【名人英語】跟麥明詩學習回應問題，十優劍橋畢業生不是神？ 

多謝你用這方法去教英文，很中肯、🙏🙏🙏👏我是71歳的婆婆、很喜歡你。

I quite like the way you explained her conversation lines! 😊👍

看了你的短片真的学习很多新的英文字，谢谢

Really like the way you present the talk and try not to overly criticise her performance while providing some nice suggestions. Looking forward to see more of your vid :)

I really like your gratitude and humbleness. Found your videos useful for us. Keep up your work !

我发觉身边D英文唔好嘅人都好中意话人哋英文发音（咬字）唔好，但系佢自己又唔识讲。相反英文讲得好嘅个D人会鼓励想学习嘅人多D讲。我好认同你个point：英文系用来沟通。

多謝你啊！ break down 左尼段interview 其實對應徵工作interview 好有幫助啊。

完全唔同意對Tiffany 的批評! 看了Tiffany 的vid, 就好似上了一堂英文課，得益良多，進步不少。Tiffany 把別人曾講過的英文重播，探討如何表達可令英文可完美，相信就算講者見到，都樂意接受，我們作為英文愛好者，生活在自己的圈子裡，講英文時有那些對錯，根本自己唔知，有Tiffany這種良師益友不厭其煩指正，實在得益良多，當然學問的東西， 一山還有一山高，強中更有強中手，如果Tiffany 有不足之處，大家可以共同討論，共同研究與探索。感謝Tiffany, 多謝妳，加油，加油，支持妳!

有學到，感謝感謝，希望有更多 ～～ 己訂閱

芬尼，多謝你，你的口音很好聽！令我重燃學好英文的目標。

Like this program. Learn a lot.

睇晒個VIDEO, 我覺得明詩表達得好有條理同埋用詞都好精準。而TIFFANY既分析亦都好簡易俐落, 令我明白點解明詩要咁樣講, 希望睇多D呢D高質分享既VIDEO令我地可以學多D ^^

第一次接觸你啲片！好中意！希望你黎緊可以拍多啲！

我覺得咁分析對練好好。猶其外國啲訪問節目很快，就算聽到大概意思，都唔可以遂隻字寫番出黎，咁其實都係一知半解，都未達到溝通既效果。希望你拍多啲啦。

謝謝芬妮老師你既教導，學左好多野，希望可以有多d呢d片可以學多d英文 望到老師你條片既comment，可以見到香港人真係好鍾意雞蛋裏挑骨頭，點都要搵d野踩下人，明明個個英文都唔係勁又唔願學，依家有得免費學又要冷醒踩下人 希望老師你唔好理呢d無聊人講野唔好上心，加油 ，支持你 👍

這種教學方式非常好👍清楚易明，多謝老師。

我覺得 reputation 取替唔到 brand name effect 個含義，因為 reputation 偏向褒義，但 brand name 先有追求名牌果種負面意思，亦即係麥明詩想表達嘅。

好睇😇有趣又學到野...👍🏻

今日無意中看到您的頻道，覺得您講解得好清晰易明兼夠貼地，睇完一次已經忍不住按下了訂閱掣~

謝謝教導﹗長知識了﹗

你分析得十分好，前面的it was，強調了過去，一般在演說入邊講得比較多，強調的聲音發在was。

Learning the good and the bad, pick the good and forget the bad. This is the reason why I watch the videos of Fannie! Doing great👍

O really like how humble n honest your style is ! Ga yau ❤️❤️

妳的教学好正吖！会一直捧场。

能取10A,绝非偶然，总有值得学习的地方。也谢谢Tiffany 的讲解，让我获益良多。

講得好好。😮

或者可以试下做D电影英语赏析，经典的电影也是很有意思的

It looks like you’re perfect. Yet I’m totally distracted when I looked at your facial expressions You’re my hero in criticizing others. Thank you

i love her accent. wow, i wish i could speak like that

睇晒成條片，你開頭同結尾都有重申個重點係去學習佢好既野因為評論佢好定唔好係冇意思。我覺得個內容你冇任何去表達”吓你10A英文都係咁咋？”。但點解會有人批評你好mean & petty 主要係個標題有啲串，特別係”不是神?”，因為依個係問題所以有viewers expect 去睇你覺得佢係唔係神，有先入為主既眼鏡去睇你條片點睇佢係咪咁神。可能你係想attract Louisa’s fans/haters黎睇所以set個juicy啲既title，但咁樣不利你真正想表達既野。有種俾個圈自己踩咁，特別係RU-vid咁多人好鐘意睇人點comments。如果想好啲，會唔會唔好咁set, 而係”跟十優狀元麥明思學習英文，原來可以這樣回應問題？” 咁就唔會有先講”佢係神？”睇下點樣”不是神”既反問感覺。 我覺得既然係educational purpose, 冇必要將 extreme judgmental 是非帶入黎。我覺得你係冇心，所以唔好將d complain 睇太重。我諗有心寫一大堆野既人都係想你做得更好，唔係踩低你，包括我。小小意見，期待更好好似依條高水準既video! Keep it up!!! Add oil!!!

It's good to know Miss Hong Kong Mak saying English from your channel👧

I don't know whether it's correct or not grammatically but I've never heard 'beneficially' used in this way. People usually say 'on the bright side' (like you said) or 'the upside is ....". Perhaps this is English people's way of speaking? @與芬尼學英語 Finnie's Language Arts

難得的正面角度. 以香港youtuber常以嘩眾取寵的角度來看事情,顥得很實在.

老師教英文我們應該感謝她、老師教學並冇批評別人英文、佢係教我吔免費學英文、多謝🙏老師！支持老師！老師加油💪！We love you

Thank you for your sharing, Finnie. Undoubtedly your usage is more colloquial compared with Louisa Mak's version. You sound more like a grammarist. There's nothing wrong for either side. I support both. You are right in pointing out judging is of no use. Some points to follow though (for academic discussion only): I would say Louisa Mak's version is rich in "legal flavour". 1) "Beneficial" and "detrimental" are words commonly used in law studies, in particular real property, contract and agency law (e.g. detrimental reliance by a third party on an agent or a certain party suffers no detriment in this contract) There's a famous theory in law: "a contract must be either to the benefit of the promisor or to the detriment of the promisee to constitute consideration" so and so. The ordinary understanding is something is "harmful". Yes it's true but I suspect due to Louisa's constant exposure to these legal terminology she could pick these words easily. It simply shows her legal education background is solid. I don't think one could erase such kind of knowledge easily. Rather I would treat this as her unique selling point as a Miss HK winner. 2) Tbh "superficial" and "shallow" are more or less the same: both refer to the lack of serious thought. en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/superficial en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/shallow I would accept both during an interview. 3) I agree with Mr Tsiqsin "brand name effect" is irreplaceable. "Reputation" is a neutral term referring to a generally held belief about something or someone. Unless she specified a "good" or "bad" reputation "brand name effect" would still be the best usage here. Again given her education background it's likely for her to have acquired this term from her peers. Another term I would suggest is "halo" effect even it refers to a person more than an institution. Given the time constraints for an interview her reaction was above standard I would say. It takes time to understand what she meant but compared with other interviews hers sounds special.

只有香港local先鐘意challenge 自己人啲英文……外國不論歐美，講英文為左溝通為做野，個個都知道每人母語唔一定係英文，但人地會尊重大家用英文表達時能夠有自己嘅用法~

一流

Tiffany, 比較鐘意呢段片甘樣，先放完整段素材，再逐句回放分析。新出噶片好多都係直接放一段分析一段，缺少整段練習聽力的作用，希望能採納意見。

好老實講英文會考A Ielts 都是7.0 -7.5 她又不是native speaker 你想expect D 乜 當然唔排除她讀完law 之後英文會有進步 但你唔能夠expect 佢native 甘fluent

我喜歡你節目😂

After I have a glance of Miss Hong Kong Louisa Mak speech, I was totally immersed into what she have mention and shows gratitude of Fannie disclosing the cideo

我很喜歡聽你的聲音和英語，我住在法國巴黎，我會講流利的中文和法語，我退休了，我在學英語，妳的英語很棒。

小儀!I miss u!~😃

Great teaching!

個 that 字係 definitive clause, 不需要加 and. "Judgement was made because xxx" 不需要加 on.

件衫好似手術袍

完全聽落冇問題

麥那段回應，計IELTS 起碼有8.0 ， 以Cambridge law黎講係普通D。一般開口及著俐港燦港妹，自己講到有6.5先好笑人啦。

i am aware more on the fluency than grammatical issue in a conversation. i expect that she should have a more fluent speech in the interview.

幾時評論宣萱同陳彗珊,劉家傑,馬道立的英文,等大家學下野!

英文 最仆街既係 每個字都識 連埋一齊就理解唔到 見到字幕都要諗一諗😑😢

聽唔出佢讀好多書，但睇得出佢知識好豐厚，講得唔流暢，但用字文法準，都幾寛，深，睇字幕學到好多野。

我自已Ietls 7.5 高考UE得C 問心講得差過佢好多

麥這段話中的superficial，意思並非你所說的"膚淺/shallow"，而是指着重外表、只看表面(相對於內涵)。她是說香港人並非只看外表(港姐選舉)，亦會看教育背景。但亦可說是只看表面，因為他們並非基於麥的言論而是因其學校名聲作出有關判斷。解作"膚淺/shallow"，並不恰當，她並非說香港人"膚淺"。另外，佢前一句說自己young and green，下句still prone to failure，指仍易於犯錯，failure不是時時也解作失敗，要看context。

People usually say in conversation : it works against me as opposed to detrimental. Detrimental is too big a word in this situation. Did someone die? My goodness

In our circle ... ..very green = virgin Please learn this

每个人的生活，成长背景唔一样，用词当然有别! 就算自己母语，有时都会词不达意。我真心觉得她已经表达到她想要讲概野。可能用词方面是你平时唔会用，唔代表她表达唔贴地。还是那句大家生活圈唔一样。 我会建议你可以做名人英语分享，强调好的方面，省返些建议，整件事就会好好多。我的浅见。

Detrimental is not a common word in my secondary school.

我都唔明点解有d人甘激动，如果系睇书教英文，我真系一d兴趣都冇，依家甘咪几好，睇下片，研究下演艺人士既用词同埋用词时既表情动作，点讲都是公众人物，会感兴趣d.

I thought she spoke royal English. I was a bit surprised she didn’t

To be honest, I am Not a little disappointed by Louisa's English because most graduates from Diocesan Girls' School Hong Kong speak the Queen's English, but obviously, she doesn't. I wonder why ?

我係米國住超過十年 日常生活接觸嘅都係 醫生 護士及專業人士(當然包括地道粗口)😄我覺得麥明詩嘅英文好好呀 最大分別只係英國口音 同美國口音 自問要喺訪問時用英文表達都未及麥明詩10份之一 佢前文後理同邏輯思維都好強 大愛這小女孩 一起學習！一起學英文 ！

我覺得狀元RU-vidr Melody Tam嘅英文好d？？？？？個人認為

佢係用中文思考的，所以英文自然不似外國人，咬字亦不清楚，不過十優係堅嘅！

Tiffany 您係夠火候分析10A明詩的英語（有觀眾質疑您？我不同意）您都有A，係A level UE，明詩果個A係會考。🙂

A normal person would say: I make mistakes too instead of prone to failures. Prone to failures sounds like she is writing an essay

始終不能同外國人相比嘅，我覺得成段片用詞用得好好，我好鍾意! 而且唔似參選時咁自大（可能亦係自信），改觀咗 😍

我还是喜欢宣萱的英文

根本英文就係講reputation, brand name effect係由廣東話轉過來，隨咗香港人，根本冇人咁講英文。

U r getting prettier

By chance I came across this video. I think her accent is nice and natural. However both your Cantonese and english need more polishing. I would rather talk like her.

唔明白點解that可以直接連接兩個clauses thx

why brother with these videos, she was being interviewed and nervous

麥好靚又好氣質

[十優劍橋畢業生不是神？] 有必要這樣說嗎? 為甚麼要用這個標題?

Too many rules on grammar, English learners would not be able to memorize all these rules. After all, native speakers of any languages speak without thinking. Nice video !

我初初都覺得呢個係教英文嘅channel，理論上係要雞蛋裏挑骨頭，字正腔圓都好合理，不過後來聽聽吓覺得「老師」講嘅英文真係麻麻地好聽，加上睇多幾個你寫嘅clip topic，有意無意好似想踩佢地咁（FYY嗰條都係)，唔夠中肯，就無咗興趣再睇😞，希望未來可以再有好video激發我睇返你channel嘅興趣

chupid?

以麥明思的背景，我會expect 佢的英文講得更加好、更加自然。現在顯然比較生硬。

只要流行，多人講，即使錯誤的語法遲早也會被權威列為正確的。畢竟英文是一種比較新的語言，還有很多地方不完善。

Was ending with the s sound rather than z is the correct phonetic pronunciation

多謝你 同這個方式 教英文 我係一個長者

我可以告訴你們，我會講六種話，最後的一科就是英語，語言的溝通就是講的話對方明白了，你就成功了。

香噴噴英文点講

No matter what 芬妮 said, I still believe that 麥明詩's English speaking skills is far better than her acting skills. 麥明詩的英文水平無論怎樣講都較她演技好好多😄😄😄

如果你真係想分析，不妨開個live，我地留comment去讓你即場演說，再去分析應改進d咩會更好。

I am sure that you are a very good teacher. You are full of patience and know what you are talking about!! Having said that, this lady 麥明施 the way she speaks English which is not that sophisticated to us in England. Yes, we can understand her what she means!! Just not that sophisticated enough to our ears!! Yes, she can speak English. Lack of characters, pretty pretentious!!

Somehow i think you are better than her at talking. writing ?

中国上海的 翻墙而来看麦明诗小姐姐 表示貌似能听懂大部分此视频粤语 哈哈哈

Dear Miss, it’s always easy to pick ... she didn’t have much time to organise herself. I guess you were there teaching, pick away. I don’t know this lady at all, on the fair side, she showed modesty 👍🏻

主要佢本来口才麻麻，所以人怎能完美

我覺得就採訪呢個問題同場合，佢嘅audience喺普羅大眾，如果可以用簡單直白更加生活化嘅高頻詞彙表達相同意思，觀感會好好多咯。美國荷李活/英國都唔少高學歷藝人，並且喺當前佢地嘅專業（演藝界）成績斐然，人地都唔會咁講嘢嘅。麥小姐劍橋10A講明佢確實喺聰明勤奮嘅multitasker，但喺呢段嘢我覺得有啲故作姿態, she didn’t have to talk like that.而且整個過程可以講並不十分流暢，窒窒吓咁嘅，要思考咁耐，我個人唔認為呢啲係佢十分慣用嘅詞彙咯，仲有啲好chinglish嘅表達，夾雜住上下文啲低頻詞彙，有小小搞笑，就好似一時文縐縐一時又好貼地咁。 最後就佢嘅內容我有一啲唔喺好同意，喺我細細個嗰陣，港姐個slogan就喺美貌與智慧並重，印象中高學歷讀書叻嘅港姐並唔係無，當然可能未到劍橋十A咁犀利，但真喺唔喺佢嘅口中講出黎好似佢喺開天闢地學霸港姐第一人咯🙄️。 最後嘅最後，great video!

英文要花好时间去学 当然有老教可能学得仲快

不如你也錄一段 跟外國人交談的影片 ，給我們評一評。

香港人可解英語水平差，是香港人太注重人家什樣看自己，怕說錯文法，衹懂捉人錯處，但自己又不懂英苵語，香港最喜歡句輿句之間說一句英語，英語不是我們母語，就算苵國人亦會錯文法，若是太差是可以接受的。

我很喜歡你

十優港姐英語會話比較唔理想。去咗英國三年，但係學唔到當地人發音同用詞。 佢嘅發音比較似香港人講英語。 另外佢用詞傾向書面語，同當地人的日常會話有分別。

都經已好出奇

其實佢用brand-name effect 係好過reputation好多，就唔好暗踩人啦

希望能做“G.E.M.”【名人英語】 找出錯處 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-nW4YQ3n4JHM.html 謝謝!