I have to agree with Sooyoung. She once said when Taeyeon sang an OST, it felt like the main female character was singing. That's the one thing that differentiates Taeyeon from any other singers. Even I feel like Taeyeon's version is more Jang Manwol ish than IU's. That's not a bad thing, tho.
you might have to watch the series first.Ik taeyeon sing this well but jang man weol on IU is another level above.she portrayed her character with perfection impressively.Taeyeon was just the drama's soundtrack filler and i like this OST itself the most too.i love the both of them so i would appreciate it if you don't compare the two of them beings.
@@emanreadsss The comments means Taeyeon voice portrayed the character better in this song, not her as a person. Because he knows too IU ultimately portrayed JMW greatly with her acting. It's two different things.
@@teacher-Eri ik but she doesnt need to drag about iu played manweol in the drama and compared her to taeyeon.enough to the point where she praised taeyeon for singing well,btw no hate i love both Iu and taeyeon and hotel del luna is my all time fav drama
@@emanreadsss We can compare the feeling of IU's cover and the original singing by Taeyeon. Taeyeon "just" sing the OST? Thatns more amazing because with just a song she portrayed the main character of a Drama! That is the power of Taeyeon. Stop being a hyper protective Uaena. I like both of them, but Taeyeon's singing is above this world and no one can beat her in term of emotional singing.
I feel like Taeyeon set the bar too high that all the other singers don't impress me as much as Taeyeon did when I first heard the song. They're all great singers tho :)
This is so true. No matter how many times I listened to other K-Idols singing this song, I still think that this song is made only for Taeyeon. But you are also right, all of them are great singers and did a good job covering the song.
Wendy and Punch seem to be the most effortless ones, kudos to the rest. That Seungsik guy has good emotions and control. Miyeon could do muuuch much better.
Yes Wendy's vocal is so soft, bright and strong, there are a lot of emotions involved that's why she is the best vocal of the 3rd gen Wendy's vocal technique is huge and overwhelming wow
Wendy’s cover was the best imo. She has really great control and her tone actually suits this song. Also she sang the high part 0:23 (original) 2:35 (wendy’s cover) soo smoothly without pausing.
Actually, her voice was different with taeyeon but she knows how taeyeon sings that song. It sounds simillar bcs she knows taeyeon's technique and she able to apply that. SM really produce great singers.
@@cocoacoklat86 Exactly ! She's a Vocal chameleon for sure and she herself said she has 8 different voices which she imbibes whenever needed. She did the same thing while singing 'Stay with me' with Chanyeol at SMTOWN stages. Wendy makes her voice tone as closer to the female singers as possible :)
Wendy's voice stand out among all the girls in this video also Eun Ji. I agree with comments. Woojin & Do young for the boys. The vocalist of Melomance have a very unique voice I feel like he can make the song his own. Taeyeon queen
I think Taeyeon the only one who fit to sing this. I thought IU voice would fit in this song but I feel like her voice is too light if that make sense like Taeyeon did it with depth. I stan Queens Edit: 6.6K wow how to handle fameee 😂😂 but anyway stop fighting guys like everyone has a different opinion and of course my opinion is Taeyeon is the only one who could really do justice with her song and the only person who I think who can give a little bit justice is Eunji
A perfect example of how a song can be technically challenging without crazy octaves and belting. The breath control required for this song is pretty intense and as shown how many artistes ended up sounding breathless or airy because of incorrect technique.
Shows that Taeyeon's voice is really perfect for the song. Wendy's version is the best for me out of all the covers. I also like Punch, Seungsik, Gyuri, Mia, Seoryoung, and Donghun's cover
I like it how doyoung chose to sing in a different note/key (idk how to say it in english) instead of singing with the same note/key like taeyeon In simple, he harmonized.
@@lexa5630 well, it might be true. And nothing's wrong with it. It's understandable tho. But the thing is, instead of forcing himself to do thw original key, he harmonized. Lots of singer decide to only sing in a lower note (not harmonizing). Well, i just appreciate his singing skill.
Wendy has the Unique quality of a Vocal Chameleon. She has so many hidden voices in her body that she can summon it just like that. She sang along Chanyeol in 'Stay with me' at SMTOWN stage and she sounded nearer to Punch and performed it so beautifully without overpowering the male singer. Same thing happened here :)
@@Foxy_0813 yes Every Generation will be born to New Generation.. solo singer like BoA now it's Taeyeon times maybe the next is Wendy !! I hope so.... because so much potential on her ..Wendy can Speak English that will help for International Music like Tiffany now ..
Honestly Taeyeon's emotion in the voice surprises me everytime when other singers sing her song... Really you need to be VERY talented to cover Taeyeon's songs
Only Punch and Wendy did a good cover. I was hoping IU would do a good job since i like her voice alot but it didnt match with this song . Taeyeon's voice really suits this song ive been listening to this song non-stop after watching hotel del luna.
Wendy is clearly the best out of everyone that covered this song. Everyone else were either short of breath and/or their techniques were nowhere near Wendy or Taeyeon’s. IU, Punch and Lynn incorporated their styles but I don’t know if they’re a good match. Taeyeon and Wendy have this thickness(?) to their voices regardless of how high the notes they have to hit. I think that’s a unique advantage
If you talking about who sing this song so great, of course Taeyeon, since this was her own song 😄 if we talking about who is best covering, i think all of ppl who covered this song are best. They sing with their own style and their vocal colour. But i appreaciate to Seungsik Victon an Wonpil Day6 since they are men who sing like this are their own song.
I respect everyone who covers Taeyeon's song with wonderful voices. But let's face the fact.... The only one who can sing Taeyeon's song is Taeyeon herself
I can't really imagine someone singing the original song other than taeyeon. Like everytime I hear her voice I feel like crying, it's just so beautiful. Btw, I like Seungwan's voice the most out of them. It's more stable when hitting those high notes and is so nice to hear just like Taeyeons. Well, what do you expect from SM artists.
There's something about that third line until the end of the chorus that makes it so hard to replicate and Taeyeon did it even better in the live performance (that crescendo was an eargasm), plus the volume control this song requires skill. For me Wendy, Punch and Chaewon did well
every singer deliver the song differently but everyone did their best covering the song! really love them all, esp taeyeon💜 edit: wendy is indeed the second taeyeon in this generation. just saying.
They all really nice but honestly wendy delivers it the best here. I think taeyeon and wendy are really good at putting the right emotion and controlling between emotion and technique. They sounds like they’re singing while delivering a message but without overdoing it.
Wow. 16 mins of covers and I think there are still clips that are not included yet because after years, this song is still touching a lot of people. I really like Wendy, Eunji and Punch. They seriously know how to deliver an OST. The emotions and the vocals.
yeh I personally prefer taeyeons version the best but Lyn totally made it into her own song like she did that, it was really different and so Lyn didn't copy it just sang it her way. really like her drama ost's as well
BoA mastered the technique because Lee Soo Man wanted to replicate BoA, it is the same technique used to teach future SM female singers. Such as Taeyeon and Wendy.
no one talked about gyuri? she's a vocalist with pretty face and has angelic voice. and also fromis_9 has vocal line are so great, especially park jiwon. if you want to watch more about gyuri singing, you can watch flaylist (fromis_9's cover songs)
![◣[PART 1] K-POP IDOLS SINGING TO TAEYEON 'ALL ABOUT YOU' (HD)◥](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
