Without the main slayer Ning, the stage feels empty and so off even though the other 3 did their best, and since Ningning is also the main vocal it even feels more empty.
@@kimminjeong-zi9to obviously it feels empty if not 4 of them performing together. Not perfectly fine at all but no choice their health matters the most 🤣
that is why Ningning plays a big role in the group❤, she basically carry the stage presence of the group as their best performer, and no one can cover her parts especially the really highnotes and adlibs, Winter would struggle with those since it is out of her range. So if Ning is not around, it is best not to cover her parts
obv this was not planned tho. so dont expect someone replace her. but basically winter can cover her parts easily loll it is not the lines are the problem. it is the choreo
NN not attending the event is unexpected so ofc they won't cover her part, but the other 3 can cover her parts well if given the chance. They are just a 4 member gg so when one is missing, it will be noticeable. NN is a good performer but stage presence wise Karina is >>. Winter (facial expressions) and Giselle (energy) had also improved a lot since spicy era.
you do realize Ningning is not there and ever since Supernova came out they have literally been performing non-stop and regardless or not if they are lip singing, they have been owning the stage and performances and still are, stop complaining and just enjoy and if not go watch something else
Remarkable improvement after four years of debut. With her being placed under intense public pressure due to having relatively less training time, she is now a shining star
NingNing was rushed to the hospital shortly before the presentation and was diagnosed with dehydration and exhaustion.😭 NingNing please get well soon❤️🩹
@@anhpham6506 dont you know how normal and common is it for models not to drink water before photo shooting? water makes you look bloated even faster than after eating food
@@anhpham6506 its not a completely out of the blue or random assumption. they be making their idols do all sorts of crazy stuff to make them more "appealing".
It’s beautiful but incomplete without Ningning 🥺 She just adds something to the performance that makes it even more amazing, I love her stage presence so much :( Ningning, please get well soon, we love you T_T
Ningning take a good rest so you can recover properly, we love you! Gigi, Winter and Karina did amazing... Their confidence on stage is outstanding!... Also Giselle looks so stunning. Could not take my eyes off her.
@@wdnzgj93161 good observation but we should understand that movements in a choreography can be used again unless it is renowned by a choreographer. And it was never their intention to copy. ☺ So if you think "copying" is an issue here then what about heel-toe footwork, etc.?
Was looking forward to who would cover NN parts but they just.. didn’t huhu 😢 I remembered when Giselle was away and NN covered her rap parts and stuff.
I think they normally would’ve if they had a bit of notice but since Ning Ning was rushed off right before the show.. it’s hard to coordinate I bet. :(
Unfortunately they didn’t have enough time to prepare the back up, since the news about ningning took absence was on that Day, but they still killed it. Just give the best wishes for them ❤
@@anaakbar9722 idt aespa will have anyone covering each other’s part unless they go on hiatus but i feel like it will be giselle since shes the one w least lines
Unfortunately they didn’t have enough time to prepare the back up, since the news about ningning took absence was on that Day when they rehearsal, but they still killed it. Just give the best wishes for them ❤