Тёмный

🏆3D Printer Tier List🏆 (Does your printer suck?) 🥇🥈🥉🪦 

Nathan Builds Robots
Подписаться 44 тыс.
Просмотров 62 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 398   
@Vez3D
@Vez3D Год назад
Good video! Thanks for the kind word and honest opinion on all those bots :)
@MalignSociety
@MalignSociety Год назад
You've made a mean printer.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
You're welcome! There are two types of 3D printer developers: 1) Those who ask "What is possible" 2) Those who ask "What can we get away with" You are definitely in type 1, as are most people passionate about making good printers! There are a lot of companies in type 2.
@rosshalford4041
@rosshalford4041 Год назад
When you cant work out if he is serious or shitposting on RU-vid.
@dexxeve9420
@dexxeve9420 Год назад
WORTH A WATCH TO A QUICK ROUNDUP OF ALL 3D PRINTERS TO DATE 2023
@poepflater
@poepflater Год назад
As a pensioner I'm looking for the cheapest one i wouldn't throw off a balcony
@poepflater
@poepflater Год назад
I found an old discontinued Flashforge Finder 1 for about $130, great little printer if limited in abilities. But super nice prints
@valeriyproklov2868
@valeriyproklov2868 Год назад
The positron was built to fit into a standard 1kg filament box. In my opinion any compromise that has to be made to achieve that is acceptable, because if someone told me a printer could fit in such a small space before I saw it I wouldn’t believe them. The upside downess doesn’t even impact print quality. In fact bridges are supposedly even better. It’s only problems are a lack of a decent kit, the fact it’s Bowden, and no auto Z offset capability which is nearly standard on Vorons.
@randallporch1800
@randallporch1800 Год назад
I use a 3D pen like a welder for 3D printed parts, love it for that. Much better than products sold as 'plastic welders', which are basically soldering irons.
@Kipitrl
@Kipitrl Год назад
This was perfect! Should do this every quarter and update! Thank you!
@Kipitrl
@Kipitrl Год назад
My list of printers even though I'm a noob to all this. Longer LK4 Pro Longer LK5 Pro Creality ender 3 v2 neo Creality ender 3 s1 plus Anycubic Kobra Neo Anycubic Kobra Max bummed when I saw where this one placed. Looking forward to the new Ender and one day once I figure all this out the P1S. Looking at the Neptune 4 as well 😀
@reasonablebeing5392
@reasonablebeing5392 11 месяцев назад
I bought the K1 with the $200 off coupon from Micro Center. At that price point and with the newest extruder, hot end and a couple of convenience mods (270 deg, door (must print!), side spool holder, and lid riser), it has been producing fast, quality prints and as you said, keeping level. Still looking for a price/value 300x300 bed size core xy to replace my trusty ol' highly modded CR-10.
@groundedhippo9356
@groundedhippo9356 Год назад
My p1s I got a week ago has been a nightmare, I couldn’t get a single good print out of it, it just got clogged, made bubbly, holey messes and after cleaning the plastic of the nozzle, it wouldn’t regulate the heat to the nozzle anymore so now it just won’t print at all. Worst 1500$ I’ve ever spent. My friend says it might work if I add some new thermal paste but I don’t see any reason to believe it’s not going to keep making my life miserable.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
The good thing about it is that it just works 95% of the time. The bad thing is, when it breaks it’s quite a bit trickier to fix, and support can be difficult to find. It’s a more complex machine than the old style bedslingers. Add to that, the bambu lab community tends to dogpile anyone who complains about quality or reliability.
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Firstly that's not even the price of one. Secondly, there are 2 free spare hotend in the box, why wouldn't your first move be to swap them out in 2 minutes? Lastly, in case these weird descrepencies are real, because I do acknowledge every product has lemons, you must realize that every product has lemons. That being said, if your only issue is you got a clogged nozzle and the fix is already in the box and 2 screws and a connector away , is that really a valid reason to trash a printer when just about every printer ever can jam and this one has a design less likely to jam with the uni body hotend?
@SwervingLemon
@SwervingLemon 7 месяцев назад
​@@BeefIngot949 plus tax and shipping and any add-ons could easily get him into the 1500 price range. The one I just saw had only one spare hotend. Your criticims might be valid, if they weren't marketing this thing as the "it just works" printer for newbies. Their QC/QA isn't great, and their support is a serious weak point. Having said that, the quality and speed of print that I just saw out of one left me stunned. Genuinely shocked.
@christianlewis615
@christianlewis615 Год назад
I think this is one of the most helpful videos and tire list to be able to make a decision on which printer to buy next. I will definitely be referring to this if I buy another printer.
@JohnDStrand
@JohnDStrand Год назад
You don't like Delta printers? UNSUB! You have lost all the little respect that you had. I certainly hope JJ likes Delta printers. I should have known, when you added syrup to your coffee. Heathen!
@cpasoft
@cpasoft Год назад
I've put the Delta printers on tier C because potatoes (a Spanish expression than means "because reasons" but more ironical) ... Loool...
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Ok I had to step up to defend the position because your rating there was just devistatingly unfair to such amazing enginuity. Its upside down for many reasons. 1. It's designed to be as small as possible, having it upside down means you don't need a cube to support the opposite side from the print head saving space. 2. It let's you still get a view of the first layer through the bed which is awesome. 3. It gets literally the best bridging you've ever seen because gravity is in your side when youre upside down. 4. The moving mass is closer to the bae meaning it's one of the most stable designs possible, short of drilling your printer directly into concrete. 5. Just look at the damn thing!!! Can you believe one college dude designed that? Freaking amazing!
@themechanic6151
@themechanic6151 11 месяцев назад
what are you talking about my guy?
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot 11 месяцев назад
@@themechanic6151 Did you watch the video? The Positron.
@themechanic6151
@themechanic6151 11 месяцев назад
@@BeefIngot oh I see now, you said position earlier so it confused me. I watched a video on it. That thing is sick
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot 11 месяцев назад
@@themechanic6151 You now see why I called this man out on his absolute slander of my poor boy.
@anthonygrimaldi9483
@anthonygrimaldi9483 28 дней назад
I’m definitely a big fan of my Neptunes! Two 3 pros, a 3 max, and a 4 pro, all seemingly very good machines so far!
@Liberty4Ever
@Liberty4Ever Год назад
11:34 - "They're probably gonna make an Elegoo Neptune 4 Max" YES! That's the printer I'm waiting for. A reliable and easy to maintain bed slinger, with steel rails, Klipper and a large print volume.
@MrBaskins2010
@MrBaskins2010 Год назад
damn i was just gonna buy a refurb Sovol SV06 MAX but imma just wait for elegoo's next mixtape lol
@Liberty4Ever
@Liberty4Ever Год назад
​@@MrBaskins2010 - The curse of technology. Newer and better stuff is coming. If we wait for it, we won't enjoy the current newer and better stuff, and there's always something newer and better. It's inevitable that larger format Klipper bed slingers are coming. Manufacturers almost always release new technology on a 220 mm machine then follow up with a 300 mm machine. Hopefully, this time, they'll max out the larger and slightly more expensive machines with all of the features we want such as WiFi, UBS port instead of micro SD, steel-on-steel motion control instead of acetyl V rollers, etc. I expect this goodness in a couple of months or less.
@bpc4209
@bpc4209 Год назад
Lol, why does Nathan always look like he just woke up? j/k man love the channel!
@dangerous8333
@dangerous8333 Год назад
Haha, so true. I love that about him actually.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
Day in the life of a RU-vidr (this is more accurate than I care to admit) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-0p20R_Fx5so.html
@SingularityAdvent
@SingularityAdvent Год назад
No bullshit review, excellent.🎉
@aberodriguez4149
@aberodriguez4149 Год назад
Lol I wound out in the Clone Trooper area ! The Ender Series :( ZZZZZ Great Tier List it will point me in the right direction, thanks for sharing
@f1hotrod527
@f1hotrod527 Год назад
Enders are CR-10 clones, not the other way around. CR-10 was the game changing printer from creality, far more than the Ender. The ender was just a cheaper smaller version of the CR-10. I have the original CR-10 and It prints just as high quality as the Bambu X1C we have where I work (just a lot slower). Now the CR-10 models you show are boring, not because of the Ender series, just because they did not really improve on the CR-10 in a large way, and they are bed slingers, and you can say any bed slinger is boring at this point.
@rmfberry261
@rmfberry261 Год назад
i was questioning myself i swore the cr10 was out first.
@channelnotfound403
@channelnotfound403 Год назад
But didn't the Ender 3 start out as a all in one printer? Cause I know the CR-10 didn't start that way, with the huge box sitting at the side. That's probably one of the reason why it gets it own tier and not considered a clone.
@f1hotrod527
@f1hotrod527 Год назад
@@channelnotfound403 yes the cr-10 does have the separate control box and it is one thing I don’t like about mine. I still think the CR-10 was the printer that put Creality on the map and was more of a pioneer than Ender. The aluminum construction with V wheels was brought my the CR-10.
@tenchuu007
@tenchuu007 Год назад
"nobody likes deltas" said no other person, ever.
@alvaroaugustomeridio
@alvaroaugustomeridio Год назад
Just bought a v400 I only heard good things on this printer, hope this guy is wrong
@tenchuu007
@tenchuu007 Год назад
@@alvaroaugustomeridio I have an SR, and it's a good machine.
@Rainmotorsports
@Rainmotorsports Год назад
Of all the problems with this video the Delta thing isn't one of them. Sure it looks neat. But in reality it's powered by nightmares.
@comeoutandpla
@comeoutandpla Год назад
@@alvaroaugustomeridiothe biggest con to the 400 that I’ve heard is the hotend design. Otherwise FLSun printers seem to be solid
@alvaroaugustomeridio
@alvaroaugustomeridio Год назад
I just got mine and I've been told that chitubox slicer and the firmware out of the box are the reason I'm having misprints so that's not the best publicuty
@timothyreyes5392
@timothyreyes5392 Год назад
I'd love to see a Nathan with an F boi look not someone who looks like they just woke up 😂😂
@soapy5343
@soapy5343 Год назад
The upside down design makes the positron compact and the belts make it insanely fast
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
I still don’t understand. Was it designed by an Australian or something?
@soapy5343
@soapy5343 Год назад
@@NathanBuildsRobots the design means it doesn't need arms on the side, allowing it to fit inside a filament box
@soapy5343
@soapy5343 Год назад
Not sure if you've seen this but the video sums up the design ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-X_QLxTVtyng.html
@MisterkeTube
@MisterkeTube Год назад
The Prusa XL is too expensive and not enclosed by default, so I'd definitely say it is flawed.
@xXKisskerXx
@xXKisskerXx Год назад
its enclosure.. is a bag. For that price.. at least a basic enclosure where each wall is 2 layers of thin aluminum with a insulating barrier in between would be more in the rage for the cost... I mean.. they are charging enough for it.
@MatheusFP104
@MatheusFP104 Год назад
I love my V-Core 3. Fantastic printer
@rainmannoodles
@rainmannoodles Год назад
Ultimaker: for when you want Ender 3 quality at Prusa XL pricing.
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Lol, but really though, theyrre for a different audience. That audience wants the air filter and filament station and filament rack and employee training. Too that audience, 500 bucks vs 5000 bucks is no difference.
@omegadeepblue1407
@omegadeepblue1407 Год назад
The ender 2 really do very well
@1fareast14
@1fareast14 Год назад
32:44 the 100, a fork of the rook for speed printing is also worth mentioning (never mind, you did :) )
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
:P
@claytonanderson9665
@claytonanderson9665 Год назад
Thanks for the video man. Convinced me to begin upgrading my recently bought tronxy into a vzbot. Really neat project.
@YoruPlay3r
@YoruPlay3r 8 месяцев назад
im gonna be totally honest i came here to see where my first and only printer the anycubic kobra 2 now upgraded to anycubic kobra 2 pro ranked and i totally agree with your ranking i am now writing this comment and dipping thanks for putting my printer where it rightfully belongs
@dominikmarc4820
@dominikmarc4820 Год назад
It's flying bear after all, right... RIGHT?
@califuturist
@califuturist 8 месяцев назад
Comprehensive spreadsheet. 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
@CardboardCreationism
@CardboardCreationism Год назад
All my printers are ZZZ tier except my Ender 2. LOL I love it!
@iikkakonola
@iikkakonola Год назад
Just a thought here, your videos had a lot more sensible content just 6 months ago. Now there are tons of videos with not that much real content. Happy to see that channel has grown, but maybe quality is fluctuating a bit...?
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
RU-vid wants the content train to go Chooo choooooooooooo
@SkateSoup
@SkateSoup 6 месяцев назад
"When you have a longer tube, you end up with more friction." 🤣💀🤣
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots 6 месяцев назад
It's not absolutely true. But it's mostly true.
@kwedl
@kwedl Год назад
I got a Kingroon KLP1 two weeks ago and it's one of the worst printers i have owned so far. Corexy and those speeds/specs sound great at the price, but their Klipper configs are horrible and their cura profile is completely useless, they basicly just cranked everything up to max and even after hours and hours i can't get a decent pressure advance result. The built quality and overall parts are great, at least the V2 version with the all metal hotend, but aside from that it is basicly useless unless you completely start over from scratch with klipper and cura.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
That's not the end of the world, if it just needs some slicer and klipper tuning that is completely fixable via an over the air update, or by rolling community improvements back into the design.
@kwedl
@kwedl Год назад
@@NathanBuildsRobots Sadly i have my doubts about community improvements, there are almost no reviews about it, not even the V1 version which has been out for months and you almost can't find any redidt or forum posts about it. And Kingroon customer service is basicly non existent. I emailed them for multiple weeks now and tried to reach them via their site or social media, but no replies.
@03Cmanu
@03Cmanu Год назад
@@NathanBuildsRobots , i've got a klp1 too , two days of use and the part fan died , 3 days and it was the THR board , they send me a new one and there was communication error between the thr and the motherboard.They send me another THR and a new motherboard. Same problem. The heated bed support was twisted, the belts almost impossible to tighten without disassembling. And I'm not the only one. Now after many hours of test it seems to work well , i had to modify the steppers current because i think they set them too high and it causes the communications trouble. I'm also waiting for the printhead of the V2 they promise me. And now i use orca slcier , much better than cura. They released an emergency V2 like for the KP3S pro v2 which also had a lot of problems. So don't buy if you want a reliable printer.
@AndrewAHayes
@AndrewAHayes Год назад
Your statement that no-one likes delta printers is inaccurate although I think it was made in jest, I love delta printers and I know many other people do, if no one liked delta printers why hasn't FL Sun stopped making them and jumped on the i3 bandwagon?
@NM-wd7kx
@NM-wd7kx Год назад
Didn't flsun start with an i3 clone? If anything that leans into your point though
@josejimenez896
@josejimenez896 Год назад
Hi! Flashforge adventurer 4 owner here :) they're actually not that expensive That being stated I FUCKING HATE IT AND THE PROPRIETARY NOZZLE. Please move it to throw it off the balcony next time for me 🫶
@BenniShogun
@BenniShogun Год назад
I recently purchased an Ender 5S1. I was disappointed at first, but after adding a Sonic Pad it is much better. Going for the K1 Max next.
@Staffii1
@Staffii1 10 месяцев назад
S1 is better than the K1 Max.
@samuelmiller916
@samuelmiller916 8 месяцев назад
to be honest ive used the formlabs printer at work and I think of it as the prusa of resin printing since it just works.
@onestopfunstop317
@onestopfunstop317 Год назад
The Ender3 S1 Pro is Excellent. I have a bunch of them. I run ABS around the clock. 24/7. Zero Problems. Need to manually level about once a month. Then it's just, print, print, print.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
Nice 👍
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
Sometimes boring printer is a good thing 😃
@earlowens998
@earlowens998 Год назад
The P1P is an excellent printer that is currently $599. At that price point, the quality of the prints without modifications, the availability of modifications both for sale and that can be user created and the apps that give users control without requiring genius or professional levels, the P1P kicks everyone else's butt at that price point. The Prusa MK4 is way too expensive for a bed slinger. BTW I have a a MK4 on order so I can complain about spending too much for a bed slinger.
@astrakartoffel4676
@astrakartoffel4676 Год назад
The P1P is amazing, but i see no reason to get the P1P over the P1S because its only 100 bucks more expensive, u got like almost the same enclosure as the X1 even with the carbon filter
@doron910
@doron910 8 месяцев назад
I can't decide between the KE and the K1! Both at a reasonable price. The K1 is a corexy but it means it's more complex to mess around with and I also read it makes more noise..
@johnle7670
@johnle7670 Год назад
Subbed!! Just for the trolls! Lmao
@MalignSociety
@MalignSociety Год назад
Wait what? Did you just put a machine not tested in S tier?! Also, Neptune 4 bed leveling wheels are falling off... How in the world did you give that anycubic and elegoo a higher rating than the MK4? Looks like someone might be sponsored by Elegoo & Creality. You need to do some more investigation...
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
I also put my YT channel logo in S tier, so biased... SMH
@YouTube_Nr.1
@YouTube_Nr.1 Год назад
Neptune 4 bed levelling wheels are falling off? Never seen that before. I will have a look about that. A source would be nice 👍
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
What Happens to D Tier Printers: ru-vid.comodkKVIZItZA?feature=share
@XHolyPuffX
@XHolyPuffX 7 месяцев назад
I'm fucking dead bro 😂
@ValeriOS_3d_printing
@ValeriOS_3d_printing Год назад
Deltas are machines for expert users, but it doesn’t mean they’re C tier at all. People are only able to criticize without even knowing what they are talking about. And it isn’t the first time on this channel that this happens. I Hope that people understand the real potential of deltas printers, not for nothing they are used in industrial applications (I’ve never seen a corexy kinematic used inside of an industry) That said, happy printing on your delta printers
@TKettle
@TKettle 10 месяцев назад
My first printer was an flsun and it's been dead reliable. There's nothing "expert" about it. I haven't needed to touch it except for adding a nice magnetic bed. Sad he thinks they're bad because he doesn't understand how they work. A delta has less bearings than most other printers. Just one for each arm (3 total), whereas a prusa I think has two for each axis (6 total). To me, a standard printer shaking the shit out of the print and bed on the Y axis doesn't make much sense. There's no way that could ever be fast and you're gonna have way more problems with bed adhesion.
@lucase764
@lucase764 Год назад
I regret purchasing a Prusa MK3S. I agree with your rating. It costs too much. The print quality is ok. The stock cooling isn't very good. Their customer service is fantastic though.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
1 year ago, it’s be an A. Now, it’s more like a B, even with the MK4 upgrade, which is a little underwhelming
@lucase764
@lucase764 Год назад
@@NathanBuildsRobots I probably shouldn't be so hard on the MK3S. There are things I like about it.
@dme2453
@dme2453 Год назад
My MK3S turns out some amazing prints. I’ve been afraid to upgrade it.
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
I could never put the k1 series up that high for many reasons. Mentioned bed levelling issues. Open source license being blatantly violated Ads in their mobile app Unlike Bambulab, they don't sell nearly the same amount of spare parts Once again unlike Bambulab their whole workflow design slicer to printer is a lot worse They use klipper which should be great but they neutered it by eliminating some settings that should be there and not allowing the user to fully access the Linuxbbox they have there while still not setting it up properly. Also, it's creality who just has such a bad rap. I will never not take the time to dump on Creality.
@daliasprints9798
@daliasprints9798 Год назад
Epic troll video. 😂
@nf8721
@nf8721 Год назад
Bought my first printer (Neptune 4) without much knowledge about them and seems I made the right choice
@chalapathipenmetsa5820
@chalapathipenmetsa5820 2 месяца назад
a piece of AMS is over the P1P, K1 and the CR-30 but hey your opinion is your opinion its valid 👍
@safargris815
@safargris815 Год назад
Ordered the Elegoo Neptune 4 Pro, like the all metal guide rails. i'm excited to get started printing with it!
@2151hunter
@2151hunter Год назад
Using Kobra2 I can say that it should go to C-tier. The metal rails and metal gears is a fail - the printer CAN print fast but you don't want to be in the same room- the whole frame is resonating and it's a pain hearing it running. And you can find a lot of people complaining for the same issues. Yes, it's more durable than rubber V-wheels in the extrusion slots, but it just doesn't work...
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
I’m reviewing it now,m and editing the video, completely agree. This thing is not a standout in any way, just another boarding Ender 3 clone, albeit with some interesting features
@JosephStory
@JosephStory Год назад
lk5 24:45 I'd add that it's a single z motor drive as well. Way better out there for less money now.
@Liberty4Ever
@Liberty4Ever Год назад
19:30 - "I literally threw this one off of a balcony so I'm gonna have to put it in D tier. If I didn't do that, I'd definitely put it in A or B." This is a strange rating system. 😛 44:30 - The Ghost 6 is redeemed, from off-the-balcony D tier to A tier. 😀
@reasonablebeing5392
@reasonablebeing5392 11 месяцев назад
+1 on the Ender 2 pro - I had the parts from TH3D so I just swapped out the main board for an EZ-board (yeah I had to make adapter cables), added EZ ABL and flex plate and upgraded the power supply to a Meanwell and a metal extruder. It sits on my desk for protos and also to take with me if I need to make a practical print on demand. I wanted it to be bullet-proof and reliable and it is. The prints are high quality every time.
@andymeenanvideos
@andymeenanvideos Год назад
Printing this out after joining Patreon, absolutely spot on with your choices, Fantastic video which needs regular updates.
@glenncol
@glenncol Год назад
What about the Elegoo 3 Pro and the Neptune 4 Pro
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Christ at the Mingda. I knew they were crap, but not having any form of thermal runaway protection in current year is absurd.
@macrone419
@macrone419 Год назад
Imagine saying that Delta architecture in 3D printers does not make sense 👀
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Prusa mini with a not all metal hotend in current year still missing featured they promised years ago, taking up very similar space to a mk3 while not having much build volume, having notorious ender 3 like ptfe tube lineup issues, a price you could get a neptune 4 for.... I personally think it's absolutely nowhere near s tier. It want even s tier when it came out imo
@limoranch
@limoranch 9 месяцев назад
Deltas are so much easier to program to work with non-planar printing and the slopes and curves are just beautiful and almost impossible to do on an rail printers.
@dexxeve9420
@dexxeve9420 Год назад
This is not just a Teir list. but a quick round up review of all the 3D printers or a buyers guide if buying a 3d printer in 2023. So i would say its the most update all round very, very quick to the point review of ALL THE 3D printers out. So the video has double value for those new to 3d printers and are overwhelmed. Did i mention his a engineer too :). This prob is the best most update video round up of all 3D printers to date WATCH IT if new or want an update to 3D printers. OR else did i mention his an engineer lol
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
"Trust me, I'm an engineer" It works in every situation
@bliska8434
@bliska8434 Год назад
@@NathanBuildsRobots based on your statements in this video, I question your engineering credentials. Engineers can tell the difference between accessories and printers... AMS and Sonic Pad/clone on a printer list, janky printers in S-tier with Vorons. RatRig, Prusa Mk4 and an ender clone as "Average". Having personally used the majority of these printers, your list lacks education.
@MalignSociety
@MalignSociety Год назад
Nathan only missed 6 or 7 times.@@bliska8434
@dexxeve9420
@dexxeve9420 Год назад
@@bliska8434 SLAP!!
@Rob-vt1mz
@Rob-vt1mz 10 месяцев назад
I agree 100% it's overwhelming doing research. I'm a first time buyer with a $200-$300 budget for Black Friday 2023 on Amazon, I'm in the market for a 3D printer suitable for my diverse hobbies, including woodworking and fish keeping (4' tank), RC Airplanes, quads. At this price range, I'm trying to balance equipment quality with bed size. Top of entry level price point & bottom of mid range price point is a bit of a pain. Majority at my flying field have enders. (one guy with a 3d printed zero. Very nice) A couple guys with higher end models. While many recommend Ender printers, I'm wary of their common issues and the need for extensive modding. I'm not worried about the skill to mod but more the time for it. I'm willing to invest in a higher-quality printer within my budget and explore firmware options like Klipper and Orca. Nathan's videos have been helpfull in my research. Majority of others I've seen are more like adcopy. Working on getting my list down to the top 3 or 4 now and Q'n up the wishlist for tomorrow.
@DarkTrapStudio
@DarkTrapStudio Год назад
Maybe if you stop throwing printer youll have this higher pricepoint budget
@sierraecho884
@sierraecho884 10 месяцев назад
Did you forget the Flashforge Adventurer 5M / 5M Pro ? It´s not a great printer since the Firmware is locked, however it´s the cheapest quality Core XY I could buy for 400€. The Bamu Lab P1P cost 650€ and the K1 430€. I also love the nozzle swap, even thou the hotend cost 25€ but I won´t need them regulary anyway, I still use the same Nozzle on my current 3D Printer from 2019.
@aware2action
@aware2action Год назад
While the grading is excellent, from an user experience point of view, the slicer compatibilty has a marked impact on the performance. While Cura is easier, it is not that advanced like the Prusa slicer, or its derivatives. IdeaMaker is excellent too, interms of better support for non-standard printers such as Delta's(Flsun) and Belt Printers(CR-30). Again, it comes down to user preference, but is an important factor to consider on par with hardware quality and performance, and the final result that is achievable from the given hardware.
@TheMugwump1
@TheMugwump1 Год назад
My Ender 3 S1 Pro is borderline S tier. It's certainly open for debate, but rolling the dice with an open box from Microcenter for $178 I STILL feel like I stole this thing considering they're over $350 still. I also managed a sonic pad open box a week later for like $120.(I have your board with better 5015 coolers, so there could be a bit of a conflict of interest here,
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
Have you put any upgrades into it?
@TheMugwump1
@TheMugwump1 Год назад
@@NathanBuildsRobots Upgrades? Just your board, better cooling and a microswiss nozzle, and the sonic pad. It makes a pretty damn good combo. I had a resin printer before this thing. I'll consider linear rail upgrades if I start having issues with dimensional accuracy. Everything seems fine now. I'm building an enclosure now so I can print some ASA or nylon without poisoning myself. Also learning fusion 360 and building parts like magnetic couplers for flanges for venting outside. Pretty cool shit designing and printing your own functional parts. OH! I added a camera and mount so I can monitor with the sonic pad also a cable chain for the bed heater. I love being able to control preheating etc and also keeping an eye on the print on my second monitor. Ive got the printer in another room.
@dangerous8333
@dangerous8333 Год назад
@@TheMugwump1 Smart to have it venting outside. That's the only way to do it. Many people think an enclosure and carbon filter are enough, they do practically nothing. I don't know how far along you are with your fusion 360 training, but If you need to make quick parts, you can use tinkercad. I know how to use fusion 360 but I find myself going to tinkercad still quite often for quick simple things. I made the ventilation system for my laser cutter with tinkercad.
@onestopfunstop317
@onestopfunstop317 Год назад
I have a bunch of Ender3 S1 Pro's. They just run. It's a Fantastic Machine. No upgrades. No Problems. I run them 24/7...
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Here's the thing though: The majority of people don't have microcenters near the.
@greenman360
@greenman360 Год назад
Seeing the E3V3 in S Tier saved me a lot of time, lmao. It might be a good printer, and considering the price it could even be very good. But best of the best? LOL.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
Value, as in price to performance, is very important for me.
@darthjesus7742
@darthjesus7742 Год назад
Kobra go off the damn balcony and then hit it with a sledgehammer
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
Lmao I had high hopes, just finished reviewing it though and yeah… I’d put it in zzz tier to be fair
@crooker2
@crooker2 10 месяцев назад
Bought an Ender 3 V3. Great hardware. Software sucks... So hard. PLEASE someone create a klipper or MriscoC config for the E3V3. :)
@francisnitsch-jones5908
@francisnitsch-jones5908 Год назад
the Ratrigs should be in the S tier, sure they may need some design tweaks but they print super fast, super well, super consistently.
@YurikaEngineering
@YurikaEngineering Год назад
How about Lerdge ix? It's the only printer which doesn't need a computer to do any setting on it. That must be worth being on a board
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
I had firmware issues on the first Lerdge product I tested. It would immediately set the hotend to 200C upon powering it on...
@salvatoree.2109
@salvatoree.2109 Год назад
Haven't they sent you the Kingroon KLP1 to review?
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
No. They are afraid
@salvatoree.2109
@salvatoree.2109 Год назад
Maybe I still have time to cancel my pre-order then 😂
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
🫴
@petercallison5765
@petercallison5765 Год назад
Your next video should on the best machines to be ugraded. What's the cheapest path to a top tier machine?
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
I like the neptune 4 because it is essentially a fully upgraded Ender 3. Better part cooling, higher flow nozzle, klipper, dual z axis, ABL, direct drive extruder, all metal hotend, etc etc etc. So that would be the cheapest option. Additional upgrades could be added if you feel it needs some. Cheapest option for an enclosed printer is probably flying bear ghost 6 on Klipper. I have a hunch that the Ghost 7 may come stock with klipper, which would be awesome.
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Strong opinion: The answer is no printer. It's never worth your time to buy a crappy printer then upgrade it. You're way better off just buying a better one from the get go. If I had a gun to my head though, I'd say a Vezbot. Easy enough to mod, and clearly an enthusiast printer.
@IOERROR622
@IOERROR622 Год назад
You rank the K1 above the P1P? What. Also the P1S is S tier over the P1P when they are nearly the same printer but had an enclosure but 90% of the people only print in pla or maybe petg which both print the same.
@filamentio
@filamentio Год назад
I love my artillery printer such an underated maschine 🥰
@earlowens998
@earlowens998 Год назад
The Ender 2 Pro is selling for $125.30 right now. It has a 165 x 165 x 180mm build. It has 4 leveling knobs. you have it on the very good printer's level. I'm amazed. If it is almost worth buying for a novelty to put on the shelf, but I have doubts that it should be on the very good printer's level. I would love to see you justify that.
@reasonablebeing5392
@reasonablebeing5392 11 месяцев назад
See my other comment - this one is not a novelty but the most portable printer I own and great for protos - I have taken it with me to print practical prints real time. And good quality prints. Very good in my book.
@yotortellini
@yotortellini Год назад
Add the HevORT
@takuya2431
@takuya2431 Год назад
Im very confused. You said that you tested all of these in your intro but you have no idea if the belt printer is reliable, if the vcore is any good. I also dont understand why a tablet running klipper or the ams suddenly become a printer. It also makes 0 sense to me, why a printer becomes less good, if it has more parts in it.
@A13tech
@A13tech Год назад
thanks for the video. I have two enders 3. Im just sick of keeping them going. A few tens of kg of the material printed and I dont want to deal with them anymore. This video help me to choose a next one. Probably P1S or K1max or let see if something new will come before christmas.
@justiciaparaespana7236
@justiciaparaespana7236 Год назад
I will sell the CR10 V3 because I'm tired with the extruder and also it's heavy for me. I will throw from the balcony... I changed the motor and the extruder and still no working well. The motor skips steps and it provocates constantly clogs but, when It works, it's a great machine. I have my two Ender 3 that I will never sell them and yes... I know that they're a boring 3D printers despite that there are already more fast machines but the maintenance cost is the lowest than the K1. The K1 I'm having bad experience with customer services... The machine is OK but, as you say, the extruder was causing the majority of the problem but also has overheat problems on the conector of the camera from the motherboard. When the motherboard gets hot, the camera dies... So I had to install a Yihome camera to know what's happening on the K1 meanwhile is printing. On the last firmware update from the K1, the printer got frozen and remained with the hotend and the bed hot meanwhile I was outside when, for my opinion, was a great fire risk because it there was an error, it should be turn off everything until I come back home. At this moment I'm building a Voron 0.2 and I'm having fun and learning a lot about everything, but I bought it before summer holidays and I builded the half of the printer. On the future I'm thinking to buy a Prusa MK4 to replace the CR10 V3 because the big one is overprice for me and quite heavy. I know that the Prusa has less volume print surface but I use the CR10 V3 a few times. Greetings from Spain.
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
Oooooof on the Delta hate. How can you hate designs that look so visually cool!!!
@oic165
@oic165 Год назад
Maaaan. I just bought a V2. I needed this 3 weeks ago. Definitely following you. Great info man. Thank you.
@MisterDeets
@MisterDeets Год назад
I can fill you in on my experience with the Reborn 2 from Flying Bear. It tried to burn my place to the ground more than once with the stock firmware. The preheat setting using the built in screen would sometimes cause the printer's computer to lock up and no longer respond to anything (probably some infinite loop built into the firmware). I fixed it's homicidal tendencies by converting the printer to Klipper (that isn't very easy to do because the instructions aren't in english). The company was not very good to deal with when it came down to fixing the damage from the overheating. They forced me to prove that the parts were damaged before they would replace them (nevermind the video I posted on youtube with the glowing red smouldering hot end with deformed/melted cooling fan ducts ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-7MxLkfBDbUM.html). They were an insulting nightmare to deal with considering what happened. There are issues with this printer that no reviewer I've seen has addressed. The prints have a belt or motor noise artifact that is very evident on the prints. It is fine for functional parts, but not for anything that could be considered art unless you really like sanding and bondo.
@rockman9h02m
@rockman9h02m Год назад
fwiw i own one and i'll be posting some neat mods for it. i think the frame still is a good base to start with. The rest of it though is kinda garbage as you've experienced. Perhaps reborn 2 english-speaking owners should make a server :)
@MisterDeets
@MisterDeets Год назад
@@rockman9h02m Does yours have the belt/motor noise artifacts in the prints as well? Pretty sure it's motor noise issues.
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
God that sounds awful. That's well 0ast the "never buy, even as a base" tier of awful.
@sergeirachmaninoff4287
@sergeirachmaninoff4287 2 месяца назад
....so you're basing your judgement from a hunch and anecdotal evidence rather than direct experience? How is this a reliable assessment?
@Majkl9102
@Majkl9102 3 месяца назад
Hello thanks for video, can you help if something change after one year later? I do not own printer in this moment, I'm crafter-man, mostly i would like to print for me and my kids, figures, toys, inserts for Boardgames (here i would like to have possibility print logos in color), boxes, wall organizers, utilities, enhancers etc. What Im thinking about: 1. Bambu lab A1 with AMS (499 EURO) ++++ price + multicolor - missing enclosure/ not build well for DIY enclosure 2. Bambu lab P1S (AMS later but price of AMS itself is huge in comparisons P1S combo) (600 Euro or 850 Euro with AMS +- price + enclosure, cooling, air filters + AMS with closed environment and protections from humidity - price of AMS if is not in combo purchase Price difference between P1P and P1S is to small (40 EURO), to miss inbuild cooling system and air filter already builded 3. Creality K1 MAX AI (634 EURO) ++ price + enclosure +++ volume --- no chance of multicolor (at the moment, later price of CMS? Price of upgrade for CMS? Maybe to much…) 4. Prusa MK4 kit + MMU3 kit (unfortunally price is to high for me at the moment) What I do not like on AMS (CMS as well) is amount of waste. To be honest approach of MMU3 from Prusa is much better, would like have possibility use it on bambu or creality printer... This is for me big deal breaker, and reason why I hesitate. It is not so big to say "ok go for K1 or P1S without AMS" and it is not so small, to say "Ok go for A1 or P1S with AMS" Any recommendation which one buy? And why, considering the points I mentioned? is it worth build enclosure for A1? is it worth build own enclosure for P1P? is it worth AMS or is only "hype"? Is PVA good for supports? is PVA safe for environment (no microplastic fibers getting into ground/water)? I will be glad for any suggestion. Thank you
@ArchonLicht
@ArchonLicht 11 месяцев назад
I'm struggling with Prusa mini - after a while it gets unfixable underextrusion. PTFE tube in the heatbreak needs to be replaced from time to time, but the original one is way to expensive - and it's impossible to get a right size if you cut one yourself. But even if you do replacement with a proper one - still something just constantly blocks the heatbreak and you get underextrusion. Bowden is generally bad - direct extruders are clearly superior. And PrusaLink is just bad. The whole nonsense with putting WiFi credentials on a USB stick and then having to save the API key (and the login form is made in such a way that browser doesn't recognize it as such, and doesn't propose to store the API key as a password) - for having little to no control over printing anyway... bad, just bad.
@rodrigofarruguia1708
@rodrigofarruguia1708 5 месяцев назад
Lol....Cetus makes very good printers and it is one of the older ones. Look at reviews from over 7 years ago. They are known for making those single arm printers that IIIP, Bambu, Prusa and other followed with. Wanhao was a big name for a while and they did the cross rod gantry and very solid frames. Good reviews on Creality, you did not shit on all their printers entirely. I rank the Bambu in the same order as you but lower, they are not open source and that plumets my opinion on products. Goodluck on growing your channel.
@JumpingJack6
@JumpingJack6 Год назад
Could you do a list where you only consider print quality and speed and not adjust for price.
@keepitrealandtoasty
@keepitrealandtoasty Год назад
Your reason to put flsun delta on the flaw tier ruins your whole credibility or advice on 3d printers.
@ulforcemegamon3094
@ulforcemegamon3094 Год назад
Gotta agree , if he didn't liked deltas he could have said it before , both the Super Racer and the V400 are great machines
@peen2804
@peen2804 11 месяцев назад
“U don’t align with my personal biases therefore u r wrong”
@keepitrealandtoasty
@keepitrealandtoasty 11 месяцев назад
@@peen2804 NBR is cool . I could of possibly be to harsh on the comment , He does deliver good content . No one is perfect . Like all 3d printers they do have their quarks.
@ulyssesdraco
@ulyssesdraco Год назад
The Neptune 4 and SV07 are ten dollars in difference right now, so for $269 you can get the Sv07 with wifi functionality. There has also been some talk of a possible SV07 Plus with a larger print area coming out sometime this year.
@lun7n
@lun7n Год назад
People have a lot of problems with the sv07. Also, both the Neptune 4 and sv07 are heavily flawed having v rollers with such high speed capacity.
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
@@lun7n I just want to take the time to join you in hating vrollers. They're just such an awful motion system. Bad wear and tear, unpredictable and worse than normal precision,the ability to get flat spots by sitting for awhile , gunning up other components with the rubber dust for no positive tradeoff and the list goes on and on. I hate that it became the standard for cheap printers.
@1fareast14
@1fareast14 Год назад
29:25 a tier for toolchanger on a stock printer, name another
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
IDEX > Tool changer (IMHO)
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
@@NathanBuildsRobots Strong disagree for one reason: what do you do when you want a different nozzle size or more than 2 filament types ? Prusa has been having some issues lately but the XL at least in concept is baller af
@mattclay4
@mattclay4 Год назад
So I have a Voron Trident 350 and 0.1 as well as a Prusa Mini and Ender 2 Pro. I could recommend all these printers honestly, but the Prusa Mini is the one I would have if I could only pick one, simply due to the size and simplicity, if I had to pick only one printer to have overall it would be a smaller Trident.
@scifiguy4132
@scifiguy4132 Год назад
i love your list but the only problem i have with it is where you put the 2.4 the build is realativly easy to put together (coming from me a 15 year old) and if you put some more money towards upgrades such as steealthburner, nevermore, tap or klicky, and a better hotend like a phaetus like i did it kicks ass
@BeefIngot
@BeefIngot Год назад
I think you are in a deep deep bubble if you think a 2.4 is easy to put together. I can't even think of aore complex printer plan/Kit that isn't custom. Just the flying gantrt alone would make most people cry in frustration.
@scifiguy4132
@scifiguy4132 Год назад
@@BeefIngot no the flying gantry and assembly is the easy part (people can do that in a day) but the hard part is tuning if you self-source i could see it being hard but with new kits like fabreeko and ldo its really really easy
@xXKisskerXx
@xXKisskerXx Год назад
~delta printers are amazingly fast - their only real flaw, is they tend to be quite small print volume. ~bowden tubes are fine in almost all the applications you said were bad - I think you are quite heavily biased or misinformed, direct drive, is not better - they both have their pros and cons. ~the upside down printer - works, and "they" aren't making them, 1 person designed and got it going. Honestly, it's amazing, and one of the few portable ones (designed to fit into a spool box) as for your disgust with it - why print right side up? Just because your used to it? ~odd how you find 'more parts" a bad thing - when actually most of the "bigger built for speed" need more parts, to keep them sturdy and able to accelerate well, or handle the weight of prints as they go for large format printers. "the majority cost of a 3D printer is in the Hot End" - this is not factual on most printers, very cheap printers may suffer from this - but honestly - especially when you pay $1,000 for a printer- only about 25% of that is in the hotend area, especially as the hotend, is just the heating element, cooling of the hotend, and nozzle really... a ceramic heating coil element, titanium heat break, and aluminum cooler with fan - is less than $75, and it will print just about anything (up to 300C)
@marsrocket
@marsrocket 11 месяцев назад
Cost shouldn’t be a consideration when ranking printers. It’s subjective and precludes the viewer from finding the best printer for their own budget.
@ThantiK
@ThantiK Год назад
@4:34 - something I can say also for the Ender 3 v2 as I've repaired a million of them - their injection molded fan cover shatters on every single one. They are incredibly low quality almost balcony-level bad. I mostly agree with your assessment on printers.
@NathanBuildsRobots
@NathanBuildsRobots Год назад
Thanks thantik. If you mostly agree I must be doing something right
@3dPrintingMillennial
@3dPrintingMillennial Год назад
Add the Tevo Tornado
@3D_Printing
@3D_Printing Год назад
Does it list the Flyingbear Revision 2 with auto leveling and PEI, agg klipper
@matthewsmith2385
@matthewsmith2385 Год назад
Gotva ender 3 V2 for 100$ did the Cr touch mod and. Changed the bed springs ,Bowden tube and extruder for 60$ I believe it was a good purchase because I'm a beginner
@alexfeatherstone6676
@alexfeatherstone6676 Год назад
I got the p1p before the p1s, honestly for the cost its very good.
@Brom0timol
@Brom0timol Год назад
If you plan on only printing pla and petg you clearly don’t care about p1s pla is happy with non enclosed printer I am using my p1p with 0.2mm nozzle and I am getting insane details to my print without even tinkering !! I printed more in 1 month than with a year with my previous flsun because I don’t fail my print and don’t have to calibrate it twice a week, so much more productive !
Далее
PRUSA MK4 - Is Orange Printer Better?
51:40
Просмотров 50 тыс.
Сколько стоит ПП?
00:57
Просмотров 338 тыс.
The 3D Filament Tier List! Which Should YOU Use?
44:34
Просмотров 823 тыс.
23 3D Printers You SHOULD or SHOULDN'T Buy!
20:37
Просмотров 278 тыс.
Calibration Cubes: More Harm Than Good?
16:11
Просмотров 408 тыс.
Not sure what 3d prints to sell?
9:31
Просмотров 42 тыс.
Creality vs Bambu Lab (Updated for 2024)
43:17
Просмотров 13 тыс.
2024 3D Printer Release TIER LIST!
36:19
Просмотров 26 тыс.
3D Printer Reliability: Prusa vs. Bambulab
13:15
Просмотров 456 тыс.