they was dance so active. When tou dance like this, you do mistake in song, but i didn't hear mistakes. Then it is DANCE live and sound was a phonogram. =(
These are very processed live vocals so I wouldn't even consider them really live. This whole yt channel is always editing the vocals a lot in post to make them sound perfect
@@AtlantisBrooke why can't the voice have any effect while other instruments can? These are not very processed, if it were it would be very noticeable.
맞아요! 어떻게 이렇게나 신나는 곳에 열정적인 안무를 추는데도 멤버 하나하나가 음색이 아름다워서 너무 신기해요 라이브는 역시 라이브라는 생각이 들게 하는 무대였죠 ㅎㅎ 밴드의 합주가 신나는 느낌이랑 너무 잘 어울리고 밴드가 음악을 뒷받침? 해줘서 더 신나는 노래가 되네요 :)
You do realize these shows aren't fully "live" right? There is still post-processing, autotune being fed in etc. It's fun, I enjoy them, but its not like its raw vocals you are hearing or anything.
@@hagakure81 No caso do It's live cada artista escolhe todos os aspectos da apresentação: se vai dançar, se tem som de base, etc... É muito mais flexível nesse aspecto. O que eu acho ótimo, assim cada grupo mostra seu charme único. Nessa apresentação em particular não consegui identificar autotune ou som de base, até pq essa coreografia não é cansativa. Dá pra soltar a voz de boa.
they sound so amazing live !! this is exactly why i love billlie their live vocals are so raw and real 😭 u can hear all the movement of their clothing and breathing too i just think all live performances are so cool
THEY SOUND SO GOOD LIVE! Everyone sounds so stable but Haram and Suhyeon really take the cake, reaching those high notes after lots of jumping! Sua, as always, is a great hype queen!
@@jazzyf_orreal no, this is now about bullyng each other, this is not about fan war. this is not what a mean, stop doing that online child, grow up, this is not cool, le seraphin did her best and the all show was really good, you are just a hater with no love
잇츠 라이브라니 .. 진짜 너무 기대했었는데 그거보다 더더ㅓ더ㅓㅓ더ㅓ 멋지다 ㅠㅠ 최고다 짱빌리 !! 락스타 컨셉이랑 밴드의 조합이 .. 너무 좋잖아 ..!!!! 잇츠 라이브도 찢어버렸어 .. 이게 빌리 클라쓰 ~ 라이브 천재 빌리의 잇츠 라이브 다들 즐감하시고 함께 빌리브 생활합시다ㅏ RING ma Bell 🤘🤘
와 생라이브라고 생각 못할 것 같아 진짜 너무 잘해서... 입벌리고 봤더니만 입 속 말랐어.....🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹😭😭😭 진짜 빌리 최고다.... 라이브 최고 퍼포먼스 최고 진짜 멋있다... 속이 확 뻥 뚫리는 무대 잘 봤어여😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 다들 너무.. 너무 멋있어....🥹☺️😍😍
Why is Billlie so underrated for their live vocals? I mean they're all be like singing so stable as a group though they're still rookies. They have the most stable live vocal on stage among gen 4. Their powers are in sync as well
I have to admit i got a little nervous in the beginning (because live) but quickly faded when i saw them getting really comfortable and killin it.. good job ladies👏👏👏
for new *Billlie* fans :) - - *moon sua* 3:06 - main rapper, lead vocalist, 99' liner - *suhyeon* 2:03 - main vocalist, lead dancer, 00' liner - *haram* 4:01 - main vocalist, 01' liner - *tsuki* 2:37 - main dancer, sub-vocalist, 02' liner (japanese) - *sheon* 1:49 - main dancer, lead rapper, 03' liner - *siyoon* 2:59 - main rapper, lead dancer, 05' liner - *haruna* 2:44 - sub-vocalist, maknae, 06' liner (japanese) - other singles: *ring x ring* (debut 2021) - *snowy night* - *gingamingayo* - fandom name: *Belllie've* - agency: *Mystic Story Entertainment* (a subsidiary label of *SM Entertainment* ) - positions might not be 100% right but so far they were taken from official sources such as the debut showcase, album credits, MBC radio RU-vid live, Arirang Radio Sound K etc.
I love live, raw vocals. When you hear the vocals move with the dance moves and whenever its shaky and stuff like that, I love it. They are so stable dont get me wrong but I love moments that are less stable because its so REAL. They are so so so so sgood oh my god
@@kpoplistener1111 No pretty much all are studio pre-recorded. Some have a few "real live" words/ad-libs mixed in to make it sound more real/throw us off, but most are studio versions, smoothed out and autotuned. You are probably so used to it you don't hear it anymore. The techniques are really good these days
@@Kx____ whenever someone says “oh, they sing live”, there must be another says “no, it’s pre-recorded bla bla bla” Like they cannot accept how good the group sing
Billlie really are one of the most ICONIC performers out there, I'm so blown away watching them sing live with such a demanding choreography. So happy they got this opportunity!
Honestly I was disappointed initially when they didn’t come out with hand mics because I wanted to hear their vocals rather than see a dance performance. INSTEAD they did both so well. Jaw hit the floor when they started into the chorus. I realllly need to see these girls live because they can SING.
I can't stop watching both this and their radio show live performance - they're seriously setting the bar so high for 4th gen groups with their strong vocals.
their vocals are just wow like WOW and they are DANCING TOO singing and dancing at the same time and they are so stable I'm just amazed wow wow wow Billlie should get more recognized in the kpop world they are so talented 💖💖💖
![[4K] Billlie - “RING ma Bell” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
