Тёмный

√(-3)•√(-12) ≠ ±6 

Mr H Tutoring
Подписаться 306 тыс.
Просмотров 15 тыс.
50% 1

When given a square root of a negative number, one must first "take out" the negative number first before multiplying the numbers.
By definition, square roots of 36 are ±6. But when we use the radical sign, √, we only use the principal root or the positive root. Meaning √36 is only equal to +6.

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 70   
@MegaSquiff
@MegaSquiff 11 месяцев назад
You are VERY good, please don’t stop doing these things…a big thanks to you.
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring 11 месяцев назад
Will do! Thank you
@formulanova12
@formulanova12 10 месяцев назад
He said “don’t stop”, then you said “will do”, so you will stop or not? 😅
@schwobelabibalbol
@schwobelabibalbol Год назад
Interestingly, in Germany, we'd always have to say ±6 in exams for example. It think it's just standardized differently here and in the US.
@k.o.hakala2112
@k.o.hakala2112 10 месяцев назад
I'm confused with the "radical sign", but I'm sure it's trivial so I'll go Google it now
@k.o.hakala2112
@k.o.hakala2112 10 месяцев назад
And it's not trivial: It's a necessity around complex numbers that prevents us from proving that 1 = -1 from the definition of the imaginary unit i
@schwobelabibalbol
@schwobelabibalbol 10 месяцев назад
@k.o.hakala2112 I know it has a necessity, I just said that I used to have to write both "answers", but that changed.
@k.o.hakala2112
@k.o.hakala2112 10 месяцев назад
Yeah and what I said was untrue, it's to put away with discontinuities in the complex plane.
@schwobelabibalbol
@schwobelabibalbol 10 месяцев назад
@@k.o.hakala2112 Ok
@richardgratton7557
@richardgratton7557 Год назад
There are 2 numbers that multiply to 36, they are +6 and -6 But the square root of 36 is +6 (the positive principal root). Perhaps this way of putting it is clearer.
@vidya014
@vidya014 10 месяцев назад
Then quare root of what is -6?
@lookingforahookup
@lookingforahookup 10 месяцев назад
6 and -6 don't multiply to 36
@lookingforahookup
@lookingforahookup 10 месяцев назад
@@vidya014 Thank you. Exactly
@richardgratton7557
@richardgratton7557 10 месяцев назад
@@lookingforahookup let me clear that up for you….6^2 and (-6)^2 both equal 36. You’re welcome 😑
@3Black.1Red
@3Black.1Red 7 месяцев назад
@@lookingforahookup He meant "-6 and -6" not "6 and -6". The latter is not a square root so that's obviously not what he meant.
@蔡木章
@蔡木章 4 месяца назад
Very nice, thanks
@taraking6472
@taraking6472 11 месяцев назад
Thank you.
@theefurkan0
@theefurkan0 Год назад
I would be very happy if there was a Turkish translation in the videos.
@ketantravels3052
@ketantravels3052 8 месяцев назад
Respected sir, The way you are manipulating maths and doubts is really appreciative, It has helped me a lot I wish I could touch your foot
@aram5642
@aram5642 Год назад
Something tells me that my comment for another video was heard and the sqrt explanation came along. Thank you anyway.
@PremjitTalwar
@PremjitTalwar 5 месяцев назад
I studied at MIT (graduated in 1972). We always learnt the radical sign to mean +/- and not just the + sign. Since when did this convention change?
@sjaomsshiqkq
@sjaomsshiqkq Год назад
I want to thank you, sir. Recently, I was studying complex numbers and came across an interesting concept. We know that i is equal to the square root of -1, and i^2 is equal to -1. However, I made a mistake while applying the product rule of square roots, which states that the square root of x times the square root of y is equal to the square root of xy. I wrongly calculated that i^2 is equal to the square root of -1 multiplied by the square root of -1, which gives the square root of -1 multiplied by -1 and eventually the square root of 1. But this is incorrect. Later, I learned that we cannot multiply imaginary numbers.
@carultch
@carultch Год назад
You can multiply imaginary numbers, it's just that the property of sqrt(x)*sqrt(y) = sqrt(x*y) is only valid when both x and y are positive real numbers. If either number is a negative number, you must first separately handle the negative part of x or y, and then continue simplifying the product of square roots, once you reduce it to a product of roots of positive numbers. Likewise if you start with square roots of complex numbers in general. It will be the case that in general, sqrt(x*y) and sqrt(x)*sqrt(y) will both be valid solutions for z to z^2 = x*y, but they will not strictly equal each other, due to conventions of principal roots implied by the square root function. For square roots specifically, they will either equal each other, or be negatives of each other. I'll leave it as a challenge for you, to determine what property of the original numbers would make them equal.
@lucdhomme3105
@lucdhomme3105 Год назад
Very good explanation, thank you.
@thomasnicolai628
@thomasnicolai628 Год назад
Square root of 36 is 6 and only positive 6, regardless of the i or i squared. You can graph root of x and see
@Alfakkin
@Alfakkin 11 месяцев назад
So is x= -6 wrong?
@WilliamWizer
@WilliamWizer 10 месяцев назад
@@Alfakkin at least that's what they claim. interestingly enough, that would mean that equations like x²-36=0 would have only one solution ( x=√36=6 ) despite everybody knowing that any and all quadratic equations have 2 solutions. easily proven by the fact that x²-36=0 can be factored as (x+6)(x-6)=0 wich is, evidently, true for either x=6 or x=-6 so, despite what many want to claim, the square root of a number has two results. I understand why some prefer to work with the idea that the result is only the positive value. they are welcome to do so, but be very careful when doing that kind of thing.
@samueladler9080
@samueladler9080 11 месяцев назад
Very good explanations. But I think it helps better if we rewrite the expression in equivalent form. That is to say the nth root of X is X^(1/n), therefore the square root of -3*-12 can be written as (-3*-12)½. If we distribute the exponent over the multiplication we have -3½ *-12½ This then reduces to sqrt(-3)*sqrt(-12). So instead of saying you can't write, provide reasons why we can't write. The "you can't write" can't be a reason. I learn so many of you can't write from you. You are helping students with handy tricks, but it should come with reason why we can't.
@marksd5650
@marksd5650 Год назад
Clear explanation. TY
@shanvadi1464
@shanvadi1464 Год назад
Thanks for your clear explanation that removed my mistake.
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring Год назад
Glad to help
@YouTubeReady
@YouTubeReady Год назад
I left it at 6i^2 i^−3 = i i^−2 = −1 i^−1 = −i i^0 = 1 i^1 = i i^2 = −1 i^3 = −i i^4 = 1 i^5 = i i^6 = −1 6(-1) = -6 I would have missed this because I didn’t simply it fully.
@margaret544
@margaret544 10 месяцев назад
But, why can't we put the negative value under one root ? Why is the first way correct and the second way incorrect ?
@miracool131
@miracool131 Год назад
Does it only refer to square root of 36?
@Alfakkin
@Alfakkin 11 месяцев назад
Thank you for your help, I love mathematics but is not an easy task. I really appreciate a talented teacher with a clear approach and method, like you.
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring 11 месяцев назад
Happy to help!
@user-vu9ys6if5f
@user-vu9ys6if5f 10 месяцев назад
ขอบคุณครับ
@jan-willemreens9010
@jan-willemreens9010 10 месяцев назад
... SQRT(- 3) * SQRT(- 12) [ I like to work with i^2 = - 1 ] ... SQRT(3 * i^2) * SQRT(12 * i^2) ... i * SQRT(3) * i * SQRT(12) = i^2 * SQRT(36) = - 1 * 6 = - 6 ...
@B_P17
@B_P17 6 месяцев назад
Why did we multiply the first eq by 4 and second one with -7
@venkybabu8140
@venkybabu8140 11 месяцев назад
How do you rationalise an imaginary to infinite fractals.
@simriths.s5976
@simriths.s5976 Год назад
Thankz for the Knowledge sir
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring Год назад
It's my pleasure
@Char444
@Char444 10 месяцев назад
Didn't know i would find you here
@user-iu8yu5te9u
@user-iu8yu5te9u 7 месяцев назад
We want to inform of you vidioed
@christopherellis2663
@christopherellis2663 Год назад
-1(3×12)^½=-6
@DKRahiTeach
@DKRahiTeach Год назад
6
@miracool131
@miracool131 Год назад
Or the square roots of any number
@Gbhmagic
@Gbhmagic Год назад
so the radical is not the same as square root?... really? they never tought us that.
@carultch
@carultch Год назад
The root sign is called a radical, and by default indicates principal square root. It of course, can indicate other roots as well. The convention for principal root: Priority 1: The positive real root Priority 2: The negative real root Priority 3: The closest root to the positive real axis. If two candidates for the principal root are a complex conjugate pair, then the positive imaginary one is the principle root.
@Gbhmagic
@Gbhmagic Год назад
@@carultch awsome! i learned something new.. now its a good day
@kobey3044
@kobey3044 9 месяцев назад
(x^2) -36 = 0 x= plus 6, minus 6 wow.. 03:00 Why does he say "square roots of 36 are +/- 6" it should be only +6.. so confusing.... XP
@lookingforahookup
@lookingforahookup 10 месяцев назад
Tell me this;; how would you solve b²=36? What is the answer
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring 10 месяцев назад
b=6,-6
@lookingforahookup
@lookingforahookup 10 месяцев назад
@mrhtutoring So, therefore, how can you say that the square root of 36 is not negative 6?
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring 10 месяцев назад
By definition, square roots of 36 are ±6. But when we use the radical sign, √, we only use the positive root. Meaning √36 is only equal to +6. When you take the sqrt of left and right side of an equation, you do add +-
@lookingforahookup
@lookingforahookup 10 месяцев назад
1:30 Yes square root of 36 is ± 6
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring 10 месяцев назад
By definition, square roots of 36 are ±6. But when we use the radical sign, √, we only use the positive root. Meaning √36 is only equal to +6.
@lookingforahookup
@lookingforahookup 10 месяцев назад
@@mrhtutoring But -6 * -6 equals 36
@mrhtutoring
@mrhtutoring 10 месяцев назад
You're right. But, we use only the principal root or the positive root when we use the sqrt symbol.
@lookingforahookup
@lookingforahookup 10 месяцев назад
@mrhtutoring One thing that I know of is that -(6)² does equal -36
@WilliamWizer
@WilliamWizer 10 месяцев назад
@@mrhtutoring ok. I understand your point. please, teach me. if not √, what symbol we use when we want to use all roots instead of "the principal"?
@user-iu8yu5te9u
@user-iu8yu5te9u 7 месяцев назад
Hii
@user-iu8yu5te9u
@user-iu8yu5te9u 7 месяцев назад
We wants to of you
@delroysamouge9131
@delroysamouge9131 Год назад
What is i
@jamesharmon4994
@jamesharmon4994 Год назад
i is defined to mean the square root of -1