I was young when I first listened to Melanie. Originally, my Mom played her in the car so I kept listening to her. I really liked her, and I watched some videos that my mom allowed me to watch, but I completely forget the thumbnails. I found her again during the start of Portals. This is cool to watch for me, since I never got to fully remember the thumbnails
It’s very sad that material from crybaby era was permanent erased but you can’t blame her, in 2017 everyone was forming a hate train against Melanie it was actually pretty sad
Guys don’t worry once portals era is finished and we get all the portals music videos I’m sure it will go back to normal (since portals is the end of crybaby, and all future music she releases will be from HER perspective not crybaby)
@@GBop89I think he means that he became a fan of her when she changed her thumbnails so he doesn’t feel nostalgic since he never saw her old thumbnails
Actually the only thumbnail I recognize was Dollhouse, the other ones not. Because Dollhouse is the mv I saw from her, and I was 7 that time, I addicted to it, and then I never look back to her channel for so long. Thank you now I got to see her old thumbnail. I wish she bring those back once this portals era is over
Omg i miss her old thumbnail i remember when the first time i see it before im not mel fans so i decide to see dollhouse song and i love it and its my fav song for the first time now i feel sad cuz i can't see the old thumbnail😔😭 thank you for making the video your video give me nostalgic for me 😇🥰🤍✨💗👍🏻❤
What I don’t get is how come, Dollhouse EP and After School EP have the “R.I.P. CRYBABY” thumbnails if they were never originally apart of Crybaby’s Narrative…
I discovered melanie Martinez back when i found the show and tell snippet. I thought it looked cool so i saw her othee snippets and ever aince that day i became a fan. By the way, i was eight years old that then. So my inner Cherub awakened in Melanie's k-12 snippets era, and now my cherub upgraded to an earthling 👍
I wasn’t as big of a fan so I didn’t really remember what most of these looked like I’m glad that this video was posted (also if it’s possible could you do her old pfp)
I remember, before portals, thst i would scroll through her videos and find K-12 mainly because the thumbnail was the scene from Detention where she was smiling but crying at the same time Its crazy how nostalgic it feels lol
I was literally searching on the internet what was the old thumbnails for her music videos because I only became a fan last year with portals. The only MVs I remember the thumbnail was mrs potatohead, the bakery, dollhouse, and k-12 lol. Thank u for this!! ❤🎉
y'all gotta realize that mel is not changing the thumbnails this will be her last era unless she does a deluxe. i'm just saying that it's her choice to do what she wants. It's a 50/50 she will change her thumbnail or.. she won't.
@@zuilb7074 still in her next album sense what my thing is i think she will prob be alive she will change it all to a photo that says alive or something else. what i'm saying is melanie will change her thumbnail or not or she will change her thumbnails prob to alive or not. melanie is melanie you can't tell her what to do she does what she does best she does what she want's to do.
I love Melanie's dedication to portals, but honestly it gets a little confusing looking for a specific video on her channel. I hope she'll change them back someday! And maybe also add back her old tiktoks because I never got to watch them 😭
@@M1CR0WAV3D ive listened to her since 2019, but in 2023 like lets say a month before the portals snippets I started becoming obsessed, I was like (oo this seems iconic)
