3 Disturbing True Neighbor Horror Stories (V3) 

I swear why do some of these people just not call the police 🤦🏽‍♀️ especially the couple in the third story

always amazing when mr nightmare posts fr

This makes me grateful to have lovely neighbours 😅

I love he photo used in the thumbnail. Realistic and Erie great combo

I have to be honest, the drilling sounds in the 2nd story had my crying of laughter. Clearly I'm very mature.

Mom: what do you want for Christmas sweetheart? Me: MR. NIGHTMARE UPLOADS

on my birthday too😩 best gift i could’ve asked for

Imagine watching this when you are about to go to sleep

lol I think the tool guys were just messing with him because you looked super spooked for nothing. They probably had a job to do. You acted like a tough guy. So they checked you

Mr.Nightmare is spoiling us

Thank you I highly appreciate it!!😎💙

Listening to this while at my overnight job at walmart

The parents in the first story acting in the appropriate manner. They believed their children when they told them something happened, they tried to investigate the incidents, and moved to keep their family safe. I wish all parents acted in this manner when their children come to them with serious issues.

For the 3rd story, I'm not sure why they didn't call the police. Their neighbor is obviously hiding something and the screaming further proves there's something weird going on in that house.

Story 2 person made me so mad. 4 random men in their 40s using loud tools at some odd time in the morning, and you decide to go to sleep rather than call the police. Stupidity

We definitely need an update in the future on story 3. My mind was thinking mummified bodies at the window. That dude just gives off serial killer vibes. And the screaming in the middle of the night with an abrupt stop!? Crazy! Could be added in a possible compilation video in the future with some older stories with updates as well. Thanks as always Mr. Nightmare, and happy holidays everyone! :)

Babe wake up, Mr. Nightmare has blessed us with another video.

We’re gonna need more updates on the third story as this situation unfolds

From middle school to my final year in college Mr. Nightmare, you’ve gotten me through every chapter

The girl from the 2nd story frustrated me so much. Shed have called police the second she heard all those noises from the neighbor house in the middle of the night

Out of those three stories, it really bugs me that none of them thought to call the cops. All of those moments were screaming for a 911 call. Those weird neighbors could have been behind bars by now. Instead, they're still out there, lurking in the dark, doing God knows what.

Story 3 Theory: The two people looking out the window are corpses. The creepy 20-something-year old who awkwardly answered the door killed his parents 3 days prior and positioned them to endlessly glare out the window. I swear I thought the story was about to head that direction

"We almost called the police but we didn't" Why?

In the third story, the people in the window are probably dead. And the young guy who answered the door is either their son or some psycho that broke in and killed them and put their bodies at the window.

First story..I'll never understand why parents have upstairs bedrooms while letting their young kids sleep alone downstairs. Especially when they thought the neighbor was watching them.

Story 1 at the end : the fact that the neighbor still has those pictures he took is utterly disgusting and disturbing 🤢🤬

Mr. Nightmare sounds kind of nasally in these recordings, like he wasn't/isn't feeling well. And yet he still provided us with content. Either way, thank you, Mr. Nightmare.

In the first story, the parents should have reported CP. If he told the cops that he suspects that the neighbor is taking pictures of his kids in the pool and sleeping, the cops should have checked the creepy neighbor's camera roll. CP is a serious offense that the cops should've suspected. If needed, they probably could've easily gotten a warrant to search his property. That old guy needs to be behind bars. Edit: I was wondering what everyone was talking about in the comments till I realized my late night mistake. 😆 Meant to put "CP" instead of "PC." My bad, guys. That's what happens when you type comments after midnight, lol.

The final story in this video is exactly why all my windows are always covered, I have paranoia that someone will watch me through my windows or that I'll wake up and see someone looking at me through my bedroom window

That last story.... it's absolutely insane that they didn't call the police. No empathy at all for what could be happening to those people next door!

Story 2: you asked workers to quit working, they did. They creeped you out but stopped. You thought their choice of music was weird.

No quick hey guys at the start of the video, No annoying sponsors to shout out, No ads at the beginning. Just straight to the disturbing scary shit. Love It.

Legit want a further update on the last story because what the hell… Probably the weirdest story featured on the channel

After working a brutal week of dealing with a lot of Christmas shoppers and constantly restocking items this is so satisfying to watch can anyone else agree?

girl 2 is dumb for not calling cops

*TIMESTAMPS* Story 1 by "Father of Twins" - 0:07 Story 2 by Hynara - 5:36 Story 3 by James Michaels - 12:17

insane how fast the people in these stories jump to conclusions

Ah horror stories just after the stroke of midnight...perfect Mr. Nightmare!!

The third story is actually horrifying

Story 3… call the police. My first thought was the elderly couple in the window were dead corpses. Especially with how weird the guy was when he answered the door. Then with the screaming, either it’s a guy with some serious mental health problems and he’s yelling erratically for no reason or it’s possibly elder abuse. Either way, these people should have called the police. Something is definitely wrong with that situation.

Why were your children sleeping in a bedroom on the first floor making them more vulnerable while their parents are sleeping upstairs? If something happens (as it did) anything could happen to the children and I mean anything. Put your children on the same floor as yourselflves. Common sense.

The men are obviously playing that music to pretend that a teenage party is going on to mask the noises of what they're doing.

My grandpa died last Monday and it has been a long, dreadful week. So glad you posted a video to make me feel better. Love your content.

Currently in bed and sick with the flu. It's a treat to listen to a new video from Mr. Nightmare during a time like this!

Awesome, thank you! SPOILERS: #2 The guys could've been drilling holes to peep through or insert technology to peep? #3 Should've called the police for a wellness check. Very weird.

In the third story they deffinatly should inform the police even if they just do a wellness check because hearing screaming like that is always a concern

Story #2 I’m 99% certain they were setting up hidden cameras so they could watch and probably sell footage of unknowing girls changing, showering, etc. She should’ve called the police the second she heard loud noises at such a late time…. Let alone not telling anyone about all that activity after it seems it’s actually vacant, after all???

That last story is genuinely terrifying.

Thank you for your service Mr. Nightmare in making my day better and scarier 💀

The 2nd one wasn't good. They probably were just workers.

People's reluctance to call the police in these stories always surprises me, particularly story 2 in this episode.

Perfect!!! Sitting here wrapping gifts and I needed something good to listen too! Thanks Mr. Nightmare! What a great night cap! Merry Christmas everywhere and a Happy New Year!

Honestly the scariest RU-vid story teller ever. Happy Holiday’s Bro! 🎄❤

The person in story #2 wants to be a victim so bad. Literally nothing was happening and they didn’t do anything but you were just so terrified 🤣🤷‍♂️

Story 1 was frustrating to listen to. It just sounded like a couple of helicopter parents just looking to be "victims" of something. They just openly accuse their neighbor of one of the worst things imagineable with 0 hard evidence, and when he's (very reasonably) offended by the accusation, it's "suspicious"? What? Yeah, no wonder he's avoiding you, you're a weirdo who keeps accusing him of spying on your kids. Then story 2: She's upset about them making all of that noise at night? Totally reasonable. Asks them to stop? Also reasonable. But then she goes, "Oh no, they looked at me," and runs away to her apartment, scared? Why? They literally didn't do anything. Sure, she claims they looked at her like "predators," but we have no way of knowing what that even means from her perspective. Plus, they didn't cat call her, follow her, nothing. They literally just looked at her and she got upset despite the fact that she's the one who confronted them. She's literally the stereotypical college student who gets easily offended at random things

Normally i don’t get scared that easily from these videos but the third story here genuinely scared the shit outta me when he mentioned the muffled screams. I’m chilling just writing that Mr nightmare knows how to scare fr

The person in the second story said it's creepy for adult men to listen to teen pop music? What a stupid thing to say. Does she also think it's creepy if kids listen to adult contemporary music?

man that second story gets me so mad. The over thinking is so crazy there. She wakes up to guys doing construction or something in their dorm and starts judging the guys choice of music?? Then gets scared when they turn off the music and stop when she asked them too. She also says she woke up in the middle of the night and was scared it was them outside her window but it coulda either just been her waking up randomly in the middle of the night or them leaving since it was only like 30 minutes after she went back to bed. so stupid

Why people dont have curtains over there windows i will never know....

child scream sound affects are NOT a vibe when ur on full volume in the shower and your mum is in the room next to yours 💀💀

I was tensing up waiting for the people in the window in the third story to be revealed to be the corpses of the younger guy's parents

Well well well, if it isn’t the “Nightmare” before Christmas…

It’s currently 12am for me and every single time I listen to mr nightmare I always fall asleep given how calming your voice is. Seconds ago I was searching for a video to watch to help me doze off and got the notification one of my favorite people posted. Feeling luckier than ever❤️.

The second story isn't a scary story, it's a social interaction. You heard noise, ask people to stop, they stopped.

Story3: we heard screams coming from the house but we were so creeped out that we decided not to call the police. 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Story #3: The people at the window were cardboard cut outs or mannequins. Everything else that happened was unrelated. Now that might be a good idea for a video. 3 scary stories that turned out to be nothing.

For the Second Story: This is why you call the police, for peace of mind, and no one knows who f****** called the police cuz they wouldn't have seen you do it

Mr. Nightmare dropping a gem on the holidays! Thanks man, and happy holidays to everyone! 🤶🤟🍻

Story 2 - she said it was weird that middle aged men were listening to early 2000s pop songs bc that's what teenagers would listen to...does she know when people who are now middle aged were teenagers? Oh sweet summer child, sometimes us olds like to listen to the music of our youth, also. It seems like she probably caught them stripping things from the apt., they bounced, and the rest is just her scaring herself. 🤦‍♀️

You should do a video of updated stories, like how the last story said they’d update if something happened

MrNightmare will always be one of the best. These stories never grow old. Happy Holidays everyone. Have a scary Christmas ahead. Stay safe.

Definitely a good idea to be watching this in the dark knowing full well I'm paranoid with a very detailed imagination Update: the sound effect at 14:43 gave me a heart attack

Story 2 is a classic college girl thinking all men trying to jump in her pants.

Story three is scary. Hope those people are safe. Hopefully the screams are the last thing they have to deal with coming from that house.

I'm sorry? It's weird for middle aged men to listen to pop music? Everyone has different tastes. Do we now say that teenagers can't like 70s or 80s songs? Lol, why the judgement on the music choice?

I'm 10000% sure the guy in the 3rd story just had mannequins in the window, lmao.

I miss when people used to comment about the stories

Time to add another Mr. Nightmare video to my sleep playlist 🔥🔥

A perfect way to unwind for the night listening to some scary stories from Mr. Nightmare. 🤓

the ground is wet outside with a slight fog. the perfect night for mr nightmare to post ❤

I thought for sure the two people at the window in the third story were mannequins.

Wow, I thought that you were done uploading for the year after the compilation. This is a pleasant surprise! Thank you for a whole year of amazing videos, have a merry Christmas!

Story #2 sounds hard to believe

#2 was a waste of time

Remember Always be afraid not of fictional monster, but the ones that exists In Real Life

Here's a short horror story- as I sat in my room in complete silence.. the only noise were the restless thoughts running thru my head. I accepted my fate knowing I was powerless to the pending outcome.. I grabbed my last blunt, sparked up, inhaled deep and whispered in a low chuckle... "I'm really gonna die a virgin..."

In the first story I couldn't help but notice that a camera flash through a window would basically result in having overexposed pictures. Still creepy.

the second story just sounds like socially awkward renovators to me, I don't know it just seems weird.

Mr.nightmare is the only one who can make an 18 minute video seem like it’s only 5 minutes long.

Thank you for making these videos, they are always entertaining and fun to watch with my friends. Even though they make me paranoid and scared i love the story’s! Thank you Mr Nightmare.

so the guys were in their 30s & listening to music from 2000? is it really unusual to play music from one's youth? she didnt like the men noisy& didnt like them quiet. it is natural that they would approach& look at someone calling through the window but she felt ogled. this is a karen

Mr Nightmare videos is like a Christmas present gift 🎁

13:02 Was that a voice change lol

Listening to new horror stories from Mr. Nightmare is a blessing, a new upload from him always makes my day ✨🙏

If youtube had a yearly wrap, Mr Nightmare would be by top channel 😅

This videos never disappoint. Been watching for years. Perfect video for me to watch before going to sleep

Every time someone says "I thought about calling the police, but didn't" I facepalm. These people would be the first to go in a horror movie. 0% survival instinct.

I wonder if there are any old stories with updates when they said they’ll update.

For people asking about “updates” on previous stories he has done, do you know how much of a logistical NIGHTMARE that would be going back to find the stories he’s told to get updates

The guy in the first story is definitely a predator. Unfortunately, the father with the twins had no proof. Sure, he called the police. But there's not much they can do without evidence. Unless multiple reports from different people start piling up. The girl in the second story definitely should have notified the police. And even the property manager. It sounds like those guys were creeps and up to no good. Same idea with the second scenario. That couple should have noticed the police. Sounds like something odd was going on.