fun fact, regarding Kyoko, "it is really very special. Because she got her wish of "getting people to listen" while in fact it was something like charming or hallucination, she got the magic power related to those things. However, because she lost her family, she began to subconsciously reject that magic, and thus by the time of the events in the anime she had already lost those powers. That's why she only fought with the magic she learned after that. We had that all set up behind the scenes, but were never able to work it into the story to explain it explicitly."
Reina appears and says "やっと見つけた (yatto mitsuketa)". English sub reads "There you are." But the words have double meanings in Japanese. The line "やっと見つけた" literally means "At last, have found." (with no subject, with no object). The surface meaning is "At last, (I, Reina) have found (you, Kumiko)." But Hibike has its hidden story and the hidden meaning of the words is "At last, (you, Kumikko) have found (my 'love')." I wish more and more people may reach the hidden story.
劇場版第4弾「ワルプルギスの廻天」前にここまでで自分なりに消化できていないことをメモし考察します。映画公開前でありながら一部映画内容の展開と結末を予想しています。多分的外れですが万が一合ってたとしたら結果ネタバレになるのですみません。 本編・リベリオンは５セットほど視聴。考察サイトなどは未視聴 ①EP10 ホムラのタイムループ前（魔法少女になるターン）、マミ・マドカが事前にワルプルギスの夜が来ることを知っていた。 ②EP12 ワルプルギスが消滅した際、黒子の人形が踊りながら回転する演出→人形が二人ずつペアになって回転、それぞれがマドカとホムラに見える ①・②について自分なりの見解 ワルプルギスはマドカの一部を取り込んだホムラが魔女（便宜上魔女ではないが）と化したもの。魔法少女の素質は因果の量で決まる。タイムループの始まりはマドカが起因になっているのでループする度マドカに時間軸ごとの因果が結びつき莫大なエネルギー係数を加算された（QBの説明より）。ワルプルギスもマドカを取り込んだホムラだとすれば同じようにホムラの中のマドカ部分に因果が結びつきより強力な魔女となっていくことになる。タイトルの「ワルプルギスの廻天」を「回転」と「廻天」のダブルミームと予想。「回転」はリベリオンで残されて転校してきたマドカがEP10の始まりのマドカであることを示す。記憶を取り戻したマドカであればEP10で事前にワルプルギスが来ることを認知していることの説明がつく。どうやって元の世界（EP10の世界）に移行し、ホムラがワルプルギスと分離しマドカが記憶を取り戻すのかは予想できないが映画にて描かれることを期待。「廻天」（意味：衰えた勢いをもり返し形勢を一変させる）はホムラの中に取り込まれたマドカがループを繰り返すことで強力化しホムラとの力関係を逆転させることを示唆している。その結末がEP12となるのでタイムパラドックスが生じることになる。タイムパラドックスを生じさせる原因はマドカとホムラ（ともしくはQB達も）にあるので、EP12（もしくはEP10）に帰結する瞬間これらの原因は全ての時間軸・宇宙から取り除かれることになる（多分）それがワルプルギスの廻天の結末。 ③EP12 サヤカがソウルジェムを消耗し消滅した際、マミが円環の理に迎えられたことを理解していた。 自分なりの見解 これ以前にベベの消滅にマミは遭遇していた。その際に円環の理を認識した。 ④EP3 病院にベベのグリーフシードがあったこと ⑤EP4 上条の態度が急変し、サヤカに辛くあたったこと ⑥EP10 ホムラがタイムループする前ではマドカ・マミのみ魔法少女として登場、ループ3回目にサヤカが魔法少女として登場、以降でキョウコも登場と魔法少女として登場するタイミングがループ回数で違うこと ④～⑥についての見解 すべてQBの仕業。タイムループがあるまではQBはマドカを普通の魔法少女、サヤカを魔法少女の素質なしと判断していた。なので初回はマミ・マドカのみが魔法少女として登場。タイムループ後マドカが強化されより注目するがQBに騙されていることを知ったホムラの妨害にあう。マドカを契約させる動機付けのためにサヤカは魔法少女に選ばれる。（なので本来は魔法少女の才能がない）また、サヤカと対立する可能性が高く混乱を生むキョウコが隣町から引っ掻き回す役として連れてこられるようになる。④・⑤EP3でべべのグリーフシードをQBがセットした目的は3点。１マミが居ないところで二人を魔女の結界に取り込まれさせ契約せざるを得ない状況を作ろうとした ２仮にマミが連れてこられてもべべには敵わずやられることが予想でき、二人に契約を強制させようとした（ホムラの妨害により失敗） ３病院にセットすることで魔女化したベベが絶望を撒き散らし上条が絶望に捕らわれるよう仕向けた。上条を救いたいサヤカを契約させることに成功した。 こうやってアウトプットしてみると長文化するし、なんか無理が多いので違うのかな？ってのが正直なところ。どちらにしても映画が楽しみ。 Convert Japanese to English Before the 4th movie "Walpurgisnacht Rising", I would like to take notes and consider things that I have not fully understood so far. Even before the movie is released, we are predicting the development and ending of some of the movie's contents. I'm probably off base, but if it were, it would spoil the outcome, so I'm sorry. I watched about 5 sets of the main story, Rebellion. I have not watched any review sites etc. ①EP10 Before Homura's time loop (the turn she becomes a magical girl), Mami Madoka knew in advance that Walpurgis Night would come. ②EP12 When Walpurgis disappears, shadow of a dolls dance and rotate → The dolls rotate in pairs, each looking like Madoka and Homura. My own opinion on ① and ② Walpurgis is Homura who took part of Madoka and turned into a witch (although for convenience's sake she is not a witch). The quality of a magical girl is determined by the amount of cause and effect. Since the beginning of the time loop was caused by Madoka, each time the loop occurred, the cause and effect of each time axis was connected to Madoka, and a huge energy coefficient was added (according to QB's explanation). If Walpurgis is also Homura who has absorbed Madoka, then in the same way, cause and effect are connected to the Madoka part of Homura and she becomes a more powerful witch.The title ``Walpurgis no Kaiten'' is predicted to be a double meme of ``rotation'' and ``restoration.'' "Rotation" indicates that the Madoka who was left behind at Rebellion and transferred is the Madoka at the beginning of EP10. If Madoka has regained her memories, this would explain why she knew in advance that Walpurgis was coming in EP10. I can't predict how they will transition to their original world (the world of EP10), how Homura will separate from Walpurgis, and how Madoka will regain her memories, but I hope it will be depicted in the movie. "restoration" (meaning: regaining lost momentum and completely changing the situation) suggests that Madoka, who is taken into Homura, becomes more powerful by repeating the loop and reverses the power relationship with Homura. Since the ending will be EP12, a time paradox will occur. The causes of the time paradox are Madoka and Homura (and QBs as well), so the moment it ends in EP12 (or EP10), these causes will be removed from all timelines and universes (probably). is the ending of Walpurgisnacht Rising. ③EP12 When Sayaka consumed her soul gem and disappeared, she understood that Mami was welcomed by the principle of the circle. My own opinion: Mami had encountered Bebe's disappearance before this. At that time, I recognized the principle of circular circles. ④EP3 Bebe's Grief Seed was found in the hospital ⑤EP4 Kamijo's attitude suddenly changed and he hit Sayaka harshly ⑥EP10 Before Homura's time loop, only Madoka and Mami appear as magical girls, Sayaka appears as a magical girl in the third loop, and after that, Kyoko also appears, and the timing of her appearance as a magical girl differs depending on the number of loops. Views on ④-⑥: It's all the QB's work. Until the time loop, QB had judged Madoka to be an ordinary magical girl and Sayaka to have no magical girl qualities. So in the first episode, only Mami Madoka appears as a magical girl. After the time loop, Madoka becomes stronger and attracts more attention, but she is interrupted by Homura, who learns that she has been deceived by the QB. Sayaka is chosen as a magical girl in order to motivate Madoka to sign a contract. (That's why she doesn't really have the talent to be a magical girl.) Also, Kyoko, who is likely to conflict with Sayaka and cause confusion, is brought in from the neighboring town to play a role in stirring things up. ④・⑤The purpose of the QB setting Bebe's Grief Seed in EP3 is 3 points.1) He tried to create a situation in which they were forced to enter the witch's barrier without Mami and they had no choice but to make a contract. 2) Even if Mami was brought in, it was predicted that Bebe would be no match for them and the two would be defeated. (failed due to Homura's interference) Bebe, who turned into a witch, spread despair and caused Kamijou to fall into despair. He succeeded in getting Sayaka, who wanted to save Kamijou, into a contract. If you try to output it like this, it will take a long time, and there are a lot of things that are impossible, so maybe it's wrong? That's the honest truth. Either way, I'm looking forward to the movie.
12:41 The subtitle here is 'Don't tell him', but Asuka is referring to her mother, so it is 'her'. In the original language, there is a nuance here, as if she is saying 'that person' rather than 'her'. In fact, throughout this conversation with Kumiko, Asuka refers to her mother as 'that person' and never 'my mother or my mum'. This makes both Kumiko and viewer perceive that Asuka does not like her mother, and it is because she is revealing her inner self in this way that Kumiko is able to say it out loud, I guess.
