Good evening, good morrow and good day - and welcome to Slice & Dice, a hub for all things TTRPG. This is where all our sessions, chat and other content will be uploaded for you to watch at your leisure... and, more importantly, catch up with the latest episode!
Our current Series are: Lord of the Rings Roleplaying - a series of bitesize videos covering all aspects of the epic TTRPG from Free League Publishing. A Slice of Dice - our fireside chat series where we get to know the community and find out how they got into the hobby.
We also have TTRPG meetup events and chatter throughout the week - find out more on our Discord.
Like what you see? Please consider liking, sharing, subscribing, and get in touch!
Great to see another video of a fan of the game. Most of the videos I run into keep saying 'forget LOTR 5e, just go with The One Ring', but this game has its virtues too I think. Looking forward to more videos from you!
Oh yes, I have come across many people who feel that way - but there are several things that feel much better for me as a LM and a player in this game! Glad you feel the same 😁 perhaps another video topic?!
@@sliceandd6 For LOTR 5e? I would say "Journey" and "Encounters on the road" during Journey phase. I'm trying to DM/GM/LM a game and I've read about the encounter rolls for places like the GreenRoad, Trollshaws, etc. but I don't know when those encounter rolls would occur, when exactly to roll the d12. I think that's pretty much the only thing I'm still trying to figure out.
@@sliceandd6 Build discussions are always fun too! I think Dwarves make the best melee Champions. Bardings are good Captains. Elves make good ranged Champions and also great Scholars. Hobbits for Treasure Hunters. Ranger Wardens (no explanation necessary I think, haha). And Bree are decent Messengers.
'Because thats how the dice have fell' smooth Jack, but it looks like you loose your cool when the discussion turns to Mantis shrimp. Miss you and the guys Kimbo, hope to see you soon X
While a few of the elemental disciplines aren’t actually spells, they are all magical. The unique non spell effects won’t be able to be dispelled, counterspelled, or impacted by globe of invulnerability. All of them would be impacted by a beholders anti magic cone or some other anti magic field. Another thing to keep in mind is that the features water whip and fist of unbroken air would be subject to magic resistance since they’re still magical.
You make good points and then contradict yourself almost right away. The idea that its unique to cast spells isn't even unique to monks (shadow, sun) let alone a martial character. If you consider that a lvl 11 character (im assuming now, white room): would use some ki points for stunning strike, dodge, dash, increase accuracy, etc. AND cast at least a spell, hopefully two or three. The monk just can't do all of what people praise of them being able to do all at once. If you are able to get a short rest ever 2 fights then the problems go away almost immediately. Another thing. There is no elemental monk that will out cast a full caster, let alone a half caster. I also cannot believe you said a monk is the most jedi thing you've seen in 5e. A Bladesinger does exactly what you describe, a man in flowing robes wielding a sword in one hand a blasting away foes with his other open palm. Now just imagine you can use your powers more often, get better choices and much more versatile, get a combat ability that makes you better in melee than a monk. I played a Bladesinger 1-15 and i literally flavored it that he came from a monastery's library, training in martial arts and spells. We need to stop sugar coating that monks are poorly designed "FROM A GAMEPLAY" perspective. I also love the flavor and versatility and lore and imagery of a monk. I just wish the class was designed to meet the standards of the game.
This is a pretty good video and has made me want to go try an Four Elements Monk someday. That said, there is a couple things that one could do to me the subclass even better. 1. Ki-Fueled Strike from Tashas. All the Elemental Disciplines (save for one) require you to spend at least 1 Ki as an action. You can then follow that up with a Bonus Action Unarmed Strike or Attack with a Monk Weapon. Note, some Monk Weapons are Ranged Weapons. From thrown (dagger, hand axe, Light Hammer, Javelin, spear, and Darts) and Ranged Weapons (Sling, Shortbow and Light Crossbow). Then more with Dedicated Weapon (after you gain proficiency with them first). 2. With some Elemental Disciplines being Spells, either taking a dip into Sorcerer or the Metamagic Adept Feat, would grant you ways to alter your Elemental Spells. Though, I don't think Quicken Spell would work as the Disciplines require you to spend Ki points as an action. Though Careful Spell, Distant Spell, Empowered Spell, Extend Spell, Heightened Spell, Transmute Spell and even Twinned Spell could all be quite useful for a Four Elements Monk. Casting Rush of the Gale Spirits, yet having the winds bend around your allies while pushing the enemies away. Flames of the Phoenix, instead becomes, Waves of the Phoenix, Winds of the Phoenix, Stone of the Phoenix. Clench of the North Winds now holds two targets instead of one, or even Eternal Mountains Defense, Mist Stance, and Ride the Wind could potentially be twinned, targeting not only yourself, but one other as well (Note: None are self targeting spells, just single target by default, though may be up to GM if they'd allow twinning the Disciplines).
Hi Hero, yes apologies for the imbalance here, I’ve now got new software that’s a lot easier to adjust levels so future audio should be a lot better balanced
Helpful criticism here. Please adjust your music to match the volume levels of your mic. Every time there's a transition between you talking to music, the music is extremely loud.
hmm i am a year late on this one. Okay! I find the biggest downfall of Wo4E is not having enough impact in an average adventuring day. At lvl 3, you can use one discipline in combat before being locked out of your subclass. your elemental attunement is potentially useful, but unfortunately such flavor/utility is easily grabbed by a full caster. so by the time you get your utility feature, another player has likely been using an equivalent for the last two levels. Short rests are common, but not free. to compare it to the fighter: battlemaster, psi warrior, rune knight, and even samurai can all utilize their subclass combat abilities more than once per short rest right at lvl 3. An argument can be made that stronger features should be available less often, but I think I am safe to say 80% of the Wo4E options are not stronger/comparable to the fighter subclasses. finally, in using ki, it not only limits subclass features, but main class features as well, which is something not found anywhere else in dnd5e (if I'm not mistaken). This is a list of unfortunate issues, and i have been highlighting early levels in particular, but that doesn't mean It isn't enjoyable to play. I really love the flavor and the characters i can build. but .. With power creep It has gotten increasingly difficult to feel impactful as a WO4E monk. There are a lot of trap options, and it is easy for players to spend 8+ levels feeling jealous of the other monk subclass. You made a good point in it being more enjoyable around 10th, but most games end at 10th level, so... sadly most people just see the grind, and none of the perks if dnd5e is truely moving towards a 5.5e, I home this is one that gets a work over.
The Ki Fueled Strike in _Tasha's_ helped to address one of the big gripes about this subclass, which is the opportunity cost of using Elemental Disciplines. So now you can more easily mix your elemental powers with your martial arts; for example, you can pull someone close and hit them, or knock them prone and then hit them, or paralyze them and still get a hit in, or cast _fly_ and then go up and hit your enemy. Absolutely agree with allowing players to take an extra Elemental Discipline at 3rd/6th/11th/17th, and allowing them to switch Elemental Disciplines whenever they level. Also agree they should have added in the Elemental Evil spells; while the Arcane Trickster and Eldritch Knight continued to get more versatile every time new wizard spells were released, the Four Elements monk was forgotten. But as the power creep continues with every new release, the Way of the Ascendant Dragon has several features that a lot of people dreamed of adding to the Four Elements monk: changing your unarmed strike damage to an elemental damage type of your choice, an extra language (they get Draconic, while the Four Elements should get Primordial), an elemental damage breath weapon that you can use for *0* ki points a number of times equal to your proficiency modifier, enhanced Step of the Wind at 6th level, an elemental damage resistance aura at 11th level, and even more AoE elemental damage at 17th level. I think that's a bit much, but here's another idea that really adds to the flavor of the Four Elements monk on a regular basis. (Keeping in mind that we don't want the features to compete with the monk's existing features but rather complement them, and we don't want the subclass to become overpowered.) Take those non-damage elemental cantrips - _control flames, gust, mold earth,_ and _shape water_ - and allow the Four Elements monk to take one of those cantrips at each of their feature levels: 3rd, 6th, 11th, and 17th. Then allow them to cast those cantrips as _free actions_ when they use certain ki features: * Immediately before or after you use Flurry of Blows, you may cast _control flames_ or _mold earth_ as a free action. * Immediately before, during, or after you Dash using Step of the Wind, you may cast _gust_ or _shape water_ as a free action. * Immediately before or after you Disengage using Step of the Wind, you may cast _control flames_ or _gust_ as a free action. * Immediately before or after you use Patient Defense, you may cast _mold earth_ or _shape water_ as a free action. Additionally, when you spend a ki point to throw a missile caught with Deflect Missiles, you may deal 1d4 additional damage. If you know _control flames,_ you may make this additional damage fire damage. If you know _gust,_ you may make it magical slashing damage. If you know _mold earth,_ you may make it magical bludgeoning damage. If you know _shape water,_ you may make it cold damage. (It's not a lot, but it encourages you to use that monk feature and you get a little something extra.) That way, when you do the ordinary things monks do, you get some elemental flavoring and have opportunities for creative tactics, without going gonzo. It encourages the DM to think about how they use objects, water features, and other terrain.
A lot you mentioned I had included in redesign of the W4E monk. Including the 4 cantrips. But I also redesigned its casting to where it’s “spells” aren’t actually spell you cast but are “Spell-like” monk abilities that you can instead of casting.
Fizzban’s treasury of dragons includes a belt that lets a Monk recover a Martial arts die worth of Ki once per day. Also increases your Ki save DC. That will help this subclass a lot. Something else to consider is one level of Arcana Cleric to get Booming Blade and Green Flame blade as Cleric Cantrips and GFB working off Wisdom . You also get 2 Level 1 spells and can scribe scrolls!
