印度会崛起为下一个中国？印度人信吗？| OVERLAP 

這位印度學者很敢直話直說，也切中要點，證明印度人狠角色也很多，只是在印度國內沒人甩他們的諫言。

我很認同这位學者的幾個觀點：1，你可曾經見过什麼東西是Made in India的，但你去外國旅遊別說非洲，就是歐美貨架上的商品中Made in China都佔多數，即使在印度本國中國的產品也比比皆是且極受歡迎，只有簡陋的農具才是印度國產貨。2，中國的高端科研人員大多願回國服務而印人卻外流；海外華僑賺到錢了就回鄉興學辦公益而印人一去不回頭。印人嚷嚷他的國民年齡結構比中國年輕，殊不知那是醫療落後衛生差勁國民短命所至；印人嚷嚷他是人口第一大國有人口紅利，殊不知他的文盲人口幾佔一半且生產力低劣；在戰場上作戰的時候他們的士兵听不懂他的長官在說什麼，往哪裡打，因為南方的士兵听不懂北方的長官说什麼，東區的也听不懂西域的說什麼，原因是全國沒有統一語言。嗚呼，哀哉！ 中國？國土比印度大三倍，黑龙江人說的話海南島人听懂；江、淅人說的话僵、藏人听懂。夫三哥哉認輸吧。

我是一个在华小读书的印度裔，小时候也回过几次印度，我同意这个学者的观点。虽然我也很希望生活在印度本土的同胞可以更富有，但是涉及到经济发展，我觉得实事求是远比夸大其词更有用

谦虚使人成功，骄傲让人落后。中国人永远要保持一颗谦虚的心态，努力实干。不管印度发展怎么样，中国面对的都是全世界，从最高科技到最大市场，挑战困难永远都在，没有什么时候是完全顺风顺水的。认清困难才能一往无前。做好自己的事情是永远的王道。

Hope Indian don't take it as insult or discrimination, he just wants India to wake up

这是一个有智慧的印度学者!

哇，還是印度人了解印度，句句精闢，好棒的訪談

强！太强了！如此清醒和真正聪明的印度人，恐怖如斯。然而正如视频中讲的，印度的问题是一个系统性的问题，即便印度有这样有智慧的人士，面对这样的一个系统，除了远离，就是无可奈何了。

圆脸的水平值得尊敬！

I have been following this Indian scholar for years. He’s a very good scholar in my opinion. His analyses were based on facts. I like his objective attitude towards world affairs.

如此的对话十分有益，很能深刻理解今日印度的根深蒂固的顽疾，感谢圆脸，感谢这位印度的有识之士！

Indian problem has been comparing itself with China. China progress itself without looking at India, because India wasn't it target, it simply progress passed it and still going. It's a sad reality that 800 million Indians still waiting for free food handouts from the India government on a daily basis, the West are celebrating the democracy and freedom to ensure that the Indian stays at this position and level therefore no there won't be a national security threats?????

印度人也很聪明，有的知道如何通过反华来推销自己，有的知道如何通过亲华来获得利益。 中国人应该保持冷静； 了解自己并了解他人。中国人可以自信，但绝不能傲慢。今天的印度肯定落后于中国，但它正在获得西方富裕国家的支持来对抗中国，再加上其国内潜力和快速发展的海外侨民在西方主要国家全方位的在政治、技术、商业、法律、媒体、医疗、公务员、大学获得权力中心地位，而中国和海外华人的影响力正在退缩。西方主要媒体的印度背景评论员可以评论涉及世界任何国家的问题，但华人背景的媒体人只被安排评论涉及中国的问题。印度人不必躲在” 亚洲人” 的后面，但海外华人现在发现有必要自我认同为亚洲人而不是中国人会更好。即使是简单的已经在北美持续了百年的 “Chinese New Year” 说法现在也是政治不正确的，美国和加拿大华人在有形和无形的社会政治压力下被迫使用政治正确的 "Lunar New Year”说法 。叹！很无奈。

實事求是 是進步的要件之一…。 接受現實真實 才能去改變或改善它。 一直迴避和遮掩塗飾， 內部爛的地方並不會就此消失或變好。 這位和那些電子寵物和殖不同的是， 他只是就事論事， 並不是刻意歪曲抹黑， 這才是愛自己國， 他不是恨國者，更不是"公知"。 公知現在是貶義： 假愛國之名卻故意歪曲醜化實際狀況，想要的是詆毀國家的宣傳效果，而非為了國家好。 他的話沒有任何詆毀的意思， 直面問題本質，沒有刻意拉踩， 說的都是很切實的問題而且還很克制。 換中國那些真正拿了NGO錢的公知， 那講出來的是些什麼？ 中國天天都要崩要亡了。 都是又要當又要立的樣子， 還想要寫得像自己是什麼拿牌坊的， 和恨國也沒有兩樣了。

这么客观冷静分析的学者，非常值得尊重，反而让我们感到紧张和压力。自大不可怕，冷静自省的人让人敬畏。

Salute to both the guest and host. It's hard for many Indians to swallow, but facts are facts.

神奇之处就在于中国崛起，自信心提升最多的似乎是印度人。这感觉就像我高中同学发财了，所以我马上也要发财了。。。

The guy is intelligent and courageous. I wish all countries have such kind of scholars who criticize their own countries in a honest and constructive way.

Thank you Mr. Jayant Bhandari for showing us the truth, this is a serious wakeup call for everyone, especially for the Chinese people.

中国绝大多数最优秀的人都留在中国为之奋斗。❤❤❤

这老兄和很多华人一样，爱之深恨之切。问题是希望，危机可以是机遇。只要路子对了就有希望。

I would say it like this -- electoral politics in a democracy actually doesn't serve the people -- the big money involved and insecurity causes the result of division and hate being used as a way to finance their political campaigns. This is why I'm for the Chinese one party system. I live in the USA and I was born in Taiwan. I understand the importance of identifying the problems in my own countries in order to find the right solutions.

这哥们很勇敢 敢说，敢刨析自己， 说明印度将来还是会起来的， 只是时间问题。

我在欧洲遇见的所有印度人都在想尽办法留在当地，没有一个愿意回去的

20 年前，没有人认为中国会赶超日本，英法德 甚至意大利。我不是说中国一定会被印度赶上，而是说我们要继续努力。

Thank you for your sharing. It is natural to worry about the potential risks to Mr. Jayant Bhandari's personal safety resulting from his candid discussions of Indian politics and economics, yet fostering an environment where diverse perspectives are shared and respected can contribute to a more harmonious and more productive society.

Jayant is wise smart n intelligent. professor Jayant you are awesome 💪

Couldn't agree more. I go to India every year for businesses. The country is so inefficient at every level. The workload of 1 person is typically split into serval jobs, from hotel room cleaner to government functionalities😅

China doesn’t need comparing herself to others. If the Chinese people continues to be humble, learn by doing, and work collectively, China will be stronger and stronger. How will you think if comparing China 2024 to China 2023?

Mr.Jayant Bhandari is putting his life for speaking so honestly. He is indeed a brave man.

贵视频太可爱了，作为主播所具有的素质、教养值得尊敬！喜爱！

If half of Indian politician and think tank like this guy mindset a realist and pragmatic. Indian will not have hard time to fix the problem. Sure India will be rich, but where are the wealth are concentrated, that's the concern.

这个印度学者对自己国家的客观情况非常了解👍

很棒的一次訪談🎉🎉🎉

长見试了！这才是真正的学者。客觀、公正、希望印度的政府官員都能看见此節目而有所作为。

很像旧中国，很佩服我们的先辈，也很敬佩这样的印度专家，这既需要勇气也需要能力， 向您学习。

好！强烈建议再次连线，说说这位学着看待中美，中欧之间的问题观点。

我现在60岁，这辈子几乎没有见过印度制造的工业品

Splendid interview! Great questions and with well analysed views.

一个説实話的人值得我们尊重。

这位印度经济学者很不错也很现实，比国内的一些专家都强多了。

Thank for inviting Mr. Jayant Bhandari to the show. Big Thank You to Mr. Jayant Bhandari for your honest perspectives of India.

任何一個國家都有機會崛起，但是要具備適應當下底層經濟條件的政治結構（最根本條件），並在當下的宏觀大背景下做出順應歷史趨勢的選擇，腳踏實地。 但印度不具備以上條件。首先其最根本的經濟條件和散裝的央地結構，根本就不滿足其搞英美民主，結果就只會讓富的越富有，窮的依舊停留在部落文明。 任何不實事求是，腳踏實地的強化發展，成天想著投機取巧的國家，都不可能實現所謂的【崛起】 中國的建設發展是花了幾十年的時間忍辱負重地再一次次挫折中一點點往前走到今天的，靠的是專注踏實地走在當下的每一步的。若有人把“國家崛起”歸因於“10年內就能達成的成就”，這樣的人未免歷史觀太狹隘了。

very fair statement, i gain so much knowledge from this, thanks 🙏

最瞭解印度的印度人，讚！

You know, by and large, what the difference is between China and India? India is obsessed in comparing herself to China (at least in Indian and Western MSM), while China just kept her head down and focused on doing the work. Just do what you have to do, India, let the numbers speak for themselves.

He is a smart and intelligent person, that makes him see the difference between his country and the world and speak out honestly. 👍

WOW, it’s so refreshing to hear a caring voice to speak the issues without hesitation. If only everyone, every leader in the world has the integrity, courage, intelligence of this man, to see things as it is. Acknowledging the problems, stepping up to the challenge, working together to achieve the goals, best for everyone, stop the insecurity, jealousy, hatred, greed. Allowing ourselves to better education, open our hearts and our minds to different cultures, except that we are all in this together. After all, we all want the same happiness, joy, good health , wealth , friends and family to share our stories.

This gentleman is really a learned frank respectful Indian who's brave enough to criticize his own motherland with the intention that the Indian government can seriously look into the problems that hinder it to become a recognized global power.

这位印度人头脑清醒，眼光犀利。可惜没有为印度工作

Thank you for this informative video about India. Anyway hopefully India continues to progress in the new year 2024 and beyond.

The scholar is so honest and knowledgeble across the world

圆脸开始做访谈节目了吗？真棒！

A very nice guest you have, very outspoken, I can see he meant well for India, wish him well, also I am reading LKY books and man he can foresee the situation so well

Excellent interview and discussion 👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍

印度如果更多像这位先生的话；超越，乃至世界第一，指日可待。不过西方乐见如此的印度，这才是他们可接受的发展中国家。

这老哥也太狠了，不过批评莫迪的有点对，依靠仇恨穆斯林团结印度教，问题这穆斯林人口并不低啊，要是玩崩，没控制好，真的就是完完全全的灾难性的，印度再解体一次都有可能。😂😂😂

I really appreciate India scholar, his insides to the India current problems are well stated. India and China shall be friends and work together. I hope India leadership will change. We wish India catching up quickly.

加拿大這邊很多印度裔的移民,表面上很和諧,私底下(因種姓背景,學歷,經濟狀況...)互相看不起. 去過認識的印度裔的人辦的party,細看是這樣子. 我希望華人到了國外能夠團結互助一些.

中国人还是做好自己就好了。人均GDP中国离发达国家的确还有一段距离。现在专注工业4.0才是关键。

Wow, it is so nice to see 圓臉in here👏👏👏

印度必須如這位印度評論員誠實謙虛面對自己的缺點與真相，才有機會讓自己成為偉大而可信賴可互動的國家，可惜缺乏睿智遠見的領袖又採用西方民主選舉制度，讓印度的沉疴難題近乎無解而且愈發惡化

下一期希望重點討論一下，印度政府怎樣敲詐、掠奪、蠶食、吞掉外商在印度的投資，例如稅務、針對性立法追憶性懲罰、複雜的司法制度等。 有哪些外資投資商在印度被印度政府剝了幾層皮的？ 為什麼這麼多外商知道印度投資的風險這麼高，仍然要不惜一切去投資印度？投資印度回報如何吸引呢？ 為何中國有這麼多大品牌企業明知印度反華歧視中國的的政策，為何偏要向虎山行要在印度紮根？例如國產幾大手機品牌商。 在印度投資的外商最終真的能佔領印度的市場份額？還是最終會被印度逐漸蠶食掉技術股權和資產？ 外商投資印度的心態是否都是想在資產被吞掉之前，儘快掘幾桶金走？

A very good interview.

強烈建議轉發這則視頻給全世界的地球人看

The best summation on the state of affairs in India! Thank you.

Good conversation , I learned a lot on the issue .

Mr. Jayant, thank you so much for teaching us so many things about India

所有想去印度賺錢的企業與個人，建議好好的看看這個討論再作出決定。

回答很中肯！这就是现实！

Very interesting and impressive conversation

It's a pity that Zephyr didn't get to ask "Can India still able to attract foreign investors even after incidents like Xiaomi who got a huge fine by the Indian government? " 可惜圆脸没问到专家“印度还能继续吸引外资即使有小米和其他外企已被印度政府重罚？”

印度精英回流，將是印度崛起的轉折點。它不一定由印度本身引起，也有可能是西方包括美國的崩潰或東亞的崛起引起。很難講一個世紀之後會發生印度和中國在亞洲齊頭並進的競爭，中國的政局和反腐是中國穩定發展的關鍵，最擔心在領導人更替時出現問題引起集體意志的變質。國家也有生老病死，中國也要做長久之計，印度是另一個零和國家，沒有中國和諧共存的傳統。

非常精彩的采访

Great speech from Mr Jayant Bhandari. ❤😅

这个对话非常非常棒！！！！！thanks. lot, 小胖

Insightful conversation. This gentleman is intelligent.

A very frank assessment indeed, and very hard words.

well done interview!

圆脸做主持了！！😊😊😊❤❤❤👍👍👍👍

谢谢分享~

You give me a very insightful information.

When folks living in US or other parts of the world aske me about India, I ask this simple question to them as well. Please tell me what Indian made product you or others use and they go quiet and thats the general answer.

看到有追的頻道主波士頓圓臉在別的頻道出現　真有點高興

這位少有的誠實印度學者，確實是值得稱讚，印度本身傳統體制問題太大了，真是無法改變，所以這是永遠無法解決的問題，包括宗教信仰的社會，也是一大考驗！

He speaks truth, I admire it,

Good interview. Zapher Try not to smile too much when guest is describing Indian deficiencies

Jayant is one of the best India experts. Watched his interview few years ago and he was impressive

Jayant Bhandari is an extremely intelligent Indian. For China, this kind of understanding person is the most terrifying.

Indian scholars’ multi-angle analysis is very pertinent

Although I have never been to India, I have always paid attention to this country. Thanks for the great talk Mr. Jayant and hope you are staying safe.

很有意義的節目，讓我對印度有更實際的認識，謝謝主持

Very insightful

This Indian scholar tells the true between China and India. He is very objective.I'm gonna give him a thumbs up.😎

One of the few Indian scholar who saw the reality and accepted the truth.

中印都是人口大国，又是邻居。希望中印能处理好，解决好边境争端问题，互补互利共同发展好经济。

爱之深，责之切。可以看得出来，他真的很爱自己的国家。

说的很中肯，也剖析的很直接

好节目

Lies and bluffing, are made naturally from India. No hard feeling, this is truly what I felt after these years. Of cos, there are ones are genuine and naive, but not that many.