國外聲樂老師點評 MIRROR《Rumours》｜Vocal Coach Reaction to THE FIRST TAKE「Rumours」 

作為香港人只想說一句：老師你辛苦了，能看出你很盡力的不冒犯和說得正面😂🙈 但強調香港還是有很多歌手唱的不錯的，以後請繼續做更多點評，香港網友們愛你！❤

我今年99歲，我唔係呢位外國老師嘅fans，不過我聽出呢位老師既點評非常之善良同埋正面。 每次點評Mirror 都顯示出佢容忍力的極限進步， 我覺得好感動，好想喊。😍🥰🤩❤🧡💛💗💓💞💕

我今年500000歲，來自光之國M78星雲。我唔係呢位老師嘅fans，不過我覺得佢講得非常中肯同正面。每次見到佢咁難受嘅樣聽住mirror嘅歌點評，真係覺得佢容忍力好大。十分感動😢 但望到5:37 當下二胡lo展現自己嘅二胡實力都震驚到淡定嘅老師，希望冇對佢造成內傷。

看到老師耳朵流產的表情很療癒😂

老師真係講得好客氣，辛苦晒😂😂😂

我覺得老師聽得好辛苦，仲要好辛苦咁唸一d唔奉承又唔傷害到人嘅評論，真係辛苦老師啦😂

我今年92.2165歲，我唔係呢位外國老師嘅fans，不過我聽出呢位老師既點評非常之善良同埋正面。 每次點評Mirror 都顯示出對於容忍力極限嘅進步， 從而為世界和平作出貢獻，我覺得好感動，好想喊。 我哋要好好珍惜呢位善良正面嘅外國老師

She must be thinking “why am I doing this to myself”😂

无意冒犯，我个人觉得再做Mirror的视频的意义不大 。他们的唱功，就是普通人唱KTV的水准，甚至很多普通人唱的会更好。歌唱技巧几乎为零。而这位老师是教导声乐的。她很尽力地用正面的，委婉的评语去评价Mirror。我觉得做这个reaction更像是对于老师的语言组织能力的严峻考验。放过她吧。诚恳地请求给她一些值得点评的作品。

When commenting on Mirror and its members' singing abilities, Rozette always puts in great effort to find words that won't offend Mirror fans. I greatly admire her kindness and linguistic skills, haha! The questions she raises, such as "Who would like this group? What aspects of them do their fans actually appreciate? Are they good singers? Do they have impressive dance skills? Are they exceptionally good-looking?" truly reflect the sentiments of many Hong Kong/Cantonese music fans!

花姐，你可以諗諗，開個節目，搵Rozette教mirror十二個上堂，拍成真人show，對viu, mirror, 觀眾, 老師四邊都好喎

真係辛苦，都差啲諗唔到咩客氣既詞語😂聽到耳朵流產

衝著喜歡老師才會點開並把這集看完

欣賞老師，只聽頭十零秒已經即刻知道佢哋唱歌十分普通

老師不愧是老師, 專業級大師級的聲樂老師, 評論一針見血, 教學簡單易明 , 老實說, 全團MIRROR共12人, 這次FIRST TAKE四人當中, 中間兩位是12人當中算是唱得比較好的兩人, 但在專業的老師面前.... 連合格也談不上.... 請MIRROR要好好努力學習

老師評語真係好客氣好留手啦，辛苦哂，証明左香港歌手唔一定要識唱歌都可以紅😂😂

It is embarrassing and awkward for me, as a Hong Kong native who loves Hong Kong culture, that Rozette might mistakenly believe that Hong Kong people only like Mirror or assume that Mirror represents the quality of Hong Kong/Cantonese singers. I feel that I need to apologize to the teacher and the CZ Media team for the time and effort spent on researching and editing videos about Mirror. This boy group, Mirror, has been in the Hong Kong music industry for six years, yet they lack talent in terms of singing, dancing, and acting (except for the leader Lokman who had film works and was considered a highly anticipated new Hong Kong actor even before joining the competition and Mirror). The boy group can be considered as one of the most inexplicably popular groups in Hong Kong in recent years. Even if Mirror stands still without dancing, they may not sing well, and many ordinary people in Hong Kong could have sang better. However, they have a huge fan base, and we Hong Kongers generally cannot comprehend this.

睇得出老師好努力，好善良，吾想踩但又極度頂唔順佢地d所謂唱功。😂

我聽到這首歌出來的時候，我也感覺是個災難。。。。 辛苦老師把整首歌聽完，看到老師的樣子慢慢母湯起來真的。。。。

老師說得對 他們需要更多的學習 這一點真的非常重要

Thank you for being honest! We need more of these honest comments. A lot of their fans don't wanna hear the truth tho.

好勇敢，夠膽評論mirror

Recommend making video on HK singer Hins Cheung張敬軒 His live performances on song酷愛are impressive

After watching several videos on your channel, I have become deeply fascinated by Teacher Rozette. I immediately subscribed to your channel. Every time I see the sparkle in Rozette's eyes and her undeniable smile when she hears outstanding performances from singers, I can feel her passion for and enjoyment of music. Rozette also expresses her professional thoughts in a down-to-earth manner. After watching more videos on your channel, I have gradually learned to analyze why I like/dislike certain singers' performances. The teacher is truly exceptional!

我今年2023歲，我唔係呢位外國老師嘅fans，不過我聽出呢位老師既點評非常之善良同埋正面。 每次點評Mirror 都顯示出佢容忍力的極限進步， 我覺得好感動，好想喊。

老師睇到o哂咀個樣真系好好笑 佢好nice 比想像中用詞好好多😂

我是真的替老師心疼，為什麼要虐待他的耳朵，可是我又覺得老師的表情好好笑，好好看！我好煩喔我自己！！

老師正確又不失客氣

辛苦了老師😂😂 對她來是折磨

呢啲就係香港頂流天團。所以話香港樂壇沒落真係多得Mirror 同理撐Mirror 嘅人唔少

面對災難，默默忍受，這一切最終會過去，讓時間洗去心中的痛苦

可以叫老師點評一下同樣上了THE FIRST TAKE的香港歌手 陳柏宇的 One Day 有天 OR 你瞞我瞞可以嗎? MIRROR最多算是香港的路人合唱團而已 代表不了現在的香港歌手

05:37太經典啦!!!!笑死

love her honest reaction.

係未婉轉說話挑戰😂好善良既老師

😅😅辛苦老師了，耳朵流產…

The coach is like hope their singing ends asap, no words to describe it anymore...

看得出老師在絞盡腦汁的想想好話

哈哈，上次姜濤條片我留言話唔知老師有冇機會見識AL嘅二胡技巧，點知真係成真，仲嚇親老師😂

觀看了你們頻道幾條影片之後，我深深迷戀上了Rozette老師，馬上訂閱了你們的頻道。每次看到Rozette老師聽到歌手出色表現時眼中閃爍光芒和難以掩飾的笑容，我感受到她對音樂的熱愛和享受！Rozette老師也能以平實的方式表達她專業的想法，觀看你們頻道更多影片之後，我也逐漸學會分析自己為何喜歡／不喜歡哪些歌手的表現。老師確實非常專業！ 評論Mirror及Mirror成員的唱功時，Rozette老師總是很費力地尋找不冒犯Mirror粉絲的詞彙，這讓我對Rozette老師的善良和語言能力佩服不已，哈哈！老師提出的疑問：「誰會喜歡這群人呢？喜歡他們的人到底喜歡他們的哪些方面呢？他們唱歌好聽嗎？跳舞好看很整齊嗎？他們長的特別帥氣嗎？」這些提問道出了不少香港／廣東歌歌迷的心聲呀！ 讓Rozette老師誤以為香港人只喜歡他們／讓老師誤以為香港／廣東歌手只有Mirror這種質素，身為土生土長熱愛香港文化的香港人，我真的感到非常尷尬和害羞，對不起老師和CZ Media團隊花了時間研究和剪接影片的辛勞。Mirror這個團體在香港已經出道了六年，無論是唱功、舞蹈、演技，都缺乏實力（除了隊長Lokman在參加那個比賽之前已經有電影作品並被視為備受期待的新演員之外），可以說是近年來香港最沒道理地火紅起來的團體。Mirror即使站着不跳舞，也未必能把歌唱得很好，很多普通人唱得更好，但是他們卻擁有龐大的粉絲群，我們香港人普遍都無法理解這一點呢！ 香港還有很多唱Cantopop的歌手唱得很不錯，希望CZ Media團隊未來能夠繼續點評更多廣東歌，包括獨唱歌手，以下是一些值得推薦的Cantopop Solo歌手人選：張學友Jacky Cheung、陳奕迅Eason、王菲Faye、衛蘭Janice、王菀之Ivana、李幸倪Gin Lee、陳僖儀Sita、側田Justin、小肥Terence、張敬軒Hins Cheung、馮允謙Jay Fung、張天賦MC；此外還有一些香港唱歌團體也值得推薦：Beyond、Mr.、Rubber Band、SENZA A Cappella；如果需要更多國際話題的廣東話歌手，值得推薦的有：王嘉爾Jackson Wang（韓國男團GOT7成員）和G.E.M. 鄧紫棋。 香港網友都愛你們！請多聽聽和評論香港廣東歌吧！xoxo！

每次姜一唱，老師就會臉色一沉

我覺得並不是所有偶像團體都是不會唱歌的，請大家聽聽8-90年代的外國男子偶像團體例如Westlife, backstreet boys, 甚至去到2010年代的已解散團隊one direction 這些團體唱功是很不錯，歌曲也非常好聽，我不敢說是所有90後的回憶但至少是陪我長大的, 另外私心請老師評價one ok rock Wherever you are live

老師很有修養

橘老師 真的辛苦了 🥲🥲🥲 看得出來真的很努力想要講好話

我今年-1歲，我唔係呢位外國老師嘅fans，不過我聽出呢位老師既點評非常之善良同埋正面。

香港樂壇最能體驗一人一票的好處，只要有足夠資金宣傳，無論什麼質素也能當選。

you can just say they suck, we all know that. honestly this level of performance is like what you would fine from mediocre civilians in a karaoke lmao

Almost every video reaction of yours has been of top notch and of well-rounded singers, Mamma Mia!...., what just happened here is nothing short of a calamity. To say that it was ear piercingly bad is a massive understatement. HK singers whose live performances are worthy of note include Eason Chan, Hins Cheung, Hacken Lee, Janice Vidal, Gin Lee and Gigi Yim.

我今年666歲，我唔係呢位外國老師嘅fans，不過我聽出呢位老師既點評非常之善良同埋正面。 每次點評Mirror 都顯示出佢容忍力的極限進步， 我覺得好感動，好想喊。

一句可以總結成條片 ：咁都可以上到The First Take 係咪傻L左😂😂

我自己好喜歡Mirror 嘅，但都希望Makerville 能睇到呢位老師comments ，俾資源同時間佢哋好好咁去學唱歌、接受專業嘅演藝訓練，最好去外國學藝，提升水平，做到令人心服口服，先會行得更遠。

我记得有一期是不是reaction的姜涛，老师后来把耳机给扔了.....感觉比较尴尬，哈哈。

香港係一個冒險家嘅天堂 亦都係一個尋夢嘅地方

佢哋呢班人都唔係唱歌嘅，係偶像派，講到咁已經好俾面呀唔掉爛部電視已經真係好禮貌

我今年-213歲，我唔係呢位外國老師既fans，不過我係坐時光機過嚟睇下2023年，我都係走先

感受到老師的大愛

老師聽完都係一頭霧水😂

I have been watching these series and loved it. Tbh, let's provide Good singer and work for Rozette to watch, she deserves those. And it will be more entertaining and educational for audiences. :) Just an advice.

I really hope mirror fans can watch this. I’ve been telling them fans that mirror’s vocal skills is as good as the karaoke goers. No techniques in their singing. I barely even hear any vibrato, switchers, vowel mods.

辛苦了，老師！

老師的表情😂😂😂😂😂

anson lo: we did it!

「一個從未訓練轉音的菜鳥」😂

老師非常有禮貌

Roxette trying not to sound harsh on the mirror. She was holding her grudge and so lost of words to use not to offend mirror's fan. I heard from a mirror's fan said ' I know they are out of pitch or tone but is forgivable coz their main thing is not about their singing '...... I see the point then

Mirror 不要再掉香港人假 不用再點評他們浪費時間 香港有實力的可以點評一下 張敬軒live

Well speech!!!! tysm :)

好少見老師目瞪口呆個樣🤣

真係辛苦老師了😂😂，對於清醒嘅我地黎講，又點會mad at you。我真心唔識欣賞佢地啲歌，唔係我唔想聽，係真係不堪入耳。我今次都係因為想睇老師而入黎，最後同老師一樣聽到面容扭曲，耳朵受罪。

There are many other Cantopop singers in Hong Kong who sing remarkably well. I hope that the CZ Media team will continue to review more Cantonese songs in the future, including solo and group singers. Here're some of my personal favourite recommendations. Cantopop solo artists: Jacky Cheung 張學友, Eason Chan 陳奕迅, Faye Wong 王菲, Janice Vidal 衛蘭, Ivana Wong 王菀之, Gin Lee 李幸倪, Sita Chan 陳僖儀, Justin 側田, Terence 小肥, Hins Cheung 張敬軒, Jay Fung 馮允謙, Wilson Ng 吳林峰 and MC Cheung 張天賦. Additionally, some Hong Kong singing groups worth recommending: Beyond, Mr., Rubber Band, and SENZA A Cappella. If you need more internationally known Cantonese singers, I would recommend Jackson Wang 王嘉爾 (member of the South Korean boy band GOT7) and G.E.M. Tang 鄧紫棋. Hong Kong netizens love you! Please listen to and review more Cantonese songs! Xoxo!

Sounded like singing in the Karaoke. They really need a good vocal teacher.

Vocal coach.. You should try to see JJ Lin sing the Disney song version .

我今年1歲，我唔係呢位外國老師嘅fans，不過我聽出呢位老師既點評非常之善良同埋正面。 每次點評Mirror 都顯示出佢容忍力的極限進步， 我覺得好感動 TT

7:11 😂老師模仿好精準

Can you do Eason Chan? 😃

老師辛苦你了,哈哈哈

希望睇到對陳柏宇Jason Chan「有天」The First Take版嘅評價

可以評論一下。張敬軒 嗎？（也是香港歌手）

同薑糖一樣善良，薑糖贏孝順，老師贏英文not bad😂😂😂

4:40 佢地自己投入/享受，就是他們的現況

梗係enjoy，因為佢地以為自己已經好勁

辛苦老師 聽完真係要洗耳

老師，你真厚道

老師想講 what 7 they sing ？😂😂😂

很喜歡老師最後的教學部份！！

这老師聽的好辛苦😂

香港而家真係🙄🙄坦白講 就算mc同林家謙都只係正常應該有既入門水平 得Eason係專業大師級 偏偏香港人唔欣賞 好多00後甚至話佢唱歌悶 香港今時今日好可悲 香港人仲唔改下膚淺無禮的特點真係死路一條

你已觸犯鏡安法,請小心

原影片底下嘉評如潮 我是活在平行時空嗎

想知團中唱功最好個幾果 比老師評下。想知Ian 評價😮因為我個人會聽佢d歌

Dead air at the end😂😂

可以點評一下陳奕迅的 ＜我們＞嗎？ 陳奕迅風格沒有過多炫耀歌唱技巧又沒有常飆高音。 但每次聽都有撕心烈肺的感覺。 所以很想聽聽老師的專業評價

😂表情已經說明一切，由開口唱一剎那個表情表現尷尬😂

看老師非常婉轉地表達評論時很好笑 鏡安法會跨境執法嗎?

辛苦老師了

感覺到老師想快啲完，佢無野再講了😂😂

替老師辛苦，好辛苦找到一個讚點，英語不錯 Actually, they should be “kindergarten band” instead of boy band. Their fans say that people should not be harsh to their idol because the band only the kids. The concept of the band is selling *hardworking and diligent*. Especially, the angry boy who is the most hard working children 😅

整個視頻老師如坐針毯似的 😂 好奇誰推薦的，那來的自信 🤦🏻‍♀️ Doing reaction for this video is not easy for Rozette … 😮‍💨🤦🏻‍♀️

好攪笑，佢地拍撑你的樣子發呆的感覺，干什麼事？哈哈

Very honest comments from a professional teacher! Personally, I think BTS will have a very different interpretation of this song. What a waste 😅😂🤣