國外聲樂老師點評 林俊傑《她說》Vocal Coach Reaction to JJ Lin「She Said」Live Performance 

很多人问为什么不先介绍每位歌手的背景或者加上歌词翻译再给老师点评。因为：不了解才真实，才无所顾忌讲真话。不如让每位歌手用声音去证明自己，在这里天王天后和素人都一样。那些口口声声说点评但是全程尬吹的真的很受不了.... 至于歌词，我们中文不好，不可能翻译的很好，对别人的翻译也不满意。这一点就像有些人不满意我们的中文字幕一样，基于文化不同，理解是会有偏差的。所以我们更想让老师用心去感受意境.. 或许这也是这个系列另一个特别之处吧。 ​

這聲樂老師Rozette真的太厲害了!!! JJ剛出道就有在節目上唱跳Michael Jackson的歌, he's a big fan of Michael Jackson!! Rozette竟然在他一開口唱兩句就說出這話！我真的驚呆了～ 太厲害太專業!! 我想真沒人指出說過他的唱法像Jackson. 我想JJ如果知道有人發現他的唱法真深受Jackson的影響，一定會很開心！

這老師太神了連林俊傑喜歡Michael Jackson都聽出來了佩服

這老師牛阿，講著講著還能直接上一段一模一樣的，太專業了

老師好專業 在不認識之下沒有粉絲濾鏡 非常精準的描述JJ紮實的唱功、強大的控制力、靈活的應用以及情感豐富的抖音 早期專輯曲風就已經這麼強了 看到他近年各種選秀舞台上的表演老師豈不是要瘋了😂😂😂

天啊 要不是老師點評，真的不知道這演出有那麼多細節😮！ 不懂音樂單純就覺得「很好聽」😂原來背後的技巧那麼頂級讓國外老師也動容，跨越語言的藝術交流

原來好聽的背後有這麼多細節

這首也是JJ的歌中我最喜歡的~ 就是寫給以逝的友達以上! 我也覺得JJ是這世代最會唱的男歌手! 新馬來的歌手 每個都是歌唱大家!

他确实跟Michael Jackson 的声乐老师Seth Riggs上过课 He actually been with same vocal trainer of Michael Jackson. What a sharp hearing u had 👍 很多人问什么真的 真的 真的烦 自己查啊 麻烦 Seth Riggs吖 DLLM

林俊傑根本是行走CD, 現場聽和放CD毫無差別.. 真正實力派的！

這位老師真的專業沒話說 聽幾句就知道有MJ的唱法 牛+1

見識到真正的專業⋯我真心佩服，有時候看我是歌手節目老師點評，我也希望有這種評語

5:06 除了JJ把這首曲寫的這麼好以外，也很謝謝孫燕姿把歌詞寫得這麼好，成就了一首好歌

真的被老師猜中，林俊傑非常喜歡麥可! 太猛了 還模仿過

不得不说这位老师真的很专业很有眼光 林俊杰是她的TOP 1

現在回來看老師講評～ 現在老師已經是小迷妹一枚 跟我一樣😂

JJ是MJ的超級粉絲，所以唱歌有學到MJ的技巧，老師很厲害，一聽便聽得出來！

老師真的專業，居然聽出JJ是MJ的粉絲

很喜歡老師的評論，而且有句話說內行人看的是門道，這老師短短聽幾句就已能夠完整的說出全部的精髓還能即興示範，真的很厲害👍

This singer is from my country Singapore and we Singaporean are always proud to have such a good singer and the song is composer by himself. Below will be the translation of the song into English. She dropped by in silence She took away the silence slowly Simply the last promise didn`t take away the loneliness Our love cannot be wrong But the beautiful loneliness is a sweet torment She says it doesn`t matter If ony in the night there is a hope when she`s tossing and turning Until the night falls The fireworks won`t be perfect When memories turns into ashes The end has not yet come She said it would be alright BUt I`m afraid it would be destroyed day by day Until the night falls The flowers won`t fade The leaves fall off after Unleash all the pain I`m not afraid of daybreak from now on I think I`m just afraid of waking up

N年前誇年聽到JJ現場演唱,讓我徹底改觀他偶像包裝的形象 ,現場演出功力真的好強阿,很有實力的歌手.

哈哈 老師喜歡跟無感一個歌手完全可以從表情看出一切😆😆

老師邊看影片一邊笑，實在很可愛! 完全能感覺到享受其中~

JJ 現場唱超厲害的

What u hope is true..he is very very famous ...one of the rare talent of chinese pop...he wrote and sing every song he sing...

JJ Lin「She Said」 He quietly came in He slowly took away the silence Only as a final undertaking But he still didn’t take away the loneliness There’s nothing wrong with our love It’s just that the beautiful one-person show is too much torment She says she doesn’t care As long as at night, the repeating time will have focus If they can’t wait until it’s dark, fireworks won’t be so pretty The memories are burned to ashes, but there’s still no ending I was afraid the “I don’t care”s she always says would day by day start disappearing If they can’t wait until it’s dark, the flower buds don’t dare to whither The green leaves follow, releasing a painful flavor Now I’m no longer afraid of the dawn, I think I’m only afraid of waking up Repeat * I’m not afraid of the dawn, I think I’m only afraid of waking up

JJ Lin is very well known in Asia. He is a Singaporean and very popular in China, Taiwan and Malaysia. He celebrates his 20th year career by going on a world tour(JJ20) from Nov 2022 in Singapore, Malaysia, Taiwan and from 2023 in Hong Kong, USA, Europe and Australia.

這老師分析能力真的超強

老師真的厲害 JJ還真的是麥克傑克遜的歌迷 太令我驚訝啦

JJ的聲線與音準，轉音，音色都超讚的，還自彈自唱真的超完美，唱歌又有感情他是在演繹唱歌超有感情的事讓聽者有共鳴，百聽不膩💯💯💯💯💯👍👍👍👍👍👍

Dear coach he has crowned the chinese pop "walking CD "

以前只覺得莫名好聽 現在才找到原來有那麼多技巧在裡面

這位評語老師好強 雖然她不懂中文 但果然音樂是全世界共同語言

JJ喜歡麥可傑克遜這是真的

特別回去在聽了一次老師示範顫音的強弱的地方，才了解到原來有這種差異，學到更多知識的感覺 還有共鳴位置轉換，真的超棒的啊

真的是專業的!!!第一次觀看影片,音準直接完美複製包刮唱腔跟共鳴點~ 十足的滿足觀賞體驗

He trained under MJ’s vocal coach Seth Riggs. If you compare his pre Seth Riggs performances to his post Seth Riggs performances, the improvements are noticeable. This guy is legend. Anyone who knows mando pop knows who JJ Lin is.

這講評真的很專業，我竟然看完了❤

不虧是行走的CD 強調好幾次JJ會唱麥克的顫音 很多人也不會注意 後面還自己示範顫音@@

congrats on discovering J J Lin, he also sings in English. Singapore's pride, he's a down to earth citizen who sings from a place of having a good heart to encourage people along with excellent training and skill.

JJ 的 Live 功力真的無敵～ 華語樂壇天花板❤❤

幾乎聽不出換氣聲，真的好厲害❤

老師真厲害 講解得真好句句是重點且讓人聽得懂學得到東西 喜歡聽老師講評 很有幫助謝謝老師

林俊傑就是一個唱歌怪物的傳說華語樂壇人物

太厲害了

超級棒❤

Thank you, really enjoy the video 😊

Thank you for the video I love JJ lin so much 💜💜💜

聽林俊傑唱歌是一種享受

厲害又專業的講評❤

超級喜歡老師的講評，生動有趣

老師好可愛😂

喜歡老師的講解❤

老師太強了!!!

Love Rozette, so professional

好專業的老師

評得十分好

這老師反應好可愛😄😄

专业的听两三句就喜欢林俊杰 林俊杰真的太厉害了 唱作双神

OMG I love this song!! The way he interprets this piece is so masterful and full of emotion!!

天哪真的好好聽

Thank you for reacting to JJ Lin! Love it! ❤

Love his voice!!

老師眼裡好有愛～～

Thank u for reacting to JJ! So good!

超喜歡這個老師的評論❤❤很中肯

JJ 真的厲害

This is very beautiful 😂❤❤

歌词即有意境又完美贴合旋律，😮不会失望的哟

让Rozette听“害怕”，旋律又特别又优美

Very good ears! JJ has beening taking vocal lessons form MJ‘s former vocal coach, Seth Riggs.

老師聽到喜歡的部分那個吃吃笑太可愛❤❤❤ Love u tittering when u heard the parts u adore

老師好專業 行走的CD 讚

希望老師可以放JJ近期既歌既reaction ❤❤❤

好專業🎉

JJ歌、確實都令人感動👍

好專業

太神啦

行走的CD當之無愧~！！

JJ LIN IS SIMPLY AMAZING ❤

好喜歡呢個老師好專業

這位老師真的好厲害抓細節⋯ 都說中了！

我好喜歡她的微表情☺️

我好喜歡看老師聽JJ唱歌時的表情，一種享受的迷妹的表情❤

聽這老師的點評,唱得有感情要的是掌控不是失控

我只想說，老師你太可愛了～

感謝這個平台讓我驗證自己的耳朵 還有一些事情.

好喜欢这个老师，她好纯真好real

這位老師點評的方式專業又可愛。

JJ Lin, his singing voices and tunes is always gorgeous and amazing 😍. It's flawless and speechless overall lives performance with his beautiful piano 🎹 playing on stage.His solo singing as a vocalist singer is awesome 👍😎 ....👍👍👍👏👏👏💪💪💪🌈🌈🌈💖❤️💝🤩😍😎🙏😇🎹🎹🎹 Honestly speaking, his Prado is really beautiful while singing out the entire song🎉🎉🎉

This is my favorite song in 2011.❤❤❤

老師真的超專業

真的是很真摯的講評～👍👍

这位老师太专业了，我喜欢你点评时候的激情，你的学生一定特别喜欢上你的课。

JJ~ 真的很喜歡他 實力堅強還不斷學習進步~ 我們愛的沒有錯☺️☺️

Thanks for reacting to JJ ! Yes he is a big fan of MJ and he composes almost all his own songs 😊

老師老實說講的太好了，每次看她講評簡直不只專業又講得大家淸楚明白！👍🏻

老師果然是專業的.藝術境界是感性推動理性專業的極致

Ms. Rosette you are incredible. This artist is a big fan of MJ. You are truly professional just by listening to his vocal you already know. 🎉Hats of to you.

JJ 是我心中最棒的音乐人，喜欢JJ 20 年了，他值得