3 Scary True Subway Stories 

Notice, they all took place in New York. Apparently the NYC subways are the home of the creepers at night.

When I was 5 I was in the restroom peeing and then Jared walked right up beside me and.... Oh wait, wrong Subway.

Who needs Netflix when u have MR. NIGHTMARE

That second story was really disturbing. The fact that those people pretended to cause a bad situation just to get good hearted people to fall for their trap is despicable

Son: Dad, do you believe in ghosts? Dad: No Son: Well the maid told me the house is haunted. Dad: Pack your bags. Son: Why? Dad: We don't have a maid.

When I saw the title I thought it was the Subway sandwich store

9:16 "Psssst! Over here, buddy... come hang out with me in the tunnel." What I want to know is, does that line ever work? lol

"A head, just a head, like a decapitated head." When you're trying to hit that minimum word count on your school essay. But to be serious someone holding a decapitated head is no joke. Stay safe out there.

Who hates it when they are all the way down in the comments and the video finishes and u have to go all the way back up the top to choose another story

Subways have been around since trains were put in place. That means, what, 140 years of various subways that have been built, built upon, and abandoned? Who knows what all took place in them, what horrors and terrible acts occurred. In places like New York and Chicago, there are underground labyrinths of abandoned subway tunnels, rooms, and structures that have been forgotten over the decades, places where dark things happened and bad people roamed. Who knows what's down there?

When the sun goes down, stay above ground.

Dad: hey just checking on the kids Babysitter: oh good they got freaked out by the clown statue so I covered it up with a blanket Dad: get the kids and get out Babysitter: why what’s wrong Dad: we don’t have a clown statue Turns out the kids had a clown statue and the dad had memory loss

These originals are the scariest

Wendy's saved him. Thank GOD

Story 1 - The creepy stalker-type story. Always a classic! Story 2 - The dialogue at the end… it sounds just like something from an action movie man… Story 3 - STRAIGHT OUT OF A HORROR MOVIE. Yikes.

My scary subway story: I ordered a 12 inch, but it was 11 INCHES LONG!

When I went to New York, the subway station's floor was covered in blood and the ticket lady was crying

Steps for watching Mr Nightmare: 1: baracade your door 2: Close any windows and close the curtains or blinds 3: Dont watch at early morning hours (3am or 2am 4: Lastly, Dont expect to get any sleep after watching Edit: Holy crap! I didn't expect so many likes tysm Also Burrito yourself in 20 blankets

Who else is binge watching Mr Nightmare 7 years after this video was posted

number one is just completely fucking creepy

SCARY SCHOOL STORIES !? (TEACHER OR STUDENT PERSPECTIVE)

i watch this channel so much and it makes me wanna carry a gun everywhere just in case

I have a scary subway story The worker forgot to toast my sandwich

But the subway car is full even at 3a.m here in china😂

When I read the name I thought it was the restaurant subway 😂

I went to visit my brother and stayed at his house. I struggled to sleep so I got up to watch some tv. I heard "pssssst" so I looked around and saw nothing. My brother was asleep so I knew it wasn't him. Unnerved I continued to watch tv. I heard "pssssst" again. it scared me so I got up and had a look around. I found nothing. I was completely freaked out and was convinced there was someone in my bothers house messing with me. Finally after hearing the "pssssst" sound a few more times I realised it was an automatic air freshener going off every 20 minutes. Thank Goodness for that

“This is New York and we just like to carry around decapitated heads”

My scary Subway story, I asked for ham an I got turkey

Please do scary stories about being on planes our in boats in the middle of the ocean please and thanks for the vid!

Scary True Subway Story -They ran out of flatbread.

Me: goes on the subway Mr. Nightmare : 3 scary stories in the subway Me: wtf

Why are you uploading these at night....you monster!

If only the antagonists in these stories were Canadian. "Sorry we beheaded this guy, eh."

I live in NY I see scary/crazy shit 24/7

Common knowledge as a New Yorker, when it’s late night to midnight, the creeps and crackheads come out to play in the subway

These videos make me so paranoid BUT IM ADDICTED TO WATCHING THEM I have a serious problem 😂😭

I remember shopping with my mom in the mall, she went up the escalator and I told her that I was going to check the shirts in the aisle, after I tooked enough time looking at clothes, I hopped on the escalator and so this guy who seemed to be waiting on the escalator, which weirded me out. As I got off, moving the pace faster, he was moving in my direction, but acting like he was looking for something. After I yelled for my mom, he quickly ran back. God knows what if I never yelled for my mom.

Here's the scariest subway story: Jarod Fogle

This was the exact opposite of my experience in Japan. I actually felt safe waiting at the stations there, even at night. As far as I know, there were no decapitated heads.

Am i the only one whos eating a subway sandwich At the subway With headphones? No... ok then......

I was at subway. I ordered a blt. I got the blt. I went home with my blt. I opened the blt. A FUCKING GHOST POPPED OUT OF IT.

And this is why you don't fuck with subways at nighttime kids. Or at all really.

Subway stations are just scary in general

Here have some 🍔🍔🍔🍔🍔🍔 from the Subway in the subway

Lol no subways in Michigan! I don't have to worry about this stuff.

It's 4am, I hope my cat can protect me. 😂🙀🙀🙀

Subway horror story..... They played gucci gang on the speakers......

I would have stared right back at that guy on the train when the dude was being followed. I've been in situations where people stare at me and I just look at them as long as they do to me.

We make your trains delicious with fresh creeps and stare from the purge farm

Once I start watching these scary true stories, I can't stop.

I need to travel the subway more at nights.

New Yorker here, our subways are an entirely different plain of reality during the late night hours, these are the only stories I actually believe might be real.

Subway; eat flesh!

Subway stations in New York are so fuckin hot 😫 like you would want a train to pass by so bad so you can feel the wind cause it's so damn hot

SCARIEST TRUCK DRIVER STORIES!!!

Story 3 gave me the "chills" OMG Wendy's saved his life

My scary Subway story, I asked for ham an I got turkey

I got a scary story. You were watching this video then BOOM RU-vid is banned in your country

I have a subway horror story messing up my order

Tunnels and subways give me the creeps at night .I couldn't imagine being there late at night no way .

I have a scary subway story I once went to a nearby subway and they forgot to toast the bread DUN DUN DUN

This is why i would never take a subway cause there are creeps, drunk crazy people, and also probley even psycho killers in the subway

Scary Netflix and chill story?

does mr nightmare have scary library stories?

If young metro don't trust you... 😂😂😂

Onetime, my Footlonng Sandwich was actually... 11 INCHES!!!

Oh crap it's Danny again! Don't go picking up the phone and telling a stranger what your doing!

Nobody: Literally Nobody: Random Guy: psst... Over here buddy

Ey Mr nightmare do u think mcdonalds sells fake meat?

I have a scary story Me and my family where out at the mall and this guy was like following us or something but we just went in so we didn't think much of it. Then he was still behind us, then me and my oldest brother walk to the food court but he was still behind me. Then he got really close and he put his hand under my dress and my brother turned around and punched him so hard he lost 2 teeth. I'm 13 and my brother was 16 so always have some one with you at all times!

i’m gonna need a face reveal. guys, back me up. what if he’s like super hot and we don’t even know. lol

Thought you meant subway sandwiches

Don't order subway in the drive-thru. They will mess up your order and that's pretty terrifying!!!! no mayo!!!

what about Thomas the rape engine?

Mine is worse, once I went to the subway and this girl SNEEZED ON MY SHOULDER! It was the worst subway experience of my life!

Whoever lives in nyc knows that it’s a really bad idea to be in the train after 10

I'm going full screen, remember me

I thought this was going to b 3 true scary Subway stories, like the fast food place subway..😂😂

The guy was holding a freaking head WTF 😷🤢😧

I'm watching this as I'm doing my math homework. Double the horror!

I would always wear earphones to avoid conversations

Anyone else trying to seek comfort in the comments?👌🏻😂😅

I have a scary subway story. standing on the subway train and standing for 2 hours

Who wants Graveyard Horror Stories??🤔

How bout 3 scary true school stories? School is about to start up so it would be perfect!

i remember a time when i was in a Canadian subway. when i was leaving a train this guy who was exiting the train as well was looking at me. he was mean looking and he approaching me. i was leaving the station at a brisk pace trying to get away when he grabbed my shoulder and then said "excuse me sir, you dropped this" he was holding my phone and then handed it to me. "i suggest you put it somewhere safer, or else someone might steal it. take care and have a good day sir"

I’ve always been interested in subways due to how vast and cavernous the tunnels are. So exploring them sounds like quite the treat! ...of course, I would never even think of actually doing so...

This why if I lived in America I would own a gun, hell I would own a gun anywhere I legally could

Well time to avoid the subway at night

Welcome to the comments you are save here please choose anything you'd like 🍏🍎🍐🍊🍋🍈🍓🍇🍉🍌🍒🍑🍍🍅🍆🍞🍯🍠🌽🌶🧀🍗🍖🍤🍳🍔🍟🌭🍕🍝🌮🌯🍜🍲🍥🍣🍱🍛🍙🍚🍘🍢🍡🍧🍨🍬🍮🎂🍰🍦🍭🍫🍿🍩🍪🍹🍸🍷🍻🍺🍾🍶🍵☕️🍼 enjoy some music🎤🎧🎷🎺🎸🎻

So far, I have survived quarantine with mr nightmare criminal minds and the office. Thank you man you bless every second of my life, and its really easy to absorb myself in your videos. Thanks

I got a scary story My exams

Only New Yorkers can really understand this lol

I have a very scary story. I had no WIFI for two weeks! and I had no data.Worst 2 weeks of my life.

“U should be cautious in closed spaces like a subway station late at night” U SHOOULD BE CAUTIOUS EVERY FUKIN PLACE U GO, that’s something I learned from mr nightmares vids

Thank god I have never been on a subway

who else saw only the title and thought this was about subway sandwiches

Road trip stories, 10 scariest.

Creepy story- Women A boarded a subway. She sat down and saw two men in black coats sitting on both sides of women B.Women A couldn’t see the women B face because she was looking down. The next stop a young man with a yellow coat boarded. He told woman A that she needed to trust him and get off the next stop with him. Woman A got off the next stop with him. The man in the yellow coat said he was a doctor and women B was dead. The two men were holding her up.... Edit- I fixed it since people said it was confusing I’m sorry🥺

Why mr nightmare?!? I can't resist these videos and it's so late at night!