Long explanation but yes to Ahsoka no time passed but didn't involve herself in what happened for the future 2 years because she knew where it would go and didn't want to interfere.
I think she might have been stuck there and only got rescued due to Ezra now knowing she was alive and stuck there. They assumed she died in season 2 so they had no reason to go back, and I know the Inquisitor Ties would have let her leave but I assume Vader had them recalled or destroyed when he left
Some time passed between when she left to the world between worlds, and arrived back on Malachor, since she got back after Vader fell, and then came out of the temple ruins. Plus Ezra of course spent time in the portal.
@@digitaladventurer2142 It hasn't said yet how she got away from malacor but she obviously never interfered in a way to change the timeline for what she saw up until Kanan's death. It's all speculation until the Ahsoka show comes out and hopefully they give us answers
And because Anakin and Ahsoka give the code name Fulcrum at Kallus After Malachor set between Rebels season two and Rebels season three and then Kallus give too the code name Fulcrum at Cassian in the Last season of Andor tie with Rogue One and before original Trilogy of star wars
Here are all of the voices you heard. Brace yourself!: Yoda (Attack of the Clones): "Truly wonderful the mind of a child is." Obi-Wan Kenobi (Clone Wars ep. Overlords): "What is this place?" Qui-Gon Jinn (Clone Wars ep. Overlords): "A conduit through which the entire Force of the universe flows." __ (Empire Strikes Back): "Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter". Ahsoka Tano (Rebels ep. The Mystery of Chopper Base): "Just when you think you understand the Force, you find out how little you actually know." Yoda (Revenge of the Sith): "Train yourself to let go of everything you fear to lose." Ben Kenobi (Rebels ep. Twin Suns): "What you need, you already have. Unfortunately, you seem to be letting it all go." Kanan Jarrus (Rebels ep. Path of the Jedi): "I won't let him lose his way. Not like I did." __ (A New Hope): "The Force is what gives a Jedi his power. It's an energy field created by all living things. It surrounds us and penetrates us. It binds the galaxy together." Yoda (Revenge of the Sith): "Rejoice for those around you who transform into the Force." __ (The Force Awakens): "I see your eyes. You already know the truth." __ (Rogue One): "I'm one with the Force, the Force is with me." __ (Rogue One): "The time to fight is now!" __ (The Force Awakens): "Show me....grandfather." __ (The Force Awakens): "We'll see each other again. I believe that." The Father (Clone Wars ep. Overlords): "And now you see who you truly are." Anakin Skywalker (Revenge of the Sith): "I won't lose you Padme." __ (The Force Awakens): "And I will finish what you started." __ (The Force Awakens): "The Resistance will not be intimidated by you." The Daughter (Clone Wars ep. Altar of Mortis): "It is his nature." __ (The Force Awakens): "The belonging you seek is not behind you." __ (A New Hope): "This is our most desperate hour." Yoda (Revenge of the Sith): "The shadow of greed that is." __ (A New Hope): "Help me, Obi-Wan Kenobi. You're my only hope." Anakin Skywalker (The Clone Wars Movie): "You never would have made it as Obi-Wan's padawan. But you might make it as mine." __ (Return of the Jedi): "Obi-Wan once thought as you do. You don't know the power of the dark side." Daughter (Clone Wars ep. Overlords): "I am Daughter." Kanan Jarrus (Rebels ep. Spark of Rebellion Part 1 ): "You want a ride?" Kanan Jarrus (Rebels ep. Spark of Rebellion Part 2): "You can learn what it truly means to be a Jedi." Kanan Jarrus (Rebels ep. Spark of Rebellion Part 2): "Kid, I'm about to let everyone in on the secret." Kanan Jarrus (Rebels ep. The Siege of Lothal Part 1): "I survived one war. I'm not ready for another one." Kanan Jarrus (Rebels ep. The Last Battle): "Battles leave scars. Some you can't see."
Please, at least use a spoiler tag with some empty lines. Tara is watching all of Star Wars in chronological order and is not familiar with many references you mentioned. She wants to remain blind to what is to come. No matter how small and insignificant it may be. Thanks!
I love all of Rebels but this episode might be my favourite. It’s beautiful, moving, mystical, mind bending, creative (and influenced by the wood between the worlds in the C S Lewis Narnia story The Magicians Nephew). The scene at the end with Hera and Ezra talking, followed by Ezra staring at the wolf and saying good bye to Kanan, is just so exquisitely beautiful and moving.
So my question was.... when Ahsoka went back to the temple, did she go back to the point of time she had just left, OR did she go back to the temple, but in Ezra's "present" time? I asked this on Tik Tok, and most said she went back to the point she left (meaning she's been alive since the incident)
I LOST IT when this episode premiered. With the context of characters, Ahsoka’s story and fight with Vader, the Morris gods, palpatine, Kanan’s wolf walking off, the emotions, the music, the story, everything is just so perfect, this is the single best episode of Star Wars and perhaps all media I’ve even seen! Never have I reacted with such enthusiasm before!
To add to what others have said, it's presumed she remained on Malachor to wait out her time where she shouldn't be alive so that she wouldn't cause a paradox with other events. That's based on her deduction with Ezra trying to save Kanan and causing a paradox. I'm not going to spoil the rest of the series, but essentially she stays in isolation until after the events of the finale, although we do not have an answer as to how or when she comes back into the picture yet.
I never thought I'd see time travel (well, sort of) in Star Wars, and I never thought I'd love it this much. The wonder and majesty of the World Between Worlds is astonishing, and the fact that Ahsoka essentially faced the Inquisitors, Maul, Vader, and the Emperor all in the space of a few minutes is insane! This was also the episode where it hit me just how Ezra really has grown. He only needed "One Last Lesson."
Sidious is like the Joker, he’s just so over the top, fun to watch, can’t stop smiling 100% evil villain, in the best possible way, kinda like the Joker. Love villains that aren’t one dimensional, and aren’t purely evil, hut palps is the exception, and Ian Mcdiarmid just cannot be recast. I usually believe that good characters aren’t just good characters cause of the actors portraying them, but cannot imagine anybody else playing Sidious, at least no in live action.
@@ncard00 For what it's worth I think Sam Witwer, Ian Abercrombie, and Tim Curry all did decently with the role in the animated shows before they brought Ian Mcdiarmid back in to voice him late into Rebels' run time, but I do agree, Ian Mcdiarmid's work for the role is just the best.
Back when Rebels was originally airing, those of us who were fans were flabbergasted by the fact that many people, who were otherwise Star Wars fans, wouldn't give it a shot because they saw it as a "Kids show.". Kind of amusing to think of in retrospect, given just how adult and complex it could get, especially in yhe second half of the 4th season. In the home stretch now, and i cant wait to see these reactions to what lays ahead.
Ahsoka has a very impressive track record. She's fought Ventress and survived every time. She fought Grevious twice and survived despite him cutting down Knights and Masters. She overthrew a corrupt government. She brutalized Death Watch. She fought Maul and defeated him despite him having killed Qui Gon (even more impressive She can take him 1 v 1 while Qui Gon and Obi-Wan had to fight him together). She survived Order 66 when so many fell. She made quick work of two Inquisitors. She briefly fought Maul again. She fought Vader, gave him a good fight, and survived. And she even encountered Palpatine and survived. Anakin was a way better mentor than people give him credit for. His training was intense, but it made her overpowered and prepared to face anything.
There are instances in Star Wars lore where weird things happen, along w/ Mortis keeping a watch over us, and now another relic being discovered. This is a real growing up moment for Ezra and my girl when we watched this (she called me from college). Its time to run into the fight itself.
I liked how there were quotes from movies in the past and future at the time of this episode, and hearing the voices of the Mortis gods. It was so weird hearing it but I loved it.
After putting off the last season of rebels for a long time, I finally caught up and finished it just so I could watch these reaction when they came out, love these videos cant wait for everything else to come ✨
Ahsoka didn't die because Ezra saved ger- it's a loop, but Ahsoka apparently needed to learn what was in the Sith temple- which we see her go back into with the owl Morai. The owl is the Daughter from the Mortis arc that gave her life to save Ahsoka- but she's the embodiment of the light side of the Force, so can't truly die- only be reborn as something else.
The mortis arc is easily a top 5 clone wars arc for me, tbh one of my favorite things in all of star wars, and this episodes does not disappoint, it rlly hits hard and is interesting af
In "Twilight of the Apprentice" when daughter said it was Ashoka's force ghost that was walking into the temple and then watched the difference between that episode and this one.
2:05 the voices... in the world between worlds, time is all at once, so some of these lines are from the past, and some are from the future. I've forgotten the release order, but this is cool. Can't say more without spoiling!
I think I understand a little bit how the gateways work if you notice the portal that he goes through is from a Jedi Temple it is round he sees the battle with Vader and ahsoka That was at a sith temple and the portal was a triangle...ezra hears kanan and runs to it , That portal was also round but it wasn't the same portal he came from It was the Jedi temple on Curasant Where the emperor is he is luring Ezra... But it didn't work so he revealed himself.. I think each portal represents a planet in the Galaxy... Makes sense And the shape represents Sith or Jedi
If you look carefully at the end of season 2, you can see her walking into the tunnel by the temple. She was on her own journey for a few years after Ezra saved her. I think it was covered in comics or a book.
The voices basically unite THE ENTIRE timeline up to this point. And between the last episodes to now, this is often considered the best Star Wars content ever. Dave wastes NOTHING. 2 more to go. Tissues are a MUST
here's what is said and by who and when lol.. GOING THROUGH THE PORTAL: “Truly wonderful the mind of a child is.” - Yoda, Attack of the Clones “What is this place?” - Obi-Wan on Mortis “A Force that consists of two parts. Living beings generate the Living Force, which in turn powers the wellspring that is the Comic Force.” - Qui-Gon, Yoda arc in the Clone Wars “Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter.” - Yoda, Empire Strikes Back “Train yourself to let go of everything you fear to lose.” - Yoda, Revenge of the Sith “…UNDERSTAND THE FORCE…” - Ahsoka, Rebels “What you seek you already have. Unfortunately, you seem to be letting it all go.” - Obi-Wan in Twin Suns “I won’t let him lose his way, not like I did.” - Kanan AFTER THE PORTAL, EZRA LOOKING AROUND: “The Force is what gives the Jedi his power. It’s an energy field that is created by all living things. It surrounds us, it penetrates us, it binds the galaxy together.” - Obi-Wan, from The original movie Star Wars AFTER THIS, EZRA WANDERING: “Rejoice for those who transform into the Force. Mourn them to do not. Miss them do not.” - YODA ROTS “I see your eyes.” - Maz, TFA “I’m one with the Force the Force is with me. I am one with the Force the Force is with me.” - Chirrut! Rogue one “The time to fight is now!” - Jyn Erso Rogue one “Show me, Grandfather, and I will finish… what you started.” - Kylo Ren, TFA “We’ll see each other again… I believe that.” - Rey to Finn in TFA. “Grandfather…” - AGAIN FROM KYLO “The Resistance will not be intimidated by you.” - Poe, The Force Awakens “… show no mercy.” - Palpatine, ROTS “I will finish… what you started.” - AGAIN FROM KYLO “I won’t lose you, Padmé.” - Anakin, ROTS “Something… inside me, has always been there,” - Rey, TLJ “It is in his Nature.” - Daughter, Mortis “The belonging you seek it not behind you, it is ahead..” - Maz Kanata “It is our most desperate hour. Help me Obi-Wan Kenobi, you’re my only hope.” - Leia, ANH “A shadow of greed, that is.” - Yoda, ROTS (CONTINUATION OF LET GO QUOTE) Owl hoots. “You never would have made it as Obi-Wan’s padawan… but you might make it as mine.” - Anakin to Ahsoka, on Christophsis when they first met. When Ahsoka remembers: “Obi-Wan once thought as you did…” - Vader “You don’t know the power of the dark side.” - Vader When Ahsoka calls to the convor owl Morai: “I am daughter.” - The Daughter, Mortis. This episode basically brings all the movies and shows together.. Love every second of it
WHAT an absolute cracker of an episode. WHAT an absolute cracker of a reaction too. It's official - you are now part of a relatively exclusive club of Rebels fanatics. Welcome, good to have you onboard.
From Asoka‘s perspective, there is apparently zero time differential between her fighting Vader and her being pulled into the world between worlds, meaning that in the space of like a few hours she fought three inquisitors, and three Sith Lords, and at the very least, got away with it. And she did all of that, except for Sidious, on what is implied to be a dark side force nexus. She boss rushed basically the whole sith on hard mode.
I seen this episode so many times, but I never realized it till not to long ago, the wolf told Ezra to save Ahsoka. That was his mission in this episode.
The way I saw it, was that Ahsoka and Ezra met each other in a place outside of time, so since neither travels to each other's time, no time "travel" occurred. She saw Ezra in the future back then, we just weren't privy to seeing it until now. It's like they both stepped into a room from their different places in time that existed, spend an hour/half hour or however long there together in real time, then went back and appeared after that amount of time happened in their perspective points in time.
Ahsoka never died, no. She's been off on her own since going back to Malachor just as Vader is leaving, where we see her at the end of season 2. Cannot wait for you to get through this last arc. It's a blast.
Erza from the future saved her then she went back here to the place where she fought Vader but a few moments later. At least that is how a interpreted the situation.
If you think about it Vader had a few people disappear on him while fighting,,lol obiwan Disappears at the time of his death maybe this is where obiwan goes , figures out a way to go here What happens to them after they become invisible.. It's a very interesting concept .. maybe this is like a limbo A transitional place before one becomes a spirit... We're time and space has no meaning.. definitely one of the most talked about episode.. Obviously they're gonna go more into it in the future would be awesome to see a live action Mortis daughter ,father and son Sam Witwer / could reprise his role again As the mortis brother just in live action..
The way I understood it, Ezra basically pulled her into the future from her fight with Vader, and then when she went back into the portal, she returned to that timeline and walked out of the Sith temple. Ezra may have thought she died back at the end of season 2, but the viewers saw her walk out of the temple as well at the end of the Season 2 finale, so not sure why we (viewers) would have thought she died.
As already stated for the last reaction, here comes my very long comment, so for anybody how actually gets through the comment I really hope you will let me know by answering and maybe even sharing what you think of "The World Between Worlds". Full transparency: I copy at least parts of this comment because I don't want to write it new every time. Here is my current understanding of it: For me "The World between Worlds" works like "TimeTravel" in Harry Potter (or DARK if somebody has seen that show), meaning everything has always happend. You can't change the timeline, you can just travel through but that will already be considered in the current events. Of course, it will still be desirable to get into the World between Worlds because Characters in the Universe don't know about the Future (not like we as viewers) and would still like to change things at multiple points at the same time and therefore influence the Future, but generally what is Canon now can't be changed when a Character goes into the World between Worlds, it can only be explained (like the end of Season 2 of Rebels was explained in this Episode) That is the reason I think this is the case when it comes to keeping Canon intakt and not making StarWars to complicated and full of plot-holes. Here comes the in universe explanation: This one hinges on the idea that THE FORCE is there to keep balance and that the World between Worlds is a manifestation of the Cosmic Force, the part of the Force that encompasses time and space. Naturally the World between Worlds would then be a bridge between different places and times BUT if you do use this bridge it changes nothing about the time or space you go to since in terms of Cosmic Force there is no Time and Space keeping events apart (as pretty obvious because of how the World between Worlds works). So, when you travel to a different time/space, it is simply like you would travel in the normal world just that boundaries of Space and Time no longer exist. Right, now the last problem: Paradoxes! My personal believe is, that because the World between Worlds is based on the Cosmic Force which is Time and Space (and holds both in place) you simply can't create a Paradox. Remember: The force keeps balance and structure so it would be very strange if a manifestation of the Cosmic Force would allow for a Paradox to be created (the exact opposite of balance and structure). The only problem here is of course that Ezra could have created a Paradox in Rebels if he would have saved Kanan (and killed himself in the process). Here are the two explanations I personally think are reasonable: 1. The simple HE DIDN'T DO IT. The Cosmic Force showed him the event and he didn't create the Paradox because of Ahsoka reminding him that loss is needed. Because the Cosmic Force is a force of Nature there doesn't need to be a limit or some sort of barrier. If it is a natural rule that you can't create Paradoxes even if you have the opportunity you simply can't create them. Something will always interfere (like Ahsoka did in this case). You simply can't explain some natural rules. 2. The vision was not real but in fact created and produced by Palpatine so that Ezra reaches through giving him entrance to the World between Worlds because, as we later see with the flames, in order for him to enter he needs to connect with a person inside and the Lothal Temple will not allow him to enter because you need to use the light side of the force to enter the World between Worlds from that Gateway (I am sure there are others, some maybe needing the dark side or even "the middle"). I find this a pretty good theory, especially because Palpatine appears in the same gateway as Kanan was only moments ago and while we don't know much about the World between Worlds yet, I find it quite hard to believe that a gateway can simply change it's connected place and time. The only thing that is a bit strange would be how Palpatine can do something so powerful but not enter the World between Worlds itself BUT we also know Palpatine is a master of deception so this would be a power he would be very interested and skilled in. Lastly I wand to point out the Mortis-Gods and their different uses in controlling the gateway. Starting with the basics: The 3 are symbols for the 3 directions of the force: Light (Sister), Dark (Brother) and "the Middle" (Father). What is really interesting is that for the Gateway to open in this Temple you needed to connect with the Sister and therefore use the Light side of the force (the map glowed Golden/Light). This is very good for us as no Sith could have entered the Temple, even if they understood what they needed to do. I want to point out that Ezra had no problem opening the gate after concentrating a bit. Now, when Ezra closed the gate he needed to interact with the Brother and therefore use the Dark side of the force (the Map glowed Red/Dark). He did actually managed to pull it of BUT he was so drained from that effort that he passed out shortly after and was probably gone for several hours, considering the Time changed from Night to Day. This to me shows that over the past 2 seasons he has distanced himself more and more from the Dark Side (since the beginning of Season 3) and has truly become a Light-Side Force-User (no Jedi of the old order, like Ahsoka, since he was never knighted by Kanan). What is even more interesting when thinking about this is however the possibility of somebody being in Ezra's position who never had contact with the Dark-Side of the Force. Such a person would probably not have been able to close the gate fully, giving the Emperor a possible entrance into the World between Worlds. Even powerful Jedi like Obi-Wan and Yoda would not have been able to do so since they never connected with the Dark Side and have no experience in using it. Ezra used it extensively in the Past and even he had problems with it. As you can see, Ezra was basically the perfect person to have interacted with this specific gateway into the World between Worlds in order to keep the Emperor out. Oke, that was my comment. I hope at least somebody got through it 😅 and maybe has some thoughts he would like to share
You are correct NO TIME passed for her. He saved her and at the end of that episode we were seeing the future, or this episode now. In their eyes she was dead or lost in time. Kanan's death and the last episodes break my heart EVERY time I watch them
Wonderful reaction to this superbly well crafted episode. In addition to everything everyone said, the Music... how awesome it is, especially in the last scene, after saying goodbye to Kanan, Ezra in the beautiful background and the song ending in the so familiar notes...
This episode had a lot of reference to the OG trilogy especially the dialogues and the voices you’ve heard, you should rewatch these last episodes after you watch the OG :)
Oh man I love this episode! These last for episodes are some of my FAVORITES in the star wars franchise. Really excited to see what you think about it!
I know it can be confusing to wrap your head around. Ahsoka was definitely alive at the end of the S2 finale, so Ezra didn't change the past by pulling her out. I'm pretty sure she returned to the place and time he pulled her out of. That shot of her after she went back through the portal matches really well with the shot of her walking away in the S2 finale. Also... and I never even noticed this before re-watching with you... but Morai flew through the portal with her. And once again, if you look at the S2 finale, Morai is there at the end as Vader is limping away. I suspect Ahsoka spent a lot of the time in between stranded on Malachor. I don't think there were any ships left on the planet at the end of S2, but I have to go back to those episodes and count the ships again. Also, yes, some of the voices you heard when Ezra was in the World Between Worlds are definitely the voices of people you haven't met yet.
if you rewatch the last few seconds of the 2nd season finale you see vader fly away in his ship and you see a shadow enter into that door in the temple. I and have understand it she was dropped back at the time she was pulled out just after stabbing the floor and sending vader down. In the worlds between worlds time seems not to be a factor(as you noticed all the dialogs in the background)
This is in my top 3 episodes, twilight of apprentice, twin suns, and world between words, the only other is the end of the last episode of season 4 (epilogue) that will relate to the Ahsoka show
Ahsokah did not miss out on anything from her perspective because Ezra pulled her into his present time from the past. Then she went back in and rejoined her past time just after fighting Vader.......................I think LOL.
sad thing is: as we see anakin would have killed her without hesitation. Dave Filonie even confirmed that when he said they didnt need to be enemies and they would show her mercy, he was lying. He wanted all the jedi locations from her and would have killed her afterwards like it was nothing.
I will be shocked if in Andor season 2 they don't do a live action version of the secret cargo episode from season 3 of Rebels where Mon Mothma officially joins the rebellion and starts the alliance. I saw video of Cassian escaping somewhere with Mon Mothma on set shooting a scene. I wonder if Cassian rescued her before she met the ghost crew.
Ahsoka was wrong Ezra wouldn't save Kanan. Kanan's death was an illusion created by Palpatine to trick Ezra into helping the Sith get inside. That could be an interesting reaction.
Ahah welcome to the marvellous world of time paradoxes 😁 If you liked this you should seriously start watching Doctor Who. I don't think Ahsoka went back in time, too, personally. I think she remained in Ezra's present time (thus she saw her in the "future" in season 2 finale). It does make more sense to me.
Actually the question is: Did Ahsoka returned back to Malakor right after the duel with Vader or 2 years later. The answer to this is unknown. My guess is that we are going to get some clarity in the upcoming Ahsoka show. Fun detail about the duel: 3:04 Ahsoka used exactly same move Gandalf used in his duel against Balrog in Moria - destroying the surface under the opponent. It worth to keep in mind for later :D
The answer is known, she return just few minutes after her duel with Vader, you can see it at the end of Twilight of The Apprentice after Vader limp of the ruins you see her going deeper in the temple in that triangle shape.
I like that scene where Ezra reacts what really happened at Darth Vader and Ahsoka After Malachor and the important thing that i like Is that Ezra had almost find out that Vader Is Anakin seeing his true Blue Eye through the broken Mask and even Ezra didn't see Ahsoka's reaction that She was in back while She Is continue to fight against Anakin. And the Moment that i like Is that Anakin and Ahsoka react that Malachor Temple Is going to crash over them and they were distracted and they were blinded to continued to fight Just like a true clone Wars Moment. I Hope that you must see Clone Wars and Bad Batch because they are both important and you will see that Anakin was innocent because of Palpatine that he Is the true villain. But you must learn that Ezra and Ahsoka and even Rex will never see Anakin in the end of the movie return of Jedi........ I Hope that Ezra must learn that Darth Vader Is Anakin After he frees Lothal because It's very important. After Ezra and Ahsoka were attacked by Palpatine, i Hope that Ahsoka was return on Malachor Temple to see Darth Vader Is ok and to told him that Ezra Lost Kanan. You see? Anakin and Ahsoka made a wonderful Adventure during the clone Wars until season 7 made them separation before Ezra Born. Star Wars the clone Wars are sevens seasons and you must Watch It, ok?
I 100% believe This episode was Dave Filoni's way of introducing to Star Wars the time travel mechanic to ret-con everything sequel trilogy to get true Legends Bad-Ass Jedi MASTER Luke (hint.. Mando season 2 finale), Thrawn Trilogy (Rebels, Ahsoka series, and upcoming Mando-verse Filoni directed big screen Thrawn movie), then finally... The Yuuzhan Vong War!!! Outside of the Old Republic stories, the Yuuzhan Vong's introduction, which Emperor Palpatine allegedly built the Empire to prepare the galaxy to face off with... Is Absolutely cataclysmic to anything close you've seen in anything Star Wars... Like.. TRIIIILLIONS die in this upcoming war after Thrawn 😮😁 and Filoni needs Luke in his prime as a major part of those stories!!
