Kabhi kisi backward class officer ka bhi interview lelo bhai wo inse jyada bahadur hote hai unke experiences jyada sunne ko aacha lagega ... Jay hind..
Being a pahadi (Kumaoni) and from a family of army personnels It gave me goosebumps to have Colonel Joshi on the channel. Kalika Mata ki Jai! 🙏Jai Hind! 🙏🇮🇳
I Salute Indian Soliders not just because they fight for our motherland, that any other country soliders does. It because they believe in humanity, respect of enemy as well; which no other country does. "Hum Dushmani me bhi Sharafat rakhte hai"
Hey Ranveer, can you bring Retrired IAS officer Sanjay Dixit Ji to your podcast. He is 1 of the few Indians who does a Perfect analysis of current Events related to the India. And surprisingly, he also has Answer to every Question related to India and its History. His Expertise lies in Indian History, Partition of India, National Integrity and islamic invasions. Thanks!
@@chatrapatishivajimaharaj3738 I mean why he run boycott campaign, I mean if he didn't want to watch movies he shouldn't, why boycott? That too Brahmastra
The way he speaks of Capt. Kalia is a sentiment many of us feel. Sad that many people don't know his story. We'd hate to play cricket with that terrorist country if we knew his story
@@sarthakmishra6240 RU-vid mai mil jayega us pakistani fauzi ka video jisne capt. Kalia ko humiliate kar ke mara tha ... Capt. Kalia first martyr thae kargil war ke ... jinko body ke saare parts ko dheere dheere kaat kar maar diya gaya
@@shreemmishra2711 thanks for explaining... But why are you getting rude just because I asked about him here? Isn't it allowed to ask something in the comment section
I felt the same while watching Uri like the tactical moves in movies like moving in straight line convoy in pok without securing angles that attack helicopter scene etc were very inacurate... Uri was just supposed to be a popular film benifitting from nationlistic sentiments in our country regarding that incident
Not only army even spy movies . In movie Raazi they showed the main character of Alia Bhatt as emotionally weak and his 🇵🇰 husband as some saint. Even the writer of the book (calling sehmat)on which it was based told this
It is obvious none can bring out 100 percent in movies. Professional defence personals will surely take out mistakes.. But its quite ok for general public. Personally I liked Uri a lot. It was very touchy.
@@surendrakulkarni2683 What u think about the audience has no value at all. Probably u are among those who pretend themselves as if you know everything about the reality of Wars n battles.In reality you are among those who just nod by other intellectuals.
Lol it was a very stupid movie insertion across loc via a chopper lol.....one stinger missile and that chopper would be gone 🤣🤣 troops going in random formation no assualt group or support group no buddy pairs moving close proximity to each other (very ideal situation if someone wants to ambush them one lmg burst or rpg or and ied and multiple casualties )🤣🤣 unnecessary picking up hand to hand fight just to look macho 🤣🤣.....room intervention technique is just lol 🤣🤣....when a civilian like me can see such flaws it would ve like almost a paraody for a soldier to watch that shit 🤣🤣 Surendra is right bollywood survives with such trash because india is filled with emotional fools who only wish to live in their fantasy world away from reality they will only enjoy such masala movies
@@malviyaamulya7953 , I am not denying the fact that it has some technical flaws. Not every audience picks the points like u had. At least it is far better than stupid illogical action movies of Bollywood or even South Indian movies. In the end the aim of majority director is to attract mass public.
Thank you very much Sir for remembering Captain Saurabh Kalia who was mercilessly tortured by the Pakistanis before killing him... justice still pending....it reminds of the Muslim invaders ....No Indian should forget this ....Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Uri, LOC, Border best hai But Shershah mein thoda love story PE focus Kiya gya hai na ki operation pe focus Kiya hai isliye woh inn 3 movie se alag hai
There are lot of movies specially focused on the protagoniat's eyes to make him look like he's having a killer's eyes as he had been in the close combat situations. In videos i saw those same killer eyes in him 🙏. Clearly a deep feeling of lashing out on the enemy and does all the things that the enemy can imagine
thank you ranveer for this clip seriously such a eye opener as i have moved form teenage to 20's i thought what movie are showing only 50% above that might have happen but by watching this there is no doubt no one can match the sacrifices the way army do for their respective country
@Rey lol. Sersah added more masala. Captain Vikram Batra didn't called her fiance after his Mission instead he called his father but they wanted show love story so they showed different.
URI special forces k uper hai or aapko gurantee k sath nahi maloom hoga bharat ki kaunsi special force hai jo outside India mission executive karti hai apne FSS ka badge bhi nahi dekha hoga mene 3 saal volunteer kiya ha or meri deployment lagbhag middle east mai thi because of my fluent command on arabic or FSS ek private force hai jiska koi record government apne paas nahi rakhti
Watched the whole video. Sir did not explain much why URI movie was far away from reality. But I think URI movie was thoroughly researched and depiction of reality was correct. No fiction. This is what I feel. Anyone of you if you know something else about this film which I don't know, then please share this knowledge in the comment section and help me refine my knowledge.
Bhai koi soldier ki maa ko bhulne ki bimari nhi thi,koi lady airforce chopper ka istemal nhi kiya gya tha jiska pati mar gya tha,n ki ajit dhoval apna hr phone tod dete hai,N ki koi pachi jaise dikhne wala drone use hua tha.Bahut saari chize apne mn se kuch bhi dal diye the ye sab nhi dalte to bhi film bahut achi hi bnti.
@@abhinayrangari9693 thoda sa creative freedom liya tha movie banane ke liye warna movie boring ho jaati.............thoda bhot chalta hai unless they are disrespecting anyone
Helicopters were not used so close to the border in the real LOC strike and the initial strike in Myanmar did not inflict so many causalities as shown in the movie plus NSCN-K did not do ceasefire. There was already a reconnaissance team for a few days inside LOC before the assault/strike teams moved in. Also our Mi-17s do not use minigun and there was No battle between Indian and Pakistani helicopters. In the last scene Mr. Vicky was shown shooting militants from under the river via normal Rifle/ammunition and he wasn't even wearing a diving set. (I found how's the josh dialogue post operation and screaming "Indian" Army while stabbing the terrorist was quite cringe but this one's personal.)
I and my brother both are defense aspirant. Whenever we used to see movies with Army officers, we always point out the mistakes the filmmakers make in uniforms. He is right.
This is unexpected from you Ranveer bro!! I mean content is different from title of the video which looks so firm!! Please Don't upload such titles.. We're anyway gonna watch such inspirational interviews!! Just to attract more people doesn't need to upload fake titles. 🙏
@@rohitarora7823 URI ने Indian Army को नीचे दिखाया? Isn't it strange!! I mean how can someone make such thumbnail😂 I'm not saying URI movie shown 100% truth but still the title is beyond my intellectual thought process😅
@@vaibhav2973 cheap and spurious contents require such misleading titles and thumbnails.. That's why I said, it's not expected from BeerBiceps channel!!
i feel proud that in belonging from same hometown of cpt Vikram Batra and Sourav Kaliya sir I form palampur Himachal Pradesh and they both legends was also from that place ❤️❤️❤️❤️ jai Hind
I wouldnt say URI was a bad movie the stress of combat felt real the pain after loss of soldiers felt painful agreed Close Air Support by mi17 was stupid ( writers imagination) I never trust any military movie to be historically correct but as long as they try to get some accuracy it makes me happy. URI and shershah had that but other movies like BHUJ or shows like shoorveer 🤮
@Rey Shershaah was lovely story was more accurate still the combat tactics didn't feel that good and it's ok to do that story was about Shershah and it was portrayed beautifully unlike URI which was about the operation
Hey Ranveer, can you bring Retrired IAS officer Sanjay Dixit Ji to your podcast. He is 1 of the few Indians who does a Perfect analysis of current Events related to the India. And surprisingly, he also has Answer to every Question related to India and its History. His Expertise lies in Indian History, Partition of India, National Integrity and islamic
There were many loop holes in URI frankly..specially the last helicopter scene it was supposed to be a covert search and destroy op without alerting the Pakistani military..if the depicted scene were true then we would be in a full on war with Pakistan right now..other than that Vicky did an excellent job playing Capt. Vihaan..History TV 18 channel showed the actual thing
Hey Buddy can you explain about the following Indian Legends, Kingdoms and Philosophies: Indian Legeneds: 1. Adi Shankaracharya 2. Gautam Buddha 3. Mahavir Jain 4. Ashoka the Great 5. Guru Gobind Singh 6. Swami Vivekananda 7. Bodhi Dharma: He spread Martial Arts to China 8. Rani Rudramma Devi: How she is the Best women Warrior of India 9. Bodisena: Spread Buddhism to Japan and it is still followed highly there Indian Kingdoms: 1. Vijayanagara Empire 2. Sathavahana Dynasty 3. Chola Dynasty 4. Sikh Empire 5. Gupta Empire 6. Mauryan Empire Indian Philosophies: 1. Questions in Prashna Upanishad 2. Bhagavad Gita and Uddava Gita 3. Charvaka Philosophy 4. Why Yoga and Meditation is so Efficient 5. Debates in Ancient India 6. Why Indians worshiped idols, nature and everything. There are a lot of controversies around this. Many invaders and current day Indians criticize this. But Gita gives an excellent answer
URI is more fiction than reality ... Infact the characters are fictional too ... The bird drone scene, the mother's nurse moment, the female fighter pilot, the death of the para sf company commander's brother in the grenade mishandling, the last moment raw info incoming about pakistan's air defence setup by interrogating a Pakistani parliamentarian ... Everything was fictional ... A movie has to contain things rhat are fictional but when you make even the major events of the story imaginary and fictional then there it causes the problem to those really associated with these things ...
With all due respect to colonel joshi URI was thoroughly researched and the team while making the film took utmost care to keep whatever possible we could to actual reality. Infact some part was of research was so real that it was not possible to depict on screen. The cast and crew associated with the film shall always be grateful to the support offered by Indian Army.
He has certain likings when it came to war movies. it is very evident from the list of movies he mentioned he liked. So lets just take it as his personal view. I personally loved URI and I felt it was more realistically depicted than border. When border came it was time of ham actions, loud dialogues so it was made accordingly.
Sir coming from defence bg and having talked to lot of serving and retired defense personnel/families including few Special forces people, there are certain things which are far from reality. Heptrs were not used so close to the border in the real LOC strike and the initial strike in Myanmar did not inflict so many causalities as shown in the movie plus NSCN-K did not do ceasefire. There was already a reconnaissance team for a few days inside LOC before the assault/strike teams moved in. Also our Mi-17s do not use minigun and there was No battle between India and Pakistani helicopters. In the last scene Mr. Vicky was shown taking out targets from under river from normal Rifle/ammunition and he wasn't even wearing a diving set. (I found how's the josh dialogue post operation and screaming "Indian" Army while stabbing the terrorist was quite cringe but this one's personal.)
As far as I know URI is the best military movie from India specially it shows how difficult special operations are and what it takes to serve the country.
Entertaining movie ... Yes Best Military movie ... No ... It is more fiction than reality ... Infact the characters are fictional too ... The bird drone scene, the mother's nurse moment, the female fighter pilot, the death of the para sf company commander's brother in the grenade mishandling, the last moment raw info incoming about pakistan's air defence setup by interrogating a Pakistani parliamentarian ... Everything was fictional ... A movie has to contain things rhat are fictional but when you make even the major events of the story imaginary and fictional then there it causes the problem to those really associated with these things ...
Ghanta, URI movie just had masala and nothing more than that. In reality 4 Para SF and 9 Para SF conducted that operation. 3 squads (3x6) + 1 medic was involved in it. It was a very small duration hit within 45 mins the contact was over and our troops returned back. Out of those 19 people 1 officer from 4 para got Kirti Chakra, 5 got Shaurya Chakra, and 13 got Sena Medal for that op. And no one shouts like bitch in operations and say "how is the josh" they quietly go and do what they are suppose to do and they come back. They are being the shadows, nobody knows them.
you cover a lot of information on hindu mythology. we would love if you can bring Rishabh Shetty from Kantara and discuss about this masterpiece. Seriously incredible piece of work it is. better than a lot of Bollywood movies.
German war movies are the closest to reality - Das Boot, Der Untergang, Im Westen Nichts Neues, Stalingrad. Even Finnish and Norwegian and Movies - Talvisota, The King's Choice are brilliant. Letters from Iowa Jima, Flags of our Fathers, The Thin Red Line are also good movies.
yup I know the story in childhood I was there my father was part of that war...when he told the story it's goosebumps....me and surely your also with anger
How can he praise sershah and not URI ? URI movie is so realistic depiction of commando operation. There is no such Indian army movie made like URI. Shershah movie is famous for romance and emotion. URI is just raw represtion of army operation.
URI Subse bakwas movie hai Bollywood ki..👎 Nana patekar ki "Prahar" Subse best movie ab Tak ki..95% reality base movie hai. Keval actions drama dikhane se koi movie best nahi banti. By the way my Father also working in Indian Army..so i know how's their life in duty.
@@nikhilbro665 bhai tuu ne toh URI ko sabse bakwass movie ka tag dia 😂😂😂 Itni superhit movie ko, super successful movie ko. Prahar ki story line alag hai iski alag...usme army life dikhaya gaya hai... training dikahya gaya hai ..URI bss operation based movie hai...usme fight scene ko jitna realistic dikhaya ja sakta hai...utna dikhaya......aur movie successfully kaffi acha Banya gaya hai ....its quality was compared to Hollywood action movie... and I don't know on what basis , you have given a tag of sabse bakwass movie of bollywood to URI. Aur rahi baat army life ki.....I stayed in army hostel till 12th , studied in army school, experienced a disciplined, ruthless army life like recruits in hostel. My father was also in army. You don't know better than me.
Only Bollywood war movie that felt realistic was "Shershah". (Here I'm talking about the fighting sequences, they all felt realistic and accurate.) Ofcourse, the songs were just added creative liberty.
Yeh bhi koi baat hui... shershah achhi hai because dil ke pass Hai. Uri achhi nai usme masala hai. Stay on one aspect. Border again based on true war but it has all ingredients of bollywood movie but wo achhi hai. According to me all movies were good which inspires all Indians for Deshbakti, jazba and junoon. I listen to Ranveer podcast with an aim to learn. However this attitude of the guest speaker not appreciated
@@mayankindian3750 Hollywood only inspires wow factor but essentially what am saying that at macro level if any war movie is able generate patriotic sentiment it's good. Look at the larger perspective.
He has scene Fauj more than you. Do you know he was in NSG and part of the team that went in Akshardham temple attack? And he eliminated one terrorist too? State of Siege movie was made on this. Now coming to URI. Helicopters were not used so close to the border in the real LOC strike and the initial strike in Myanmar did not inflict so many causalities as shown in the movie plus NSCN-K did not do ceasefire. There was already a reconnaissance team for a few days inside LOC before the assault/strike teams moved in. Also our Mi-17s do not use minigun and there was No battle between Indian and Pakistani helicopters. In the last scene Mr. Vicky was shown shooting militants from under the river via normal Rifle/ammunition and he wasn't even wearing a diving set.
Uri film... One thing I noticed was the about the ukhrul attack. In medias it shows that indian forces goes to myanmar n india border n did surgical strikes using helicopters. But in our local news print medias told that none of the terrorist was killed or captured. Later it was showed that the pics of helicopters were from another event like drill or training... There was a controversy about it.
