3.5 American Standard Madera VS 3.5 American Standard Afwall! 

The last generation of Afwalls that didn’t suck

I was looking forward to this comparison! The results are what I was expecting

Great test! I love both toilets so it's hard for me to pick a favorite. Those are my favorite Maderas after the Standard versions.

Awesome video aft! The afwall did better on the rag and bag tests and the madera did better on the dirt test.

You did a great job on the test and the toilets

Both are awesome toilets

Both great classics! I think they did about the same, but I do like the Madera a little bit better.

Those maderas are cool but they almost always leave things behind

Awesome

Both are great! I bet if you tried it with the 1.6 version of both I bet the Afwall would win again.

Both were great, but I'd personally prefer the afwall a bit more than the madera because of its wall mounted design that is to imply I'd prefer to have the afwall installed in my bathroom at my private residence home even though these are commercial heavy duty toilets that require heavy duty commercial plumbing systems. I prefer these tankless commodes that use a flushometer valve instead of a tank.

Cool!

I think the Afwall won! Honestly rather impressive, I always thought the Afwalls were subpar, this really proved me wrong!

Honestly, I actually dk which to choose from but they're good though.

They are both great in my opinion. Which one do you like better? If you had to pick one.

Wow epic war

I’d use the Afwall more. Both are great toilets!

which one did you use?

Additional review comment: The Afwall has hidden siphon jet/s plus a larger trapway mouth opening than the (Cadet masquerading as a) Madera. What would be a TRUE test would be to swap out that Afwall for an identical wall hung Cadet on flushometer as the Madera is of the Cadet flushing class and type. If the floor and wall hung terlits is of the Cadet flushing class and type, then this would be a real test, so that looking straight down at the bowls, they both look identical and you wouldn't know which was floor mounted and which was wall/carrier mounted. I also think that if you add dirt, you should weigh the amounts so that they're truly identical. Scientific method matters sometimes.

I like the peace out to end the video just like Henry my boy from Collins hill high school does.

The Madera has the siphon jet in the bowl, the Afwall does not!

Gotta love both of them!

These are both epic toilets! I think that the Madera won.

you should've done the same year as they both have the same trapway (this comment is extremely late)

Madera or cadet because cadets can be on flushometer not on tank They used to build one to put it on

Can I have them?

Hi

I think the madera won and you should flush them both at the same time