國外聲樂老師點評 周深 x 美依礼芽「secret base ～君がくれたもの～」Vocal Coach Reaction to 未闻花名ED 

周深是一個最佳的輔助人，合唱時他總是為了呈現歌曲的效果而去配合對方！他說只要歌曲好聽他不在乎唱幾句，甚至只是輕輕和聲！這就是他！

那個推拉音是非常典型的日式唱腔，怎麼說呢，如果少了那個推拉音就少了靈魂，所以美依禮芽才這麼唱，如果老師有去翻其他日本的歌手就會發現這個推拉音頻率出現的超級高😂😂😂老師可以把它當成是典型的日系唱腔喔～習慣了以後會發現這種唱法其實蠻有意思，有種：啊！就是這個，這就是日本的感覺，搭配日系動漫食用風味更佳喔～強烈推薦老師去試試看！😘

很棒喔，老師說周深是大師級的；很有禮貌配合美依禮芽；第一次合唱選這歌是中庸之道，

小美被稱作Push pull 的習慣應該和日式演唱風格有關，不曉得是不是受到日本演歌影響，那種口氣常在日本歌者的表演聽到，其實也蠻習慣的。

A few information to share: 1. Teleprompter used in the performance was written in Japanese. This means, very likely Zhou Shen can read Japanese. 2. Someon in Station B has done an autotuning testing. Both singers' vocal had not been autotuned. 3. After the performance, Zhou Shen mentioned that there will have further collaboration/s with Maria (plus one more artist) 4. Maria had been publicly requesting to have collaboration with Zhou Shen on more than one occasions. Here she has it. 5. Others vocal experts also commented that Maria has a thick/rich high pitch. That is very good. 6. This performance already has more than 2.5 million views so far in Station B alone. It could be one of the all time hits.

這位點評，真的實在是太厲害了👍聽一次點評，學習太多的東西！🎉

很喜歡老師就事論事的評論，兩位歌手都很棒。周深的歌都很好聽，請他小心多保重自己的身體，不然粉絲可心疼了。

深深的合唱推天下有情人、愛情轉移跟山楂樹（節目是我們的歌跟聲入人心）。 深深跟小美兩位天使我超喜歡❤

我从来不会这么认真听一个点评老师的点评，也不会觉得太多停顿，因为都在点子上，这个老师很可的👍

好希望周深本人來回答老師的問題哦。 也想看老師跟周深合作的舞台。😊😊😊😊

用假聲純粹是周深在這首歌的選擇， 老師可以聽他獨唱的第二首歌「生活總該迎着光亮」， 這首歌唱得超有力量，超級好聽， 合唱歌很明顯他有關照到小美

老師大概也不知道深深唱了一整首節奏又快又長的非母語的歌曲吧? 這首歌真的比較沒有可以發輝之處。 當二人要配唱,若無法兩者兼美,深深通常還是會選擇讓對方比較起來呈現的更好。 依舊期待他們2人後續的合作!

Teachers really wonderful, what she comment is mostly accurate. Coz watching behind the screen for Zhou seng, not this song, other song for duet performance. Zhou seng always find the harmony during duet and try making both singers to be comfortable when singing. What teacher said at the beginning Zhou seng changing he falsetto and interpretion.

Perhaps Rosette does not realize that Zhoushen is singing in Japanese, and many Japanese songs are performed like this, especially songs written for female vocalist

只要是深深的我會追

期待老师能去到中国参加节目，带给我们不一样的音乐，以及能够和中国的歌手擦出火花

老師都覺得❤❤聲音累，他日日都飛機當車坐，行程很密，我都替他累😢

8:00 這或許是日本歌手的習慣？印象中很多動漫歌曲都聽過歌手這樣唱呢~

美依礼芽之前说想和周深一起唱极乐净土，希望能有机会听到。

啊！好新鮮！插隊了！不用等一個月看react周深了！

Jack-of-all-trades you name it he's got it truly multi-talented !

想讓老師聽一下周深唱的一期一會

maria shen @Topheronie Yes, Rosette is correct in noticing something different in Zhou Shen's singing key with the young Japanese singer. Firstly I agree with R's observation that he shows some fatigue. I've been noting the same throughout the past months. Yes, Shen Shen has been even busier in his multiply scheduled musical commitments this first half of 2023. He flew back & forth from city to city, released a multitude of OSTs and songs, two very successful outdoor musical stage shows with mainly approx 30,000+ impromptu attendees (not scheduled concerts). A duet stage performance with a renowned Chinese Baritone singer Liau C. Y.. Zhou Shen was also was especially appointed as the lead singer in the honorary National Centre for the Performing Arts (National Opera House) in Beijing, by a renowned music composer Shu N. to sing his glorious & beautiful composition serenading the spirit of the Republic of China . 美依礼芽 the young Japanese singer who adores Zhou Shen had been longing and asked to be honoured with a duet stage performance with him. Yes, she finally got it, June/27th she got her wish, hence her excitement and Zhou Shen's attempt to adjust or to adapt his key with hers. This is one of the two songs she sang with Zhou Shen. I humbly hope Rosette now can have some understanding for your silent query from your sharp observations as a great music artist & coach 😀

日文始終不是主語言，另外他合唱時盡量都是收斂自己，盡力去配合對方，達到效果，加上好似深深是趕去演出，同場配合採排應該都是好趕時間，時間上一定不足夠！而且配合小美

小美的音色是渾厚類型，猜測周深是為了讓歌曲層次更豐富所以選擇假音詮釋。 推拉唱法應該是日本歌手的典型唱法了，熟悉日語歌的朋友應該都蠻習慣的^^

這插隊插得好！

以周深的音域之廣 他配合別人的確是比較適合 而且深深本人謙遜有禮 也不在乎誰是主唱 我只是覺得製作團隊應該有系統的推薦老師去點評的歌曲 比如依照出道時間先後 不要時間跳來跳去 這樣老師可能會覺得歌手發揮不穩定 而不是一直在持續進步中 不管如何 我覺得這老師很專業 就是被噴後 點評變得相對保守了

Well I recommend you to hear the fancam of this stage, personally I think it's better than the official one. Like, thicker and more in tune maybe.

謝謝老師的點評。 但實話實說，周深要唱不是母語的歌詞與唱腔的時候其實已經可以先從70分開始打起。 美依的歌聲，說實在的，(不管是動漫宅、還是日歌狂其實我很喜歡那個抑揚頓挫) 我真的很喜歡那種頓一下然後唱出來的感覺 08:00，突然覺得「感覺對了」那種feel 周深也很棒，不容置疑，因為輕輕柔柔輕描淡寫的那種唱法，也非常舒服 但這一場，我覺得兩人的搭配是非常棒的(但我給周深非常高分，畢竟日語要唱成這種感覺屬實不易) 我覺得都很棒，畢竟不同語言，這是一場好的表演。

You are right, whenever he makes duet , he’ll do anything just to make the song perfect and the partner more comfortable . Understood you must be busy, but if you have time , can ask your friend or your teammate to find more duet he’s done, you’ll find that. And just because he’s capable, and he’s willing to adapt to the partners, almost all the duet was perfectly done, some are even better than original ( i mean, original songs are deeply embedded into our minds, most of the time, we tend to feel original is better, but from zhoushen, he always shines over the original)

This is a celebration show for the 14th anniversary of the video website Bilibili. The program was recorded on 20230626. Zhou Shen and Maria probably learned the song they performed a few days ago, and according to the host's introduction, they met for the first time on the day of the recording. So they may have only rehearsed this song once or twice. The song is a Japanese song, and Japanese is not Zhou Shen's native language, which could be the reason why his pronunciation sounds different from usual.

無敵深深❤❤❤

當然是周深才有這個實力去配合美伊。

Wow.... Good to see that the reaction should be following closely to the pace of Shen Shen's schedule. Thank you so much

他不想搶主角所以用假音的方式唱那幾段，聽了也不太習慣XD這首反而喜歡原曲帶來的感動。

Thanks for reacting to this song. 100% agree with your opinion with the female singer. Personally I much much much prefer Zhoushen sang solo for this song. He had sung many Japanese’s songs so well and beautiful that the Japanese vocal teachers were amazed and loved him. Zhoushen obviously presented higher class of singing techniques in this duet.

I think Zhou Shen is singing in the register to match with her with harmonic effect

周深會根據各種不同語言，用不同的發音方式，而不會一成不變。

老師可否點評周深的unravel😊

好快！(*´ω｀*)

老師講的好含蓄 這首歌算是動畫名曲了 他們這場的表現聽覺真的不是很好 我還是認為動畫聲優三人的那種單純比較符合歌曲內容

他會用這種演唱方式是配合日本人的特有發聲技巧⋯⋯

深深這首歌第一句出來音準就飄了 老師說的竟然是: 喜歡這是現在錄製XD

我覺得他不是累，真的是配合另一個人。 因為他唱另一首歌沒有這些問題。

虽然我是很喜欢❤❤，但这场的确有肉眼可见的瑕疵。当然演唱还是很出色的，但我也有“他累了”的观感。。。越来越喜欢老师的reaction，不会多加个人喜好，很真实地评价歌曲表现，不好就是不好，瑕疵还是会被挑出

确实，周深的这次未闻花名，不知道什么原因，太多假音了，唱得不如他平时

很高心老师有更多的分析小美～挺多日本歌手都有这个风格 周深还是那么的厉害，两位都要好好休息都是魔鬼行程的人

很想看到，老师对周深《月光》 的反馈，这首歌有好多拐弯，翻唱难度也很高。可以安排吗？

我发现在老师 面前无所遁形。这也是 喜欢看她的点评。不说废话，她在听，在猜，在respect，而且特别的准。

深深加油❤❤❤

The "push-pull" thing can be found among a lot of Japanese female singers. Also the bonus clip of each Rozette's demonstration always gives me goosebumps

很喜欢老师的点评，客观、专业！很棒的感受，学习到很多知识！

請老師評 周深，萨頂頂(左手指月) 華晨宇(孩子)最後長高音……是否完美 🙏

Awesome Zhou Shen❤❤❤❤❤❤

Around the world nobody fighting with週深 He is number one guy 👌👌👌👌 He is angel no one to see👌💪💪💪💪💪🍷🍷🍷🍸🍸🍸

You are right. I like the imperfection of live performance in this AI era.

Thank you for your reaction video! I wanna say that this version made both singers' voices quite dry so I recommend you to hear the fancam of it this stage to hear their real voices, it definitely better than the official video !

Thanks for explaining

I believe the 2 of them met for the first time on the day of this performance

深深的這次演出我也不愛，感覺很不像他😢但老師的表情從期待逐漸變成毋湯，讓我覺得很有趣很真實🤣

吾知點解，我覺得老師可能不太喜歡這歌😮這歌沒發揮到❤❤的水準，只是配合對方唱這首歌吧

小美的推拉感应该源自日式的演歌，GUESS。

這首歌不需要表現力量反而是首悲傷的歌

Singing in Japanese, I understand why Zhou Shen had pitching issue in the beginning. This song is not Zhou Shen style, he normally starts with whispering. I guess he wants to leave the focus on 美依礼芽, including choosing the key.

那個推拉的部分是因為日本傳統的聲樂還是有受演歌很大的影響，我們很多人已經把它當作是日樂的特色了

插多啲❤❤的歌吧😊

it's because he pronoucate different language which is japanese

Actually he was singing in Japanese whitch is not his mother tongue, so I think that's why he sang the wrong words.😂

我只能說，這位老師的耳朵是真毒辣 之前看的時候，她說周深在這首的表現方式與她熟知的有所不同 我當時也不懂有啥差異，反正好聽就好。 直到最近看到底下這則視頻 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-uEHg-2TDAY8.html 或許是因為對周深而言，要全程唱日語也是種挑戰，所以他時不時需要看一下提詞器 這就好比，賽道你熟，你可以馬力全開。賽道不熟，你就只能開的保守些，且戰且走的感覺

中日唱法不一样，小美唱法和闽南歌差不多。我更喜欢闽南歌唱法。

周深前面给人太多惊艳了，这首比较起来，确实平平无奇。

「他是大師級的」 誰說不是呢😂

I beleive that you are correct he has been crazy busy recently. He had to fly around to attend so many performers . You are profesional so you are able to catch up his tiredness of his voice. He is so popular in China now. Thumbs up to you!!

老师点评一下勤深深的歌吧🙏，拜托拜托😊😊😊

🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼👍👍👍👏👏👏😘

小美是天生歌姬 聲線渾然天成

Could you please have Rozette reacting to Tia Ray 袁娅维 - The Train to Spring 开往春天的地铁 and Tia Ray 袁娅维 - Eternal Summer 盛夏光年?

我在其他平台看到有人说是因为小美唱错段落所以周深及时补救唱了和声，虽然这个表演也很不错，但是我会prefer周深的一期一会，比较喜欢那一版的歌词和旋律的契合度。

深深❤️❤️❤️👍👍

I too think he is perhaps working too much. He must take care of himself and not tire himself out too much. His body is his instrument, he cannot replace it. He must learn to say no to some invitations to allow his body to rest and keep his amazing voice.

Can find a song Zhou shen duet with others (doomsday spaceship/Roseboy) or with a band ? Those are much better pick

希望可以讓她認識日本 中島美雪 歌姬的現場❤❤❤

I think it's due to the language they are singing in, which is Japanese. In Japanese, it's possible to speak without noticeably changing the shape of your mouth, as the pronunciation is generally more forward in the mouth

美依礼芽的推拉感是日本本土流行音乐或者说是日本民族音乐的一种表现形式，很多日本歌手在演唱手法上都习惯用这种方式去演绎，无论流行歌手还是日本的民族原声歌手都是如此，听的很多了。

It make me worried when she mentioned that he might be tired 😢. He has been very busy these days and he didn't even change his clothes when he went to take the plane after the performance. I know that it was the correct key for the song (as a duet performance) but still make remained me his busy schedule 😢😢😢

I like Mei Yiliya's music, she is a very powerful vocalist too. She wanted to collaborate with Zhou Shen, she saw his performance on stage of her song. In the interview with Mei Yiliya, she loved Zhou Shen's voice & wanted to make music with him.

It can be seen from the teacher's gaze that she has become a fan of the zhoushen

Zhou Shen was singing in Japanese, not Chinese. In that case if he was pronounced some word wrong, that should be accepted

Love Zhou Shen💞

老师越来越客气了，是不是上次被香港顶流咆哮哥的粉丝踏伐了才变成这样

谢谢老师让我明白了为什么深深的声音听起来那么干净动听，更像是乐器甚至AI，因为他的声音没有推拉，甚至少有换气声。老师不懂中文是个遗憾，要知道深深的中文咬字真的比大多数歌手强太多了。当然这一点从深深的多语言天赋也可见一斑。😂

❤

I want to remind that Zhen Zhen is a Chinese singer, Japanese is not his native language , and this girl is a famous singer of Japan. I just want say that, it’s not easy things for Zhen !

he was singing in Japanese

哇哇哇！好惊喜呀！

这也太快了！！！！

I enjoy/appreciate the music & singer more after hearing your comments and explanations. thanks for the video

👍👍👍👍👍👍

老師應該是不懂日語希望聽一下ado,Lisa這些知名歌手的歌

老師說的沒錯啊，因為兩人合作是很突然也很短的時間決定的，兩人行程都很滿，橋不出時間定調啊。 其實我本來想安利一位歌手，她讓我不只是驚訝了，而是驚嚇。那就是黃綺珊，AKA小霞或黃媽。