In the third performance, the woman in white dress is not a professional singer. She's a TV show host. Rozette is good to notice that she's less experienced.
Coach Rozette we really appreciate your honest and professional comments. I would love to see your reaction on Tan Weiwei’s “Night of Ulaanbaatar” from The Singer. Thank you we love you!
The last show, girl in white is a TV host in China, she cannot sing well, that's why u cant really find her doing duet or 3 part unison. But her husband is China famous singer, u reviewed his video before and love him so much. Before this performance, her husband help her a bit by choosing simpler verse for her to sing in this song, those difficult parts he said leave it to the 2 professional singers. 😂
You are right, the 2nd song is older than the first one. This song was written by the 2 ladies at the left and right of the 2nd song. And the three ladies in the 2nd song are the original singers the song was intended for. The 2nd song was definitely live, with no autotune, since it's part of the concert. I'm not sure about the 1st and the 3rd ones though, since they are parts of 2 Chinese musical entertainment shows, which you should know, is often autotuned. For the 3rd song, the lady is white is a show host. She is not quite a singer. That's why her singing is often simpler. It's a song for the ladies. The original recording of this song with the ladies from the 2nd song have more 3 parts harmonies. So if you want to get that, go listen to that one. You should learn about the background of the song. It's touching, emotional and meaningful for the ladies.
Wonderful observation. I love your reviews, of these chinese singers, starting with Zhou Shen (erm perhaps not so much on the first one, but I still commend your frankness and honesty). But also would like to appreciate your frankness, again, and sharp observation of this chain of comparisons across the various groups. The lady in white in the last performance is indeed more inexperienced than any of the other singers because she is not actually a singer by profession, unlike the others. So this may account for the fact that her singing is abit simpler, without as much flowers or flair in her techniques, because she is more an actress/variety shows host. But I think she still did a pretty decent job (albeit with some assistance from the production team). :) Oh just a fun fact as well, the lady in white is the wife of Jason Zhang, whom you reviewed quite recently.
黃琦珊 &丁当 are definitely better, when both singer have big voice and now hold back and sings it's very beautiful. 譚維維 魏雪漫 金池 are more relax performance because it's a concert not a competition. and this video was really old. 龔琳娜 美依禮芽 谢娜 (white dress gal) roxette you're so right, she's just a famous TV host, she's not a professional singer, BUT her husband, which u have done reaction to, Jason Zhang Jie is her husband.
I actually like 龔琳娜's voice the best out of all of them in this video... 美依禮芽 is good too but I think she's much better when singing Japanese songs... Not expecting too much from 谢娜 since she is not a singer... 😅😅
Speaking of 3 part harmony, can Rozette please review The Sound of Silence from Super Vocal? In addition, it would be a dream of mine if Rozette could also review my favorite singer, Jolin, maybe her 2015 MAMA performance? Thank you for the amazing videos! ❤
