Hello from the US! I've just subscribed to your channel and I have one request, please react to Katrina singing Whitney Houston Medley, Somewhere Over the Rainbow, and Katrina's one take covers. I know you love Gigi but you will love Katrina too. I'm part Filipino, Taiwanese, Hispanic, and White and I love supporting my ethnic families. ❤
「With all due respect, I’m not asking」 老師說得實在太好了,Jay 真的不需要陷入自己的情緒裡面。就算可以理解歌詞,每個人都還是會對歌曲有自己的解讀。就算你把歌詞完整翻譯出來,也把文化背景詳細解說一次,也不能保證橘老師會有一樣的感受。畢竟看這系列的影片我就是想看老師獨特的看法跟你們之間討論的火花碰撞😆 另外 grenade 那首歌不覺得橘老師保守,她只是更能對歌詞共情,因為歌詞感覺細思極恐啊! 是要怎樣深沉的愛,才會說出這樣的話🤣
8:25 (the note) I mean let's be fr ,he said she refuses to study the lyrics but he told her several times that if she doesn't understand the language she won't understand the lyrics + it's a vocal coach reaction not a song writer reaction (even if she is both) her job here is to explain the sound a singer makes , why it's that way and how it can be better.
@@brunoccj I think they have a point re: nuances being lost through translation. And the beauty of Chinese songs often lies in the genius of the lyrics.
5:44 Rozette : I came for songs, not musicals or opera. 我其實有點認同老師,因為就算我沒看電影我還是很喜歡 並且以我的英文聽力只聽得出來內容大概是有人掛了好想再見到你一次。完全單純是音樂而非電影帶給我的喜歡。但又像Taylorswift走紅很大一部分是靠他歌詞很打動人心,完全不懂英文的人很可能無法共鳴。
Me😊 the video is actually up on bilibili and i've watched it. Unfortunately she said she'd never liked the song faouzia chose, the song itself, not faouzia's singing. Overall she wasn't as impressed as i expected her to be by it.
@@Ysbfjksxl yeah same, I'm quite disappointing this time with the video because I always waiting for her reaction to faouzia, but this time it's more cut? And she always has ^something^ (you know what I mean) to comment about faouzia. Idk this time I'm disappointed
Jumping in front of a train means protect her without second thought, idk why they think it's literal go die for you. To me, i feel the same way for my husband, would protect him from danger with my life. Dont get the pessimism .
@@Peachu_n_Goma_Home well, personally, if a person is "self-centred", not knowing to give unconditional love, or never had experiences or thoughts of sacrificing themselves for loved one, she or he may not interpret the lyrics the way you do.
I wasn’t going to comment, but I find it funny that they said they didn’t like one note that Faouzia did in the song (Grenade) and that it didn’t fit… Then they ended the video showing Rosette doing things to the phrases of the same song that don’t fit…at all. The way that she’s extending those phrases don’t sound good.
@@singaporechickenrice2484 Really great, so you can now SHUT UP as it’s your point and start by yourself 😄 and another time if you want to discuss as a human, I will allow you to know my point as a human, BYE
Naying was very nice on this one, i lked her. Yeallo and Tia were amazing too, great performers. Sad to see her go i wanted to more of her. For faouzia it's not surprising rozette didn't like her tbh. Idk if her style and voice isn't her cup of tee or something else, its ok really! But i can't not help not to notice now that not single performance of her she liked now matter how varstile it is aside from the vocal praise she covers it with. It didn't bother me then but now it feels different. She kept cutting the video and nitpick on the lyrics being suicidal not her techniqus or her noticible emotions or her flows if any yet ending the video with her singing the same song she hates and would turn off !!. So weird.
@@hayyanalmemsani805The issue with her as a vocal coach she does have strong bias towrds songs she likes if they were not intrpted the way she prefers. Look back at her comments during IWDWS or LOTB. Insted of focusing on the performance she rants song done too innocent, appearance or like a teenager cuz it didn't set with what preferd to see. Grenade entire time was overanalysing lyrics over looking at the performance, techniques or flaws. Then showd a cover of a song she hates multiple time to sing . shows lacks of credibility
Of course she doesn't need to like her songs choices or the way she interprete them completly understable, after all it's personal preference. She just needs to be more objctive.
@@mahmoudtabakhi6463 YEAAH I WAS ABOUT TO SAY THAT ,i feel like she don't like faouzia , every episode she is like oooh idon't like that song or that note or idk but it's ok ,we know that faouzia one of the best singers there
The only example that get close I think is the song in the TV show "The Wire". Nothing is a black and white in this crime/police show and the song "Way Down in the Hole" fitted the overall vibe and conveys the message with a bit of helpless heaviness. But yeah, even with this example I agree that it does not come in close in terms of the weight it carries.
I love Tan Weiwei's performance. It's not only music but art. I know it feels too old but the song which crys for justice moved me a lot ... I don't know why but I was in tears😅 Maybe some people like me can never get rid of old stuff...
On this stage, Tan Weiwei is the only one who is not participating in a singing competition. She doesn't care about the outcome of the competition at all. I feel that she is using this platform to speak for the people at the bottom of this unfair society, to make a powerless and desperate cry, and to finally be stubborn and unyielding.
@@joeyyang7980 you're right, I was gonna say she's generally more thoughtful about her performance. But it's more about her effort and thoughtfulness to a song, is not for the sake of giving a performance that scores well, but in service of best presenting the song to audience.
I think the way jkai( background guy) was saying it to rozette, makes her defensive. It's not doing justice to what TanWeiWei accomplished in this performance, by saying the lyrics is profound and meaningful. Because as meaningful as a lyric can get it's a good read. but this is a song, it wouldn't be a song without the music and the singing, and the music is more like creating the space the song is about or the interpretation of it, but the singing is the character, it's the emotion, it's the person that's telling the story. But the thing is, this isn't just about the lyrics that she can't relate, this Chinese style music, is not just any Chinese style, it has a JianHu (or WuXia) flavour to it that she can't relate too. While we like to think generally, that music goes beyond language, that you can feel if it's happy or sad. this is different. JiangHu has a certain vibe, it's always about some character highly skilled, and therefore can live as an outlaw, but at the same time has strong moral compass. They like living a simple carefree life not bounded by law of the nation. But that sense of justice is very strong and it's all its about with he main character, like YangGuo may be in a relationship that is taboo, but he has a strong moral compass, he has virtue and he sticks to it even more than those that claim to be righteous. People who are familiar with this immediately relates all that lyric that singing in that context.
I am somewhat upset because you are the only musician who comments on the show every week, perhaps because your comment depends entirely on whether you like the song or not, without any analysis. I mean, that's your personal taste. We are here to see how proficient the singer is since we are watching a video of a vocal coach
you people should realise by now, t hey don't really care about giving the viewers what they want. This is like a side gig, it's like they get around and do a reaction together, but mostly centres around the one who are not familiar with Chinese culture and it's music at all. It's casual, they're not trying to be politic, or consistent in the sense that you want. They just do it when they can put some effort editing and translating it And barely goes beyond that. Because the main reason they're doing this is to get rozette to comment on the vocal technique and what's going on with the vocals when the singer sings etc. The one about seeing a westerner like rozette reacting to Chinese culture and music is more of a bonus.
@@Rosannasfriend it's ok to have a favourite, it was pretty clear she's chante biased. Her style and taste resonate with and it's fine really! Still it surprised me the most when she said chante vocally is her best when it was so clear it was her weakest and not stable! I thought she will be fair and reasnable. Then surprised more when she sang the same song Faouzia did when all what she did was cutting her videos and hating the song!!
I resonate with Rozette's feelings towards Chante. I don't feel that Chante (and all these other singers on stage) are being evaluated and ranked on the same vocal standards by the audience. I guess that's just how the rules are designed in the show. I'm sure Rozette has her personal preferences and biases, but when it comes to singing skills, she did mention previously that Faouzia and Chante are the two strongest vocalists in this show, which I think many people would agree with.
With so many Halo covers on YT, vocal performance is lackluster for Moore. A-lin ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-iTDjvFBgUJ0.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-L6X0PqIWfzQ.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-6fAK0MHs4xE.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ww-LpIczi_A.html
I really enjoyed watching your commentary and sometimes I even delayed watching the full performances of the songs in order to wait and watch it with you guys while listening to your reactions - to keep things fresh! To be honest, I am rather disappointed with today's episode as the editing was too much. I found it hard to follow your commentary as the each of the performance was broken up into too many bite sizes that I couldn't even tell which part of the performance you were commenting on. I hope you will keep the full reaction video in future. I really, for one, watched all the 1.5hrs reactions video that you posted in the past.
身為中文和英文都算流暢(雖然母語仍是中文)的人,譚維維那首《人間道》引起的辯論真的不得不站在杰凱那邊。中文歌和英文歌的歌詞差異真的普遍差很多。英文當然也有寫得很美的歌詞像是 Lana Del Rey 也有許多詩意的描繪,不過中文的言簡意賅和一個字、一個詞就能涵蓋的千言萬語,真的不是英文這種「直白」的語言可以匹敵的。
You sang Grenade and Halo really well. I even prefer your versions over Faouzia and Chante. But I can't stop laughing after all you said about Grenade, and then you proceed to sing it with such emotion. Haha
有一点annoying了。每个文化背景下的影视剧都有很好表达剧情的theme songs,至于你看没看过,你看过的话剧情和你个人的connection有多深都有关系吧。in my opinion,before she even listened to or commented on the song, 第一否定对方不会喜欢,第二全盘否定其他文化背景的作品,真的很冒犯。只是因为你看了一个你很喜欢的影视剧,一个你很喜欢的主题曲,没必要吧。