judges

नाईस व्हिडिओ

😅

Until no order karnataka rent act why?

@succeslawclasses Can we track when the judgement would be given. What is the case number of this SLP?

how can we watch live proceedings of SC?

Which is the lady judge

Please upload the proceedings of the court headed by Justice A S Oka!

She is a waist judge of this century

States official languges of union of india decree against me. Unknown

Hats off to Ladyship, those people who cannot bear a woman voicing her strength and valuable time will talk negatively . Kudos to the judgement of Bilkis Bano and demonetization

Corrupt lady judge

When an advocate can't ask questions, then think how common people can get answers. Look at the arrogance ofcthe lady judge. Shame shame..

I dont understand its citizens right to know information about public bodies right? Is there any ban on advocates? I think ladyship sensed lack of bonafides.

Judge argument is not correct

AIMS of the RTI going to AIIMS

This is what the situation is for somebody who do public works courageously. Then who will come forward to question scams???

Its our right to know the information from public organizations its our right ...

What nonsense it is.... She can't ask reason as per RTI.…...And if he is not getting information then definitely he will approach higher judiciary ....Threatening for cost is really nonsense

SIR gareebo ka paaisa nahi dubna chahiy... Aap last hope hai investors ke

Hatsoff to Lordship

RTI is a fundamental right of the citizens. If the public department does not share the information, something is wrong with it.

🎉How happy these accept with glee when prashanth bhushan,dave etc file rti in SC. Double standard

Who has set-up whom, finally?

I was keen to watch the video because of Justice Nagarthna but her demeanor is disturbing...sad ...😢

Y chndarachund he is agent of congress.

RTI Clarifications themselves mention that no reasons need to be given. Kerala High Court upholds the same.

It is a senior judge BV Nagarathna... She is not scared of doing the right thing including giving bilkis bano, demonitisation dissent, justice by overturning SC 's own judgement

बको ध्यानं काkचेष्टा

सहारा की गलती की सजा आम जनता को नहीं मिलनी चाहिए हुज़ूर, 600000ऐजट एंड 1000000करोड़ जमाकार्ता का क्या होगा सर 🙏🏻🌹🙏🏻भुगतान कैसे होगा 🙏🏻🌹🙏🏻आपसे हम सारे ऐसे आशा लगाए थे, बट अफ़सोस केवल केवल सहारा सेबी की बात हुई आम जनता की बात नहीं हुई महोदय कुछ कीजिये नहीं तो अब देर हो जाएगी, हम सब पैसा जमा किये अपने पेट काट कर बट ये क्या होगा सर, यह कहानी कोइ नहीं भूलेंगे 🙏🏻🌹🙏🏻

She is rite nd shud b next cji

Sahara jaise dhoke baaz companyke taraf ladne itne lawyers

Itna bada kand huva or sarkar sc dekhti rahi mera bharat mahan

सत्यमेव जयते

Sahara India pariwar jaisi chitfund companyo se garib niveshako ka sampurna bhugtaan ka nirnay supreme court kab dega .....

Reverse the sahara.

Of sahara sebi case

Can u upload 4 or 5 September hearning on this channel so we can se it

Please live bhaiya 5 sep...vala

Please live this case 5 September sahara sebi case.

Public is clapping the Bulldozer justice because long delays in court cases and loosing faith in judiciary. Long live Yogi Ji and his Bulldozer.

This Gavai is agent of congress.

N what is this nonsense…practice on your profession ?? Justice pervades every particle & I am an advocate of justice….he must have confronted her…..I am sorry, this is very sorry state of affairs

Absolutely ridiculous…..information is information. Why should he give reason ? I had a hope from Justice Nagratnna….pity