The new Springtrap is a way more horrifying - I jumped, when he whipped out. Besides, the old one didn't scare me. The other animatronics are better in old version
the jumpscares of the old fnaf are better, cause it makes you feel the panic and the heart beating faster because of the visual things like the red light. And the noise of the animatronics are scarier
New Springtrap jumpscare is kinda better (old looks like he's just walking in friendly), but both games aren't actually scary. Fnaf 3 has the scariest atmosphere imo, but the main antagonist has sooo bad jumscare