Agree on a lot of the bottles you mentioned. JW Dant is a great pour. Love New Riff single barrels. I went with our club to select a barrel about a year and half ago and it was a fantastic experience. I never pass up a 1792 full proof or Russell store pick as I have yet to have a bad one. A few other possible contenders to consider: JTS Brown (another HH BIB), Smooth Ambler Old Scout, Yellowstone Hand Selected, Ezra Brooks 7 year, Old Forester Statesman & Blade and Bow
Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare are both Mashbill #1. Different age, Buffalo Trace is younger at roughly 8 years old where Eagle Rare is 10, don't know if the barrels come from different places in the rick or not.