Somebody who has the power needs to contact this company (since they are still active today doing shows) and have them send a video or HD photograph of that puppet dancing on stage. At least then we can get a clear photo of the Pirate Percy puppet from the Candle Cove Screaming Episode.
1:01 Barney, Thomas and Friends, Angelina Ballerina, and Bob the Builder. Not the 2015 Bob the Builder, Handy Manny, Thomas and Friends: All Engines Go! Chuggington, The Huggabug Club, Ricky's Room, and Barney's World.
This video is certainly very close to what we are looking for, but it is definitely not the same video that we see in the Scream Episode. In the Creepypasta video there is no piano, and there are no glowing things, and indeed this video dates back to 2013, when Scream Episode was published in 2009. We need to keep looking.
ohhhh we find the puppet!!!! from candle cove video, yaaaaaaayyyy!!!!!! i know it’s maybe not that exact same video, but it’s so cool that we find it!!!!!!
That puppet on the piano is definitely the same one from the Candle Cove video, but I don't think this is the exact video that was used. The original video would've been uploaded in or before 2009, since that's the year the "screaming episode" video was originally made.