【追星心理學】「姜濤不紅，天理不容」？點解姜b咁受媽媽粉姐姐粉歡迎？ 

主持人，你的理論係正確的！👍 其實，何止中女，老中青、少女、小孩都喜歡佢，可以話由3歲到80歲都有佢嘅🍬。喜歡佢嘅真誠、坦率、努力、有智慧、孝順、與人為善，不因成名而驕傲。希望佢秉承這謙卑之心，繼續上進，為自己、為社會作出更多貢獻👍

一個真誠，纯真，年紀輕輕視野廣濶，用心自己演藝事業的男孩，心痛他經常被傳媒haters抹黑，攻擊，但善良的姜濤從沒反擊，只努力做好自己，看著他的進步，作品及個人演唱會得到行內外的好評，加油，你會越來越多人喜歡支持的，那些惡意攻擊你的媒體haters, 不必理會，they are nobody, 繼續做你喜歡的事，開心健康過每一天❤❤❤

姜濤粉絲年齢由3歲到90歲，當中包括不同層面及不同職業嘅人，姜糖不只是得中女。

個日去姜濤fc開倉排隊 見到好多唔同年齡層既fans都有 唔係靜係得中女或者媽媽粉 學生粉都好多👍🏻👍🏻 (自己係廿幾歲姜糖)

我係新糖，我睇咗你呢條片兩次，雖然你成日話吾特別鐘意姜濤，但我因為聽到你話好欣賞佢，所以我俾咗like，comment，subscript 你喇。佢而家成日俾haters及其他粉追擊俾負評，我都好心痛吾開心。其實姜濤為香港樂壇及經濟幫助咗好多，好多人包括我開始聽返廣東歌。我希望你吾好成日話吾鐘意佢喇，試吓去認識佢多啲，踏出第一步，好似我csl 你頻道一樣😄。

我喺男士。 欣賞姜濤喺佢幫廣東哥凝聚到一班新聽眾，同埋佢態度幾humble

學者：你誤會了，姜B唔係剩係得中女鍾意㗎咋，今日3鏡仔喺中環置地有活動，我親眼見到好多妹妹仔、學生，少女們都鍾意姜B 㗎，啲fans真係覆蓋老中青年齡層！😆

我係一個68歲婆婆我都比佢迷上左 鍾意佢的 真 真 真 乖 乖 乖 真係好鍾意 佢傷左心痛極了 每天看片我都心痛望早日康復

我75歲都係姜糖🍑❤️

好難用晒言語表達晒🤔暫試表達就覺得姜濤由全民造星至今都覺得他型仔可愛好聽好睇、言行、樂觀積極、造型、思考、夢想、努力、面對壓力、作品及說話等等像自己一向認同及嚮往方向,好希望這嚮往繼續出現、繼續成功！姜濤/自己、自己/姜濤、就這樣溶入自己生活世界不可缺少似的、可能生活想開心啲真係需要娛樂！尤其早幾年香港發生的事！希望大家繼續支持姜濤🙏繼續保持正面支持姜濤🙏不要走入負面言論群，這樣只會影嚮姜濤事業發展、身體健康和生活的愉快！🙏

Im a 長者, 姜濤 fans, lots of 少女學生 put on uniforms crowded in landmark to see 姜濤, so not only 30-40 ladies fans, but agreed u 要 protect 姜濤 as little brother的心理 n because his 勵志故事， humble n 真誠令人喜歡

現在才睇到呢條片，鍾意姜濤的不單只中女，好多長者或中年男士都鍾意佢，仲係學者專業人士，例如阮大勇大師話想姜濤做佢個孫，幫姜濤畫咗好多幅畫；董啟章先生寫咗幾篇文章讚姜濤，等等。好多同姜濤做過野的長輩都對佢讚不絕口，話佢好禮貌，識得尊重人，為人真誠，努力上進，例如陳詠謙，小克，Edward Chan，張敬軒等等。而同輩例如Tyson Yoshi, 湯令山等讚佢善良，對推動香港樂壇有使命感。所以鍾意姜濤的人無分性別，年齡層闊，社會階層廣，專業領域跨度大。當然，如果閣下現在再講返此話題，可能都會有唔同睇法。

雖然今日至留意到呢條片 其實姜🍬由兩歲到八九十歲都有 就好似最近十胎「作品的説話」推出 吸引大量學者都發表支持及欣賞#姜濤 從他呢幾年成長 努力 進步 尤其2022 叱吒 chill club頒獎 他在舞台的表現對別人批評回應 保護隊友 以至推動廣東歌大志 通通一再證明他值得萬千寵愛

呢班中女fans係屋企影響力超強，會影響家人包括先生、兒女喜愛姜生，又掌管家中財政大權！所以姜濤影響力係一出道已很大，而且將越來越強勁！

Very interesting analysis . Kt 成功不是刻意定位。 good timing to the market

其實只係因為姜濤的fans base 特別大，fans 年齡層非常廣，而當中以消費力最強既中層最draw 傳媒attention ，因為這正是推動廣告商搵代言的主因，所以你先有呢個感覺！

由一個大肥仔減到咁，性格好有堅持呀。係一個唔會蝦人嘅男仔。佢喊得好真實會令人心痛。

姜濤係呢個香港年代明星! 在無力感之下有一位年青人又努力又可愛又靚仔，加上佢係得到冠軍! 得到100萬好多現實香港人覺得佢係一位幸運兒! 有財神感覺，幸運兒帶比人運氣.廣告得到大賣，帶動經濟，只要有他出現就有起色! 姜濤效應.

姜濤魅力在於佢為人真誠善良 不卑不亢係每個人追求真善美既模樣 而佢既品格亦係經過挫折去打磨而成 所以更顯珍貴 而且更重要 佢對初心既堅持 係好少藝人可以做到～（當然佢舞台上既表演都係吸引之一）利申 學生 not auntie😬

我也非常喜歡姜濤這個「鄰家男孩」，他那份未鑿的天真，在今日的社會裏，珍貴如寶。所以，「'姜濤不红，天理不容」。

少年姜濤單純願望成為artist ，由於成長期因為超級肥胖，沒有朋友，於是沈醉綱上世界，更喜歡模仿台灣跳唱偶像，造就日後超級冠軍造星之路。姜濤超塵脱俗，底子純潔，純純兔形象給予粉絲們無限想像，祝願姜濤星運捷捷向上，繼續大紅大紫。

相信喜愛姜濤者並不是要保護他，而他也不是弱者，姜糖是欣賞他的善良，纯真，努力堅毅，無爭，大愛的天使性格。

我哋鍾意姜濤誠實有禮貌🥰孝順父母👍❤️為自己夢想而奮鬥👍為咗演唱會去隻腳痛，走去拍衝擊波🥰👍都完成咗佢嘅任務💪同埋愛惜兄弟💪唔理人哋點樣睇佢佢都我行我素👍改變自己人生💪

有料 市場需求一齊 最短時間得到最大的利益

講者太偏面，全民造星才真正令佢成功的原因，觀眾一天天看著他比賽奮鬥成長，亦將他的才華及優點展露人前，這才是真正的原因

真善美的姜濤😇

第一次看到这段分享片，其实我也不是姜糖，但是我对姜涛很有好奇心...为什么他那么受欢迎？ 慢慢关注他的一些访问一些作品，他的人真的很独特和很真诚... 他只想做好作品奉献给懂他的支持者欣赏。 我不是中女也不是婆婆级，我觉得懂他和欣赏他的人不会有分年龄阶层。

好愛姜Admin🌹🫚🫚🫚🍑🍑🍑有啊今年有個小妹妹都係鍾意姜濤同埋好多小弟弟仲有梓樂🌹😁😁即時老闆仔😁😁😁⭐️⭐️

姜濤粉絲年齡由3歲至90歲各年齡層男女老少都有，有普通市民，學生，高學歷醫生，會計師，文人，公司CEO，姜濤乖乖仔健康形象，謙卑有禮，尊敬前輩，考順父母，隊中不爭不搶，所以得大多人喜愛亦令好多人妒忌佢，佢吸粉能力之廣亦係佢實力之一

姜濤係少有甘謙卑的年輕人，最近佢遇到不少批評，但從冇惡言相向，係非常難得！

好優秀嘅presenter 推論得清晰易明、合情合理

I don't disagree with the theory about nurturance drive, but I found it rather superficial, like a macro economist explains what economic forces drive a recession, and you said it is only because interest rate. From what I know about Keung To 姜濤, he has more attributes than his innocent and cuteness characters that attract the older folks. Let's be frank. He got the charming qualities on stage, with his dance, his move, his vocal. This is more than just nurturance. His honesty and openness with himself cannot be found in most artists. From day 1, I tried to fact check his past with the intention to catch any of his lies. To my surprise, I could not catch any. Well, his love life could be distorted, or somewhat secretive which is understandable. Also, it is important for an artist to be connected with his fans. His honesty helps on this aspect. In summary, I would rather hear more in-depth analysis of this "idol" rather than just a simple theory.

Spot on analysis, fair and reasonable. Those are the exact reasons I support him like nobody. There are some more to it from my angle though - Keung is definite symbolic as in he doesn’t give what the market needs eg all his reactions / expressions / when in interviews etc all are from his true self and heart (not as commercial) I feel like this the most from him. I guess artists / public figure in the market tends to give what the market needs (no right or wrong) while he focuses more on what he wants to bring to the market and the message) that’s also somehow a credit to the management on how do they manage their artists ( Take an example imagine back in those days there were management prepared the artist too well and warned media to avoid certain types of questions blah blah blah) that said the management are still there to tune and recommend obviously which is what the one and only popular age 22 needed as well) I guess I could continue with another 50000 words on this topic. There has been debates(organic)/ discussions even within my own community. He s more than just a superstar and someone popular and commonly accepted. He is a phenomenon. Yes circumstances made the man, luck is obviously there but also his own hard work and effort that people shouldn’t miss. In terms of fan base, from what I observe / in my circle I heard from age 2-80 (no bias please perhaps the age 2 are also influenced by his age 32 mum 😂) but who cares - he s just so lovable and accepted❤️ Absolutely those with the highest purchasing power are eyed on him and these are the most powerful kind of support ever I believe as it’s out of just sexual driven kind of love more those support him all want him to succeed badly in whatever ways. And what we(they) are doing are the most practical / effective kind of support 🤗 also an excuse of shopping : retail therapy for those who has the most purchasing power lol There are really another 700000 I could tell nonstop -- the political atmosphere / social vibe etc That’s enough for now 🍬🍑🍬

好多少學生都鍾意姜濤and Black pink

姜糖喜歡姜濤夠真唔造作，紅而不驕，其實佢優點頗多，有排寫😅

我都係，唔係特別鐘意姜濤同 Mirror 但唔抗拒亦好欣賞佢哋嘅努力💪🏻

我永遠支持姜濤，

我發現如果我話Ian靚仔，我老公係認同的，如果我話姜濤靚仔，佢係有D妒忌的，所以係米男性都吾太鍾意姜？今天去左置地觀察，姜濤的fans由6歳至70歳的女性都有，AL是十多歲至二十多歳的女性為主

很喜歡你們五分鐘心理學， 加油！

放心,只要講嘅係事實,唔係事非,糖嘅都唔會無理,因為糖都唔會想令姜濤失禮

2024至2044行九運，大旺中女，姜濤得中女必得天下。

我最佩服嘅係姜太D前夫，都咁忠意佢。👏👍

其實吾衹姜濤，12個鏡仔都好乖，型像健康，無負面新聞。所以佢哋甘受歡迎系有道理的

好多小學生鐘意姜濤

分析得好好，日本因為一般都好大男人，好多女士一早已經鍾意小朋友 feel 明星

多謝你嘅客觀分析。

個人魅力無法解釋

分析得好好。謝謝欣賞姜濤

深山有直樹.世上有姜濤

👍🏻

姐姐粉表示最後幾分鐘呃得好開心🥳

真係講得超好 好鐘意呢期節目

Never never give up 🏆

姜生成為中女們的精神領袖同宗教領袖

簡單點講，姜濤就像當年嘅林志穎或者任何一個巨星最初出現在觀眾眼前，不論喜歡或不喜歡，都是大眾會討論認識嘅新artist，姜濤好珍惜自己嘅前途，努力和想做artist嘅初心係大家有目共睹，佢嘅作品有自己嘅主見，不是隨波逐流嘅商業歌，有更多新嘅元素和非主流嘅元素，又年輕又靚仔又可愛又跳得又唱得又有個人特色又食腦又唔黑人憎，借問聲咁嘅artist香港有幾多個呢？姜濤唔紅，天理不容❤

謝謝！

well said about Keung Tao

我觉得Anson Lo也很独特 他的取向可以说成就了他的与众不同 跳舞的时候身体柔软又有力度 魅力四射 有女性的性感又有男性的力量

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Thx

好多人都用common friends呢個詞，但應該係mutual friends才正確

姜濤真係好charm

thanks for sharing. I love your channel. is there any books/articles suggestions regarding this kinds of "idol worship" psychology please? Either Chinese or English is good. thanks.

最近TVB 出咗 Super Tiger, 就係傻傻以為可以照辦煮碗

我係柳炒,但身邊D人係咁力sell姜B

讲得唔错。就是独特性Lol

主持人吾追姜濤，今日又邊有話題！

接近姜誕又入嚟睇多次,留多次言,其實原來佢紅咗,就算冇犯錯都多HATER,啫我冇針佢都畀人屈係HATER

我係媽媽我鍾意佢 我爸爸都鍾意 但係我個仔都鍾意喎😂 你都講得岩 對佢冇性幻想 淨係想佢好 中女係消費能力高架 但未買Bvlgari 😅

求中文版字幕

明星偶像同歌手嘅身份唔代表對等

如果有mirror, 冇姜濤出現，才再聽番本地廣東歌😅

頭盔王 haha

姜逃係好可愛 ❤

點解當初咁多人鍾意tfboys， 就點解依家咁多人鍾意他.

明白本身對姜濤不感興趣，又何來會深究？不認為姜睇準這個討好的定位，fit自己入去，佢祇係做番自己。真誠坦率單純無機心，以下三十字省了。。。。

鍾意畀人洗腦

主持人不停在片中強調姜濤不是你杯茶，這種行為是基於什麼心理呢？😅😅

姜濤不是因市場因素而討好歌迷：不要小人之心．多些了解他的內心世界。

唔知佢地支持人地個仔既同時, 有無關心下自己個仔呢~

Rock 介紹得既人 都係比rock本身有深度 果個rock 淨係識得食辣 練大隻 最憎佢就係明明自己溝女好廢 又要扮高手 扮正義

姜濤有INFJ特質嗎？

小妹覺得Peter有魅力過姜濤得多

的而且確我身邊喜歡姜都係40-50以上的，後生既真的唔係佢哋杯茶，起碼我認識嘅唔會追姜，反而喜歡Mc或者林家him

馬後砲

姜濤/ 教主係大家好想身邊出現的人： 他們擁有人性美好的character: 真誠、善良、純粹、勤奮、熱情、努力、talent….. 可惜這些年這個咁壓抑的社會，好多真善美, 有talent 的人都被隱藏、磨去棱角…… 難得有這些人出現，所以大家好想keep 住呢種人，追求真善美。

成班c9😂

U are so biased!! Pls read the comments in Chinese asap. They all prove your opinions are based on shallow observations!!

癈話連篇🤪

its a shame that many of his die hard fans are very toxic

收皮拉，有咩实力，有樣，有演技？ 又唔識跳舞

靚女点會鐘意尼個低B仔牙，系D大媽中女當佢傻仔甘吹捧佢D低B動作懶可愛

Peter你都算勁 夠膽講唔欣賞肥濤 夠膽講班中女 竟然都無比人插...真心有料😂

我個價值觀唔同可能，好討厭姜濤尼種小白臉的感覺，我喜歡大男人例如Rain。。。

低能先鐘意

唱好啲先啦！唔覺佢明星或歌！廣告推銷員。bad taste！