I love how everyone makes this a Bea vs Carly thing just like the producers of the show wanted them too. They were both amazing. There ain't no shame in the fact that Carly wanted to focus on school and Bea's success has been amazing and her music is great.
I absolutely love her but I don't think Britney gave her good song choices, she needed songs that would help her with the nice rasp she has in her voice. like her song paper doll
I agree Bea definitely had the voice to hit those notes too ("Titanium") she should have given her some challenging songs buts I think she as well as everyone watchimg the show knew that out of her Team only Carly Rose would make ot the farthest
@@My.Dear.Journal bea def could’ve done as well as Carly if she had the right songs, Beas performance of chasing cars is amazing in my opinion and carlys version of broken hearted
The X Factor fucked up. Bea was definitely one of the better contestants on the show. With better song and outfit choices, I think she would've gone further.
breeatsuga ok ik she didn’t win but whoever won probably isn’t as known as she is now she has tons of songs out and has 1.5m on insta. Who cares if fifth harmony was in the same season as she was that doesn’t make her any less of a good singer plus they where probably older then her she was like 13 or 14 then
Bea had a sort of naturality and truth in her voice that scares people looking for "perfect pitch". Bea is a true artist, not a pop singer or a studio artist, she is the real deal.
they edited it to make it seem that way. Beatrice has explained this in another video. She talked about how X-Factor isn't how we really think it is. I can't explain everything... They both have very different voices/styles-- Carly is more "old soul" whereas Be a has a nice raspy voice... Both are very different, so why can't we appreciate both and not overanalyze?
What people don’t understand here is that Carly is a seriously vocally trained singer. Her voice is incredible, but it’s not a radio voice. It’s a broadway voice. And she has done Broadway since x-factor. Bea has a radio voice.
this song had great significance. A White Flag means surrendering and even though Bea was eliminated, she did not surrender. She continued to pursue her dream of singing
This girl is from my town... Her sisters go to my school, she's gone so far. I remember first watching her when she was just in middle school and I was still in elementary school
I think it was rude how Carly, at the end, walked in front of Beatrice, definitely suspicious. But ya gotta remember both girls are 13, & the only 2 at that age. And being away from home at that age hasta be hard & I'm sure they became friends. But from their behaviors Bea seemed more down-to-earth & real, while Carly seemed more competitive & wanted to be favored over Bea. I get it's a contest but behaviors show true personalities.
Angela Magic Salveson If you look again, you’d see that Carly Rose was only trying to get to the center of the stage. And Carly and Bea Miller were both great.
Beatrice talked about this and told everyone how the video cut out portions of the whole performance. You have to remember this is TV and they edit videos like this to get views.
izel alvarez no, it was when she was singing chasing cars and white flag. And Simon also elected to have her leave the show because she was getting to sick to continue. She got signed to his record label immediately.
How did X-Factor get canceled when they produce bigger stars than the Voice and American Idol??! Fifth Harmony, Bea Miller, Diamond White all came from just this one season of the show.
only know the first one who is now kind of a flop lmao. the others are more entertaining like the voice has a gimmick to it. we have x factor in the uk but not american idol so it’s kind of a regional thing
Ok i used to think it was so unfair when Britney would say Bea’s voice was too loud, but she would never say anything about Carly’s voice being too loud, cause let’s face it, it was.
I really like Cece, but vocally I think Bea was more consistent. They both had really rough points vocally at some points, but Bea had a better chance of winning because she was edited more positively and she had a more unique voice. Cece could belt really, really well, and had a few amazing performances, but also a few pretty bad ones. She was never gonna win.
@@TheMurrmursonbottle CeCe said herself that she knew right from the start that she would never win the show, and that she's not the type of person X factor would want to win
