The producers I'm able to make out, in order of appearance Circus-P nostraightanswer Aki - EmpathP =ODDEEO= darkbluecat（カハP） 雄之助 GHOST MystSaphyr Lystralle? MakkuSan? S??pp??? K?????
The two types of flower that appear in the video are Daffodils and Harebells (this one im not sure 100%) Daffodils means rebirth and new beggining Harebells (aka. Bluebells) most common meaning is humility and sometimes gratitude
@@rattheninja2877 @MiraPixel I commented in that Goodbye video long ago but until now revisiting it I see the comments have been turned off. I'm pretty sure the flowers shown are all magnolias, which in the color pink mean youth, innocence, and joy; the tree of the flowers (independent of color) means luck and stability/longevity for what I have find. All of the shown ones being broken could signify the absence or/and tarnish of all of those elements. They could also be freesias or cyclamen (as @KingArubin said before here) but due to their meanings, pink or not, I'm very unsure of such. As well, let me remind all that flowers are something temporary as we humans are. They wither when cut or when their season end, but only in one of this scenarios they'll grown back again. The flower at the end of the Goodbye MV is supposedly the one the girl fell with (and the one she has been holding all MV), this one lays now in a glass of water trying to extend it's lifespan but due to it already being cut, there's not much that can be done. At least we see the girl kept going after all, and she even got some new flowers, she had me worried for so long- 👍
Actually I was originally wanting to say exactly that, but I thought it was too much :D But it's nice to see someone sharing the same kind of weird humor :D
I remember listening to "Goodbye" for the first time. I was diagnosed with high functioning anxiety, with depression as a major side effect. It was so suffocating. "Goodbye" seemed to be that outlet for me to pour out all my feelings. Feelings I didn't know why I felt. This is such an amazing follow up. I have learned how to use my anxiety as a strength and I have friends and family to support me in my depressive episodes. I'm no longer saying "Goodbye", I'm saying "Hello, Again". Thank you as always for your lyrics Circus. Over the years its been your creative genius I have connected with the most.
This comment is probably the most relatable comment I've ever read. Only difference is I'm still working on my anxiety, but at least I'm not on the verge of suicide from it anymore. (I've been trying to look at upsides more and more lately)
@@ama_whiterose I'm still going through coping mechanisms. Talking to a therapist or counselor is definitely something I would recommend. They can personalize coping mechanisms for you. Much better than finding a generic list online. Dont be afraid to confide in friends and family. Anxiety is the mental illness where outsiders believe you have it all together and you're super organized BUT you're just really hoping everything doesn't fall apart at your fingertips. It has taken me years to get comfortable with just looking at someone and saying "I have anxiety." In fact, I recently emailed a professor saying I had anxiety and that's why I was turning assignments in weeks early and waiting for the new ones to be put up on the website. Everyone's anxiety is different. But no one deserves to go through it alone. That goes for any mental illness or ailment. God bless everyone.
Apparently I don't check my notifications because I didn't realize this had blown up. Please if you relate to what I said, reach out to a family member or friend. Reach out to a counselor or therapist. They can help you. You don't need to do it alone. Please believe me. If you were waiting for a sign, this is it!!! Go for it. Own your life.
The art is very similar to that of Goodbye....hmm ....obvious connection? EDIT: Oh...there's a definite relation...I read the description....so wait...did Miku survive? Yay her!
Hyperdontia 2580 At the end of goodbye, It showed Miku in a coma, then in this song it shows the same flower she had when she fell of the radio building.
It actually took me a few listens to figure out what exactly this song meant to me. Coming back to this song after hearing it the first time and no really understanding the deep meaning, I went to the comment section to see if anyone had expressed their own takeaways. Depression is what lots were saying. I didn't get it at first, even as someone who has had chronic depression for years and years. But after listening closely to the lyrics, I figured out why it was hard for me to understand despite the connection that I expected myself to be able to pick up on immediately. For me, this is a song about recovery. That is something I haven't experienced much throughout my years of mental illness. But now that I understand, it's really hit me. Just because the program is broken doesn't mean you need to give up on it. There are plenty of people out there who can try to find the problem for you. It might take a few tries, but you have to be optimistic about who you CAN be with the help of professionals. I've only ever had two therapists, one who I loved that quit and a replacement that wasn't right for me. I took that as an insult to myself, so I stopped looking for more therapy. But this song actually has me thinking about it again... I know that sounds kind of stupid, but I really do like the hopeful and yet realistic tone of this song. If there's a possibility things can get better, it's better to look for that instead of waiting. I think I'm going to look into seeing a therapist soon now. I knew I've needed to see one for a while but this song seems to have been enough of a gentle push to make me decide that, yes, I want to get better, and I will; it just might take some time and a few tries. I'm unsure if this was the exact intention of the song, but I'm still going to thank Circus for what it means to me. Goodbye attracted me before. But I think Hello, Again is going to be my new go-to for when I'm feeling bad. The tone of this makes me hopeful without being unrealistic. I really enjoy it. Wonderful work.
I hope things are at least a little better now, but I’m proud of u for still being alive, even if things feel impossible at times. Life can be a rollercoaster, and for some of us, it’s a lot more intense downs and occasional ups, but there’s always gonna be a light at the end of the tunnel. When we reach it, we get to choose what to do with that light. You might go down more tunnels later, but you’re never going to be trapped forever. That doesn’t mean that you never saw the light or that the light you experienced was any dimmer. Idk if my analogy makes any sense lmfao but yk- just hope ur doing well man, but it’s okay if ur not
@@xMythStarx this was a really sweet comment to see. I'm doing well! My depression is a chemical imbalance thing so it will probably never really go away, but things have been good despite that. I just got married to my partner of 6 years! I still need a lot of work, but things are definitely better compared to where I was before. Being able to keep up the optimistic point of view, even if it feels unnatural, has helped me a lot. Thank you for caring enough to worry about me. It means a lot. I hope you are doing good as well!
>Accessing hard-drive surrounded in a whirring sound >Searching the archive Corruption of data inbound! Pop-Pop-Pop Pop up an error As cycling, spiraling gears halt up La La La Lock up the server Something has gone wrong My heart, it feels heavy Tears flowing down my face Process to process the halting of pace So I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, what is there to be done?" Find a mechanist, a mechanism Working one-by-one With a busted up database I'm losing the chase But I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, Just who can I be-come-/?" >Accessing visuals All the bubbles have popped >Initialize reality This command can't be stopped-/ Pop-Pop-Pop Pop up an error As cycling, spiraling gears halt up La La La Lock up the server It's been far too long My heart, it feels heavy Tears flowing down my face Force-quit and transmit a crashing bitrate My mind it feels restless Amassed in this virus Is there a remedy for something like this? So I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, what is there to be done?" Find a mechanist, a mechanism working one-by-one With a busted up database I'm losing the chase But I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, Just who have I be-come-/?" [Hello, how are you?] [Hello, what can I do?]x2 My chest, it feels empty Tears nowhere to be found Shut-down and restart empathy.exe And in this short moment Reserve power kicking in Circuit a feeling to be unbroken So I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, what is there to be done?" Find a mechanist, a mechanism Working one-by-one With a busted up database I'm losing the chase But I'll say "Hello", again "Hello!" and turn to face the sun [Hello, how are you?] [Hello, what can I do?]x2
Fun fact: My brother told me that he saw a new song from Circus titled "Hello, Again". Though, he didn't remember which Vocaloid sings it (he was probably lying because it's Miku and he doesn't want to ruin the surprise lol) Now, the interesting thing is, before I even heard the song or found out who sings it, I keep on mentioning it as "Hello, Goodbye", instead of "Hello, Again". And when I heard this song for the first time, I realized that this song is literally the sequel to "Goodbye", which is also sung by Miku. Coincidence? P. S. I actually suspected Avanna sings this before I heard the song. How dumb of me.
Hello, how are you? Hello, what can I do? EDIT 1: Happy 11th Anniversary, Hatsune Miku! EDIT 2: Okay okay I just wanted to say I had an absolute blast producing this song and you have grown so much as a songwriter that being able to produce a song you wrote wound up being super fun cause I could just experiment with how I felt and imagined it. TwT I'm proud of what you've accomplished! Also, we threw a few cameos in there! Can you spot them all? Not just producers, but songs- thank 6LIN for them, and this entire video, as she did fantastically.
wow i’ve listened to your music for years. goodbye was so important to me...,,, and now,,,, its hello,,,,, i dunno. thats like, monumental to me. i love this. everything about it. thank you.
i remember listening to goodbye when i was in the depths in my depression, and then listening to this when i was struggling to recover from it. this honestly reminds me of all ive gone through to get to this point. those three years of struggling through everything actually means something, and i wouldnt be who i am without those experiences.
At first I though 'find a mechanist' meant find help for her robotic depression, then I realised the background for that lyric. Could it be suggesting the vocaloid producers are the ones that help miku through her depression?
Her voice is oddly really robotic, yet pretty clear to the point where it's pretty good English that you can understand without subtitles. Oh yeah, AND THIS SONG IS SO GOOD, THANK YOU MR. CIRCUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUSSSSSSSSS
Your songs have helped me through some rough times and I always look forward toy your Music, It always proves to be Unique, Creative, and done so well. It makes me go back, look up and think about the Lyrics, and the musical compositions are on par as well, showing the love done by who makes it whether it be you or a collaborator. I will never get tired of going back, relistening and loving your Music. Thank You, So very much for being you, and making what you've been making. I dont Know if VocaCircus will see this, but I just wanted to say something on the low chances you do
After watching a TADC animation using this song, whenever 2:42 comes on I can’t stop thinking about Caine taking the cast’s long-lost friends away from them
I think in this song, Miku has just woken up from a coma (recall that she jumped/fell off of a building at the end of goodbye) However, she suffers from memory loss and can’t remember who she is or what happened, and only has scattered memories and is trying to find somebody that can explain who she is
My theory is that people that work on Vocaloid and make songs using the Hatsune Miku voicebank is helping her through all of her hard times. That's my theory on the song and I just want to say a thank you to VocaCircus for all the lives you changed for the Vocaloid community and those new to Vocaloid. Even though this comment won't be noticed, please know that if you get discouraged just know we will support you through your way. I hope you get more popular because you surely deserve it.
As someone with anxiety that causes weekly/monthly/annual (varying severities) breakdowns, this song perfectly encompasses how it feels to get back up. You operate as a robot until you can operate on your own and it takes a while, man. Goodbye is similarly what a breakdown feels like and how it progresses.
I remember finding goodbye back in middle school and sobbing because it was exactly how I felt. But now hearing “Hello again” all these years later brings a smile to my face and reminds me to keep fighting my demons. Much love ❤️
This was a perfect way to experiment with the beat and melody. It had that “doesn’t-sound-quite-synced/ why-can’t -my-brain-grasp-it” feeling to it. Like it skipped a beat every once in a while. Just like a glitch! I love this.
When it comes to the struggles I've faced with my mental health, getting better has been a slow process, and despite the setbacks I've had, I feel like I'm making my way from "Goodbye" to "Hello, Again." Thank you as always for your gorgeous music, Circus ♡
It took three months to figure out but the pink flower is most likely a cyclamen! They are most known for symbolizing goodbyes and departure. Daffodils, on the other hand, represent rebirth and new beginnings ^o^
After some years of not hearing goodbye, my depression kicked in again and when I searched for it, this song popped up and I was not expecting it. It really helped me, now I'll seek comfort in this song and in my restart than coming back to my spiral of sadness that I always go to. Circus always do amazing things
Here just as it's about to hit 1M! Thank you for all of the music over the years, Circus! I've been around since the 715 era, and your music has only gotten better since then! I'm looking forward to what's in store next 🎉🎉🎉
The message "feeling to be unbroken"She wants to say that she can't stand it anymore and she's trying in every way to get rid of this illness that is making her brain corrupt, which is probably depression, in my opinion.
The grammatical implication of the comma placement is compelling. Rather than saying hello another time, the comma placement implies she's greeting the concept of again itself, which is a compelling concept in itself.
I have been in a super exhausted area in my depression lately and feeling cornered. I feel so worthless and completely covered in darkness and it's so hard to move from here but this just this is why I loved your music Circus. It always finds a way to speak to my heart whether it makes me feel I'm not alone or makes me feel uplifted. I just need to find a way to restart and bring myself up into the light so for this thank you so much. For some it's just a simple song but to me it speaks to my sore tired and ready to give up heart and now it's trying to pump strong to keep going. Thank you.
i feel like this song is about learning to deal with deppression and working through it even with a "busted up data base" or screwed up mind if you will and the way Circus was able to put this feeling into words is amazing and im probably wrong but this was me take on the song
I love the editing, 6LIN did amazingly omg! the constant moving keeps things from standing still in the beat parts but also gentle enough to put focus on the lyrics on screen, the glitching and the way it flips through the people in that one scene; NICENICENICE
i just think this is how miku was gone (almost?) in "goodbye" but now she is back, and she is rebirthed by many other producers and is living in many other songs, it's why she needs to find a mechanist (a producer) and she is struggling to remember who she is because she is actually many other people, produced by the producers.
Usually I expect a lot from Circus-P songs, but this blew everything out of the water. You've improved so much over the years, and that progress is evident in this song most of all. Holy gods, fantastic job Circus!
Accessing hard-drive surrounded in a whirring sound >Searching the archive Corruption of data inbound! Pop-Pop-Pop Pop up an error As cycling, spiraling gears halt up La La La Lock up the server Something has gone wrong My heart, it feels heavy Tears flowing down my face Process to process the halting of pace So I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, what is there to be done?" Find a mechanist, a mechanism Working one-by-one With a busted up database I'm losing the chase But I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, Just who can I be-come-/?" >Accessing visuals All the bubbles have popped >Initialize reality This command can't be stopped-/ Pop-Pop-Pop Pop up an error As cycling, spiraling gears halt up La La La Lock up the server It's been far too long My heart, it feels heavy Tears flowing down my face Force-quit and transmit the crashing bitrate My mind it feels restless Amassed in this virus Is there a remedy for something like this? So I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, what is there to be done?" Find a mechanist, a mechanism working one-by-one With a busted up database I'm losing the chase But I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, Just who will I be-come-/?" [Hello, how are you?] [Hello, what can I do?]x2 My chest, it feels empty Tears nowhere to be found Shut-down and restart empathy.exe And in this short moment Reserve power kicking in Circuit a feeling to be unbroken So I'll say "Hello", again "Hello, what is there to be done?" Find a mechanist, a mechanism Working one-by-one With a busted up database I'm losing the chase But I'll say "Hello", again "Hello!" and turn to face the sun [Hello, how are you?] [Hello, what can I do?]x4
I love this song. I love it because I can relate to it, as someone who had nearly died and woke up from a concussion barely remembering a thing, from holding a spoon to simple spoken language. It took me a long time to readjust to living, and a lot of things in my life had changed that I wasn't comfortable with at first, but then I had a kind of revelation and found something I could do with my life. These days I want to be helpful to people, helpful to my family, and take better care of myself. That's why this song indeed does resonate with my heart, and that in itself is something. I'm saving money for a good microphone, so I hope I may have your permission to use the instrumental to make my own cover of this. Thank you for your contribution over the years, Circus. I hope to see more of it. 😊
I've been following you for a few years now and I have to say the improvements you've made have blown me away, from lyrical pacing to instrumental structure and sound as a whole, it's amazing to see how far you've come from your days as a cover artist to original songs like Circus Monster and aiSeNMa. I really hope you keep making songs for a long time, I can't wait to see what you come up with next.
I was pretty bad too when goodbye first came out. And I was very worried about you, circus.. It was such a relief to saw you heal with this song. Circus I always want to support you.
i like how it's like a human saying "hello, how are you" and a computer saying "hello, what can i do". the human wanting to make a connection, and the computer wanting to provide a service, as is the nature of both of them.
You deserve 100M subs. Ur the best vocaloid producer your songs inspire me to live my life better than what I have now.. I wish you could teach me how to make songs.. My life has been moved and changed thru ur music. THANK YOU FOR THIS T-T
Oh, I just noticed when she says "Who can I become?" It is spelled 'be-come-I' meaning you can become yourself, to me that means you don't need a label or be "something", just be come yourself again. I love that.
2:17 :000 Ghost!!!!! that's!!! ghost and pals!!! but that aside, this song is absolutely breathtaking. it sounds so beautiful and the melody really speaks to me! i've loved your work ever since i was 9 or 10! amazing job! ^^
A few years ago I was diagnosed with severe depression and anxiety, and there was very little I could do aside from take medication every day. One day though, I tried singing this song and I felt a little better. I'm not a good singer, not by a long shot, but it makes me happy. There wasn't really a specific video this would be best for, but I just wanted to say that songs like this were great ways for me to vent out my feelings and thoughts, even if it's just in my head and/or nobody else can hear me. In just a few months I'm planning on coming off the medication for the first time since my diagnosis, and I wanted to just get this out into the internet
oh wow... i didn't know there was a sequel! when i first found goodbye, it was one of the only things i'd listen to because of how much it resonated with me. it was a somber reminder of a time i've overcome, and i found myself going back to it every once in a while. now, once again, you've given me something to relate to, because i've finally found myself in a mentally sound place where i am no longer wishing for a release every second, and for that i thank you.
