‘Risk inflation’ in what our British government does very well and the Israeli government is even better. Keeps the population in fear. The world is beginning to see our selfish and greedy politicians for what they are. We all deserve better.
A sta rade predsjednici, premijeri i političari ostalih država???Kako jedan premijer ili predsjednik države drži u miru po nekoliko miliona stanovnistva??Obmana a, lažima, prijetnjama da nece biti penzije itd. Znaci strah!!!
It's good to see this "Unherd" interviewer getting called out on their distortions. They like to think of themselves as free thinkers, but here is another example of just how must they're thought is aligned with propaganda. Good on Mearsheimer.
There is no future for Israel. Free Palestine! ✌💯 Zionism is different from Judaism. Righteous Jews DO NOT support Zionism. Palestinians, including Muslims, Christians, and Jews, lived in peace altogether before Zionism. Zionism was the cause of war in Palestine, and therefore responsible for all losses from both sides. Occupation, apartheid, and genocide are undeniable. Their inhumanity is crystal clear and very well documented by human rights organizations, some of which are Jewish Israeli. Israelis are occupier colonialists of Palestine, therefore due to the international law have no right to self-defense, let alone right to offense.
There is no future for Israel. Free Palestine! ✌💯 Zionism is different from Judaism. Righteous Jews DO NOT support Zionism. Palestinians, including Muslims, Christians, and Jews, lived in peace altogether before Zionism. Zionism was the cause of war in Palestine, and therefore responsible for all losses from both sides. Occupation, apartheid, and genocide are undeniable. Their inhumanity is crystal clear and very well documented by human rights organizations, some of which are Jewish Israeli. Israelis are occupier colonialists of Palestine, therefore due to the international law have no right to self-defense, let alone right to offense.
Anti-Israeli government is not anti-Semitism. If I can recall right, Israel had been protesting against the Israeli government for ten months - before Oct.7, 2023 - because the Executive branch wanted to encroach on the Judiciary. The Israeli government, truly, has the most to gain from this Hamas-Palestinian civilians-Israeli government Massacre/ Genocide .. Nowadays, the Israeli government has violated the international law and basic human rights by killing children and civilians and committing ethnic cleansing. In the present context, Anti-Israeli government is more like, Anti-Genocide, yes? .. Oh, and if they can afford free healthcare and free education, I would say they can afford their own war crimes
💞The whole world is seeing the TRUTH about the illegal occupation. There is no turning back. The world is now knowing what Palestinians have been going through for 75+ years. Blessings, Everyone....
And the whole world knows that the western countries apply double standards and are hypocritical when talking of "rules based order" and the application of international law.. It reveals how ineffective Arab countries are, how the UN is controlled and that there are countries who avoid diplomacy and push for military means to achieve their objectives and that the west are not the good guys anymore and seek to control the world majority.
Exactly! Israel are actually the New N@Z!S since they use the same tactics as h!tler did by dehumanizing and committing genocide against the people in Palestine 🇵🇸
"The biggest insult to the memory of the holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to justify the genocide of the Palestinian people." - Norman Finkelstein
@@thedownunderverseFrom that part of the world, I hear words such as "settlements" and "settlers" and these "settlers" have an Army deployed to protect in that part they have "settled". It sounds like an occupation and looks like an occupation to me.
There is no future for Israel. Free Palestine! ✌💯 Zionism is different from Judaism. Righteous Jews DO NOT support Zionism. Palestinians, including Muslims, Christians, and Jews, lived in peace altogether before Zionism. Zionism was the cause of war in Palestine, and therefore responsible for all losses from both sides. Occupation, apartheid, and genocide are undeniable. Their inhumanity is crystal clear and very well documented by human rights organizations, some of which are Jewish Israeli. Israelis are occupier colonialists of Palestine, therefore due to the international law have no right to self-defense, let alone right to offense.
It never was about Hamas, this is a FAKE PRETEXT a monstruous lie that has 1 goal, the huge natural gas deposits discovered by British Gas off the coast of Palestine at the beginning of this millennium. worth about 500 billions !!! Should Israel carry this cruel war to the end and start drilling for natural gas, the family of the British Foreign Minister Rishi Sunak will earn 60 billion from it. The destruction of Nordstream is very obviousely a part of the same plan as well as everything that happend since they knew that there is a fortune in the ground of the sea that will can make Israel become a global player ..!!
"The biggest insult to the memory of the holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to justify the genocide of the Palestinian people." - Norman Finkelstein
IDF (Israeli DIAPER force) are going to far because whenever they’re defeated by the resistance group they take it out on the civilians which is women and children. They are modern day n@z! cowards
"The biggest insult to the memory of the holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to justify the genocide of the Palestinian people." - Norman Finkelstein
@@thedownunderverse You z!onist cowards are in a desperation mode since all of your lies are easily exposed. Your Israhelli Hasbara propaganda talking points is NOT working anymore. Israhelll is an n@z! colonial apartheid regime occupying Palestine 🇵🇸
Isrile is not a state or country. Palestine is country that occupied by zionist israil. Israile has no power/ ability to exist without USA and uk This old man lying in fornt of world.
They jail their own people for not joining the army, the loved ones of the hostages couldn't for weeks raise their voices out of fear of being jailed and tortured. As for the ones (locals, rabbis, doctors, journalists) speaking up for the Palestinians they are met with private and public humiliation, beatings, jail time and austricised from the community as a form of punishment. I'm sure if every Israeli was able to live a life at the other side of the wall they would know they are being lied to and they would empathize with their neighbours verses spew hatred.
What type of argument is this? You mean Palestinians the greatest threat to themselves?? They voted Hamas who was founded on hatred of Jews. Their goal is to literally kill all Jews. They celebrated/supported October 7 (70% Percent of them). Hamas is maximising civilian deaths by so many ways, including their decision to break ceasefire 2x, not to release the hostages, firing rockets from civilian zones, etc.
1. Nobody jail people who doesn’t go to army 2. Nobody is afraid to be jailed and tortured wtf are you on 3. Supporting the palestinians ja not the same as supporting hamas People who support hamas and are inside of israel will get jailed its not about supporting palestine “innocents” 4. You completely ignore the fact that palestinians celebrated on dead israel bodies in october 7, the f$cking celebrated it, why would israelis sympathize with them? 70%+ of gaza wish to destroy all of israel so any israeli who sympathies with them are sick Yes there is innocent in gaza but all they can blame is their sick hamas government who love to kill israelis more than they love their children
*There are saheeh hadees reports which indicate that faith and goodness are greater in ash-Shaam(Greater Syria-Palastine) than in other lands.* It was narrated that Abu’d-Dardaa’ said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Whilst I was sleeping, I saw the pillar of the Book being taken from beneath my head, and I thought that it was being taken away, so I followed it with my gaze, and it was taken to ash-Shaam. Verily faith, when tribulations come, will be in ash-Shaam.” Narrated by Imam Ahmad in al-Musnad (36/62); classed as saheeh by the commentators on al-Musnad. This is similar to the words of the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him): “The heartland of the believers is ash-Shaam.” {Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa (27/42)} It was narrated that Ibn Hawaalah said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “This matter will end with you becoming massed troops: troops in ash-Shaam, troops in Yemen, and troops in Iraq.” Ibn Hawaalah said: Choose for me, O Messenger of Allah, if I should live to see that. He said: “You should go to ash-Shaam, for it is Allah’s chosen land, to which He will gather His chosen slaves. But if you refuse, then go to Yemen and draw water from your ponds, for Allah has promised me that He will take care of ash-Shaam and its people.” {Narrated by Abu Daawood (2483).} This goodness will remain among them, if Allah wills, until the end of time, until Allah, may He be exalted, destroys the Dajjaal and his followers at their hands, when the Messiah ‘Eesaa ibn Maryam comes down and leads the believers in the fight against the Dajjaal. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (r) said: The Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) highlighted the distinct character of the people of ash-Shaam by noting that they will continue to comply with the commands of Allah until the end of time, and that the victorious group will remain among them until the end of time. This is speaking of an ongoing matter that will remain with them, that they will be numerous and strong. This description does not apply to anyone in the Muslim world except the people of ash-Shaam… knowledge and faith are still present in that land, and whoever fights in that land to support the faith will be victorious and will be granted divine help. End quote from Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa (4/449). It was narrated that Abu Umaamah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: I said: O Prophet of Allah, what was the beginning of your affair? He said: “The prayer of my father Ibraaheem and the glad tidings of ‘Eesaa. My mother dreamt that there came out of her light by which the palaces of ash-Shaam were illuminated.” Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Silsilat al-Ahaadeeth as-Saheehah (1545). Ibn Katheer (may Allah have mercy on him) said in his Tafseer (1/444): The fact that ash-Shaam is singled out in conjunction with his light indicates that his religion and his teachings will abide in Bilaad ash-Shaam. Hence at the end of time, ash-Shaam and its people will be a stronghold for Islam, and in that land ‘Eesaa ibn Maryam will come down. (End quote.) With regard to the lack of religious commitment in some eras, this may happen for some wise purpose that Allah, may He be exalted, wills. But this does not cancel out the general principle. In some hadiths, the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) indicated that the people of ash-Shaam may become corrupt, and if that happens, then its impact will affect the entire ummah. It was narrated from Mu‘aawiyah ibn Qurrah that his father said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “If the people of ash-Shaam become corrupt, then there is no goodness in you, but a group of my ummah will remain victorious, not harmed by those who let them down, until the Hour begins.” (Narrated by at-Tirmidhi (2192).
"There has never been an occupation in history where the occupier presented itself as the only victim in the world. This enables the said occupier to live in peace while committing unspeakable atrocities against the occupied without the feeling of guilt. "
@@DavidPurcell-gq6id You think you are talking to a stupid American huh? I'm well travelled, well read & know the issues around the world.. Who controls the borders & allow passage of people, goods & services? Who controls the water, electricity, phone signal etc? You can't govern WB or Gaza when you don't have control of your borders, water, electricity, communications etc..
@@DavidPurcell-gq6id Nope, it's under occupation. Palestine is not a sovereign state but, a Zionist occupied territory since 1967. Palestine has no army as countries should. Palestine is not represented in the UN as a state. All it's exits and entrances (air, land and sea) are controlled by the Zionist Regime. Water, electricity, fuel, food and aids are also controlled by Tel Aviv. The IDF can enter or leave Palestinian territories at any given time because, Palestine has no sovereig rights or powers to reject.
@@DavidPurcell-gq6id Israel has occupied Palestinian since 1948. Gaza’s food supply, medicines, electricity, water, travel is ALL controlled by Israel!! Saying Hamas governs Gaza is like saying inmates run Super Max prisons here in America where their locked down 23hrs a day & monitored 24 hrs a day.
@@KJ-yises And your response to Prof. Mearsheimer's argument that Hamas is a resistance movement, inside Greater Israel, acting against the oppression of that is is... what?
There is no future for Israel. Free Palestine! ✌💯 Zionism is different from Judaism. Righteous Jews DO NOT support Zionism. Palestinians, including Muslims, Christians, and Jews, lived in peace altogether before Zionism. Zionism was the cause of war in Palestine, and therefore responsible for all losses from both sides. Occupation, apartheid, and genocide are undeniable. Their inhumanity is crystal clear and very well documented by human rights organizations, some of which are Jewish Israeli. Israelis are occupier colonialists of Palestine, therefore due to the international law have no right to self-defense, let alone right to offense.
@@KJ-yisesCan you think for yourself, or do you always just repeat establishment propaganda so you feel informed while circle jerking in the comfort of your social bubble’s confirmation bias?
Hollywood "Nazis", that is. The Germans of the REAL history simply wanted them out of their OWN country. A perfectly reasonable desire to have. The big H never happened, period. On the other hand, the demonic Nazi has indeed existed -- in countless Hollywood productions since the wars end. And yes, Israel does seem to be doing everything it can to imitate the behavior of those celluloid and digital Nazis.
My God! Who is this honest man? Is there a truth speaking man still alive in this hypocrite world?!! Though not a single baby will be saved with this truth - yet hats off.
John Mearsheimer I believe he was in hot water before because he wrote a book called the Israel Lobby, which criticize them. This guy knows what he's talking about. Basically Israel's reasoning is stupid, they are committing a genocide to prevent a Holocaust or so they want us to believe. But we all know if that was the case, why would Hamas want to trade hostages instead of executing them?
Definitely not this man. His arguments are weak. His argument is basically “Israel is a stronger state a thus has no right to self-defence”. What a bs.
@@karmaakabane4516 That is not his argument. Israel is an oppressive state; resistance to it is a right and a duty. Did Nazi Germany have a right to kill those who resisted it? Hannah Arendt didn't think so.
@@karmaakabane4516 listen to what is actually being said rather that what you perceive it to be. There is a lot of incorrect information that was shared with the world following the 7 October incident. Fact, approximately 1200 people died, hostages were taken and Hamas broke through the Israel defence. However, what was reported by the Israeli government of the incident and what happened is widely debated by many scholars across the globe. Mark Ragev admitted in an interview with Mahedi Hassan that Israel thought 1400 people died originally but then they reduced that figure to 1200 when they found out that about 200 Hamas fighters were amongst the dead and burnt. Big question, who burnt the Hamas fighters? Also the claims about burnt babies in ovens have now been debunked. Many more examples of the lies and exaggerated information given by Israel which proves that they can’t be relied upon to tell the truth
@@karmaakabane4516 that's not actually his argument but nice try. His argument was about the notion behind WHY Israel's bombing Gaza indiscriminately. In Israel's own words, they are doing so in order to eliminate Ham*s. Well the questions follows, why can't they eliminate Ham*s using a more controlled and tactical method? The Israel government would say they need to act fast because Ham*s would eradicate all of the Jewish people if they don't eliminate them first. Here John Mearsheimer challenged that reasoning about Ham*s having the capability to enact upon another hol*caust which they obviously don't. Hamas only advantage over the IDF is their knowledge of their terrain, obviously because that's their land, same thing happened in Afghanistan. Mr Mearsheimer is right, the reasoning is quite absurd because Israel the one that possess the military might, not Ham*s. Israel's just using those type of reasoning so they can continue to bomb Gaza to expel the Palestinian so they can have the land for themselves.
I don't know how exactly killing of more 1000 innicent israelians can be justified, that "Hamas is not a state". To kill innocents and being punished you just have to have a gun and someone you damaged. Like Israel should decide: Hamas killed our children, surely let's build them a state, so nice people. Morons.
Really? Hamas is soo weak. It fired 5,000 rockets on Israel just on October 7th? It managed to deceive “the most powerful military” in the world in 16 years and brutally murdered, raped and tortured kids, women, men. 1200 of deliberate and evil murders! J His argument is weak. Yes, Israel is more powerful than Hamas/Palestinians but doesn’t mean they don’t have right to protect their own people/right to self defence. It’s like saying that because I’m richer, taller, more muscular, or whatever I should allow someone who is shorter, poorer and in bad shape to attack me because I’m “stronger” or more “powerful”. Makes no sense. There were two ceasefires already and it was Hamas who broke it 2x. It’s Hamas who put their own people at risk, it’s Hamas who is murdering their own people. It’s government’s responsibly to care for their people but Hamas sacrifices their own people for money and spread of anti-semitism and hatred. I’m not saying that Israeli government is perfect or that violent settlers are without fault. But it’s wrong to say that Palestinians are victims and Israelis are bad guys. You thinking that the whole issue can be summed up in 3 minutes is just plain stupid.
I love John Mearshimer. Such an excellent point. Although barbaric, senseless and tragic as the attacks on October 7th that killed some 1,200 Israeli’s, Israel’s sovereignty as a state was never the least bit threatened and still has continued to not be. They keep using the terms Nazi, Holocaust, Genocide but the Jews are under no serious threat of ANY of these things by Hamas. They have a 3 billion dollar machine that intercepts their rockets from the middle of the sky. Hamas has no chance of actually eliminating Israel, regardless of however much they wish to. This is not an attack from a distant land. This is RESISTANCE.
That 1200 Israeli numbers were fake and it turned out that even the majority of the actual numbers were israHELL diaper force and armed settlers and not civilians.
Fascism is an idea, and ideas travel fast. The far-right ruling coalition in Israel is engaging in fascist actions, behavior and rhetoric. It could come to your doorstep one day. @@talmudovsky
@@talmudovsky the idea can only travel to Israel as it is Israel that came stole their land, homes and their olive farms. Palestinians in Gaza are the descendants of refugees of the Nakba. 7 Oct has happened to Palestinians since 70 years ago. The idea of Hamas is only aimed at Israel to free itself and the Palestinians from occupation and injustice and it is propaganda to make it seems like it is a threat to the world. The Israeli propaganda machine has lief to us many times even when we could see the truth with our own eyes. You are one of them. It happened on your doorstep as this is how you have been treating the Palestinians inhumane so Hamas did the same. I see no great differences between IDF and the settlers with Hamas. IDF shoots unarmed civilians, destroyed homes, shoots and bombs that tear apart and crush people with it. The only difference is that Israeli military has tanks jets and funds and weapons that are directly shipped from the usa and he Uk.
Israel was given State status because of Western atrocities against Jews. Accordingly, it stands to reason that Palestinians surviving unprecedented (IDF & US sponsored) Humanitarian Crimes, DESERVE a internationally recognised State in their Homelands. As regards Israeli nuclear power, the IAEA needs investigating it in earnest, not just Iran!
"The biggest insult to the memory of the holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to justify the genocide of the Palestinian people." - Norman Finkelstein
The League of Nations recognized that Eretz Yisroel was the homeland of the Jewish People in 1922. Long before the Holocaust. The UN Resolution 181( The Partition Plan of 1947) offered both parties a state. The Arabs refused and chose war. In 2000 and 2008, Israel 🇮🇱 again offered the Arab leadership everything it wanted including East Jerusalem ( 2008) but again they refused. Could it be that the Arabs want to replace the Jewish State with a Arab state? Israel 🇮🇱 is not a party to the Nuclear Poliferation Treaty.
He is actually very stupid, delusional or someone’s puppet. His argument is basically “Since Israel is a stronger state they don’t have right to defend themselves from people who what to brutally burden them” what a BS. It’s like saying that if someone is richer, more muscular and roller they have no right to defend themselves from someone who is complete opposite who is pointing gun at them.
@@thedownunderverse You z!onist cowards are in a desperation mode since all of your lies are easily exposed. Your Israhelli Hasbara propaganda talking points is NOT working anymore. Israhelll is an n@z! colonial apartheid regime occupying Palestine 🇵🇸
Sir, please educate Piers Morgan. He labels everyone who calls Hamas a resistance movement a terrorist supporter. Please educate him for the sake of all who can see the truth.
What's uh... what were their methods again for "resistence" again? Oct 7th happened so long ago and I didn't want to see my angelic resistence fighters in social media videos for some reason.
@@mrfrankie5479what methods were u programmed to believe hamas used on 7 October. Coz the beheaded babies, babies on ovens, babies hanging on clothes lines, pregnant women with her stomach cut open, people bound and burned, rapes have all been debunked. Infact when asked about it the one kept saying they heard it from someone else but nobody could ever confirm or provide evidence of these claims. But from investigations, which u can see by max Blumenthal on the real news network. Of those killed two thirds were military. And the one third, most killed by idf helicopters. This was also reported by Israeli newspaper Haaretz based on Israeli police investigation. As well as witness report Yasmin porat. So what's ur claim and sources for the claim?
Israel don't want one state nor two state solution, they Israel don't want both, they just want a land(west bank) and east Jerusalem not it people(Palestinian), Israel don't care about Palestinian, they saw them as a treated, even with 750k and 300k expulsion and thousand of Palestinian be genocide, yet they still cant kick them out and cleanse them, 2 million in Israel, 3.2 million in West Bank, and 2.2 million in Gaza, that why they kick them slowly2, demolish their house, stealing their land, old century houses, uproot their olive tree, and harrassed them, even many be killed by IDF(true name = IOF) and illegal Jewish settler, If Israel go one state solution today even in future, even without 2.2 million or 2.3 million, Israel will add 3.2 or in future maybe 4 million Palestinian, it will be Bi-National state, and also possible have Arab prime minister, today Israel without West Bank and Gaza, Arab made up 20%. 2 million 45 thousand Arab, 15% are Arab Muslim rest 5 are Christian, Bahai and Druze(both Bahai and Druze are deviant sect or stem from Islam). Jews made up 79% of total population, 1% others like Armenians, Greek, Assyrian, Arameans, Turkish, and Circassian, Around 7.2 million Jews, if today Gaza+West Bank Palestinian be add to Israel, 2+2.2+3.2 Million will made up 7.4 million Palestinian vs 7.2 million Jews, it will made Israel will all Palestine territory annexed to have Palestinian Arab Prime Minister and President, that not included if 6 million descendant of refugee allow to be return to their native village, town and cities. even just half or quarter of 6 million today, around 2 million or even just 1 million, it will made Israel Arab, just like population in Jordan 10 million -12 million Arab, that why Israel don't want 1 state don't want 2 state, far to want refugee return.
*There are saheeh hadees reports which indicate that faith and goodness are greater in ash-Shaam(Greater Syria-Palastine) than in other lands.* It was narrated that Abu’d-Dardaa’ said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Whilst I was sleeping, I saw the pillar of the Book being taken from beneath my head, and I thought that it was being taken away, so I followed it with my gaze, and it was taken to ash-Shaam. Verily faith, when tribulations come, will be in ash-Shaam.” Narrated by Imam Ahmad in al-Musnad (36/62); classed as saheeh by the commentators on al-Musnad. This is similar to the words of the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him): “The heartland of the believers is ash-Shaam.” {Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa (27/42)} It was narrated that Ibn Hawaalah said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “This matter will end with you becoming massed troops: troops in ash-Shaam, troops in Yemen, and troops in Iraq.” Ibn Hawaalah said: Choose for me, O Messenger of Allah, if I should live to see that. He said: “You should go to ash-Shaam, for it is Allah’s chosen land, to which He will gather His chosen slaves. But if you refuse, then go to Yemen and draw water from your ponds, for Allah has promised me that He will take care of ash-Shaam and its people.” {Narrated by Abu Daawood (2483).} This goodness will remain among them, if Allah wills, until the end of time, until Allah, may He be exalted, destroys the Dajjaal and his followers at their hands, when the Messiah ‘Eesaa ibn Maryam comes down and leads the believers in the fight against the Dajjaal. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (r) said: The Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) highlighted the distinct character of the people of ash-Shaam by noting that they will continue to comply with the commands of Allah until the end of time, and that the victorious group will remain among them until the end of time. This is speaking of an ongoing matter that will remain with them, that they will be numerous and strong. This description does not apply to anyone in the Muslim world except the people of ash-Shaam… knowledge and faith are still present in that land, and whoever fights in that land to support the faith will be victorious and will be granted divine help. End quote from Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa (4/449). It was narrated that Abu Umaamah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: I said: O Prophet of Allah, what was the beginning of your affair? He said: “The prayer of my father Ibraaheem and the glad tidings of ‘Eesaa. My mother dreamt that there came out of her light by which the palaces of ash-Shaam were illuminated.” Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Silsilat al-Ahaadeeth as-Saheehah (1545). Ibn Katheer (may Allah have mercy on him) said in his Tafseer (1/444): The fact that ash-Shaam is singled out in conjunction with his light indicates that his religion and his teachings will abide in Bilaad ash-Shaam. Hence at the end of time, ash-Shaam and its people will be a stronghold for Islam, and in that land ‘Eesaa ibn Maryam will come down. (End quote.) With regard to the lack of religious commitment in some eras, this may happen for some wise purpose that Allah, may He be exalted, wills. But this does not cancel out the general principle. In some hadiths, the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) indicated that the people of ash-Shaam may become corrupt, and if that happens, then its impact will affect the entire ummah. It was narrated from Mu‘aawiyah ibn Qurrah that his father said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “If the people of ash-Shaam become corrupt, then there is no goodness in you, but a group of my ummah will remain victorious, not harmed by those who let them down, until the Hour begins.” (Narrated by at-Tirmidhi (2192).
@@admirosmani3765Hamas caused it because Hamas doesn’t give a fuck about their own people but money and spread of hatred. Evidence: 1) Hamas has a goal to eradicate all Jews. They were created out of hatred. 2) Despite knowing that Israel is more powerful state with a history of ethnic cleansing they chose to use all the donations they have received for weapons, their own pockets and October 7th. Foolishly thinking that Israel won’t defend itself. But they are not foolish, they did it deliberately sacrificing their own people for clout, money and hatred. 3, They maximise civilian deaths, they broke ceasefire 2x already, they don’t want to surrender and release the rest of hostages.
@@admirosmani3765 What about all the others saved by Israeli warning of impending war? What about all the civilians saved from starvation because Israel allowed food trucks through while Hamas took food banks for themselves? While 18000 deaths is undeniable, Israel had its hand in preventing a lot more if it had the same "tactics" Hamas. Fuck it, if Israel had the same tactics as Hamas they would have dropped a nuke first without even warning. Something you "pro-palestinians" seem to ignore or be in denial of.
Not finally, John Meirsheimer has been around and soeaking on the middle east , Ukraine, northern Ireland for decades. If only a few politicians has the sense to listen millions of lives might have been saved, americans might have had healthcare and a better infrastructure and israel might have been curbed or at least more mental health facilities might have opened for them.
yeah a guy in flip flop destroyd a whole tanks wich is supposed the most advanced army Israel is isn’t greats army it’s an absolute joke run by man children
With all the butt-kissing the USA is doing with Israel one cannot help but wonder, "What carrot has Israel dangling above our heads? There's something there. I can feel it.
Wow, just wow. When Mearsheimer breaks it down the way he did, that Hamas is a merely a disenfranchised (my take) group within Greater Israel - which is a state - and therefore their actions constitute a resistance movement, his argument is so profound in its simplicity and factuality that Freddie Sayer should have no rebuttal whatsoever if he had a brain at all. What a total schooling in logic from John. Absolute respect.
Watch the whole interview. Again and again the interviewer is politely and patiently schooled in the elements of intelligent discourse, having got it wrong over and over.
It never was about Hamas, this is a FAKE PRETEXT a monstruous lie that has 1 goal, the huge natural gas deposits discovered by British Gas off the coast of Palestine at the beginning of this millennium. worth about 500 billions !!! Should Israel carry this cruel war to the end and start drilling for natural gas, the family of the British Foreign Minister Rishi Sunak will earn 60 billion from it. The destruction of Nordstream is very obviousely a part of the same plan as well as everything that happend since they knew that there is a fortune in the ground of the sea that will can make Israel become a global player ..!!
Sounds like some out of minded professor trying to solve some 5th grade problem. It's not 5th grade, there is no meaning in exact definitions. There are thousands of people suffering on both sides.
It’s not Hamas against Israel, it is resistance against occupation. The end of X occupation = the end of Y resistance. Who faces whom is beyond the point, Isreal chose to occupy Palestine, the resistance wasn’t given any other choice.
You, like many others, are being deceived. There is no occupation, whether deemed illegal or not. This issue is a matter of the specific application of international law, which has been maliciously obscured from public discourse.
loll what a hallucination. Israel did not "conquer" Palestine, you cannot conquer a country that never existed. In the UN's 1947 partition plan, the Jews received half of the land and established a state on it, the Arabs chose war. The Palestinians use the UN quite a lot in their narrative, so it's appropriate that you don't be hypocritical and accept that partition plan too. The struggle here is religious really (just listen to the Palestinians themselves) . Between Muslims and Jews, but why would you know.. you live here?
@@hanna319 The last laugh is the best one. I contend that there is common gross misconception regarding Israel’s rights over several territories, including the Gaza Strip, City of Jerusalem, and Judea and Samaria (also known as the West Bank) and regarding rights of Israeli citizens to inhabit these territories. Israel’s 1948 declaration of independence was based on the 1947 GA partition resolution 181(II). This resolution, not being under Chapter 7 of the UN Charter, was not legally binding. Furthermore, it was outright rejected by the Arab League, rendering it null and void. The establishment of the State of Israel is based on the universal principle of international law known as 'uti possidetis juris,' which states that newly-formed sovereign states should retain the internal borders of their preceding dependent area before independence. In this case, it includes the borders of the British Mandate, encompassing the Gaza Strip, the City of Jerusalem, and the West Bank. This law has been applied numerous times in the last two centuries to provide a legal foundation for newly created states across the globe. In the Middle East, it was used in the creation of states such as Syria, Lebanon and Jordan. It is uniformly applicable in the case of the State of Israel's independence claim. As a result of the Arab invasion in 1948, the Gaza Strip, West Bank, and East Jerusalem were belligerently and illegally occupied by Egypt and Jordan according to international law. The Jewish population was ethnically cleansed, and Jewish cemeteries and synagogues were desecrated or destroyed. In the 1967 war, instigated by Egypt and Jordan, Israel re-claimed these territories. With the exception of the Golan Heights, Israel has never had the need or desire to expand its territory beyond the British Mandate for Palestine. On the contrary, Israel unilaterally left Gaza and entered into the Oslo Accords as a provisional treaty aimed at the creation of a Palestinian state on territories rightfully owned by Israel. I hope you now realize that you have been lied to about "illegal occupation of Palestinian land", "evil colonial settlers", etc. You have opportunity to research and, if you wish, rebut my statement. You are correct in saying that the conflict has deep religious roots. I am fully prepared to address your considerations in that area as well.
I can quickly screenshot Hamas's charter to prove you otherwise. Article 13 There is no negotiated settlement possible. Jihad is the only answer. The Preamble to the 1988 Charter stated: ″Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam invalidates it, just as it invalidated others before it″.[citation needed] It emphasizes the importance of jihad for the Palestinian question, adding that "initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and vain endeavors."[45] The charter also states that Hamas is humanistic, and tolerant of other religions as long as they "stop disputing the sovereignty of Islam in this region".[46] The Charter adds that "renouncing any part of Palestine means renouncing part of the religion [of Islam]" The original, 1988 version of the charter emphasize four main themes:[47] Destroying Israel and establishing an Islamic theocracy in Palestine is essential;[47] Unrestrained jihad is necessary to achieve this;[47] Negotiated resolutions of Jewish and Palestinian claims to the land are unacceptable;[47] Historical anti-semitic tropes that reinforce the goals.[47] The Covenant proclaims that Israel will exist until Islam obliterates it, and jihad against Jews is required until Judgement Day. Compromise over the land is forbidden. The documents promote holy war as divinely ordained, reject political solutions, and call for instilling these views in children.[47] The updated 2017 charter appeared to moderate Hamas's position by stating that Hamas is anti-Zionist, but retains the goal of eliminating Israel.[47] Its claim that it is no longer antisemitic has been refuted numerous times due to the actions of Hamas as well as the statements of its leadership including Fathi Hamad who has publicly called for the killing of Jews Please reply so I know you read this rather than ignored it. I took the effort to copy paste what is not a fucking secret to anyone, I atleast expect you to read it and reply.
I have learned so much intellectual thinking listening to calm rational John Mearshimer. Quite a few people can benefit by listening and reading widely; then think by your own self just for a few minutes.
How do you think there Is going to be any freedom if you don't write 'free' In capital letters ? Or don't put flags at the beginning of your post ? You must be more thoughtful & serious with your aspirations.
He understands this but he's talking in realistic current terms where the Israeli occupation is in fact currently in a position where it does control the region. In other videos he does acknowledge the land is rightfully Palestinian.
@@thedownunderverse You z!onist cowards are in a desperation mode since all of your lies are easily exposed. Your Israhelli Hasbara propaganda talking points is NOT working anymore. Israhelll is an n@z! colonial apartheid regime occupying Palestine 🇵🇸
All the Palestinians ever WANTED AND DESERVES IS TO LIVE IN PEACE IN THEIR OWN STATE AND LAND.WHICH THEY HAVE LEGAL RIGHTS TO AND DESERVE..WITH NO ZIONISTS AROUND THEM CLOSE TO THEM AND INTERFERING IN PALESTINE BUSINESS AND AFFAIRS PERIOD
@@mrfrankie5479 you need to enlighten yourself and watch what Scott Ritter has to say.l Palestinians ruled themselves without interference from Israel their Never would have been any conflict .why do the Palestinians have to adhere to rules, regulations and Laws the Zionists enforce upon them..Zionists ARE THE OPPRESSION .WOULD YOU LIKE SOMEONE ENTERING YOUR HOME LET YOU OCCUPY YOUR OWN BACKYARD AND STILL HAVE RESTRICTIONS AND RULES YOU AS THE OWNER SHOULD RECOGNIZE AND FOLLOW TO EVERY LETTER.AND WHEN YOU DON'T YOU GET THROWN OUT OR IMPRISONED.
It's facile. There are very few regimes that even come close to what nazism represented. They definitely do not look like Israel - even the current Israel controlled by the Israeli right-wing.
Looks fairly appropriate from my perspective. As I learn more about Israeli society I wonder though if it isn’t a beast entirely of their own making through state propaganda, mandatory military conscription and an ethno-theocratic state.
Great respect and credit to Professor John Mearsheimer who as one the World's greatest leading experts in Geopolitical Sciences has always spoken out about and provided true real-world perspectives on both the Ukraine - Russia and the Palestine - Israeli conflicts over the years.... In particular to highlight the reality, hypocritical and duplicitous faces of US, UK & EU Governments & mainstream Western Media Channels in supporting and whipping-up continuous warmongering rhetoric for their own personal political and financial gains, not for the World or humanity.
He's a man who wants his homeland to burn down to ashes, that's why he supports Putin and against Israel. It's okay, every country has people who hate their own homeland.
The one part that he got so incredibly wrong, was saying that Hamas is occupying part of greater Israel- that's what Israel desires, to take the whole of Gaza, and expand Israel.
I think that with "Greater Israel" Mearshemir refers to Israel + Gaza + West Bank. Or, he refers to the much greater "Greater Israel" that would comprise parts of Lebanon, Siria, Jordan, Egypt, Iraq. The first is like already in place, they rule those lands in practice, the only reason Gaza and the West Bank still are not part of Israel officially is because there are too many Arabs in them. Israel needs to drive them away first, otherwise there would be too many Israeli Arabs.
How far is the gentleman being interviewed telling the truth? Is Gaza really part of "greater Israel"? Is this a figurative expression referring to Israel's control of Gaza and the West Bank? Doesn't the international community consider Israel's occupation of these lands illegal? Shouldn't terms like "greater Israel" be avoided, given what is at stake?
Israel is the Third Riech here in every action it's taken on the Palestinian people since 1948. When Israel bias is dropped that becomes an imperial fact.
If Israel the the desires of the THIRD RIECH! Gaza wouldn't exist 😂🤣 Hundreds of Palestinians who worked in Israel EVERY DAY safe in Israel RIGHT NOW!!! BECAUSE, they didn't know about the attack.
@@RobespierreThePoof Historical perspective shows that the Zionists learned their ideas and their tactics from Nazi Germany and from apartheid South Africa. What are the Gaza Strip and the West Bank if not bantustans - as any two-state solution would be?
this is mainstream propagandised though versus an intelligent analysis of the facts and reveals the laziness and shallowness of Freddy's reading of the opposing sides. motivations.
UnHerd is an odd channel I think. It did a subtly slanted but very 'anti' vid on the big pro-Palestine march last month, which mis-represented it completely. My wife was there & said it was nothing but peaceful & life-affirming, with many, many families & small kids
Yasmin Porat Speaks Out: Israeli Hostage Contradicts Official Account. Yasmin Porat spoke in an exclusive interview about the events she witnessed. Amid the chaos of heavy crossfire and the ominous sound of tank shells exploding, Porat made a shocking claim: Israeli forces didn't spare anyone in their path. "They eliminated everyone, including the hostages," Porat said during her conversation with Israeli radio. Her account paints a picture where the hostages, instead of being rescued, were caught in a deadly crossfire instigated by the very forces meant to save them. The event turned from a potential rescue operation to an unfortunate catastrophe where lives from both sides were lost.
Gaza is not part of “Greater Israel”. And to call Hamas a “resistance movement” after October 7 makes me even more inclined to dismiss this man as a bit of a fool. He gets Russia/Ukraine wrong, and now he is stumbling about with Israel/Hamas.
