yeri's voice in bad boy bridge actually added a diff vibe to it which i rlly enjoyed, i love her tone. and seulgi is doing amazing as always, and joy surprised me with her vocal ability. i remember she used to have a difficult time going falsetto but she's improved so much. irene also amazing, all the girls worked hard to make up for the lack of wendy. i hope wendy, gets well soon and comes back
@@chennie8811 SM has a habit of loving to stick to the "roles" they give members - would assume its simply because of that. Also iirc bridges are more often than not some of the hardest parts to sing? So it would make sense it goes to lead and main vocals, not "sub vocals"
Let’s appreciate Seulgi Let’s appreciate Irene Let’s appreciate Joy Let’s appreciate Yeri And of course, let’s appreciate Wendy for being back (Edit) Ok, I'm not a Wendy anti....I’m very happy she’s doing well again. The purpose of my comment is to equally appreciate the four girls who performed that day.
this shows how talented is Seulgi. Just imagine that she's the main dancer but yet she is the one who take the role as a main vocalist. Seulgi is really an all rounder in short an ACE .
@@hxcneeey3604 she can be good at rapping if she focuses on that like her part in happiness its just that if she raps too then others would have less lines
What a tough time for Seulgi, she has to be the main dancer and the main vocalist at the same time. But the members did really great covering her lines. So happy Wendy's really back and RV is coming back too.
Yeah. From the limited experience I have with Kpop though, it seems the higher register is preferred and Yeri's voice sounds the most beautiful to me in lower registers.
@@rev_exo_xo8259 I definitely couldn’t not compliment her. As someone who sings, I know how hard Wendy’s parts are. And Seulgi doing Red Flavor’s high notes, especially that being the 3rd song in a row, needs more praise u.u
When the other members did a really good job (especially Seulgi tho bc she originally had many lines already) but at the same time, you know Wendy’s voice is just irreplaceable.
Joy and Seulgi did a great job except for the very last part where Seulgi lost her breath a little... But given as a main dancer she dances and sings extra parts, it's awesome... Joy's voice is naturally suitable for high notes too... Joyyyyyyyyyyyie💚
"except for the last part where Seulgi lost her breath a little" have you tried dancing for 2-3 minutes straight while singing? This girl just did that and did it incredibly good while dancing pro. As a singer myself Im amazed actually
So you had to point out Seulgi's mistake even though she had to literally take over both the vocal and dance part. What about Joy? Was she perfect. Oh well you are a Joy stan, obviously you wouldn't want to talk about her mistakes.
where does she lose her breath and is completely normal rv is one of the few groups in kpop that really sings live without having a playback back because seulgi is the lead vocalist of the group and the main dancer of the group, it was perfect
This is why Seulgi is my bias. She did a great job, singing Wendy's line. Let's also appreciate all the members for doing such a good job, it may feel empty, and i know we all miss Wendy that time.
I think it helps that lots of RV songs have a part that one member does the first time and another member does the second time (e.g. the super high part in psycho) It means that one member can sing that part twice instead
If y'all ever doubted Seulgi's main vocal abilities, then see this ... I mean ofc Wendy is Wendy and she's a great main vocal but Seulgi covered the hardest parts of Wendy's lines ... I never see Seulgi as a lead vocalist, for me both Wendy and Seulgi are main vocals, ofc Wendy's vocals are something else but Seulgi is a great main vocal too !!
wendy has the only ability in the group to be the main vocalist yeri is the main rapper of the group irene is lead dancer and lead rapper sub v she sometimes works in the group joy is sub voc and seulgi is main dancer and lead vocalist if you look at it, seulgi has the most difficult position she is the lead singer and the main dancer both positions are clearly the most important wendy her main voice makes a difference, but perfumes and singing well seulgi is queen and always live never with playback❤️
@@seulmin2400 ofc Wendy is the main vocal for a reason, but there can be more than one main vocal in a group & I've read that Seulgi was to be the main vocal in her group but then Wendy joined & she became one and she deserves, but I was just saying that Seulgi also deserves that position (as well as main dancer). Obviously Wendy will be the MAIN main vocal, but Seulgi can be one more. Like in EXO there's Chen-Baek-Soo, all are main vocals but Chen is the MAIN main vocal. I hope I explained my point now :)
@@highcrackheadenergyremixes yes i agree both voices are strong only seulgi had proven in this performance that she can manage all points super super and that live dance sing visuel everything🙏
@@seulmin2400 Seulgi very much has the ability to be a main vocal. In any other group she would most definitely take that role but Wendy is just on a different level but Seulgi is still AMAZING
They can not be red Velvet without Wendy we need her like red is Wendy and velvet is seulgi joy Irene yeri and without Wendy they are not red velvet we need her god plz take care of Wendy plz make sure she stay with us plz god😢😔
For me, Joy can't only be a sub vocal, even SM and the group acknowledge that (her getting to sing a high note in umpah) but in ratio to seulgi ONLY being a lead vocal and Wendy being the main vocal it fits. Also I kind of love seulgi covering Wendy's pre chorus in psycho because 1. She is amazing for pulling that of but 2. You can hear her struggling to sing that high meaning Wendy is the only one of the group to pull of that part perfectly without even struggling a bit 🥰 I just love this group!!!
Wendy's line isn't just a lot but also very high and hard to sing. They seem exhausted covering Wendy, kuddos to them, especially Seulgi since she covered Wendy's psycho line, it was a different tone from her line
While i was watching these i feel the love of the girls on wendy even though i’m a fan and surely they miss wendy AND I MISS OT5 i hope wendy back soon GET WELL SOOON WENDY❤️🥺
they did a good job covering Wendy's part :) no need to fault on the other girls, they did their best to cover Wendy's parts. it's noticeable that they have different vocal techniques and i just noticed that's Wendy's parts can make u breathless.. like literally... she gets the parts that need sustained, belted notes and it takes good control to do that. I'm proud of the rv girls doing their bests. They're reliable :) But Wendy's parts are hers for a reason.
@@sooobrangdan I think the purpose of the comment above is to highlight Wendy's importance to the group, she's the backbone of the group and carries most all of the hardest part of their songs.
@@sooobrangdan Seulgi did her best (and so were the rest) but even she admitted she kinda strained her voice a bit while singing some of Wendy's lines so I wouldn't say she 'owned' them. They are all appreciated nonetheless because they are all important and irreplaceable.
they re just covering Wendy’s parts, not supplanting her. It also means they sing more than their original lines, so they can be tired with singing and dancing. besides, Wendy also cracks sometimes. I hope you respect their efforts.
I’m so proud of them, especially Seulgi. She really did a great job doing Wendy’s parts. Imagine doing her own high notes/ parts and some of Wendy’s high notes/ parts + being a great main dancer in all those three songs. So it’s really understandable that she was somehow tired because she became a main vocalist, lead vocalist, and a main dancer. Truly an ace. Her talents as an idol should be appreciated by many. And also Irene’s beautiful voice, Joy’s honey voice, and Yeri’s angelic voice. But ofcourse our Wendy’s powerful vocals is irreplaceable. So glad that she’s back.
Meskipun member lain ngecover dengan baik, tapi part Wendy punya nyawa tersendiri, warna dan daya tarik vokalnya adalah yang paling terasa berwarna, suaranya itu bisa berubah sesuai genre sedangkan saat yang lain mengcover namun menurutku tetap terasa celah kosongnya itu. Seulgi dan Joy memang bisa dan layak menjadi main vocal jika berada digrup yang lain, Irene dan Yeri juga mampu menyandang lead vocal dan rap jika digabung dengan grup lain, tapi Wendy terlalu sempurna, pengucapannya terdengar jernih dan lantang, dia juga bisa menyanyikan bagian rap, dance nya bagus dan itulah alasan mengapa aku merasa tetap ada celah yang kosong tadi.
They really done it perfectly look at Seulgi she did a great job covering Wendy's part... She already have the 2nd hardest part after wendy also she is the main dancer so she had to do really well in dancing but still she done well doing all the hardest parts and focusing in dancing in the same time
