Zabardast, I can't believe how Jawed sb is speaking non stop. It looks like he wrote notes and giving a speech. Hats off to his intellectual power. Alas, Muslim world can't understand him ..... but people will remember him for centuries
Thts wht attracted me to him.. i was lost and was a muslim jst by name. Bt his arguments got me thinking and nw i am on the journey to obeying my creator.. its jst ming boggling hw can ppl after all these facts deny Allah. I find him as the greatest scholar of our time. I hve nvr seen any scholar hving debates with counter Questiom and still being flawless.
You need a specific attributes and behaviour of reflection and Cognitive (علمی رویہ ) behavior to understand him. Unfortunately majority are lacking that behaviour. That lacking is a big hurdle towards to understand Quran.
Sir I think no one in this world right now can explain this topic in such a discipline way of speaking that you have done. Your are unique person in this world right now. I pray and hope Allah Pak give you long healthy life with peace and happiness. Ameen
It is so easy to ask questions . But it is not easy to answer questions. Ghamdi is Superb to answer their questions. These young people appear as kids in front of hamdi in spite of their claim of having higher qualification.
یہ چند اصطلاحات کا استعمال کرنا جو کہ عوام کے لیے اجنبی ہیں، لوگوں پر اثر رکھتا ہے 😂 یہ بنیادی منطق یا فلسفے کا متعلم با آسانی کر سکتا ہے ۔ معترض کوئی ہم جیسے ہوتے تو کچھ اور بات ہوتی🙏
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
beautiful questions.... philosophical questions.... never thought i would see them asked to an islamic scholar ... and he is giving a very philosophical answer i wish Islam had gone this way ... the philosophical way .....
by the way the question the Spectacled person is asking is .... does the simulation theory of the existence of universe hold any water .... according to Islam .... a very good question
@@protonx80 beautiful questions for only morons with small brain . We are enjoying the highly intellectual discussion of Javed ghamadi sb . But these 3 morons destroyed whole conversation by their stupid questions .
@@sayeemazharul1245 i agree ... however because there are people who are asking philosophical questions .. and people capable of answering them .. there is hope yet ... for humanity hope is what sustains this life ... i think sometimes
کیا بات ہے غامدی صاحب آپ کی اللہ تعالی آپ کے علم و عمل میں برکت عطا فرمائے،،،،اور کیا ہی اچھا ہوتا اگر آپ کی یہ گفتگو دیگر زبانوں میں بھی ترجمہ کر دی جاتی تو بہت سے لوگوں کو فائدہ ہوتا
Aam maulvi insan ko atheist bana kar chorr detay han, jab k Ghamdi Sahib atheism ko jarroon samaith naist o nabood kar deta hay. Ya Allah thu hamain vo baseerath aur samajh atha farma k hum Qur'an aur Islam ko aisay samajh sakeain jaisay Ghamdi samajh sakta hay.
3. 🌟 Iska khulasa, (maloom ka jayza lene ke baad) - Wajood ek haqiqat Hai. - Quwwat ek haqiqat hai. - Quwwat ka jahoor ek haqiqat hai. - Usme hone wale tagayyurat ek haqiqat hai. - Tagayyurat ke andar : tanawwo, hama'haangi, tawafuk, gaaid, maksad aur maujooniyat ek haqiqat hai. - Nafs ka ilm akal aur shauur ek haqiqat hai. - Is Zahoor ka jof, misyan, kamzori ek haqiqat hai. - Apni Taujeeh aap karne se kaseer hona ek haqiqat hai. - Aur fir madde ka hamare haatho me musakkar ho jana ek haqiqat hai. - (Madde ka) Mashiyat aur irade se khaali hona ek haqiqat hai. 🌟 Aap in Haqaaiq ko mante hai ?? 🎉 Agar is mehsoos ko aap mante hai, is maloom ko aap mante hai. Aap mante hai ki ye sab maujood hai. To fir iske samne 3 sawalaat quran aapke samne rakh dega. 🌟 1. Ye madda aur Nafs, kya aap apne khaliq hai? - Iska jawab ye ho sakta hai. Lekin iske liye aapko ye sabit karna padega ki ye aapke hathon ke andar aakar musakkhar nahin ho jate. Inme mashiyat paayi jaati hai. Inme irada paaya jata hai. Madde me to, abtak ka jitna hamara jayeza aur tazjiya hai isme irada aur mashiyaat daryaft nahin ki jaa saki. Nafs ke andar thodasa ehsas hota hai ke hai, kyunki usme ilm o akal bhi hai, aur kisi hadd tak irada bhi paya jata hai. Lekin mene aapse arz kar diya ki uska irada bhi, fauran mehsoos ho jaata hai ke uska apna nahin hai. Uski mashiyat bhi maloom hoti hai apni nahin hai. Uska ilm bhi maloom ho jata hai ke uske apne wajood se nahin futa hua. Uski wajah ye hai ke misyaan (maybe nisyaan) ka shikar ho jata hai. Jof ka shikaar ho jata hai. Killate azimat ka shikar hota hai. To iske nateeje ke baad, jahir hai ke ye sawal wo hai jiska jawab ab tak bhi paanch hazaar saalki tareekh hai, dene ki jasarat nahi kar saki. Ke ye dar haqiqat jo kuch bhi hai iska ye aap khaaliq hai. Agar ye aap khaaliq hai ka jawab mil jaay to me saara ka saara mazhab ka mukadma wapas le lunga. Uski wajah ye hai ke uska maani fir kya hai, uske maani fir ye hai ke taujeeh ho gayi. Masla hal ho gaya. 🍁 Host to other students : Aap Evolution etc se related koi sawalat karna chahenge ?? 🌟 Ghamidi sahab to them : Ye ek jawab ho sakta haina ke ye madde ke andar jo tabdeeliya ho rahi hai, jo tagayyurat ho rahe hai, jo nayi duniya wajood me aa rahi hai, asal me ye aap hi apna khaaliq hai. Ek cheez ye ho sakti hai, ke ye apne wajood me, khud khaaliq hone ki sifat rakhta hai. Ye baat koi kehne ki jasarat nahin kar saka. Yaani itne do dhai hazaar saal me insaan ne aaur bohot tarakki ki hai, pichle chaar paanch so saal me kuch aur aage badh gaya hai. Lekin batadreej ye baat bilkul mohkam ho gayi hai ke ye jo kuch bhi hai, ye aap apne taujeeh karne se kaaseer hai. Ye nahi bata sakta, ke ye kaise ho raha hai sabka sab. Yaani kaise hota hai me mitti ke andar se, ek ameza paida hota hai, uske andar tagayyurat hote hai, ek katra e aab wajood me aata hai, ek insaan ke factory ke andar jata hai, aur uske baad usse jita jaagta insaan ban jata hai. To ye aap se aap, aap se aap ka matlab hai ke ye khud creator hai, iske andar irada maujood hai, ye khud apne aap ko bana sakta hai. Madde ki wo mashiyat wo irada kaar farma ham dekh sakte hai. Nahin aisi koi baat nahi hai. Ek jawab ye ho sakta tha, lekin is jawab ko koi bhi sunne manne ke liye tayyar nahi. ✅ Question in sum up : Evolution ke jariye aate hai ye changes?? - Ye maloom ho jana chahiye na, ki ye jo madda hai ye apne andat tabdeeli karne ka, naa sirf ye ke aone andar tabdeeli karne ki salahiyat rakhta hai, balki us tabdeeli ka control bhi uske haath me hai. Kaha hai?? Me jab chahu iski tabdeeli ko rok du. Jab chahu iski tabdeeli par asar andaz ho jaau. Me ek mamooli insaan jo khud ek madde ki takhleeq hai, wo iske amal ko rok sakta hai. Me is jameen ko banjar kar sakta hoon. Me iska paani rok sakta hoon. Me isko koi aur surat de sakta hoon. Me iske andar se baaz ajza ko leke jahaz uda sakta hoon. Ye to khud mere haath me bebas hai, ye khud apna khaaliq kaise ho sakta hai. ✅ Question in sum up : Agar aap isko musakkhar kar sakte hai to Aap bhi to madde ka hissa hai. The very fact ki aap isko kar sakte hai, living beings ek ke baad dusre ko produce kar sakti hai ye show karta hai ke madde ke andar ye potency hai. - Ye to hai, ye to uske andar salahiyat maujood hai ki wo tagayyurat ke andar badalta chala jaata hai. Tagayyur karne wala kon hai, ye amal ho kaha se raha hai. ✅ Question in sum up : ye matter probabilities ki wajah se ho raha hai. Ke har cheez probable hai. - To iske andar maanviyat kaise paida ho jaati hai, hamangi kaise paida ho jaati hai. Aapki shakhsiyat ke andar shauur kaise paida ho jaata hai.
The entire gamut of premises adduced as polemical proof of the existence of Almighty Allah s.t. by respected Janab Javed Ahmed Sahib appears to be of academic drill. To me, your existence & the existence of this Cosmos are two paramount testimonies to the existing of Almighty Allah s.t. Iqbal Khan from India. 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
RIP the intellect of these students..RIP.. They lap it up when it comes from west just like it is from God...u ponder for 2 minutes and the whole story is gone..
How can the whole existence be a darkness, just because one doesn't beleive in God. I can still be curious and amazed and learn about everything around me.
Because you can't find the reason and point of living in this world, with all this suffering, pleasure, and love. There will be thousands of unanswered questions.
A humble suggestion to improve it further is that for such delicate topics which are prone to deep thinking/analysis one has to be very patient to hear to speaker/schalor. Here in all 4 parts the host remained very impatient and tried to rush next step in very hast thus breaking the thought and thinking sequence or tempo again and again. On the part of audience this rush can be expected as the listeners were young and as usual over posses with own learning but hurry on the part of host can't be understood. Regards
غامدی صاھب کو دوسروں کے کہنے پر بہت وقت تک فتنہ سمجھا لیکن لاسٹ ویک سے مسلسل سن رہا ہوں قسم سے یہ آدمی تو علم کا سمندر ہے مجاھد آدمی ہے اتنے مشکل سوالات کے جوابات کسی بھی آدمی کیلیے دینا نہ ممکن ہے لیکن سر سلام ہو آپ کو اور اللّه ہمیں معاف کرے کہ میں نے آپ کو بہت برا سمجھا تھا باقی آپ کو جو سننا شروع کردیتا ہے وہ پھر اڈیکٹ ہو جاتا ہے،اللّه آپکو لمبی زندگی دے امین ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
جہالت کی سب سے بڑی پہچان نشہ ہی ہے ۔۔۔کیونکہ فہم و فراست نشہ کی بجائے اگہی عطا کرتی ہیں ۔۔۔ایڈکشن نہیں ۔۔۔ مگر اپ نے تو غامدی صاحب کے متعلق اچھا نہیں سوچا تھا ۔۔۔اپ کو تھو کرنی چاہیے تاکہ اپ کے وہ غلط سوچ باہر نکل جائے ۔۔۔۔ویسے اپ کا معلوم ہے کتنا ۔۔۔جس کی بنیاد پر کہہ رہے ہیں کہ دنیا میں کوئی انسان کامدی صاحب کے جیسے علم ۔۔۔غامدی صاحب سے کبھی یہ سوال کریں کہ انہیں اپنے اصل کے متعلق کتنی معلوم ہے ۔۔۔اپنی ذات کے جوہر یعنی اپنی روح سے وہ کتنے جڑے ہوئے ہیں ۔غامدی صاحب پر اپنی روح کی کتنی معرفت کھلی ہوئی ہے ۔غامدی صاحب کا تو یہ جسم اور ذہن بھی اس دنیا کے جانے کے ساتھ ہی ادھر رہ جا ۓ گا۔۔۔غامدی صاحب کے سل اپ کی طرح ان کی روح ہے ۔۔۔رو باڈی سے نکل جائے تو انسان کو مردہ کہا جاتا ہے ۔۔۔انسان کا یہ سوچنا سمجھنا بات کرنا یہ ساری باتیں انسان کی روح نکلنے کے ساتھ ختم ہو جائیں گی ۔۔۔ایسے میں جو اصل ہے وہ روح ہے تو روح کو کتنا جانتے ہیں اپ یا اپ کے غامدی صاحب ۔۔۔روح سے وابستگی اور اگاہی کے بغیر انسان کی گفتگو کو خالص شورو ہوگا تصور کیا جاتا ہے بلکہ نیو خان کی نان سٹاپ بس سروس کی طرح جو شور زیادہ کرتی ہے اور سفر کم سمیٹتی ہے ۔اپ کے غمدی صاحب بھی معذرت کے ساتھ اسی سروس سے کافی مشابہ ہیں۔ ۔۔
We all are stupid... as we all have same questions in our minds but don't bring on tounges.... I am glad they have brought them for questioning.... Now I am satisfied..
whoever created whole galaxy can't be same God we talk about as our god is too much busy in awarding and punishing the the people in this life and some people say he has to look after the afterlife department also.
Modern day Ullma jo ha wo ye tak nahe bta skte ke ye student jo sawal poch rhe ha is ka matlab kya ha jawab dena to dor ke bat haa. LOOK AT GHAMDI sahab Ma Sha Allah , kese khatam kar rhe ha sare doubts
Khuda ko kis ne paida kia? Agr aisa hota k khuda ko kisi ne paida kia hota to phir usko bhi kisi ne paida kia hota aur phir usko bnane wala bhi koi hota aur phir usko bhi kisi ne banaya hota... Is trah aap aik "Infinite regress" me phans jaenge aut phir apki takhleek hee nhi poaegi.... Lkn aap jante hain aap jeete jagte insan hain jiska mtlb yeh he k apko takhleek me achuke hain aur yeh apko takhleek me laane wala maamla aik jaga jaakr ruk rha he .. aur woh he Khuda.. who can create something out of nothing jesa k uske 99 names me se aik naam he
میزبان کو ہی بات سمجھ نہیں آ رہی. اور آڈینس غامدی صاحب کی بحث سے آگے کے سوال کر رہی ہے. یعنی غامدی صاحب گفتگو کے جس مقام پر ابھی پہنچے ہی نہیں آڈینس اس پر پہلے ہی سوالات اٹھا رہی ہے.
Simple answer to this question , according to Quran is that Allaah is a probable entity . This entity will never be proved or rejected. The fact is that the universe is a function of constent natural laws , even any sudden change is also dependent of natural laws . Man has discovered some of these laws . Islam speaks to conscious mind , insanes are not its addressees. Expression of the Quran is in a spoken language. In all its injunctions Quran invites our intellect to understand the social ,ethecical n religious problems n extendes its logical n scientific solutions. we human beings having material origion are absolutely helpless in building a conviction or belief about metaphysical bodies or phenomena . we have to endorse the divine message n lead our lives according to religious instructions to achieve a disciplined system . Is this a universe without its creator ? No , we can' t rule out its Creator . Can we prove the Creator by argumention or by deeply studying the sequence of natural laws ? No , never. Conclusion : Our intellect, our conscience , our intuition has an inherent n innate inclination towards a regular n disciplined existence . We get satisfection n peace of mind and purpose of life by accepting the existence of the CREATOR . Our conscious mind , our common sense n logic demand us to accept the principles n teachings of religion to manage the probable accountability before our CREATOR . We can't afford the risk of the challenges of the LIFE AFTER DEATH . Solutes to Javed Ahmad Ghamidi Sahib . Alhamdulillaah his explanations have a warm acceptence accross the planet . 15th Dec 2022 Islamabad Pakistan
5. Is ek ek cheez par gaur karo .... Ye ek ek cheez apne wajood shahadat de rahi hai ke iske andar gair mamooli manviyat hai ... Gair mamooli akeedas hai ... Gair mamooli riyazi hai ... Ye kawaneen me bandhi hui hai ... Ye koi begaid karkhana nahin hai ... Ye maloom hota hai ke ek cheez dusri ko tashkeel karti chali ja rahi hai ... Iske andar irteeka ka amal bhi agar hua hai ... Wo bhi aisa behangam nahin hua ke uske nateeje me aapki naak ki jagah haathi ke naak lag jaati ... Aur uske kaan par aapke kaan lag jata ... Woh bilkul ek kaayde me, ek jabte me har jagah wo behtareen cheez ko paida karne ka bais bana hai ...
Ghamidi is my favourite scholar! He is living legend of religion,philosophy, most of the time I am speechless about the logic and concepts of great Ghamidi But unfortunately he miserably failed to answer this most difficult question of this universe, might be that’s the biggest sign of existence of god that regardless the intelligence of human kind, he is not able to even describe, define or explain God’s existence. Regarding students, they actually done well, if you listen again ayaz questions were extremely related but taimoor question was quite dump but he done well in previous video. Host 7/10, ayaz 6/10, taimoor 4/10 hain 2/10 Ghamidi sb 5/10
Define God's existence? Ghamidi miserably failed. Haha.... you have not listened bro. Or your understanding is weak? Listen to the last two minutes, what do they demand!?
What is God: for a child, it is his or her parent; for an adult, it is whoever takes care of his or her needs, including employer and spouse; and for an elderly person, it could be a doctor or nurse.
Many people who convert to Islam or revert back to Christianity is because religious organizations provide a sense of community, comradely, fellowship and a sense of belonging. These powerful emotional needs are fulfilled, even if religions are not historically and scientifically accurate or just myths. "ignorance is a bliss" Matrix-quote. originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist .,,, ,
قرآن کے تین سوالات کیا خود مادہ اور نفس اور ان میں ہونے والے تغیرات کا خالق ہے؟ مادہ خود بے بس ہے کیا یہ خود خالق ہو سکتا ہے۔ یہی معاملہ مادہ سے پیدا ہونے والے انسان کیساتھ ہے۔ کیا یہ محض اتفاق ہے؟ نہیں پس اس کا کوئی خالق ہے
I don’t see any evidence for anything un-natural, therefore I am not convinced that there is anything unnatural or supernatural like gods, spirits, miracles, magic, ‘jadoo’, ‘jins’ and ‘rooh’ and gods . originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist, , , ,
Anchor and students are very much witty thn ghamdi sb is....They have a very beautiful compatibility with the modern arena This Gandhi Service Living Inn fast ages... This brand has become outdated now!
The question you have asked is a logical fallacy, if somehow we answer the question that who created the creator a new question would arise that who created the creator’s creator and we will fall into infinite regress. To overcome this logical fallacy we must have necessary first existed from whom other things came into being, this necessary existence is GOD. Atheists also believe in a necessary existence but according to them that necessary existence is universe itself but now we know that universe is not eternal rather it came into being at some point in time which is 13.8billion years according to Science. So we have to discard the Atheistic argument of the Eternalness of the universe and accept that the necessary existence must be GOD.
![[3/4] Existence of God Proved by Javed Ahmed Ghamidi](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
