Тёмный

8.02x - Lect 16 - Electromagnetic Induction, Faraday's Law, Lenz Law, SUPER DEMO 

Lectures by Walter Lewin. They will make you ♥ Physics.
Просмотров 4,6 млн
50% 1

Electromagnetic Induction, Faraday's Law, Lenz Law, Complete Breakdown of Intuition, Non-Conservative Fields. Our economy runs on Faraday's Law!
Lecture Notes, Non-conservative Fields - Do Not Trust Your Intuition: freepdfhosting....
THIS LECTURE IS A MUST - Read the Lecture Notes of this Lecture.
Assignments Lecture 13, 14, 15 and 16: freepdfhosting....
Solutions Lecture 13, 14, 15 and 16: freepdfhosting....

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

27 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 4,6 тыс.   
@humang
@humang 3 года назад
I'm over here getting an MIT education without the cost of tuition... love it.
@shreyas.k898
@shreyas.k898 3 года назад
Where is This MIT
@saaranshsharma2354
@saaranshsharma2354 3 года назад
@@shreyas.k898 Massachusetts
@codingdens
@codingdens 3 года назад
@@shreyas.k898 Cambridge, Massachusetts
@stevegiroux2
@stevegiroux2 2 года назад
Same here while I’m studying science 10 I’m in advanced science physics cool
@sushilsaini6459
@sushilsaini6459 2 года назад
In INDIA , we study these things even before high school.
@sobanapathy1628
@sobanapathy1628 3 года назад
Any class 12 indian students here🖐️🖐️
@vaibhavbhatt6286
@vaibhavbhatt6286 3 года назад
Yep
@tasneem6427
@tasneem6427 3 года назад
Look, where I have ended up 😓
@krithikraj7945
@krithikraj7945 3 года назад
Hlo 😅❤
@saubhagyasharma9933
@saubhagyasharma9933 3 года назад
Me 10th
@landofartandcraft8956
@landofartandcraft8956 3 года назад
Me
@sentenced7259
@sentenced7259 8 лет назад
I can see why MIT are keeping chalkboards as opposed to replacing with hi tech. Your chalk skills are amazing. Great lecture too! Thank you.
@dadaimiza
@dadaimiza 4 года назад
Sentenced 🙂
@joslinnick
@joslinnick 4 года назад
Chalk > SmartBoards
@garyoneil2143
@garyoneil2143 2 года назад
Hello once again Dr. Lewin; Your lectures are proving to be a fun and productive learning experience for me. Your passion for physics, your knack for communicating and educating, and the strength of your convictions in the wake of the controversy created surrounding the validity of Kirchoff's Loop Rule, have inspired me to challenge my own understanding of concepts that I've often failed to appreciate. I credit you for empowering and inspiring me to treat both sides of the controversy equally and fairly. It's amazing how so many have attempted to set the record straight and discredit your provocative claim by simply declaring that you are wrong; and then proceed to apply their own spin to the results of your experiment, defending Kirchoff's Loop Rule, and focusing only on your error; while adding nothing toward understanding of the concept of Faraday's law that you were presenting. All of the arguments I've reviewed and studied are convincing enough at describing what we were all taught; but none seem to convey an understanding of your point of view or your presentation, sufficient enough to challenge them. I wasn't looking to be told what I know... or think I know. I was intrigued by the possibility of learning something new. I began dissecting your lecture, hanging on every statement and visual aid presented until I became certain that I understood you every step of the way. At 38:36 in your lecture, you make the statement "So far so good!", and I am in complete agreement with you up to that point, including your corrected Ohms Law equation (at 35:59) up through and including your statement at 40:28 "... and now it's not so simple... because there's no battery." This is where you switch from a conservative model to a non-conservative model, at which point the difference between them becomes quite clear and intuitive. Aside from correcting your Ohm's law error, you never discovered nor took note of it through to the end of your lecture. I'm speculating that the error may have been steering your thinking in the moment and stayed with you; but maybe not. Continuing from 40:28, you follow with "and so now when I go from point D to point A... I don't have the "1" and therefore I now find -0.1 Volts... I find a totally different answer." This is where I became disconnected, and asked myself the question "How can the voltage drop across two resistors be opposite in sign when the current is flowing in only one direction? So I listened further for the answer... As you stated... this is not intuitive. At 44:20 you make the point: "keep in mind that with non-conservative fields, it depends on the path". That statement seems intuitive and clear to me, and I interpret this as the encircling path of the loop with the induced emf flowing in one direction only at all points around the loop; but changing direction in concert with the building and collapsing of the magnetic field that induces the emf in the loop; as observed in your multi-turn loop demonstration using a solenoid and center reading Galvanometer. In the schematic drawing shown in your lecture notes, you correctly show the loop current flowing clockwise inside the loop, with current flow from node D flowing down through R2 and down through voltmeter V2 to node A. On the opposite side of the loop, you correctly show the current flowing up from node A through R1, and up through voltmeter V1 to node D. Missing in your drawing is the polarity of the connected voltmeters. Your schematic is accurate and clearly indicates that the the polarity of the voltmeters, and the voltage drops across R2 and R1 are reversed; as they should be when diametrically opposite the loop from each other with current always flowing around the loop in the same direction. Therefore experimental measurements must observe this convention; with the positive side of voltmeter V2 connected to point D, and the positive side of V1 connected to point A. Assigning the the polarity of the voltmeters, consistent with the convention used in your schematic will show that V1 = + 0.1V, and V2 = +0.9V, with their sum now equal to the 1.0V induced emf in the loop. Your experiment demonstrates and satisfies all of the supporting findings of Oersted, Faraday, Kirchoff, Lenz, and Ohm without conflict. Additionally, it also demonstrates that the validity of Kirchoff's Loop Rule is independent of conservative and non-conservative fields. A slight rearrangment of how the loop is presented, may also make it a bit more intuitive to conceptualize. Unfortunately; I am unable to upload my rearranged schematic drawing to RU-vid. Best wishes and respectful regards; Gary O'Neil
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 2 года назад
Gary I am sorry that you still do not understand this. Do not feel bad, you are not alone; non-conservative fields are not intuitive. Yet they run our entire ecnomy. All the best!
@billyhuntuk
@billyhuntuk 8 лет назад
If everyone had a teacher like you, learning would be not only easy but enjoyable :) Thank you for all your lectures.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
Thank you for your kind words.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@Srikrishnakarthik
@Srikrishnakarthik 4 года назад
@@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 I have been watching your lectures...and You are a true GURU. Namaste.
@Atanu
@Atanu Год назад
Prof Lewin. Your lectures are among the best science lectures ever delivered anywhere. The MIT students were incredibly lucky that they got it live,but thanks to the marvel of the internet, practically anyone anywhere in the world (provided they understand English) can learn from your incredible ability to teach. My deepest respect for you and a deep bow of gratitude.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
thank you!
@siddharth5485
@siddharth5485 9 лет назад
Mr. Lewin, you are a brilliant teacher. I really love your methods of teaching which make Physics extremely interesting to learn. It's a privilege for a young student like me to be watching your lectures. Thank you so much, sir, for uploading them on the web and making it accessible to all.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
+Siddharth Jayshankar Thank you.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@bruceedwards8003
@bruceedwards8003 4 года назад
Wow, I teach electro tech to apprentice electricians, and I found this lecture to be fantastic.I thought for a moment that it was going to get too complicated, but no ,just the opposite. I understood all that was being taught, and while beyond the scope of what I need to teach, this additional knowledge has help me considerably. How lucky we are to have the brilliant teachings available, and I have not have had to pay university fees to get it ! Also I wont feel so bad now when I make errors in my own presented white board calculations !
@AkshaySinghJamwal
@AkshaySinghJamwal 4 года назад
For those that keep saying that you wished he was your teacher when you were younger or whatnot: look at the bright side, that it is possible that he is now a teacher to everybody is a beautiful thing. It's a wonderful time to be alive.
@marianamehrer258
@marianamehrer258 4 года назад
But you can be that teacher as well 😉
@oneperspective8601
@oneperspective8601 3 года назад
Lmaoo 😂😂
@michellewest6929
@michellewest6929 3 года назад
Absolutely! I cry with pure joy watching his passion scream through his lectures!
@kunalk8937
@kunalk8937 3 года назад
THATS GREAT PRIVLEGE WE ARE ENJOYING.
@melchiortod29
@melchiortod29 3 года назад
He is also a very sexy man
@07HDFatboy
@07HDFatboy 8 лет назад
I found your channel by accident, and love how you teach and do your lectures. I am 60 and never went to college. I thought college was going to be like high school. If I had known there were professors like you, I would gone to college instead of going in the navy. Thank you for putting your channel up for us to watch.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
Thanks for your kind words
@dh66
@dh66 6 лет назад
At the shit university I attended, one of my calculus professors only showed up for half his lectures and had only a single intern in his first year of his master's attempting to teach the rest AND "correct" all our homework.
@haroldvalentine3128
@haroldvalentine3128 4 года назад
I was very blessed in that the Navy became my path to multiple degrees: Associates, Bachelors, Masters, and multiple other graduate level degrees and certificates. 10 years as an Enlisted Machinist Mate (made it to Chief before getting my commission). I retired as a Commander with a total of 38 and a half years on Active Duty. And... I am now a GS15 as the Deputy Director, Operations at Naval Supply Systems Command HQ, in Mechanicsburg, PA. My Wife and I truly love our greater Navy Family and we thank you for your service. V/r “TRACER”
@SomeOne-ee3dx
@SomeOne-ee3dx 8 лет назад
He's the real doc from Back to the Future.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@stevedecker4510
@stevedecker4510 5 лет назад
Haha! I was thinking the exact same thing but only a much calmer and low key Doc! How funny! LMFAO!
@CraneKyle-l3v
@CraneKyle-l3v Месяц назад
Sir walter lewin I am in class 10th from India.I was very bad in physics and didn't liked it but because of you I am addicted to physics that even I am now able to understand these topics Thank you very much.And we all students are gglad that we have the greatest teacher of all time.
@eugenenasis2322
@eugenenasis2322 8 лет назад
Lectures with applied demos and derivations are always better than an entire lecture of numerical problems. Great lecture!
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@SiddharthBhatt24
@SiddharthBhatt24 8 лет назад
Our physics teacher shows us clips from your videos since demonstrations are not possible in our tiny classrooms. Needless to say, we're hooked to you
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
super! great teacher
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@dogfiffer8467
@dogfiffer8467 6 лет назад
if your teacher needs to show you this video in class, you might as well stay home and teach yourself with youtube videos.
@Selvyre
@Selvyre 6 лет назад
He probably just shows them the demonstrations if I had to guess, not replacing his own lectures with that of Walter Lewin's, great as they are. When you're in a tiny classroom, demonstrations are hard, so these videos are used to supplement that where demonstrations would take place. I've seen instructors do that in other classes when the room is too small, too. You have to work with what you're dealt.
@marklee1194
@marklee1194 5 лет назад
Same here.
@scienceotherside2000
@scienceotherside2000 3 года назад
Dear Sir, I'm a student of Engineering Physics at Politecnico di Milano. Your lectures are absolutely amazing! You have the power to make people fall in love with Physics. I wish I had you as my Physics professor.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 3 года назад
Wow, thank you!
@kathyfann
@kathyfann 2 года назад
At 66 I have found I love your videos as a beautiful distraction from life in general. Thank you I am no longer bored.
@dennisfahey2379
@dennisfahey2379 Год назад
What a fantastic teacher! His students are very lucky.
@صفاءالنجار-د2ب
@صفاءالنجار-د2ب Год назад
Yep
@pierocahuanovera7899
@pierocahuanovera7899 Год назад
So is
@SahilSingh-u7b
@SahilSingh-u7b Год назад
This legend is growing old 😢 if he dies the world will miss a genius.
@Voidy123
@Voidy123 11 месяцев назад
My old physics teacher was this passionate, I loved physics and because of him I do not stand confused looking at something that seems like magic, in my head I'm thinking of all the laws of thermodynamics and try to figure out where the magic comes from.
@neelwaghmare8773
@neelwaghmare8773 5 лет назад
When you teach,I don't feel like you're teaching a subject but teaching reality and truths.
@nachoImagine
@nachoImagine 8 лет назад
Not all heroes wear capes. Thanks a lot! Regards from Argentina.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@manbeefcake
@manbeefcake 6 лет назад
Some capes are bathrobes
@sudeshsharma9395
@sudeshsharma9395 5 лет назад
Who say hero wear caps
@dolphinwarrior2535
@dolphinwarrior2535 4 года назад
this is the best youtube comment of all time. i love it! i will use this line too! and credit you. cheers mate!
@amirali2759
@amirali2759 4 года назад
Entire physics world is dependent on your lectures. In other words not only the students sitting before you are learning. Your lecture videos are seen by rest of the world
@samarattia7347
@samarattia7347 4 года назад
Physics is very easy to understand with your lectures professor.
@Ranjeetajaipal
@Ranjeetajaipal Месяц назад
🤩🤩 yes
@hrishitasurve3975
@hrishitasurve3975 4 года назад
Now I think I'll be addicted to the sir's lectures, truly great and amazing to learn!!!
@FTheG
@FTheG 4 года назад
funny that some students are not satisfied with this kind of lectures... I find them inspiring and so clear! I wish I had such kind of teachers at university...
@JH-ux1re
@JH-ux1re 2 года назад
I’m in physics 2 this semester. I wish I could have such a professor! Now I have to study on my own by watching helpful videos. I never watch TV, instead I watch RU-vid a lot. This video is so fun!
@kneD-e
@kneD-e 2 года назад
Hey can you explain me what's normal physics and physics ll in college? I am in high school and have studied this already
@francescopaolociminale5258
@francescopaolociminale5258 Год назад
I'm an ignorant human being. This guy is the teacher that if he was at the right place and time in my life, now I was an astronaut . Well done. The world needs more teachers like you. 🙋‍♂️Greetings from Tuscany .
@bhuvi_78
@bhuvi_78 Год назад
I’m a class 12 student from India, and I have all the topics covered here in my JEE syllabus. The lecture was truly very interesting and helpful. Thanks a lot sir ❤
@raghurammahale7338
@raghurammahale7338 6 лет назад
Why hasn't someone given this legend the noble prize
@Aman-vb6mf
@Aman-vb6mf 3 года назад
Sir I am your biggest biggest biggest fan ........... Your teaching are very great ..... although I am in 11th , but I never intend to miss your lecture.......... Meeting you is my dream 🤩🤩.....❤️❤️love you sir❤️❤️
@randallegendre7342
@randallegendre7342 Год назад
I'm an Eddy current and Remote Field tech and this helped me understand the theory side of my job. Thank you.
@Shehaib
@Shehaib 8 месяцев назад
Sir, what an amazing teacher you are, i'll never forget this lecture❤
@YdvSyAero
@YdvSyAero 4 года назад
Dear sir ,your lectures plus demonstrations is too much awesome and make the student to much excited for physics .Keep it continue sir .love from INDIA
@sefinternal743
@sefinternal743 7 лет назад
amazing my man. I'm going to be an atmospheric scientist, I love your lectures, love how you teach, and it's very fun to learn.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
:)
@DellConagher1
@DellConagher1 6 месяцев назад
Its incredible that anyone can talk to a highly qualified person like and get a response at the comfort of their homes. Thank you
@earfors
@earfors 5 лет назад
Walter Lewin; such a beautiful mind, great teacher, and he tells it as it is (as currently known). Love him!
@jimmyday656
@jimmyday656 3 года назад
Yes just like a Beautiful Mind.
@littlerhino2006
@littlerhino2006 3 года назад
It's amazing that such high-level lectures are available for free. Thank you for posting.
@stuartkerr1012
@stuartkerr1012 8 лет назад
These videos gave me a better education and a genuine love of physics that the education system nearly beat out of me.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
That's what MIT is good at!
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@0623kaboom
@0623kaboom 6 лет назад
LOL I enjoy the electronics refresher TBH ... since 90% of electronics is Physics the rest is just Murphy's law ;) lol
@MariaLopez-dc7mx
@MariaLopez-dc7mx 3 года назад
I'm not one of those who can easily talk about phisics, but I found myself watching these lectures and I discovered an amazing world.
@hafizzulqarnain5379
@hafizzulqarnain5379 4 года назад
Actually all this stuff is experimental. Professor makes it interesting with his demonstration. God bless you sir. You are a great teacher .
@mr.physics6707
@mr.physics6707 4 года назад
Your method of teaching is very high....your lactures are so entertaining and increasing my curiosity to learn physics....thank u professor...
@ManojAcharya
@ManojAcharya 2 года назад
Yours concept and way of teaching is so Clear and 90% Students can understand ❤️ legendary work💖 Lots of love sir from Nepal🇳🇵😊💖
@X90d3
@X90d3 8 дней назад
I am a sixth-year science student from Iraq and I thank you for your excellent explanation. I benefited from it ♥️
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 6 дней назад
you are most welcome
@Scientist1642
@Scientist1642 5 лет назад
The whole Incident with ElectroBOOM was so amusing. I'm happy it happened just before I watched this lecture. Understanding the confusion helped me to digest the topic better. So thank you Dr Lewin and ElectroBoom. :)
@soniyakhatri3451
@soniyakhatri3451 3 года назад
I too am watching this video right after electroboom
@sankarguha9205
@sankarguha9205 4 года назад
My respect to you, Sir. Knowledge is always heavenly!
@danielmadden6882
@danielmadden6882 4 месяца назад
Thank you for leaving in the portion about student complaints. As a teacher, it's helpful to remember that even the best of us can't be perfect for everybody. You are an amazing teacher and you inspire many people.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 4 месяца назад
it is shocking that countless people have misconceptions about Faraday's Law. Even more shocking that the authors of most college books also have no clue (including Giancoli the book I used for 8.02).
@norbertkramer8433
@norbertkramer8433 4 года назад
The best lectures on physics I've ever seen. (I studied physics in Germany and I am a retired teacher now.)
@DJGravitydose
@DJGravitydose 4 года назад
36:02 ......made me remember that anythings possible! I absolutely love all of Walters lectures!
@mathapplication
@mathapplication 4 года назад
😅 I have a lab due next month by watching this video you’ve clarified a lot of things. Thank you 🤗
@beasthunt
@beasthunt 3 года назад
THIS is how you teach a class. Give real world examples beside your theory.
@abhishekgourav6144
@abhishekgourav6144 4 года назад
At MIT : WHAT!! homework too long?? Ok i cut out 2 questions u do only 7 At Schools : WHAT!! homework too long?? Ok rewrite it 2 times and from tomorrow 10 questions instead of 8 + detention+ guardian call+1 week suspension+ 10 point deducted from you final grades for complaining...
@Speed001
@Speed001 3 года назад
That's college vs school.
@sahilsagwekar
@sahilsagwekar 3 года назад
@@Speed001 that's the world vs india
@hardeoupadhyay3792
@hardeoupadhyay3792 3 года назад
@@sahilsagwekar If you don't know let me tell you There are so many countries where the school system is like this and more worst than India.
@krnmani
@krnmani 3 года назад
@@hardeoupadhyay3792 I agree with you . Eg.china ,south korea..
@ThomasJoseph315
@ThomasJoseph315 3 года назад
I wish I could take his courses. I'd love it!
@fc2p
@fc2p 3 года назад
Awesome! It takes an extraordinary professor to make this material fun and interesting. Good job.
@thekidmagician7920
@thekidmagician7920 3 года назад
Sir, you are an excellent teacher and educating thousands of people everyday. I pray to God that I'll meet you in future. Thank You so much sir 👍
@Bigboss-yl1vv
@Bigboss-yl1vv 7 лет назад
sir your teaching is the best teaching in the world
@rajat1960
@rajat1960 4 года назад
Professor you never fail to amaze me.... Lots of love for saving my exams
@AndreyAntonchik
@AndreyAntonchik 8 лет назад
Go to 5:00 for actual lecture.
@MrPotatoGamer
@MrPotatoGamer 8 лет назад
thanks
@unicorngamer_99
@unicorngamer_99 8 лет назад
thanks yo
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@mr.anonymous8401
@mr.anonymous8401 5 лет назад
Thank bro for Saving our time
@shahrozkhan8809
@shahrozkhan8809 5 лет назад
Thanks !!
@angelamolnarpemberton5145
@angelamolnarpemberton5145 3 года назад
I’m not quite sure how or why this showed up in my feed but I can’t stop watching this man teaching. I hated school. My mother had exited me out of school in the 2nd week of 8th grade so I actually have no idea what this man is saying but I still can’t stop watching him teach this. Apparently I need to be watching him so ok I’m subbing him and now apparently getting my learn on once again. Lol. But seriously I like this man and how he teaches. I would have really enjoyed having him as a teacher when I was in school. 😊
@imaginative-monkey
@imaginative-monkey 6 лет назад
0:33 "If you are very unhappy with your recitation instructor, you are complete IDIOTS, if you stay in that recitation!" I truly love this!
@Rayquesto
@Rayquesto 4 года назад
"Some are better than others... that's the way it goes in life" 0:55
@frreinov
@frreinov 8 лет назад
"Concepts is what matters." (3:16)
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@oguzhanyanik5435
@oguzhanyanik5435 3 года назад
I always find myself in these videos, very good job. Thanks to you, we understand and love physics too
@rauledom
@rauledom 3 года назад
Another outstanding lecture. As an electrical engineer who has worked with transformers, this lecture has helped me to answer one question that was not clearly answered, where is the transformed voltage? It is electromagnetics explained in a concise, simple but powerful way. God bless you Professor !
@Nocturnes1984
@Nocturnes1984 7 лет назад
Dr. Emmett Brown, could you PLEASE take me back to the future so that I can come to your classes in real life...
@stavehow5501
@stavehow5501 7 лет назад
The oscilloscopes form a second conductive loop around the energizing coil. Although an oscilloscope is concidered to be a voltage measuring device, in this case they are measuring the current that flows in a clockwise direction around the loop that they form. The righthand oscilloscope see's current flowing into its positive terminal, the leftthand oscilloscope see's current flowing into its negitive terminal and so shows a mirror image. The different amplitude of the two displayed waveforms is caused by the different values of the resistors in parallel with the one megohm resistance of each oscilloscope. If you simply move one oscilloscope to the other side of the coil without changing the connection points of that oscilloscope, both oscilloscopes will now display the same waveform.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
what you wrote is correct. The fact remains that 2 identical voltmeters attached the the SAME 2 points in a circuit can read VERY different values and that's because of Faraday's Law. This shows that Kirchhoff's loop rule cannot be applied here.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@RWoody1995
@RWoody1995 5 лет назад
@@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 But the two voltmeters are *NOT* attached to the same 2 points in the circuit if one meter is connected correctly and the other is connected incorrectly. The ends of the wires leading up to the meter are not necessarily at the same potential as the terminals of the measurement device inside the meter!
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@@RWoody1995 you are mistaken. the wires have zero resistance. In the case of an induced emf the potentials in a circuit are no longer determined, they depend on the path and thus *Kirchhoff's Loop Rule is not valid.* Kirchhoff's Loop Rule is a special case of Faraday's Law (namely when phi/dt=0). Thus *Faraday's Law is always valid.* The following videos may help you to understand this. This is very basic Physics I will therefore not argue with anyone about this. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-f3-SfzepuPs.html*LOcvkaSY-IZqheFYM5 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5be3zpj_eCY.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-wz_GqO-Urk4.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@nomadr1349
@nomadr1349 5 лет назад
@@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 Well, those voltmeters, though connected to the same points, HAVE to stay on opposing sides of the solenoid. Thus, voltmeter on the right forms closed loop with the resistor on the left, with solenoid inside this loop, whereas voltmeter on the left forms a loop with the resistor on the right, again with solenoid INSIDE this loop. Thus, strictly speaking, those are NOT identical voltmeters, what each of them shows depends on where exactly around the solenoid it is placed and how the wires are laid down, not just where they are connected. If you place both of them, let say, on top of the assembly right on the solenoid axis and far away, put all wires bundled, well, then they will show the same values.
@follow_fraser3081
@follow_fraser3081 8 лет назад
I think we should replace all schools and shitty teachers with youtube videos on topics. The good teachers will make there money from RU-vid views, the shitty teachers will disappear and we won't waste our money with a shit education. This was a great lecture! Thank you so much!
@markrudis305
@markrudis305 7 лет назад
just remember that kids need empathy and companion, and not only super awesome teachers ,
@Uncertaintycat
@Uncertaintycat 7 лет назад
I can't ask youtube questions unfortunately.
@alexluthorkos5252
@alexluthorkos5252 7 лет назад
But you can learn to search Google and response by yourself any question.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
:)
@Noogleminus
@Noogleminus 7 лет назад
Feruhlphox I could see a good place for such an idea. Schools could post all of their classroom sessions and the schools received the proceeds. The benefits: the schools would have more money to pay their teachers, as well as buying content and supplies. The schools would have a higher incentive to seek out and promote higher quality instructors. Schools would be better able to monitor their instructor's performance. Teachers would have more incentive to be better. Students would have access to lectures when their out (sickness, etc). Students would also need to behave (or the world would see them act a fool).
@harbhajansinghjoia790
@harbhajansinghjoia790 4 года назад
Greatest thing i found here is..to watch this lecture being a agriculture student...who dont have any connection with physics😎 Love to watch your lectures sir🙋🏻‍♂️
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 4 года назад
So nice of you
@yuanyi827
@yuanyi827 4 года назад
Great lecture!I love your demo at the end of this lecture! I have taken 18.02 before 8.02,I think it was a right choice.Because I have fully understood the word potential,non-/conservative field. I learned a lot from this lecture.Thank you prof.Lewin.😁
@jamesseth8149
@jamesseth8149 4 года назад
I love your way of teaching sir, thank you for sharing your knowledge
@hamidkh5488
@hamidkh5488 4 года назад
I wish I had a teacher like you in high school. Thank you Walter
@paulhughes7848
@paulhughes7848 14 дней назад
I'm nearly 50 only got the bug of physics don't understand the maths but. I understand the concepts from the cmb to the quarks down from atoms ..just wish I'd have known this when I was young but my high school teachers never inspired me ,your amazing Mr Lewin thanks
@naturelover9994
@naturelover9994 3 года назад
No words for your hardwork.... Great work👌👌👌
@iamarpitpatidar
@iamarpitpatidar Год назад
He's the man. I mean really he explains one of the most complex topics like a piece of cake.
@pankajrana3412
@pankajrana3412 Год назад
Is this is complex topic then Britishers is very duffers
@justanotaku209
@justanotaku209 Год назад
The concept were made just so clear
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
This is the most difficult and most important lecture of my E&M course (8.02) at MIT. I have opened the eyes of many who could at first not believe that 2 voltmeters attached the *the same 2 points in a circuit* can read *very different values with reversed polarity.* Look at my demo 51 min into the lecture. I show the voltage curves of the 2 voltmeters as the electromagnet changes the B-field. My time resolution was about 0.1 milli sec. There are still countless people who still cannot believe it. *However, believing is a religion; this is science.*
@justanotaku209
@justanotaku209 Год назад
@@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 Thank you sir, for sharing these amazing videos. Always grateful
@noor-ul-huda.hobbies
@noor-ul-huda.hobbies Год назад
@@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 sir I have no words for you, from 🇵🇰 🇵🇰 Pakistan
@marif4654
@marif4654 3 года назад
i am watching/enjoying these videos ...a medical student....
@gae_mon
@gae_mon 5 лет назад
You’re very good in explaining all these simple physics, and with your heart, you may find a way to explain what it should be in zero point energy field accessing anti-gravity technology that still hidden to you.
@arundhatighule7020
@arundhatighule7020 2 года назад
Whyyyy!? theoretical physics always sacrificed for technology!?
@aaryadeshpande96
@aaryadeshpande96 2 года назад
"Kirchoff is for the birds" truer words have never been spoken
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 2 года назад
It's very true. There is never any need to use KVL. You can *ALWAYS* use Faraday's. That's why it is 1 of the 4 Maxwell's eqs and KVL is not.
@getrekt7989
@getrekt7989 5 лет назад
5:25 is changing electromagnetic field
@outrospection4all
@outrospection4all 4 года назад
these lectures are priceless, elegantly presented, informative and yet entertaining! i truly love this man.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 4 года назад
Much appreciated!
@outrospection4all
@outrospection4all 4 года назад
@@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 Thanks very much to you :) I hope your lectures stay online forever available.
@ayamustafa98_
@ayamustafa98_ Год назад
I started loving physics thank to sir I am student in 3 secondary from Egypt l hope l will be amazed like you prof💙💪👏👏
@eriniramzy
@eriniramzy Год назад
Ooooooohhh, I'm Egyptian too😂❤❤
@ayamustafa98_
@ayamustafa98_ Год назад
@@eriniramzy nice to see your comment 😂💙💙
@malakshebl8614
@malakshebl8614 Год назад
i love how there are other 3rd sec egyptian students that watch mit lectures i thought i was the only one ahahha! rabena ma3ako
@____AnuragGupta____
@____AnuragGupta____ Год назад
I think Egypt is a desert with old historical monument only😂
@explorerCoolGuy
@explorerCoolGuy 3 года назад
Your teaching methodology has enabled me to discover beauty of Physics in a brilliant way👌👍
@ursdevesh4390
@ursdevesh4390 3 года назад
Doing revision with your lecture improving my physics ❤️❤️
@timothysmith3311
@timothysmith3311 9 месяцев назад
Thank you for helping me understand classic motorcycle electrical systems. Understanding the pure fundamentals removes mental blocks that prevent us from learning.
@roboboyaarushkhanna8199
@roboboyaarushkhanna8199 5 лет назад
Thank you sir for your great lecture and unmatched demonstration
@srijankapoor7449
@srijankapoor7449 Год назад
Professor I am wondering that the slybus or content you are providing in MIT is just same as that we study for IIT JEE exam. And I could see that the way your are expressing knowledge is incredible❤. I would also like to ask weather I should watch these lectures or not for my preparation?
@dawrin-tm9pr
@dawrin-tm9pr Год назад
Only basics are covered jee requires higher use of calculus in physics
@YourEditingMaster
@YourEditingMaster 7 месяцев назад
Why i didn't study by these teacher😮😮😮😢😢
@andyalice6673
@andyalice6673 Год назад
always found it so mindboggling...... Thanks Professor.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
My pleasure!
@tehyonglip9203
@tehyonglip9203 8 лет назад
Great lecture! that demo really blew my mind, i will show it to my grandchildren!
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
That's very cool, but I doubt whether your grandchildren will appreciate how mind-boggling this demo is.
@RajaaKahel
@RajaaKahel 8 лет назад
You made me less afraid of laws! Great teacher!
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
+Rajaa Kahel Nice
@neelimeshduarah1054
@neelimeshduarah1054 Год назад
There'll also be an induced emf in the circuit which when added to the other potential differences through the resistors should add up to zero ensuring that KVL holds.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
Don't feel embarrassed if this physics is above your level; you are not alone. Non-conservative E-fields are not taught in high schools. I demonstrated at the end of my lecture #16 of my 8.02 E&M course at MIT that two identical voltmeters attached to the same 2 points in a circuit can show very different values. ru-vid.com://ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-nGQbA2jwkWI.html This can also be demonstrated with a transformer. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html *In fact, look more closely at my circuit; it is a transformer. My closed loop is the secondary winding (only 1 winding) of a transformer and the primary windings are in my electromagnet.* The reason is that an induced EMF (Faraday's Law) creates a non-conservative E field. This means that moving a test charge between the same 2 points in a circuit can require a different amount of energy (even with opposite signs!). You still aren't getting any energy for free, because it comes from the source of the time-varying magnetic field. When a voltmeter reads a value V it means that the integral of E dot dL across the voltmeter is V. In cases where Kirchhoff's loop rule (KVL) applies, 2 voltmeters attached to the same 2 points in a circuit will always show the same value. Kirchhoff's original text can be found in the following link, pages 497-514: books.google.de/books?id=Ig8t8yIz20UC. Clearly he was fully aware of the prerequisite for his "loop rule". KVL is a special case of Faraday's Law. That's why Faraday's Law is one of Maxwell's equations and KVL is not. My demo was first suggested and published by Romer in December 1982 in the American Journal of Physics. This demo has now become a classic; it's done all over the world at many colleges and universities. *ElectroBOOM and Dirk Van Meirvenne believe that 2 voltmeters attached to the same 2 points in a circuit must always show the same value which is not true.* It's quite embarrassing that they each posted a video on their channel in which they claim to have proof for their wrong ideas. Also read Professor John Belcher's thoughts on Faraday's Law and on KVL. Professor Belcher is my former colleague at MIT. freepdfhosting.com/0813df09f5.pdf *ElectroBOOM insulted me in his video by mentioning that the reason why my 2 voltmeters read different values was due to "bad probing". He stated that if I had done the demo correctly both voltmeters would have read the same value. He could not have been more wrong.* The following video may also help some of you to understand why 2 voltmeters attached to the same 2 points in a circuit can give very different readings. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-LGdN7rDB3XE.html
@anupammondal9511
@anupammondal9511 7 лет назад
you are a very interesting person to me as very few teachers i have seen , are as typical as you are and your method of teaching very much impressed me , i am considered to be lucky to able to observe your videos .
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
:)
@anupammondal9511
@anupammondal9511 7 лет назад
But i dont understand why the relative velocity between a closed wire and a magnet can produce electric energy ? Is it intermolecular phenomenom or what ??
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
F=q(E + VXB). a single charge moving with velocity V in a B field experiences a VxB force (cross product). It is one of the consequences of Einstein's SR bcoz B-fields are the result of SR. Use google.
@anupammondal9511
@anupammondal9511 7 лет назад
thanks
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
You can see a similar spectacular demo (by someone else) here ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b7i2uMx7gHo.html
@samrathbery7101
@samrathbery7101 8 лет назад
Amazing lecture sir.....it really helped a lot
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
thanks
@ayangattani
@ayangattani 4 года назад
Thank you sir I am a class 10 student and I wish to enter the IIT and your videos have really helped me and my buddies.
@jamesmoore5630
@jamesmoore5630 Год назад
When I was a child; "Dr. Julius Summner Millner," had a physics show on PBS, and he did lots of experiments and that is when I started to love physics. I enjoy your show, and the heck with the math you teach physics!!! Show us something cool not hard!!!
@priyanshukr8091
@priyanshukr8091 2 года назад
I've come here just for Practical knowledge not for Rattafication before my Class 10 CBSE exam 😇
@ppr2005
@ppr2005 3 года назад
Sir I am a class 10th student in India.Here I have enrolled in a institute to guide me to get in IIT colleges.They are not able to explain Lenz law to me so I thought to search for it on youtube and found your video.I knew you from 2 years and thought that it might be difficult for me to understand it but it was quite easy.
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259
@lecturesbywalterlewin.they9259 3 года назад
SUPER Faraday's Law is not easy. Many people who took some physics courses do not have a deep understanding of F's Law and thus have misconceptions about it.
@tanishkarwekar4698
@tanishkarwekar4698 3 года назад
These lectures helped me to understand "How Physics is Beautiful ✨❤"
@Bhartiya.47
@Bhartiya.47 Год назад
lee me*- preparing for JEE (entrance test for IIT) by an MIT professor`s lectures💫 .... though he is a legend!❤
@oladeledemilade1615
@oladeledemilade1615 8 месяцев назад
You are the best teacher Sir
@pathapativarshitha1780
@pathapativarshitha1780 2 года назад
this lecture has helped me so much in preparing for my a level physics, thank you so much
@child9125
@child9125 2 года назад
I'm doing the same thing here haha
@ThomasElenye
@ThomasElenye Год назад
I really like your presentation. May God bless you with more wisdom and knowledge to continue opening our minds.
Далее
How 3 Phase Power works: why 3 phases?
14:41
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Can The Faraday Paradox Be Solved?
9:20
Просмотров 1,7 млн
Lenz's Law
15:54
Просмотров 6 млн
The Big Misconception About Electricity
14:48
Просмотров 23 млн
World's Strongest Magnet!
23:05
Просмотров 13 млн
Does Kirchhoff's Law Hold? Disagreeing with a Master
13:21
The Test That Terence Tao Aced at Age 7
11:13
Просмотров 4,3 млн
😍Вышла iOS 18! ЛУЧШИЕ Фишки🔥
0:54
Китайцы сделали телефон БАЯН
0:14