2024 SAG Winner Reaction | Lily Gladstone WINS Big!!! 

Lily Gladstone’s win AND her acceptance speech were the highlights of the entire evening. I also loved Da’vine’s acceptance speech.

There is absolutely nothing shocking about Lily winning SAG, and she should be favored on Oscar Sunday. I'm genuinely confused how anyone can describe her win as shocking.

Lily’s performance reminded me of Luise Rainer in “The Good Earth”. All in the eyes, and beautiful facial expressions, conveying the deepest of emotions.

I loved Lily Gladstone performance, rooting for her in the Oscars to win. Or Sandra hula in anatomy of the fall which is underrated.

Hi Ryan, happy February to you. I got 4/5 categories correct. I went with Murphy because of the Oppenheimer express. The love for Oppenheimer is one of the strongest we have seen this century. It only really rivals EEAAO, Chicago, ROTK and Slumdog. It's the type of film, where people just check all the boxes. The only one I got wrong was Gladstone over Stone. I know you love your stats, and I got a good one for you. Since 2000, we have only seen three actresses win Best Actress without the most or tied for the most televised wins. They were Halle Berry, Olivia Colman, and Michelle Yeoh. Berry and Yeoh were both SAG winners and were seen as a milestone in color representation. Berry = first lead black woman. Yeoh = first Asian woman. Colman did not win the SAG, but she won BAFTA and most of the high end critics circle awards. Close was in a single nominee and didn't win many critics circle awards. When we look at Gladstone vs. Stone, we see that Gladstone has won about 24 awards to Stone's 18. To me, it feels like Gladstone is heading down the same trajectory as Berry and Yeoh. The only real difference is that BAFTA omission (I don't use the word snub). Yeoh and Berry were both up for the BAFTA. Only Berry was up for the BAFTA in the next calendar year. Are you leading toward Emma or Lily? Either way, the letters Stone will appear on the Oscar envelope.

thanks to Brian for the link that led me here :)*

Emma Stone is my favorite actress and she gave my favorite performance of the year. To be fair she gives my favorite performance of the year almost every year. Hence her being my favorite actress. So it would have been fun to see her get the recognition she absolutely deserves and get another oscar. But at the end of the day the oscars don't matter and I'll look forward to her next project: Kinds of Kindness (also still waiting for that Cruella sequel)

All 4 acting wins have been my favourite performances of the year & my picks in their categories from the beginning. Words can’t express how much I want Cillian Murphy to be an Oscar winner. His performance in Oppenheimer was extraordinary to me. I haven’t been that astonished by a performance in a long time. I’m so glad this is his year. 👏 Lily Gladstone was just so powerful to me in Killers. To stand amongst & outshine two of the biggest actors in Hollywood was refreshing. I know there are arguments she’s not lead. She’s not in it enough. I don’t agree. Lily has every right to be in her category. There is precedent to past winners. She has every right to win. And I hope she does take the Oscar. These two roles from Cillian & Lily feel like wins not only for them but for reserved, subtle, nuanced, internalised type of acting. It’s rare these kind performances win over the bigger, showier ones.

If I may add, for the Oscars formula, you should look at the differences in when SAG/BAFTA happens vs when the voting period for the Oscars begin and ends.

I predict these 4 will win the Oscars. And I do believe in one of your prediction criteria saying most recent wins before the Oscars will influence the voters.

Thanks Brian from The Awards Contender for sending me here. You're so good looking.

I gotta say it again, and maybe this is just me thinking crazy, but I thought Emma’s reaction seemed, fake, over the top and cringy, I don buy it at all, again this is just me I could be wrong.

I’m glad Oppenheimer won big!!! It’s my favorite movie of 2023!!! I’m rooting for it at the Oscars!!!

I think this award season is pretty much over now. I think Actress is the only major ambiguity, I think in same way as Bong Joon Ho winning over Tarrantino & Mendes for Director because of split votes Heuller could pull a Marisa Tomei style upset & win for Anatomy

It's so cool you were actually there, lucky!

Late to the party, but actor was not a close race at all, cca gave the illusion it was, but that is not an industry award. And following this year, the industry were fully behind Cillian and Oppenheimer. And with Universal and their behemoth marketing campaign, giving Paul Giamatti all this false hope was stupid.

An oscar, Sag and golden globe -- all came lily's way largely because they had to ensure someone from the native american community wins these accolades. Had this movie not been based on one of the native American tribes and she did not belong to the same tribe, she had no chance to win. And, as everyone's saying, this is probably her first and last time winning these big awards. Hard for her to win anything again! She cannot do some regular movie and win big! Her acting skills are not above par!

Davine role in.the holdovers is so small. I wanted more of her

The way barbie is a non.event at these awards shows. The hype around barbie has died

Lily Gladstone would win because the actors branch want some original work. Emma Stone's,s Poor Things mannerisms is somewhat similar to Olivia Coleman in The Favourite. And Emma Stone was in that show too. Plus she has won an Oscar before.

EEAAO was a stronger swipe last year, only by Brendan Fraser didn’t the big 5 and the bigger 8 hahahaha for calling it someway

Emma does nt need more awards...and other actors do

SAG and Oscar rarely go 4 for 4. One of the SAG winners will lose.

I'm sorry but after watching Emma Stone in Poor Things, Lily's performance feels so so inferior. And can we put an end to this 'she's too young to win 2 nd oscar' shit? When you give a performance like Bella Baxter, you are bound to win everything. That transformation and growth. I haven't seen in a while from an actress. Fuck Gladstone', give Emma the Oscar is my opinion. Lily is just very lucky. She has Scorsese and DiCaprio, 2 biggest names in the industry, behind her campaigning. That's how in the first place she got the lead actress thing. She's clearly supporting and no matter how good she is, people need to own up to it. But lately Oscar has been giving narratives win more than talent. So yeah, maybe they will award Gladstone but truly, if we are talking talented performances it's between 3 to me: Stone Huller and Lee( Lee's subtle performance was way more impactful and humane to me than Gladstone. Just because Song is new and upcoming, Lee didn't get much recognition this year. But in true sense, her performance in Past Lives was a tour de force. And also Sandra Huller, I'm so happy. She also gave a breathtaking performance. Unfortunately, talents have to see narratives win.)

I got ALL the predictions correct, and I was rooting for all of them! I wanted Oppenheimer to win big because it’s my favorite movie of the year, and I wanted Lily Gladstone to win because Emma Stone had already won for the amazing movie La La land. Also, Gladstone is the first Native American to win that award. *Keep in mind, I have not seen Poor Things or Killers of the Flower Moon yet…. They are on my watchlist.

I am happy if Oppenheimer wins it all.

I almost vomited when I find out, that Emma lost. Unbelievable 😢 she nominated for all major award, but other two contenders not nominated for Bafta or not nominated for Sag. I think not having Sandra Huller affected race, she might splits some votes, and eventually Emma would’ve have been winner,but unfortunately, believe Emma was in fact close, but other 3 nominees not really strong enough for win. So it was Emma vs Lily I’m in depression whole day 😢

Since 2002, every actor who had won BAFTA and SAG went on to win the Oscar BUT we still have the earlier cases. Russell Crowe won both and still lost the Oscar. Plus, Daniel Day-Lewis won both in 2003 and lost the Oscar. So there's still hope for Giamatti.

PG won the CC because 90% of them loved PG and that’s a fact

Emma stone is acting in losing

Emma is an actress, I do not give Emma credit for being a good sport. Lily should not win based solely on narrative, that is insulting. Neither should she win because Emma is too young or has won one before. Emma gave the best performance IMO and should win. Lily can win for a more deserving role where she actually leads the movie!

Lily!

SAG award to Cillian is probably the end of great acting period