Тёмный

1831 Cottage Potatoe Pudding Or Cake Cook Not Mad - Old Cook Book Show - Glen And Friends Cooking 

Glen And Friends Cooking
Подписаться 629 тыс.
Просмотров 39 тыс.
50% 1

1831 Cottage Potatoe Pudding Or Cake Cook Not Mad - Old Cook Book Show - Glen And Friends Cooking
The recipe today is from the 1831 American printing of a rather strange little cookbook called "The Cook Not Mad Or Rational Cookery..." the title goes on from there as was the custom for cookbook titles in this period. Overall the book is a mishmash of recipes gathered word for word from other sources, and presented with a very Pro American / Anti European bent in the wording of the introduction.
There is a Myth created and perpetuated by a modern day book publisher that this was Canada's first cookbook... but it wasn't. It's a great story that sold countless reprints in museum gift shops across Canada; but sadly just a fabrication to sell more books.
Yes I know Potato isn't spelled 'Potatoe'... but that's the way it was often spelled in cookbooks during this time period and this old cookbook is no exception.
No 86. Cottage potatoe Pudding or Cake.
Boil and pare and mash two pounds of potatoes, beat them fine with a pint of milk, two ounces of sugar, three eggs, bake three quarters of an hour. A quarter of a pound of raisins or currants may be added, or leave out the milk and add a quarter of butter, it will make a good cake.
#LeGourmetTV #GlenAndFriendsCooking #OldCookbookShow
recipe,Glen And Friends Cooking,old cookbook show,1831 Cottage Potatoe Pudding Or Cake,historical recipes,1800s cooking,tasting history,cooking history,food history,100 year old recipes,old cookbook recipes,community cookbook recipes,cooking with glen,cooking up history,18th century cooking,18 century cooking,historical recipe,historical food,19th century cooking,the cook not mad cookbook,canadas first cookbook,history cooking,edible history

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 279   
@marilyn1228
@marilyn1228 3 года назад
Every time you open the door to that oven, I marvel at the beauty of it.
@ThackerLance
@ThackerLance 3 года назад
I like that you show the fails as well as the successes. Too many people just show the instagram worthy successes and that's just not the reality.
@kchortu
@kchortu 3 года назад
me too
@johnnykush6022
@johnnykush6022 3 года назад
He is trying old recipe, it's not even a fail. There have to be some bad recipes,
@mcllamamann
@mcllamamann 3 года назад
Would love to see a tour of your old cookbook collection. Also some of the oldest and most interesting amongst them.
@hannakinn
@hannakinn 3 года назад
I second that request! Those old recipes are very interesting.
@357Addict
@357Addict 3 года назад
This reminds me of the Mike Meyers quote from the movie "So I married an axe murderer". "My theory is that all of Scottish cuisine is based on a dare."
@andrewvermeltfoort
@andrewvermeltfoort 3 года назад
Glen, I could watch your videos for the rest of my life and be happy. I discovered your channel at the beginning of this pandemic and I have to say the level of professionalism in the filming and editing makes me feel like I should be paying you
@sittingstill3578
@sittingstill3578 3 года назад
He films advertising and marketing materials professionally. He refers to his work in some of the videos.
@andrewvermeltfoort
@andrewvermeltfoort 3 года назад
@@sittingstill3578 I know I've heard him talk about it, he's also mentioned he really doesn't make much money on RU-vid so I'm just impressed that he spends so much time and talent doing all of this
@Jacob-Vivimord
@Jacob-Vivimord 3 года назад
He used to have a membership program here on RU-vid, but he ended it. I'd love to know why.
@arhythmicnick9929
@arhythmicnick9929 3 года назад
Once I made a chocolate mashed potato cake out a cookbook of potato recipes and it tasted like chocolate mashed potato, and I never repeated the experiment. I can absolutely see that if you want a cake and all you have to hand is potatoes this is what you might come up with, but luckily I live in a time and place where there is more choice.
@FlameG102
@FlameG102 3 года назад
haha! I've done the exact same! It was out of a book of bread recipes. seemed interesting but in the end it just tasted like potato with chocolate. And the texture was just... way too dense and weird.
@hopecox
@hopecox 3 года назад
Lol 😂
@ClockworkAvatar
@ClockworkAvatar 3 года назад
my grandmother used to make something tangentially similar, though she passed the potatoes through a ricer and it was sweetened/thickened with sweetened condensed milk and flavored with coconut, you couldn't even taste the potatoes. it was like a denser crustless coconut custard pie, and it was baked with a lid in a shallower pan.
@draxe9121
@draxe9121 3 года назад
I was watching this and the recommended video at the end was a link to a John Townsends video. It hit me like a revelation; nutmeg! Nutmeg makes everything better. 🤣
@1One2Three5Eight13
@1One2Three5Eight13 11 месяцев назад
I was also thinking that this might make a good vehicle for flavours. Like how pumpkin pie tastes more of the spices you put into it than anything else.
@debbieosredkernelson13
@debbieosredkernelson13 3 года назад
"No." This comes across as a warning.. as in, "No, do not try this at home."
@janewebb3477
@janewebb3477 3 года назад
Back in the day, filling tummies and using what you had, plus hunger was the best ingredient. People were probably less fussy, compared to what they had every other day. Love the old cookbook show!! I can only imagine the amount of research you need to do for all of your videos.
@IsaacIsaacIsaacson
@IsaacIsaacIsaacson Год назад
@@Ea-Nasir_Copper_Co if you lived in a region that grew grapes, then not necessarily. They'd be an easy way to store grapes for winter
@8444mhernandez
@8444mhernandez 3 года назад
I love the passion Glen has about raisins and currents, lol.
@SuHu62
@SuHu62 3 года назад
It's hard to ruin a potato, but it Can Be Done 😄
@craftsandcards
@craftsandcards 3 года назад
Lol..." I can't even think of ways to help this" says Julie...It didn't look that appealing to me but I had high hopes for this recipe Glen !!! Thanks for a fun Sunday recipe....cheers from Ontario
@gyost8147
@gyost8147 3 года назад
It reminds me of something like the corn pudding we make. It's now usually only for holidays like Thanksgiving but it's served with the meal (alongside meats with gravy or sauce). The corn pudding can be made in various ways (it's sweeter depending on the type of corn and amount sugar added) but it is not a dessert and is intended to be part of the main meal.
@brycesefonte9093
@brycesefonte9093 3 года назад
I love your reaction. Just love it.
@TheBadcop
@TheBadcop 3 года назад
Glen, thank you for what you do. I'm going through a rough patch right now and I always find your content very soothing.
@beaver6d9
@beaver6d9 3 года назад
Another reason I'm glad we're not in 1831.
@PlayaSinNombre
@PlayaSinNombre 3 года назад
Thank you for your sacrifice...
@hannakinn
@hannakinn 3 года назад
Lol
@PlayaSinNombre
@PlayaSinNombre 3 года назад
“Then it counts as research! Brilliant!”
@redoorn
@redoorn 3 года назад
The research Glen does for his vids. Simply Impressive.
@jeffcarney2375
@jeffcarney2375 3 года назад
I love the experimentation. It sets you apart
@papa.and.mimis.country.life.58
@papa.and.mimis.country.life.58 3 года назад
Jules: “I can’t even think of ways to help this.” 😂 😂 😂 Thank you for showing the ‘fails’! Keeping it real….
@steveboverie9432
@steveboverie9432 3 года назад
My mother made a birthday cake in the shape of a steamboat. The recipe called for potatoes added to the batter to help the cake firmer. I think it was two rectangular pans, first is used for the base the second cut in thirds and stacked up at one end of the cake. The frosting was white and the port holes were Life Savers candy there were other bits of candy used for different parts. I do not remember how the paddle wheel or smoke stacks were made. The cake itself was just denser but tasted good.
@laurelg178
@laurelg178 3 года назад
Perhaps in 1831, it may have been a treat - if you had no other food available to eat. 🤣 It was interesting, and I appreciate you experimenting with these old recipes.
@larsen8059
@larsen8059 Год назад
I LOVE that you're not shy about whistle -blowing the 'myths'...don't change, Glen. Unearthing truth is important. I laughed out loud when you stared into the camera while chewing your first bite! Savory vs. sweet is pretty vital in this one, I think! The idea of a potato custard was intriguing, but...? Historical context is probably an important factor here. Our 21st century tastes are just confounded.
@1One2Three5Eight13
@1One2Three5Eight13 11 месяцев назад
Glen, I wanted to say, I always love your very Canadian hats.
@griffsimcox9459
@griffsimcox9459 3 года назад
as i was was watching you mix everything together i though "huh no salt? no butter? that's gonna be bland :)
@hannakinn
@hannakinn 3 года назад
The addition of butter would've helped a lot!
@smwillia
@smwillia 3 года назад
No nutmeg (considering the time period).
@chucklitka2503
@chucklitka2503 3 года назад
All these old recipes remind us how lucky we are to be living and eating today, with all our choices and seasonings.
@kurtisburtis
@kurtisburtis 3 года назад
Love the subtle flex of having *Culinary Landmarks* on your bench ...
@stuartt455
@stuartt455 3 года назад
When even Julie can't think of ways to improve it you know it's not great 😄.
@robmaxwell189
@robmaxwell189 3 года назад
I love the fact that you don't show only the successes or Thumbs Up recipes.
@carolelliott9150
@carolelliott9150 3 года назад
Leave out sugar and add herbs for savoury
@Jeffffrey0902
@Jeffffrey0902 3 года назад
And better yet, bacon.
@octacilioalvares5879
@octacilioalvares5879 3 года назад
Glen! You should make an one hour long episode just talking about those old cookbooks without even cooking! Cheers
@kippen64
@kippen64 3 года назад
'The Cook Not Mad' is my favourite book title.
@ubombogirl
@ubombogirl 3 года назад
when julie says she cannot even think of anything that could help this...it must be pretty bad! hahaha
@hecate235
@hecate235 3 года назад
I really do hope you have all those wonderful old cookbooks in a fire proof room and well insured. My collection only goes back to 1910. Well done.
@yellodragon
@yellodragon 3 года назад
Best reaction ever! Just "No".
@dungeonseeker3087
@dungeonseeker3087 3 года назад
Blackcurrants are one of my favourite fruits, I absolutely adore blackcurrant charlotte with barely any sugar in the fruit so it makes your mouth pukker as you eat it 😋 Also I'm surprised Jules didn't already know but pudding in English can mean just about anything.
@Kcd16
@Kcd16 3 года назад
I once added too much salt to a pot of mashed potatoes and I tried using some sugar to offset the salty flavor, didn’t work. It seems hat some recipes of way back when only worked back then. Keep up the good work Glen.
@balthizarlucienclan
@balthizarlucienclan 3 года назад
I wish we had gotten more have a description of its flavor. Something tells me there is probably an easier way to make it taste good but with very little information on what it taste like it’s hard to judge from The other side of the screen. The recipe called for 2 ounces of sugar… May be using a brown sugar and a little more of it could improve the flavor. Perhaps using a whisk to more finely blend the potatoes? I’m sure there’s a way to save the recipe and make it something more palatable. Potatoes can be used and sweet recipes with great success. There is a candy native to Maine call a Needham which is mashed potatoes, powdered sugar, shredded coconut all mixed together.You press it into squares and dip it in dark chocolate. It’s one of my favorite candies.
@mynameis999
@mynameis999 3 года назад
There is a similar potato candy with peanut butter inside. The outside potato part is almost fudge like but with texture more like marzipan. I'm not sure of its origin but sounds similar.
@murlthomas2243
@murlthomas2243 3 года назад
Wow! That was the fastest, most decisive thumbs down yet!
@OptimusWombat
@OptimusWombat 3 года назад
For what reason?
@murlthomas2243
@murlthomas2243 3 года назад
@@OptimusWombat they didn’t like the recipe! They voted thumbs down. Both of them.
@ColinLeuze
@ColinLeuze 3 года назад
Love to see the book on the show again. It was one of my favorites from our Cookbook Club. Being from Watertown, I wonder how different the culture was from Canada? It had many french people in the area.
@joelmerrill
@joelmerrill 3 года назад
That's one thing I like about your videos. You're honest about how thinks taste.
@LindaM2005
@LindaM2005 3 года назад
You know, it might make an interesting show to do those different gingerbread recipes on the facing page around Thanksgiving or Christmas.
@ubombogirl
@ubombogirl 3 года назад
i was looking at those as well...i LOVE gingerbread!
@LindaM2005
@LindaM2005 3 года назад
@@ubombogirl Me too. I'm especially curious about what they call "hard" versus "soft" gingerbread.
@ubombogirl
@ubombogirl 3 года назад
@@LindaM2005 yup...one needs some gifting to interpret these really old recipes for sure! lol...glad glen is willing to do that!
@vickiekostecki
@vickiekostecki 3 года назад
That "hard" gingerbread - 1 teacup of ginger. I don't care about all the semantics of what a teacup is - that's a lot of ginger.
@andrewbuckley9180
@andrewbuckley9180 3 года назад
Tried this potato, eggs and milk thing with cheese and it comes out ok, probably by pure luck. Seems like a sweet version which reminds me of the time I made lamb crumble with packet crumble. I have not yet lived that down - it was 15 years ago.
@ArcticSilverFox1
@ArcticSilverFox1 3 года назад
Copyrights are good for 30 years if I'm not mistaken. You should consider converting these ancient cook books to PDF since their copyrights have most definitely expired by now and a lot of people who don't have access to these books would be able to benefit from them.
@MikeKolcun
@MikeKolcun 3 года назад
So much work!!
@JerryB507
@JerryB507 3 года назад
Many Universities have already undertaken the task. "The Cook Not Mad or Rational Cookery" is available here: d.lib.msu.edu/islandora/search/%22The%20cook%20not%20mad%2C%20or%2C%20Rational%20cookery%22?type=dismax&f[0]=PID:*\:*&keyword=%22The%20cook%20not%20mad,%20or,%20Rational%20cookery%22&selected=All
@bigDbigDbigD
@bigDbigDbigD 3 года назад
I really like the way the results are presented even if the reciepe in panned.
@maryellenclouston4790
@maryellenclouston4790 3 года назад
Probably why not many copies of the cookbook still around 😂. Love how Jules says I don’t know you could even save it….lol
@rm6176
@rm6176 3 года назад
I think adding a pinch of salt might have helped.
@wendysumner8899
@wendysumner8899 3 года назад
LOL!! Love the look on your faces!!! Yeah...big NO!!! Can't win 'em all!! Happy Sunday!!
@laurac.b.devlin8605
@laurac.b.devlin8605 3 года назад
always good to be with you and julie. always glad to see you glen
@johnnygalt5867
@johnnygalt5867 3 года назад
“There are two ‘E’s’ at the end of ‘Potatoe’” - Dan Quayle
@michaelstevens1027
@michaelstevens1027 3 года назад
Best “Murphy Brown” episode ever was a dump truck load of potatoes in his driveway!
@gabriellew6467
@gabriellew6467 6 месяцев назад
A motto to be bandied about : The Cook Not Mad T shirts, aprons, napkins (serviettes) to be emblazoned with it. Fortified thusly, go forth and experiment, improvise and create! 😊
@hoilst265
@hoilst265 3 года назад
I appreciate the true history behind the cookbook. Cultural cringe is problem - especially in Australian publishing - in both Australia and Canada.
@PrinceKaladin
@PrinceKaladin 3 года назад
I'd love to see this recipe tried with beets. It definitely sounds interesting
@74jtoon
@74jtoon 3 года назад
Zero salt in the recipe is probably the first issue to remedy.
@BlackoutCreature
@BlackoutCreature 3 года назад
I mean, this is obviously meant to be a sweet dish, so I'm not sure how adding salt would help. It seems like there's only two ways to go with attempting to rehabilitate this. First is to add a lot more sugar and probably switch to like a sweet potato and make it into some kind of modified sweet potato casserole. The second would be to cut out the sugar entirely and instead mix in some cheese and chopped veggies (and yes, a little salt) and go for like a savory potato casserole.
@Goon-124
@Goon-124 3 года назад
I'd still fully load it as I do with mashed: some cheddar, bacon, green onion, cajun seasoning, maybe some chili crisp
@11679MRT
@11679MRT 3 года назад
"...no..." lol
@andycrawford85
@andycrawford85 3 года назад
What is the first canadian cook book anyways? Written and published in Canada with canadian recipes?
@PrettyGoodSamuel
@PrettyGoodSamuel 3 года назад
"...no." 🤣🤣
@johnbloodworthiii6464
@johnbloodworthiii6464 3 года назад
Nutmeg Glen. Would be fun to see Jon Townsend do this as a boiled pudding.
@richardherbst8081
@richardherbst8081 3 года назад
The flavors and sweetness that we have in this time would have knocked the socks off of the poor souls back then that may have thought potatoes were "spicy". They ate beige/ bland foods back then.
@loopylou5841
@loopylou5841 3 года назад
Please please choose a good one next week. I have added mash potato to a chocolate cake which was fine. But I think we are due a winner Glen
@DuelScreen
@DuelScreen 3 года назад
"Not a winner. No." LOL!
@gjprieur7744
@gjprieur7744 3 года назад
LOL..a fail ! I agree with Mr. Grotto LOL ...Jules is very clear "NO"...but its American so we're good here.
@Linda-n5b
@Linda-n5b Месяц назад
Maybe it’s like an album you buy the whole book for one recipe. Now you must find that one good recipe .
@bdavis7801
@bdavis7801 3 года назад
Your reaction is priceless! 😂
@michaelstevens1027
@michaelstevens1027 3 года назад
I hope you have a couple of backyard chickens to feed the “fails” to!
@kennethstevenson4817
@kennethstevenson4817 3 года назад
My grandmother is from the age you didn't waste any thing would use leftover baked potatoes, only difference was she added vanilla and it was pretty good.
@joantrotter3005
@joantrotter3005 3 года назад
Any spices or fruit?
@kennethstevenson4817
@kennethstevenson4817 3 года назад
@@joantrotter3005 The only spice would detect, would have been nutmeg. No fruit. Of course I would sometimes crumble my horded oatmeal raisin cookies it sometimes.
@fionaedge5332
@fionaedge5332 3 года назад
I find this funny, as I made mashed potato sultana cake on the weekend. Which was good, and potatoes kept it from drying out, you couldn't tell potato was inside.
@kenmore01
@kenmore01 3 года назад
I understand the concept of "no saving it", but no salt?
@jdstreeter
@jdstreeter 3 года назад
I think you are developing a theme- back in the “olden” days they did not have sugar in *everything* so any flavor was big flavor.
@a.kasper8596
@a.kasper8596 3 года назад
"It's a custard!! It's a potato custard!!!!" *seconds later*: "no."
@billinboots
@billinboots 3 года назад
Maybe some cinnamon and or nutmeg...
@jandavis1523
@jandavis1523 3 года назад
After the *look*, I was waiting for the “No.” 😉
@alexinnewwest1860
@alexinnewwest1860 3 года назад
People say the past was the worst, I guess that also applies to recipes also!
@notold37
@notold37 3 года назад
Just a quick question Glen, do you bin the rest of it or do you eat it 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🦘🦘🦘🦘
@roflepiclol
@roflepiclol 3 года назад
Ohhhhhhhh my, a new video! :D
@alwilson6471
@alwilson6471 3 года назад
English is a crazy language? I have just one word - Aluminum
@ACKMINDSEYE
@ACKMINDSEYE 3 года назад
So what you’re saying is that you can “86” the No.86 recipe? HA! I’m here all week, folks. Try the veal. 😁👍🏼
@Beachdudeca
@Beachdudeca 3 года назад
Lol goes straight to the landfill
@stitchknit72
@stitchknit72 3 года назад
I don't have any documentary proof, but in my childhood, 1940s in the Midwest, potato was spelled potatoe. Then suddenly some years ago a VP spelled it with the e & he was ridiculed and mocked. I was a Spelling Bee Champion, so paying attention to spelling was my thing.
@nancylindsay4255
@nancylindsay4255 3 года назад
Time to give up on the custardy puddings, Glen.
@brenthooton3412
@brenthooton3412 3 года назад
It feels like I should be watching James Townsend pouring a "simple syrup" over this.
@carolelliott9150
@carolelliott9150 3 года назад
I have a copy of Cook not Mad published in 1984 by Ontario Ministry of Agriculture
@jaysmok2893
@jaysmok2893 3 года назад
Withoutthe sugar.and currants and with onion and some.carrots.and parsley and other herbs for colour and flavour it might be a good side dish
@lawyeredup
@lawyeredup 3 года назад
I intend to make it my own by adding such flavour enhancers as white rice, general purpose flour, baking soda and 4 tablespoons of msg.
@Linda-n5b
@Linda-n5b Месяц назад
I also like they tell you want else you can do to make it better and different
@jafizzle95
@jafizzle95 3 года назад
I bet it could be saved by using sweet potatoes instead. But I guess at that point, just make a sweet potato pie instead lol. Idk, but it was interesting to see such a decisive "no" from you both.
@Booger414
@Booger414 3 года назад
Not sure this would work, but since we have more of a sweet tooth in modern times, perhaps increase the sugar, also using a more flavorful sugar like a brown sugar might help.
@keetrandling4530
@keetrandling4530 3 года назад
Yeeaahhhh, not trying THAT one anytime too soon 😜 BUT, on page 29 there's both a Carrot and an Apple pudding I might try...
@mateoduquelondono
@mateoduquelondono 3 года назад
I would love to see a video of you Glen trying to improve this recipe and put it in 2021 standards. Hope that you'll find this suggestion fun and eventually make it. Love your videos!
@HuNt3R47
@HuNt3R47 3 года назад
I enjoy the vid Don't forget that our 21st century taste buds are completely different to the 19th century taste buds
@TK-qu1ht
@TK-qu1ht 3 года назад
I'd top with maple syrup 😎
@carolhaycock7419
@carolhaycock7419 3 года назад
Perhaps add some Maple Syrup,or cinnamon or ground nutmeg????? I know it is not in the recipe, but they would have had such things.
@melinnwflorida1762
@melinnwflorida1762 3 года назад
All it needs is to add butter, salt, some cream, eggs, cinnamon, nutmeg, brown sugar, and substitute sweet potatoes for the white potatoes! Or, put a small "x" by that recipe title and find something else to make. A good part of wisdom is learning what we don't want to do. :)
@annettemoyle6051
@annettemoyle6051 3 года назад
Currant small black grape Raisin and Sultanas are white grapes, here in the uk
@paulburrell3821
@paulburrell3821 3 года назад
Here in the UK you can purchase three types of dried grape at the supermarket: raisin, currant and sultana
@GlenAndFriendsCooking
@GlenAndFriendsCooking 3 года назад
Thanks for sharing! Pretty much the same here in Canada and the USA - it's just that most people don't realise that the dried currant is a raisin / dried grape.
@davedamron1876
@davedamron1876 3 года назад
Maybe the baking temperature was too low. At a higher temperature, like maybe 425, the sugar and potato starch might have caramelized more. It might have given it more of a custard texture, too. Some recipes are just bad, but this struck me more as a "...and then some went horribly wrong."
@brookelynn3567
@brookelynn3567 3 года назад
I think it would have been eaten with a meal, with salted meat, the currants remind me of the sweet relishes used for potatos. Terms like cake and pudding can be confusing to modern cooks,as they used to mean "a mass of flattened cooked food" either boiled, fried or baked. Not anything resembling a modern cake or even boiled puddings.
Далее
Пришёл к другу на ночёвку 😂
01:00
УДОЧКА ЗА 1$ VS 10$ VS 100$!
22:41
Просмотров 230 тыс.
Пришёл к другу на ночёвку 😂
01:00