1. The Massacre of Karbala: A Historical Analysis - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani - Masjid-e-Ali 

+Afiya Viraney it was only Hazrat Umar ra who told Hafezzen are been killed so we should collect all Qurinic aya.s so Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra ordered to collect all Aya then it was Collected and kept with Hazrat Hafsa ra .. as Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra was First Khalifa . then IN Hazrat Uthman ra Khlafat he gave it form of Book which you have today as Quran with proper numbering like Surah numbers and Aya.s in Quran .

+reyaz mir There is no dispute among Muslim scholars, whether they are Sunni or Shi’a, concerning the fact that the Commander of Believers, ‘Ali (as), possessed a special transcript of the text of Qur’an which he had collected himself, and he was THE FIRST who compiled Qur’an. There are a great number of traditions from Sunni and Shi’a which states that after the death of the Holy Prophet (S), Imam ‘Ali sat down in his house and said that he had sworn an oath that he would not put on his outdoor clothes or leave his house until he collects together the Qur’an.Sunni references:- Fat’hul Bari fi Sharh Sahih al-Bukhari, by Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, v10, p386 - al-fihrist, by (Ibn) an-Nadim, p30 - al-Itqan, by al-Suyuti, v1, p165 - al-Masahif, by Ibn Abi Dawud, p10 - Hilyatul awliya’, by Abu Nu’aym, v1, p67 - al-Sahibi, by Ibn Faris, p79 - ‘Umdatul Qari, by al-Ayni, v20, p16 - Kanzul Ummal, by al-Muttaqi al-Hindi, v15, pp 112-113 - al-Sawa’iq al-Muhriqah, by Ibn Hajar al-Haythami, Ch. 9, Section 4, p197 - Ma’rifat al-Qurra’ al-kibar, by al-Dhahabi, v1, p31

+Tanya Espinosa it was only Hazrat Umar ra who told Hafezzen are been killed so we should collect all Qurinic aya.s so Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra ordered to collect all Aya then it was Collected and kept with Hazrat Hafsa ra .. as Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra was First Khalifa . then IN Hazrat Uthman ra Khlafat he gave it form of Book which you have today as Quran with proper numbering like Surah numbers and Aya.s in Quran .

+reyaz mir lmaooo

reyaz mir what you on

reyaz mir : I have a question about what you said, with all respect I am curious why the messenger of Allah prophet Muhammad pbuh did not order compilation of the Quran himself, when that was a responsibility he was given by Allah swt.

he did via ali. listen to other lectures of dr sayed. tq.

+Fadel Salman it was only Hazrat Umar ra who told Hafezzen are been killed so we should collect all Qurinic aya.s so Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra ordered to collect all Aya then it was Collected and kept with Hazrat Hafsa ra .. as Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra was First Khalifa . then IN Hazrat Uthman ra Khlafat he gave it form of Book which you have today as Quran with proper numbering like Surah numbers and Aya.s in Quran .

+reyaz mir so when Allah (SWT) said he sent down the Quran he meant he sent down a collection of ayahs? The Quran was compiled during the life of RasoulAllah (saww) by RasoulAllah (saww), not Abu Bakr (la), not Umar (la), not Uthman (la), not Aisha (la) and not Hafsa (la).

your right

your right

Sound distortion is in overdrive. Reducing your volume when you play it will make it easy to focus on the actual lecture.

+Sherbanu Molu it was only Hazrat Umar ra who told Hafezzen are been killed so we should collect all Qurinic aya.s so Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra ordered to collect all Aya then it was Collected and kept with Hazrat Hafsa ra .. as Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra was First Khalifa . then IN Hazrat Uthman ra Khlafat he gave it form of Book which you have today as Quran with proper numbering like Surah numbers and Aya.s in Quran .

Keralite?

+reyaz mir ok enough with your cutting and pasting we got your point.

Salam, what is your questions regarding shiism? Inshalla i can help u out.

Hi, there aren't many websites on the internet, in my opinion Ammar Nakshwani is the best source, and another good source is a religious or practicing Shia.

Check out al-islam.org there are a lot of free books you can read

Books that inspired me were "Peshawar night"s and "a restatement of the history of Islam" and of course "then I was guided" all online at al-islam.org

If you are on Facebook, please join the group Practical Islamic Spirituality. Feel free to contact me directly also if I can be of further assistance.

Khan Majeed As many as 70 verses of Quraan do have context of Ali(as) Important ones are Al Mayda verse 67 Al Ehzab Verse33 Al Hadeed verse 25 Al Raad verse 11.Open Quraan and tven debate .Who refutes Quraan you or me ?There are vivid of Ayas of Wali concept as well .If know blame game and are ignorant of Quraan this is your fault.

+Khan Majeed ,your stupid. go and read

+Khan Majeed, am sorry for my english. its not very well. I have reading your other messages olso. to onather brother of my. and i was thing how to answer your question. sud i do it just like you. or sud i do not. i have choice to do not... why?? first of all your ask me to tell you to educate if I known more then you and second you calling brother dr ammar KAFIR. when you want to learn something stop calling people KAFIR. because kafir i the one how not believe in god. and siaa sunni believes in god. i know olso a hadith that say. when you call someone a kafir and he isint, then you will be one of the kafirs.. if you want to learn first of al talk normal en behaved lole a moslim... we both know that the name hz ALi as, is not writing in the kuran. so ebu bekr or omer olso bot writing. but whe know that some hadith is comming, at behavior of Hz Ali as and the others just like omer ebubakr uthman. so dont foul your self. educate educate i olso was thingking how can i educate you... if dr ammar didnt motivates of educated you. how must i do it.. i cant.. i just can say. listen to other lessons lections of ammar.. and let your heart en mind make the choice. what good or wrong... my allah bless you and your familie. and stop blaming the sia's. because 1400 the others did the same. and the sia's will be for ever.

+Khan Majeed i mean some sura ayats. not hadith.

A Sahin Prophet of Allah had said "No one will disdain Ali except the Hypocrites"

+Sister Fadia it was only Hazrat Umar ra who told Hafezzen are been killed so we should collect all Qurinic aya.s so Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra ordered to collect all Aya then it was Collected and kept with Hazrat Hafsa ra .. as Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq ra was First Khalifa . then IN Hazrat Uthman ra Khlafat he gave it form of Book which you have today as Quran with proper numbering like Surah numbers and Aya.s in Quran .

Do more research my brother. seek knowledge and do not become a parrot. Look for it. Pray about it. even if it takes you till the day you die. seek knowledge.

+Sister Fadia he 8s only copy pasting same message. Do you think he will read books ☺

+Nida Afsheen look at the cxoment above and see .... how many times should he have to repeat this message till they get it? Yet they don't...

+Sister Fadia come on u betrayed imam hussain u Shia didn't give water to Muslim bin aqeel because ibn zayd bribed the Shia

Shameless and stupid thing to say.

was the prophet pbuh Shia? was hussain a Shia, was Ali a Shia, it was the Shia who called him then abandoned him if you people helped him this would not happen, it was the Shia who did not give water to Muslim bin aqeel because ibn zayd bribed the Shia shimr was a Persian and also a Shia tell me one member of the ahlulbayt who married a Shia you people curse umer why? because he broke fatima ribs nonsense, he didn't he broke the Persian kings ribs

+Eagle Eagle oh bhai improve your history info your own self. We are not your teachers. Read your own Sahi Bukhari and Sahi Muslim then know what are Shian-e-Ali You people are confused not us.

+Nida Afsheen lol u have no proof do u everytime you people do lecture you mention our hadiths

Read your Sahi Bukhari about Ghader e Khum Then reply back

+Nida Afsheen what's your saorce why use ours

Have a look round, Ammar Nakshawani is a Shia Muslim.

I am thinking of Shiism but the majority being Sunni is what worries me. I love all Muslims and i dont want to be hated by Sunni just because i could be Shia

Jake Bull a sect or a group that could inherently hate you for being of the same path to God says a lot about itself. Sunni-Shia unity is on the rise, I wouldn't worry about joining either.

Just because theres a bigger crowd, doesnt always mean its right. Think outside of the box :) Hope you find the right path inshAllah

The only way to Islam is through the teachings of Prophet Muhammad . The only way to access this knowledge is though his door. For the prophet has said " I am the city of knowledge and Ali is the gate. This is narrated in both shia and sunni traditions.

Yes, he has Islamic-inspired tattoos all over his arms too. And according to all Shi'a Marjas/jurists, it is permissible to have the type of permanent tattoos that Sayed Ammar has.

Sorry, but the actual ruling says that if you have Islamic tattoos, then they must be respected and you have to be careful about disrespecting them through impurity etc. Therefore, it's better NOT to have Islamic tattoos, but rather just ordinary ones, since we use the toilet, have sex, etc, all of which entail impurity, and therefore disrespect. He has a tattoo of "Ali" in Arabic on his left hand, which we use to clean ourselves after using the toilet. Isn't that the height of disrespect...? He should have thought it through a bit better, and it's not too late to get it fixed.

+sweetnawesome23 in my personal opinion i think having a tattoo is wrong cause as muslims we have to look up to the behaviours and doings of mohamed(s) and the imams, and cause i dont think they would put a tattoo i shouldnt put one, the body is a gift from god we have to respect it and try as much as we can to deliver it the way we got it unless its in the way of god, since tattoo dosent benfit the body then i think its wrong

OMG leave the man alone with his tattoos he loves them what's your problem? Under each of his videos people start to talk about them it's crazy

@@sweetnawesome23 although he has Islamic tattoos but it isn't Ali on his left hand but instead it says Free. Also Islamic tattoos are totally ok within our sect. It's more about niyat than what all you mentioned.

Too much laziness from your side brother