Cannot demand anything from a country when you are not a citizen, thats the hard truth of life, this government is on the last phase of its tenure and next one will crack down even more...one advise...get ready as soon as you can
No chance government can give PR based on protest. The integrity of the immigration system will fall apart. There are only so many spot for PR. The world is competitive, if you can’t compete or adapt, then that’s on you. Don’t ruin it for the people learning skilled trades, French, healthcare etc.
I live in Australia i came in 2007, i studied IT and then business management. But went back to india coz i was not able to apply for PR, but did not loose my hope i applied in 2014 again with all the new rules and got my PR, so do not protest that u are not eligible for PR now, you all are closing ur door on urself.
This is not backlash Your arguments are baseless Canada has delivered to you what was promised Now please obey the law and don’t play any emotional games
International students always says that community is jealous of them cause they bought cars ,cell phones.(..ASI APNE DAM TE AAYE AA). ..Bhena naal vyah kra nai.... NOW THEY ARE CRY BABIES....😢😢😢
Hun ah bhne shad maava naal viah krwa le te pakke ho jaan I dont mind .. Att v bhut chukki c ahna .. kise naal v bana k nai rakhi . asi idda hunde aa asssi ehn ker dinde aa hun beh gye na mooot di jaggg wang ... Bhande ch varroo gy pakka ajje v sambal jao , bande ban k low profile ho jao sayd GOVT kuj kar deve for being good ppl
Veere gussa na krna main kise de hakk vich ni kuj keh rhi vaise bheina nal viaah krvake ta lok bhut time pehla toh aa rhe ne uss time ta koi student v ni aunda c ethe study krn guru sahib de agge bhein nal laavan laike v Canada bhut aye ne sade nal de pind vicho hi ajj toh 25 years pehla, ikk kudi apde ske chache nal viaah krvake ayi ds baap te chache vich ki fark hunda jo lok Canada aun lyi apni ski bhein ni bakhsde, Eda de wrong way nal Canada aun toh changa banda Punjab hi reh lve oh v ijatt nal.tuhanu ki lgda iss cheej da hisaab kitaab maharaj ne Eda de loka toh nhi laina,,, eh v sach aa v apni Punjabi community de 80% lok cheap ne jo apdeya di latt khichde aa..white lok apneya nalo kite better ne
Students have no right to demand . Govt didn’t brought you here with PR dream . It’s yours visa restaurant agent & colleges . Why you don’t protest in front of these visa restaurant owners who lured you into this PR dream .
It is absolutely ridiculous for you to protest demanding Permanent Residency status from the government. Once you finish your studies, you are required to return as per the rules. Trudeau, Jagmeet, and the international students from Punjab are to be blamed for the current challenges Canada is facing. I do not see Canada recovering from this disaster zone anytime soon.
Unjustified demands by these students, if a student came here to do a diploma just after high school what skills that person will have? That Canada is obliged to give them PR? This was a big f up from Justin Trudeau and Jagmeet Singh. Parents in Punjab and Gujrat sending kids to just earn them 💵 that they did very well and now it’s time go back home.
Kujh nahi hona...koi protest naal nhi hona...eh punjab nhi ki tusi dharna laa lya te sarkar Manga mann le...you are foreign students , you don't have constitutional protection as equal to citizens...and 470 point vale v wage nu baige kehnde ne? And tenants nu tea-nuts kehnde ne? Es guest da English test lao..
@@Vishawsingh-m4l Veer rehn dio ahna nu ah samjan waali jaat hani . sanu kehnde ne puraane lagde bhut je asi khaiye tu puranya toh machde oo fer ? jado lott aounda ah puraniya nu use krke latt maar agge jande aa maada fer v purane nu kehnde ..Hun ah singh dekh le kidda taalu naal jeeb la k keh reha ki puranya nu benti aa saath dio, lol.. baad ch kehna asi apne dam te PR layi aa . Pehla MODI lamaa paya hun Trudeau paa liya . lol.
Permanent Residents or Citizens are paying income tax for 20, 30 or even 40 years, students can't compare with them , Government is responsible for every out come, it is failure of Canada Government
I agree about the citizens part. But most PRs have only been here in the last 5 years. What 20, 30, 40 years PRs are you talking about? That’s completely unfair.
PR cannot and must not be given to unskilled immigrants. If you bring skills in trades or medical, you are most welcome. Otherwise, study your Business Management course and go home
@@prabhjotsingh4738 not necessary. Just scoring high on IELTS does not mean you are skilled. Also, skills determine score, score does not determine skills.
Canada has, for decades, been in the top 10 of least racist and safest countries on planet Earth. Plus prosperous. Now there is a new negative spin that most Canadians do NOT deserve to a high degree. People must look at both sides. Since 2020, international students have been flocking to a educational system that many Canadians now feel was used by many of them as a loophole-to-immigration. Students utilizing schooling as a back-door (not front-door) ticket to living in Canada. Swarming a 50+ year tradition/system that was not not NOT designed to be about EVERY international student INSISTING on receiving Permanent Residency. Plus it was not designed to be primarily about students insisting on lengthy work permits (& spouse permits etc.). Canadians have clued in that Canada's post secondary education system has (in 5 years time) turned into what many are now jokingly calling EDUGRATION (an extreme not approved by everyday Canadians). What about Ghost Consulting that Canada told India to halt? Canadians want the $ greedy agents in other countries to stop marketing & lying to their own people about access to PR or citizenship … or accommodation/jobs … in places like Canada being relatively easy (to get). And for any people living in western countries to be ashamed of themselves if they're getting greedy too. Anyone doing things to make $ off of people's PR desires. At best, there is a 20% chance of gaining PR (better odds if you are health, trades, highly-needed-skills). What about all the YT videos that primarily Indian nationals have posted (for half a decade now including today) all advertising Canadian PR like they're selling a product? Advertising visas & permits too (all with the goal of staying in Canada). Videos not only posted hourly but also not in English or French. With very rare input from Canadian-born citizens. Are most international students truly scholars who came to Canada with enough $ to support themselves while STUDYING? Or economic migrants, who borrowed $ to buy their way closer to the head of the immigration line? To say all the students or their consultants back home have not been at times 'gaming' Canada's education programs to gain western PR or $ is ridiculous. Students have contributed to Canada's housing CRISIS because 98% conspire-to-outstay a temporary permit. This didn't exist 5 years ago. What about the IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? Fraud? False asylum claims? What about Canadian food banks & other charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages? What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by/for internationals? Home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply". Indian nationals buying local businesses then putting Indians only in key positions (while also drastically changing work practices that include working more hours for less money). Plus BC & Ontario are outlawing the Caste System. Then throw in the Sikh vs Hindu violence/extortions across Canada. Diasporas stirring up tribal hatreds (in Canada) … even though it all stems from their ancestral home. How can peace be found anywhere with this in play? Plus the Canadian government recently launched investigations in regards to foreign interference in Canadian elections, stemming from Asia continent. Canada also had to end flagpoling at the border because of international students. In recent years, Canadians everyday are having to worry about their automobile being stolen by auto theft rings. For just one small example of what Canadians see regarding this, research; "arrests in connection with $9.24M Toronto-area auto theft ring". Canadians are so so so not used to all this. So many, who have embraced multi-culturalism and immigration for decades are now VERY worried and fearful. All are praying it doesn't turn into great anger. Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Everyone I know is VERY happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian Canadians MOST upset (by all of this). Canadians are aware that some great students are going through hell. And know Canada is partially to blame which is awful. But Canada decides what needs to be done in Canada. Do you see Canadians protesting in other countries (that is not their own) making demands for themselves? No. Do Canadians now see primarily Indians protesting in Canada making demands? Yes. Protesting because they don't have the credentials to stay in Canada. And because rules designed to protect CANADA are not meeting their desires/demands. And why isn't there large crowds of African or Caribbean or Filipino or Chinese or Mexican etc., students protesting & waving their flags? They're in Canada too. Canada didn't have numerous PRIVATE 'diploma mills' until 40% of international students were from India. Coincidence? Mills that Canada is shutting down. AND the bulk of them are near Brampton Ontario and Surrey B.C.. Coincidence? If 36,000,000 Canadians travelled to India, since 2020, with the goal of being able to stay there permanently, that would raise India's population by 2.65%. Recent asylum seekers crossing into Canada… and especially international students... have raised Canada's population higher than 2.65%. More needing healthcare too (affecting waiting times etc.). Did international students and their families pay into Canadian taxes ALL their lives like domestic students have (earning cheaper tuition fees)? No. Did Canada force internationals to move to Canada as a STUDENT? No. Did Canada promise/guarantee PR? Or a job? No & no. Yet do they blame Canada when they can't get PR??? Canadians are now wondering; "What caused all this drama around international students to happen?". And when pondering this question they're thinking about Canada … and ONE other country. WHY???🤔
Long read but very well stated. All those point ate true and very concerning for Canadians reason why now especially Canadian whites are fed up with this "mass indian immigration" and what comes with that racism and the Canadian born east indians get put in the same category as the immigrants
Don’t compare with Canadian students Canada there home land just like your country India for you we are paying texes from 28 years so stop that nonsense.
Yeah they can stop coming new students but students who have already spent alot of money to come here and paid all taxes here. Then they should be permanent resident. You can stop inviting new students and what about 1million refugee who are getting money from gov ayleast students are giving money to Govt. No one saying about refugees, Lmia based people, Visitors, tourists
@@HarvinderSingh-ft3ij Nobody forced them to come here, nobody forced them to spend thousands of dollars on essentially USELESS degrees. You have to be responsible for your own actions. Some colleges 99% of Canadians never even heard of. Don't lie to yourself or to others - many comes to third rate colleges ONLY because they "may" get PR through some program. Most don't even qualify for the CRS score and should never even be in the country. The more you demand them to stay - the more the backlash. The more deaths, more depression, more hate. Cut your losses and go back. Most will be happier back home.
Racing cars. Hanging out in gangs, doing nonsense things on cars. Writing nonsense things in cars. It looks nonsense. If you tell them to behave and then they want to fight
Bro all students are not same please stop to blame on every international student, I also came here as an international student now I am Canadian citizen..specially gangs in big provinces like Ontario and Bc not all over Canada…
Well your government should have kept check on private colleges, could have higher requirements for visa, foresee future, but no They milk international students and cut funding of colleges, problem is changing conditions abruptly, rogue admissions and deceiving students@@Kaur_canada_ Lenient visa policy is to blame, no other countrie give spousal work visa to under graduate students etc. Mukdi gal hai Government just needs foreign currency but no responsibility, If a country gives asylum they provide Accommodation, Cad Government handing out visas they don't even have Accommodation, pumping in Immigrants (even so temporary) but not building up health care and other facilities. One line for the desi community with non students struggle (they milk these students as much as they can). On Government side it's cash inflow, savings on colleges grants, young labour force etc.
My demand is stop immigration all together for next 5 years ,situation is out of control in this country, it will next 7 to 10 years to wipe out all the mess trudeau has caused 😢
The problem is attitude of the students coming in. They just wanna show off everywhere and spoil the Canadian culture & values. These students have made impossible for families to go to movie theatre, restaurants and other places. They have forced Canadian to go against them. Even coffee shops environment has changed bcz of them. They have ruined each and everything. So no support for them.
bulaya gya. bhra kehne sadda bhejya c. SOP ch likh ke ke assi PR lai nahi challe. Ehna ne govt da ullu banaya kerke asli maksad PR c naa ke Study kerna. Per hun game puthi pai gayi aa.
Don’t compare international students fees with Canadian students because you chose it to come to Canada and Canadian students when they go for study other countries they have to pay like fee you pay and Canadian students’s parents pay too much tax to government If you want to fight sure but don’t compare with Canadian students
Canada has to bring more students giving good aducation for new students they waiting too now this is not fair with other students coming 2025 they want to study in Canada and making good future 🎉🎉🎉
I have been living in Canada over 50 years work Hard my first job was $2.25 hrs in union. Never collect any Unemployment or Mat.leave. Came as landed immigrant. These students came to study now they should go back where ever they came from. This govt. Ruined real Canada.
Ah donna ne lukk jana English media dekh k pichl baar ahne de bhai bandu di pant gili ho gyi c Gora dekh k . ahna de andar wala chor darn lagg janda English media dekh k
@@lovepunjab2738 patandar ehe india which sarkari jamadaar di post layi eligible naa Hon.... Par chahidi enna nu Canada di citizenship.... Maanjane ennane bhaande hi ne
completely illogical arguments. As per them govt. sara kuch chhd k int. students nu PR krn lg j, PR quota instead of demand, no. of international students te set kr lve. isn't it too much to ask? PR is given for the benefit of Canada, not for the person to whom it is given.
State is obliged to protect rights of citizens and permanent residents at first instance rather than temporary residents.This is fundamental jurisprudence of citizenship law.If you were made fool by immigration agents then that was your greed your faimly's greed to earn CAD.Buyer's must be aware of whatever they buy.
Every country gives priority to their citizens. Canada born students are finding difficult to find summer jobs since hundred thousands international students came in . So Canadians are making govt aware about this problem. Only Canadian Citizens have right to vote, international students do not have right to vote. So govt will listen to concerns of Canadian citizens otherwise they will lose in next election.
International Students pay equal Taxes and they do have have equal right but for a “period of time”. Yes it’s true Student visa is a route to PR however it’s never promised by Canadian government, it’s promised my agents who don’t represent government. Now 99% of students got lucky but these poor kids are very unlucky to be stuck in this mess. I do feel for them but I don’t think they understand that they will have to go back.
The same persons who could not or did not want to work in India are crying foul here. They forget that they came here for short term visas as guests (even as students). When the hosts (Canadian citizens) cannot sustain more guests, it is the responsibility of the guests to return to their home country both for the sake of their families and the citizens of the host country. A guest who complains becomes an irritant.
Government will soon be changing . They will tighten up these rules even more . These clowns will be leaving soon . They should increase the points from 475 to 1 Million.
If you feel that you are exploited in Canada, then you should return back. You have Canadian study and experience, and you will be better off back home. Provided you got this the right way.
please taken into consideration all the facs please help the students by giving PR their parents are in great tension All are requested to do needful for the upliftments of the students Some peoplr are commenting negatively please see their patents who have rxpend lacs pf Rupees please give PR to all the students
Why we do not have that crisis 10 yrs ago but when you come in not hundreds you guys coming thousands why you do not fight back home in india for job or study here you say your right do not compare yourself with kids live here nobody blame us it's your problems
Oh brhavo....apa pehla v fuddu bne c hun fer bani ja rahe aa...problem aa visitor visa te aa k kam kr rahe lok...thodian jobs oh khoo rahe aa...tusi hate apne sir te le rahe ho aap.... protest krna ta koi logic nal kro even though im not in canada but brothers side to baith k pta lgda hunda k match vich players ki galti kr rahe aa...jo k tusi kar rahe ho...sade v Australia vich rules hard ne but i can promise you it will back fire to all students.
Eh te ohi gal ho gai k mein bank ch paise jama keetay, sara bank mera 😂. PR is not a right. It is a privilege which deserving should get. 1000s of those who do not deserved have got it. This doesn't mean this should continue
Madam ..mai aus ton hai..last month govt ne work viza band kr ta ..jhere loka ne apni T.R pani si..oh vi ni payi..una ne student viza le leya...sirf last month vich 3 lac ton viza student viza peya Australia vich..nd kisi di ini himat ni..ithe protest kre ...agar krda oh deport ho jnda...
These are just idiots. In india in LPU university, fee for btech course for international students is between ₹170000 to ₹2,80,000 per semester while for indians it is between ₹1,20,000 to ₹1,90,000 per semester. This is just foolish to say that canada charging more fee from international students as compare to students born & brought up in canada.
Phala ta canada wala na 90000 PR kar dita bina kisa experience ta hun ki ho gya ahna nu v PR karo jina na ana time to Tex file v karda a.plese ahna nu v PR karo please 🙏🏻 g
Actually tr to pr program has spoiled everything. After that everyone thought casually about value of studies and pr. Now suddenly in night they made the changes. Everyone knows all can't get pr
What minority😂😂😂 any city any town you go you will see tons of Punjabis. You guys aren't anymore in visible minority list and may be this is one of the reason government wants to stop your sprawl. 1
Both are idiots. Their answers are not clear and baseless. As per their answers they came here on the perception created by general public, relations and friends. Government has never promised anything to anyone. Pathway does not mean a guarantee. They leave India without proper homework and thorough research. These guys are not accepting their mistakes, putting all the blame on government and others.
Crybabies doing what they can to be handed over everything without realizing they're no longer at their parents house where they'd throw a tantrum and parent will agree to their demands.
@Red FM Canada - while I do enjoy these programs I think you are fuelling the angry. If you wan to be more credible - you need to push back on some of their stupidity.
These rookies have no idea and understanding what they are talking about. Get someone mature and educated enough about the system requirements. Waste of time
It's not a government mistake. it's students' mistakes that they did not check properly before coming to canada, they trusted agents .agents picked their courses . these students have no knowledge about canadian culture and lifestyle .these young children's are not prepared for the hardship of this country .
Self employment canada government ne pr code vichon bahr he Kar dita .hallan k eh students bahut vadiya work Kar rahe Han.Government nu chahida hai k es category nu bhi pr vich add hona chahida hai.
Govt should set a criteria for only International students PR Pathway ( NOT for work permit VISA holders, they should be going back after their work permit expires ) ... Get 7 bands first if person cant get them, should be leaving country .. after this step they should be enrolled into top level university to get proper degree which can help Canada in the terms of any trade or skill likes of nurses, Dr or physios ect ect . Students should be responsible for all financial burden . Ask these 2 if this criteria sound good to them ? I am sur our Govt will not refuse ..
Visa den nu ehne khe kine c tuc ap hi bulae aa visa de de k koi wall cross kr k ni ayya main gl aaha va .. ehne visa den nu kha kine c jdo ta funding lai student use krgye
