Tru. XD But still doesn't match up the story sadly. Thing is, people do a lot of STUPID shit during puberty and they RARELY stay with the ones they fell for at that age, since back then they were overflowing with hormones. So one might as well marry someone while fucking drunk, it makes no difference XD
Maybe not since he's a good friend and probably knew Ron was into her or maybe since he was in puberty he was too stupid to see Hermoine that way because they were just "friends" and it would've felt weird. Once you grow up and mature, you realize that doesn't fucking matter. I honestly have no idea where Hermoine's affections for Ron came from tho.
Hermione Granger as a response to your channel description: yes, seeing as you gave the WRONG FRICKING TITLE! It’s ‘Hogwarts: A History’ not ‘Hogwarts history’.
Suzanna Leila.Spiegel True, but she could still have given him a love potion. Then when he was freed from it's influence he realised that he was trapped and thought "Fuck it."
And he was debating in the books. In under a love potion he wouldn't of cared. Also before in the books Ginny didn't give him anything before they kissed in No.6
techninicaly, If Dumbledore was Ron, he couldn't be gay, and it is confirmed that Dumbledore is homosexual, and ron was crazy for girls, I guess ronbledore failed
+EllaTheHufflepuffMudblood Because, as said in the last book: "Sometimes I've thought, when I've been a bit hacked off,he was having a laugh or - or he just wanted to make it more difficult. But I don't think so, not any more. He knew what he was doing when he gave me the Deluminator, didn't he? He - well," Ron's ears turned bright red and he became engrossed in a tuft of grass at his feet, which he prodded with his toe, "he must've known I'd run out on you." "No," Harry corrected him. "He must've known you'd always want to come back."
Just like we know that Dumbledore has a brother and Sister.. And we saw his brother still alive in the last movie.. To even ignore that Dumbledore has a fully written back story with which is the main focus of the new "fantastic beasts and where to find them" series.. It could have had something to it if the theory was written before the Goblet of Fire or something
wtf why would Dumbledore even be gay?!?! why do people make up stories and theories that don't make sence? I mean it's up to JK to write whatever she wants and these things aren't something that came up on her mind.... tbh people should just accept the story the way it is
Actually, they didnt change Buckbeak death, he never died in the first place. Noone ever sees his execution, they just hear the sound of the axe, that is because the executioner hits a pumpkin with it when he sees the Griph was released. JK 1 - curse child 0.
Yes, that is an opinion of an old teacher from completely different world, who was looking at them for a day, during a situation when Petunias sister died.
Petr Maly How would they have known Lilly died that fast? She only died the night before and muggle news isn't able to travel that fast back then. Also, Vernon acts cheerily and unlike someone died.
Contrary to popular belief, people in the 1980's didn't use only pigeons to deliver messages, even though it sounds like such a high-tech, people had telephones, the ministry of magic has at least 500 spare employees (as we learn, these people were building the stadium, while the ministry operated normally, maybe they just hired them temporarily, but still, hundreds of people work in the ministry full time), even though there is around 2000-3000 wizards and witches in Britain (Yes, Rowling is labour supporter and this is probably the amount of government bureaucrats she thinks is best). If there was any rule about notifying close family, than the news would come earlier, than after one teacher had whole day to uselessly watch a muggle house the same day dark lord suspiciously disappeared, headmaster of the only school and most powerful wizard in living memory would make time to personally come across the entire island and even managed to organise groundskeeper to take his motorbike, pick up the baby and make a delivery.
He's the potions teacher, he could've easily made a potion to make him able to be in sunlight (like he made those potions for Remus so he wouldn't turn into a werewolf)
I agree, except for Snape being a vampire. Except if, whatever the snake's name is, poison could effect vampires. Then there wasn't really any point to the theory. But people can believe what they want to believe. (Or the whole Sirius and Remus shipping thing(hey deserved better than that)) *barfs off side of bed*
The Anime Theorist Personally, I really like cursed child - I wonder what you disliked about it. Adrian SH I like Hufflepuff - they get as much hate as my house. And,were I not a Slytherin, I'd probably be Hufflepuff, according to non-Pottermore tests. I'm also okay with Ravenclaws, though they can be quite annoying. Honestly, the only house I dislike is Gryffindor - most of them are arrogant arses. Jamie Kincaid What use is Quidditch talent? Especially when you can use Incendio to cremate your foes. Want to try?
She sometimes tweets the answers, but a lot of them are not clear. For example, there was one theory called "Dumbledore's Horcrux is Fawkes" and Rowling tweeted, "It disappoints me to see how many people approve this theory" which makes it seems that Rowling rejected the theory, but one could argue that Rowling was surprised to see how long it took for them to guess it.
It wasn't the horcrux that caused the Dursleys to be horrible to Harry though. Before Harry was left on their front porch, Dudley kicked his mother up the street screaming for streets. Vernon Dursley wanted to give people wearing robes a piece of his mind for not being 'normal'. The Dursleys were already unpleasant from the moment we met them, and it just increased through the years as Harry's accidental magic outbursts increased. It wasn't the Horcrux that made them so horrible to Harry, it's because of Harry's magic or as Vernon called it his 'freakishness'.
And also Hogwarts has a real big problem if (no offense to anyone) Ravenclaws are the smart ones and their house animal is an eagle XD I mean srsly RAVEN is literally in the name XD lol but no eagle was chosen
Smiley Gamer1337 yo what the heck RUDE. No wonder ur slytherin. And Ravenclaws do study because they're smart. And actually I rarely study and I have straight A's.
I'm sorry to inform you, but Slytherin is the best house. We're true, determined, cunning, and ambitious. Not to mention that Merlin himself was sorted into Slytherin. True we've had some ups and downs with Voldemort and Bellatrix Lestrange and others, but we've made up with Regulus Black, Horace Slughorn, Andromeda Tonks, Narcissa Malfoy, Severus Snape, and Merlin the Great
A lot of people are unsure as to which house they are in. Pottermore.com has the official sorting hat quiz. HOWEVER, the thing with that is...it randomly picks a handful of questions. So your first time you might get more questions in which your answers lean towards Ravenclaw (for example). But then next time you take it, more of the questions might lean toward your Hufflepuff/Gryffindor/Slytherin answers. I suggest this: www.gotoquiz.com/pottermore_sorting_quiz_all_possible_question. It's EVERY Pottermore question, so you can see what you would truly be. Then, after you find out where you truly belong, go to Pottermore and answer all the questions as that house would, so you can be that house officially. And for those that would like to see which Ilvermorny house they truly belong to, here: www.gotoquiz.com/complete_pottermore_ilvermorny_sorting ~Mike
Petunias was viciously jealous of Lily. Their parents favored Lily because she was the witch in the family, thus any of Petunia's achievements were deemed essentially worthless. On Pottermore, it points out that Petunia sent Dumbledore letters for YEARS begging to attend Hogwarts with her sister, but Dumbledore couldn't allow a Muggle to attend. :(
I don't think the theory is necessarily down the drain. They certainly became more horrible when Harry came to live with them. And I don't think Petunia really hated Lily, I think she resented her because she lost her best friend when Lily was accepted to Hogwarts. However..... Harry should have made everyone in proximity to him miserable since he was a horcrux. Maybe there's something insulating to the horcrux when it is present in a human rather than an object?
If you read the books, you would notice how everytime Harry "thinks" about Ginny it's in very positive associations, so he definitely did like her before. (Doesn't he also get super jealous when she's with other guys?) And THEN there's girl who's badass, plays the same sports as him just as passionately and is witty and intelligent - so why wouldn't he fall for her?
The love potion theory is not true.Harry still missed Ginny during the horcrux hunt when she was not there with him for a long time.Plus, you need to give the person love potion to make them love you.
Here's something that's been bothering me. In POA Hermione said that a werewolf will only respond to the call of it's own kind. Then she howls and Prof. Lupin as a werewolf runs to her. Does Hermione have werewolf ancestry?
For Hagrid's patronous theory. You don't need a Happy memory you just need a strong memory as we saw in the prisoner of Azkaban. Harry told Remus it wasn't necessarily a happy memory, just a strong one
One more thing, Rowling even said that Hermione was never meant to be Harry's love interest, just to be a great friend to prove that girls just aren't there to be love interests to the main character
Luckily shes the author and can make that statement since what she wrote was so all over the damned place that it left most readers completely baffled in relation to Harry/Ginny - Ron/Hermoine relationships. Looking at what was written the interactions tell a different story for the most part. then a blind side slap to the head and relations ships flip the hell out. No, its good good thing Rowling clarified that because her story telling failed to produce a convincing argument.
Sarah Plumer if anything Rowling originally wanted Hermione and Draco to fall for each other but she then decided not to do that because it was to confusing for the story and wouldn't work
MysticWaters if that's true, I still think Draco and Hermione is real, because it's known that people bully people they like, or get known to like. ... Yeah :)
I totally agree with you, it does not make any sense unless Neville and Harry are acually very close relatives (Witch is posdible considering their family story, that every pureblood is related and how linked the two boys are)
23 doesn't make sense because why didn't his friends turn on him 22. ron can't be dumbledore because Rowling confirmed Dumbledore is gay #RavenclawAndPround
If Dumbledore went back in time and posed as Ron, then Ron would be dead and he would have never married Hermoine, Boi are we forgetting that Dumbledore died?
Yeah and what about Hermione? I mean she is a muggle born, non magical parents and Ron hated Harry in the deadly hallows with the locket... so yeah the Dursleys are only bad people
As a Slytherin I would just like to say that not ALL Slytherins are evil, remember Snape? He turned out to be a great dude in the end. I find it offensive that you would just assume that about other houses you stupid mudbl-- SQUIB!
no, he did not turn out to be a great person at all. he was a terrible person. . he looked out for harry because he was in love wit hhis mom, sure, but he was by no means a good person.
Jedidiah Wingard I agree. On every single one of the theories, I agreed with the Ravenclaw. Except for the 9th theory. Yeah, Harry pulled the sword out of the sorting hat, but so did Nevel!
Buckbeak never died in Prisoner of Azkaban, we just assume he did but no one see him die or see his corpse afterward. This allows Hermione and Harry to "save him".
SlyPearTree actually, you can hear the axe going down to hit him, and Harry and Hermione and Ron see it, we just don't because it would mess it up a bit I think.
Maliha Parikh I've seen these movies thousands of times and the first time he does hit him, you can tell because Hermione hides her face in Harry's chest.
list25 the uses the symbol the way movies portray it, which is different from the way the books describe it because of the eagle and the colors, AND the the way that you get into the ravenclaw common room is with an EAGLE shaped knocker.
Nah. It def hit the fence. If you have one of the original Prisoner of Azkaban books on page 402, lines 12-13 it says: "There was a swishing noise, and the thud of an axe. The executioner seemed to have swing it into the fence in anger." I really don't think you can argue with this.
The problems with the Dumbledore being Ron theory: He marries Hermione in the end; Rowling has revealed that Dumbledore is actually gay. Ron has a completely different family than Dumbledore. Ron has a completely different backstory than Dumbledore. Ron's a ginger, though I guess Albus' hear could have changed with this age. This might somehow be explained in the theory, but I doubt it can do that without it being too far fetched.
Dumbledore was born long before the events of Harry Potter.. There even is a movie about it which is going to expand about his story with Grindelwald.. So there is a lot more wrong with that theory about him being ron than just Dumbledore being gay and ron not.. One of the biggest problem for me is that Dumbledore has a detailed backstory to him.. If you want to make that theory you first have to ignore or change his entire family and backstory
In the cursed child, they don't use polyjuice potion to turn into Voldemort, they transfigure into him, Hermione transfigures Harry. Also, it's not necessary to use hair to make polyjuice potion, remember Hermione said in the Chamber of Secrets that you have to use some of any body part of the person you want to become and then Ron said that he's definitely not drinking some of Crabbe's toenails. So people can use Voldmort's toenails to make polyjuice potion to transform into him
One thing , they didn't use polyjuice potion to transform to Voldermort , they somehow transfigured and became him. They basically made polyjuice potion useless.
About theory #10, and the improbability of it, specifically that Remus married Tonks, I have a story. My father told me a story about one of his father's colleagues. My Nanna met the colleague and when she came home she instantly said, "He's gay." No one believed her because he was married and with about two or three children. Some years later, my Nonno, my dad's father, came home and said that his colleague went on a "business trip" with his "friend" and it had been confirmed my Nonno's colleague was, in fact, gay. My Nanna sipped her tea and said, "That's old news. Tell me something I don't know." Gay people can try to look and act straight so hard, they do that. But, Tonks was awesome, so Remus could've been bisexual.
Marta Nuñez I have a theory that threads off this and the one talked about in the video. I believe that Remus and Sirius indeed we're together during part of their Hogwarts careers however, after they graduate the war wears on their relationship. They become suspicious of each other and eventually have a falling out. By the time Remus discovers Sirius is innocent in PoA they are no longer able to have the trust in each other to fully return their relationship to its former glory, they both are happy remaining as best friends. Over the course of the rest of the books Remus develops feelings for Tonks, I also believe he told Sirius about this before he died and that it was supported. After Sirius dies Remus decides he doesn't want to let war take another person he loves away from him and pursues his feelings for Tonks
Am I the only person who knows that HARRY DID NOT DIE! The piece of Voldemort in him was what had died. And anyways, didn't Harry loose the Resurrection Stone in the woods before the final battle?
doesnt matter if they are going by the prophecy it clearly states one must kill the other since harry didn't die nothing can kill him not even himself?
I think Harry technically DID die but he hadn't "boarded the train on" as J.K Rowling put it. I don't agree with that theory but Harry was still the master of all the 3 hallows. He didn't have to be in possession of the hallows, but the rightful owner. Harry was still the master of the wand, although he wasn't using it. That means he was still the owner is the stone.
Neither can live while the other survives. That means neither can truly live, like Harry is'nt really his own person. When Voldmort dies Harry is somewhat set free but to me that doesn't have to do with immortality
OMG FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE REALIZES THAT HARRY POTTER AND VOLDEMORT ARE RELATED! Omg my 4th grade teacher claims to be a potter head and then I tell her that they're related...she has her mind blown
you guys do realise that the polyjuice poten only needs a bit of the person there turning into so they could use old Voldys toe nails or even a bit of blood for it to work.....
Sky wilson It's much harder to get those things than a stand of hair. He makes it much more difficult, if not impossible, to make polyjuice potion with his DNA. I mean, easy to pluck a hair... Cut off a bit of toenail or draw blood from the Dark Lord? That's pretty much a death wish.
for the cannabalism theory my conspiracy is that voldy doesn't have a nose because, while making a horcrux, he tried to make himself a duplicat. so like a second voldemort, but a horcrux version. one that was intimidating enough to look unbeatable, but when defeated it was only a horcrux, a fragment of voldemorts soul. since he couldn't just use his hair to make a polyjuice potion because he has no hair, he legitimately had to consume the flesh and blood of his victim, being himself. so my theory is voldemort physically ate his own nose.
Will you please quit it with the whole "Snape's a vampire " thing? I mean if you look at Ms.Rowling's twitter she confirmed several times that SNAPE IS NOT A VAMPIRE!
The problem with the Dursley/horcrux theory is it was made quite clear at the very beginning of the story, the hatefulness that they had against the Potter's and "their kind" before Harry even shows up as a baby.
Being around a horcrux will bring out the bad side in you, therefore if you are already bad, you'll become worse. So, yes, that theory does make sense. If you pay attention, Ron was already jealous of Harry Potter when he see him and Hermione walking together, it's just that he didn't say anything until he wore that necklace for too long.
@Zoe L Well yeah you could change a bit about the rule to make the theory more legit. But then again it probably doesn't matter and I'm probably wrong. Though this is probably a plot hole, for Harry is a Horcrux meaning it would make sense for people around him being annoyed by his presence. J.K just didn't think too much about that.
Books people! a lot of these theories were explained in the books. Such as The one with crookshanks and Sirius, at first crookshanks did not trust Sirius dog form but then Sirius made crookshanks trust him and communicated with crookshanks and ask to bring Petigrew to him. ( Sirius explained to Ron Harry and Hermione in the Shrieking Shack )
Ron can't be Dumbledore. For one, he married Hermione. Also what about Ariana Dumbledore? Is that supposed to be Ginny or something... Ariana died when she was 14. Ginny marries Harry and they have kids. Makes no sense. Also HARRY DOES NOT BELONG WITH HERMIONE. RON AND HERMIONE WERE MEANT TO BE TOGETHER.
That's cute that he could have been the Potter's cat. Also, we KNOW he is a cat because there info confirming he is a Kneazle cross-breed. Possibly one of Mrs. Figg's.
Sakiko Senpai they didnt need to xd Rowling said Sirius doesnt like dudes so the theory is debunked they just took it on Lupin to make a joke about him marrying Thonks
Carlos Meza no shit sherlock. I could've thought of a better joke though ;) for example: - Tonks is Sirius' cousin and she reminds Remus so much of him - the invisibilty cloak only works on bisexuals - Remus' favourite song is NSYNC's "bi bi bi" the list goes on and on :3
Thank you! Not that I believe that theory in the slightest, but that would have been the reasonable answer, it's like they forgot that a man can be something else than just straight or gay XD
I Have a Theory About Who are represented as the brothers in Deathly Hallows. Elder Brother is Albus Dumbledore. There are points that favours it. Initially he also craved the power of Elder Wand when He was with greindalward. He was also defeated by Draco Malfoy when he was cursed by the ring and also poisoned due to retrieval of Slytherin Locket quiet similar to Elder Brother. 2nd Brother is Severus Snape no doubt about it. 3rd Brother is Lily James Potter. Points favouring are that first she had a choice whether to die or not and second she died so as to provide Harry Potter Protection Quiet similar to 3rd Brother. And Last The Death Is none Other than Harry Potter. Points favouring towards it are First Each Brother that is Albus Dumbledore, Severus Snape and Lily Potter died in front of Him and second Harry was the only one who had all the 3 Deathly Hallows around Him when he goes to Lord Voldemort and mind you only a true heir of Ignotus peverell can use power of Invisibility Clock and at that same time He was the Master Of Elder Wand.
+the reason they could prevent the execution without consequences is because it didn't change anything. Don't know about the paradoxes and shit tho.. but since travelling back in time for a reason itself is a paradox as well so whatever
there are two general concepts of time traveling, one where you change the past and one where you only ensure that what happened will really happen. Harry saw himself "his future self in the past" even before he found out about time-turner. so no, in no version did the hippogriff die. it is the same concept as the one in got - the whole hold the door thing
Mara Schimmel my only question about Ronbledore is if it were true, what about Ariana and Dumbledore's brother? Would they be Ginny and George or one of Ron's other brothers? Dumbledore's past doesn't really parallel to Ron's past well enough. Right?
+R Whites Do you call yourself a HP fan? You can't even spell Dumbledore correctly. You spelled it "Dumbledoor". You're lucky you didn't get yelled at by a more hardcore fan.
I'm always in a different house every time I take the quizzes, bleh -.- Also, with all those special effects, the budget for this episode definitely went into the tens of dollars. Calm down lads, you don't want to go bankrupt =P
If you happen to already have after effects, then you don't need to spend a ton of money on the special effects. I already have after effects and can produce some amazing effects without having to pay any extra.
