9. Umar denies Prophet Muhammad pen & paper on his deathbed | S. Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 

Justifying Umars actions is the biggest destruction to the religion of islam.

"Im Shia because of this video" 😂 alhamdulilah

Alhamdullilah I became Shia, I cannot follow Sunni Islam due to the fact that their scholars give the most bizarre views and responses. The more I read, the more I hear Sunni scholars, the more I see Sunni RU-vidrs refuting the Shia or in fact refuting the Holy Prophet Muhammad PBUH and His family the more I want to stay Shia. SubahanAllah

I'm hearing new things since i embrace islam 15 years ago and it is really interesting and depressing at the same time. This speaker is a one man army and i salute him for his knowledge and bravery.

I was raised as a Sunni, but i always had a soft spot for the Shia especially when I hear Sunni's referring to them as non muslim. My first encounter with Shia doctrine was with Imam Khomeini RA revolution. Thereafter I started reading books of great Shia scholars and I began to develop a deep respect for the Shia. Now i consider myself a Shia. I thank you for this wonderful program where you proof your arguments with Sunni literature. I look forward to your videos - Cape Town South Africa

Prophet’s daughter was unhappy and Umar was not allowed to come to the funeral of the daughter of the Prophet. Isn’t that enough for you!!

After watching these lectures, how on earth can you call yourself a SUNNI? This man has proven hadiths from your own books, clear as day, yet if you still go back to practicing Sunni Islam and hating the shia then you have no hope. Alhamdulillah I am shia till the day I die!!!

About a year ago, Allah swt instilled in me the love of Ahlul Bayt (AS), after only reading a few ahadith about how one should revere them. I always used to question, why, from the khutbas I've been attending all my life, never have I heard of the mention of Ahlul Bayt (AS), let alone a praise. Today, I am eternally grateful to Allah swt as he increased my knowledge over the days and he made me turn towards the path of Ahlul Bayt (AS) entirely. To Sayyedna, many prayers for you, and especially prayers of protection for you. May Allah swt bless you and honor you and raise you and all of us with Muhammad and Aal e Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon them) on the day of Qiyamah! Alhumdulillah for Shia' Islam.

The miserable catastrophe of Gaza and the silence of the people of Deen surely shows how they treated the Nabi Mohammed SAW and Ahlebait. 😢

Masterclass, "that's why I'm shia"... Well said 👏

If omar is able to tell the prophet that the quran is enough, I'm surprised ppl don't say their shahada with omar as prophet

i was sunni and after researching and going through the hadiths alhamdulilah i have found the true path of islam and i am a proud shia

This was plain and simple, easy and proven

Sayyed Ammar has been waiting for this moment his entire life 🥳🎉

Assim al hakeem defended umar, lanat on Assim al hakeem) In order to defend umar, hakeem said Prophet Muhammad PBUH was not of sound mind ". So Umar did ijtihad over Prophet Muhammad PBUH 🤔🤐. what kind of islam is this 😑 so this hadith [4234] claifies that still today both bloddline are alive fighting & argiung. Umar followers and Prophet Muhammad PBUH - Ali followers. Musnad bin hanbal Vol 3: H 2990 - mentions what a Thursday.... what a thursday!. Umar says "what's a matter with him, is he delirious" . After saying such a thing can we consider umar a muslim? i want to ask this question to all slafis and sunnis. personaly, i was a sunni, but I dont revere people who call my PBUH delirioious. I dont even considr umar a muslim now. But we are in 2024, why an average man read these hadith themselves because wahabi sheikhs & salafi speakers muhammad wahab, wahabi muhammad salah, mufti menk, zakir naik, and this Assim al hakeem would either not mentioned those above haidth or try to defend them, but the question is can we consider Assim al hakeem muslim after indirectlly call Prophet Muhammad PBUH delirious and tried to defned umar. S Muslim. vol 4: p.367. [4234], S Bukhari Vol 6: [4845] p.316 & Musnad bin hanbal Vol 3: H 2990. Well done to Nakshawani. Ammar exhibited exceptional intellect and integrity in dismantling both the wrongdoer 9umar) and their defender ( Assim) through compelling arguments and evidence, leading to a decisive and fair conclusion, devoid of prejudice. His prowess in logical reasoning and ethical clarity shines brilliantly. well done 👍

"O believers! Do not raise your voices above the voice of the Prophet, nor speak loudly to him as you do to one another,1 or your deeds will become void while you are unaware." Umar did exactly that. And not only during this particular event, but in many others too. He would raise his voice over the Prophet, say backhanded comments, mock the Prophet etc. What an absolute coward.

Became Shia again after watching thins video… Thanks god we are not stupid to believe their stories

SALAM BROTHER SAYED AMMAAR YOU HAVE ABSOLUTELY MADE CLEAR FOR EVEN THE BLIND TO SEE YET THERE ARE THOSE WITH EYES THAT DONT WANT TO SEE LABBAYK YA RASULULLAAH SAAWAWS

Meanwhile Sunni Muftees, It's Haraam to listen to SHIA scholars

Battle of Jamal is indeed still in play. And we will win again Ya Ali a.s.Madad.

[Sahih al-Bukhari 3714] Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Fatima is a part of me, and he who makes her angry, makes me angry."

I have always told people the sunnies would not want lose their empire even if it meant disrespect to the prophet

It’s crazy because as a believer you want to go to heaven. If the prophet pbuh is saying give me a pen because he wants to write something that will help me !!! I would run and get a pen.

I am a revert many years now and I live in an Arab country , when they find out what I follow they are laughing and mocking on me , when I give them answers why I follow prophet Mohamed and his family and is from Allah to follow the Quran and prophet Mohamed and his family their answers is for them is enough the Quran so no need to argue what is Sunnah , specially when I refer to their books what is mention in their own books ! Many times I feel like I talk to blind deaf and dumb people same way Allah had mentioned in the verse in the Quran ! So now I just stopped to talk to these people that are mocking on me and slander me behind my back ! I will ignore them , In the beginning was so hard to be around them and see how much hatred they have in their eyes and hearts and how bad they talk ! But now surely I understand why is like that ! I thank Allah that he guided me to be a Shia ! Each single day I am grateful for this gift and I will not stop sharing the knowledge, no matter what ! ( one more thing , we might not follow the same leaders and have different opinions about them but surely we don’t slander and mock on you as Muslims Brothers even if you follow them which is way different than your behavior towards us ! ) may Allah guide people during this Ramadan to what is just and what is right , even if you have to loose the entire worldly life for this ! Amin

I am shia but have never heard this incident. I always had a positive and optimistic view towards Sunnies. But this lecture changed my mindset completely. How a Muslim can respect this person?! How do they learn their deen from Sheikh Aseem Alhakim? How? How?

The calamity of thursday....oh what a thursday 😢😢😢

I am so grateful that Allah guided me to the two weighty things, which is following the book of Allah and teachings of the Ahlul Bayt, may peace be upon them all.

alhamdulillah for being shia everyday

My dear brother please do not turn off the comments on your videos. Let the corrupt be exposed of the wicked words they like to use so freely.

اللهم صلي على محمد وال محمد وعجل فرجهم الشريف. I feel pity for the so-called al-sunnah who out of lack of knowledge have the effrontery to put him on the same level with Imam Ali (s.w.a) May Allah bless you Dr for increasing our knowledge about Umar bin Khatab.

19:16 as I always say SAN is an epitome of class and knowledge... He is setting the history straight... InshaAllah more people will be guided by his hard work and ALLAH swt will reward Sayed in this dunia and akhira...

Every lecture of this series I watch and all lectures and videos of Sayed Ammar reinforces why I am a Shia and why the sunni clearly have no idea what they are talking about and make up lie after lie to cover the last lie and then contradict their previous lie 😂 Accept the truth and change your destiny, stop being stubborn because in the end your judgement is going to be with Allah and you cannot lie anymore on that day. Sayed Ammar you are the best most intellectual most respected person to be teaching the Deen in this current generation InshaAllah my family and i have an opportunity to meet you and thank you in person. You have no idea how you have impacted my life with your lectures, now I know how to raise my children and how to teach them the CORRECT ISLAM! THANK YOU MASHALLAH MAY ALLAH PROTECT YOU AND GRANT YOU JANNAH 🤲🏽

Umar fleed the battle like a mountain goat as he said.he whipped a man to death because of drinking wine. He exposed a pregnant woman to a fear that caused women to have miscarreg. He was about to kill someone in accusation of Zina, and if ali ibn abi Talib wasn't there to save her, according to the Quran, an innocent would be killed. He farted during prayer. He didn't know how to do tayamom. He accused the prophet of saying nonsense(in contrast to the quran). He couldn't answer the question of other religions' scholars. Someone drank from his bottle and got drunk. He had naked woman as servant. His father was his father grandfather and uncle and his mother was his mother, sister, and aunt(he was son of a very complicated Zina and incest!!!!!!!!!!).he killed the daughter and grandson of the prophet. In a letter that he wrote to Mo'aviyah, he said I kicked Fatimah in a way that I heard the sound of his ribs get broken. In the presence of the prophet, he was insisting to spread the world of jews and Christians, and the prophet got angry at him and told him that if Musa and Isa were at my time they would listen to me and obey me. As ibn e Abel Hadid said he was a very angry scary man. We all must answer to God in other world.

Brother only GOD knows how much your video worths. Thank you and GOD bless you.

Sayed, please make a lecture on "attack on house of Lady Zahra s.a "

I am Shia because of this video

One of the best discussions, crystal clear for any human kind 👏🏻 👏🏻 Sayed Ammar Nakshawani truly deserves the most Courageous World Award of the year wallahi ❤❤❤❤

God bless you! We need more discussions like this in an era when we have a flood of misleading information

Bless you Syed! Proud to be Shia of Mola Ali as...Haq Haider!

May allah bless you sayed ammar ❤

May Allah & Ahlul bayt(as) bless Sayed Ammar 🤲

Alhamdulillah I am shia💕

May Allah and His Prophet and His family protect you Syed!!! May Allah protect you… prayers for your well being

SubhanaAllah brilliant programme. I hope you include in this series, the companion in the cave

Thank you Sayed Ammar! You are providing strength to all of us who have converted from Sunni to Shia

please make an episode explaining how the Shia prayer's way is the right way according to you and if it mentioned in Sunnah books?

Alhamduillah, the light of Shi’ism and love of Ahlul Bayt (AS) are rising and rapidly being embraced despite all the oppression, suppression, subjugation and misinformation against it. The truth will always prevail in the end!

Big Shout out to my guy @Faridresponds for his failed attempt to refute this lecture with his 10 minute video 5 references in his bedroom 🔫🔫.

That’s called bulldozing Sunni rhetorics

I really appreciate that Syed Ammar started with tafsir of the Hujurat verses from the Sahih. Thoroughly planted the roots of his argument. No doubt at all that Umar ibn Khattab had wasted away any of his good deeds by the time the Rasul and his Daughter passed away from this earth. This is supported precisely by the Hujurat verses. Pay attention. This is a trial for the majority of Muslims. Ijtihad cannot include over-ruling the Messenger of Allah at his face. There's no such ijtihad.

It was about time that the followers of ahlul bayt made videos like this. Anyone dare to refute the sheykh???

Finished!

Another great lecture by Syed Ammar Sir highlighting an important hadith which sunni brothers always run away from. Kindly share it with our sunni brothers and sisters so that they will come to know the truth and the bitter reality of the so called Caliphs.

786 Bravo, dear Sayed, bravissimo! 👏👏👏Shukar Mowla! I always marvel at your capacity to always bring in new information, details that we have not heard before in your previous lectures... Mash'Allah! Stay that way, Sayed, stay that way. May Allah continue to protect you, protect your memory (ability to remember facts, details...), keep your honour safe, preserve you from the evil eye, grant you much satisfaction in your work, grant you much health and increase your knowledge still. Aameen. Do look after yourself, Sayed. We need you! Your frankness may cause much hostility towards you... May the Most High keep you safe. Aameen. Ask your admin team to enter "Aameen" after the numerous dua that so many of us enter for you here!

Hamdillah I was born Shia ❤️❤️

In order to understand or be able to discern Omar's fault, in this Hadith, it is a condition that one has to be familiarized with and believe the concept of Isma (Infallibility).

30 days of these lectures are not enough. Please continue to discuss these crucial points. Ramadhan has not ended but I’m saddened to think these eye opening discussions will come to an end 😢. May Allah give you more, Syed 🙏🏻

If you look at Asim Al Hakeem from far away he looks like a Devil

Mashallah

Being called Rafidhi is much better than being called Ömer'i..

Beautiful lecture!Just did a video on this too 😮👍

That's why im shia also 😂

Syed Ammar love your sarcasm witty replies

Alhamdullilah im Shia ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

I'm a shia because of this video 😄

Ammar Nakswanni have put his life in danger with this series May Allah Protect him and should be always protected in public or inside mosques because exposing Sunni belief in their own books will get you suicide bombers or Jahidis.

Most sunnies don't know this

How DARE Umar denies the Prophet (PBUP) anything? How DARE Umar tells the Prophet (PBUH) “ DO NOT DO THAT “. Butthen its Umar who kicked Hazrat Fatima AS.

33:27, The best part!

Beautiful explanations Allah bless you Syeed keep it up.

Imam ali never raised voiced or disrespected prophet. For example. Imam ali knocked on the door where prophet was inside, SAW said who is it. Imam ali as says it is “i” Muhammad knew it was ali but got furious because of the way ali is presenting himself and his greeting. Which then ali got scared and never said i again and learnt the ways of greetings from prophet muhammad and how he needs to present himself as a high ranked individual and a leader.

33:12 same sayed,same. 😅

Ahsan Sayyid! 🎯🎯🎯

Ahlul Sunnah is riddled with conflict, distortion and misinformation. The fact their scholars whether intentionally or ignorantly minimize the transgression of Umar and other sahaba of the Prophet (PBUH) goes to show how weak they are.!

Who the hell is Umar to Decide or to preserve the Deen? It was God speaking through prophet Mohamed PBUH, and to preserve the Deen was not for Umar, it was the job of prophet Mohamed PBUH, It's very clear who the so called sunnis are following

I always think that when I am going to be in front of ALLAH I am going to be melted

shukran shekh for your elmu, asalam alykum from tanzania

Salam syed may Allah reward you and everyone who is part of this transmission. I wana ask about traslated quran . Which one are you reading i mean by whom is was trasnlated i want to have that one

The best scholar in town is Sayed Ammar ♥ May Allah bless him

💡

Ammar may ALLAH BLESS you.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Shia theology just makes more sense especially when you compare it the events happening in current times. Sunni just dont recongnize evil in current times and have no understanding of Geopolitics

Sura 9 At Tuaba V63 Know they not that for those who oppose Allah and His apostle is the fire of Hell? wherein they shall dwell. That is the supreme disgrace.

Can you mention which translated quran are you reading

This Request to Br Syed Amer Nakshvsni regarding Albert Einstein correspondence with Merja about Meraj

Alhamdulliah

The truth

You can't blame the Sunni brothers when they think if there ever be a prophet after Mohammad pbuh it would be Omar. Shaitan supposedly Temps Rasoolulah but Shaitan runs away or takes upturn when he says Omar. If you believe in these nonsense. What would you expect from them.

Do you know where I can get this quran

Alhamdulillah for the teachings of ahulu bait Alihum asalam if your a follower of sunnat sasalam please get out 🙏🏻

Sura 4 Nisaa V115 Anyone who is hostile to the Rasool after guidance has been plainly conveyed to him and follows a path other than that of the believers, We shall leave him in the path he has chosen and cast him into Hell; which is an evil refuge.

We're both rafida. We are the rafida of leaders who chose themselves, they are the rafida of leaders who were chosen by Allah (azwj)

31:55 I’m so sorry but do sunnis even believe in the Quran ? The prophet doesn’t speak out of liking , he speaks from allah.و ما ينطق عن الهوى ان هو الا وحي يوحى. Allah reveals to the prophet, the prophet doesn’t speak from his liking (his mind). THAT is kuffer/disbelief in the Quran just to justify someone’s actions!!!!

37:05 😂😂😂😂

Saying that prophet Muhammad could write is a total contradiction We are told he was i illiterate

That Shiekh is talking nonsense. Ages ago when I was in my hometown Afghanistan my mom used to say that Umar ignored PBU him. Now this Shiekh can't answer it because he's lying. That's a shame. I can say Umar was the big munafiq

well, i am sunni, but i have a few times listened to that molvi clips and i can clearly see he is a nasbi. i tend to agree to much of what shia view of ameer sham, how Maula Ali was sidelined and mistreated, view regarding Hazrat Abu Talib, i agree sunni view of sahaba is really flawed, thanks to Maulana Ishaq from Pakistan however, i still do not accept as of now the hardline beliefs of shia in many respects at the same time, or may be because i have not digged into the details of those perhaps

Wow

I debated with a sunni online, and they literally send me this video ( ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-It8sS2HiTaA.htmlsi=K1rR8YQPPV3XuTls ) and said this explains everything about this incident and rehashes what we shia say about this pen and paper incident, and they said, after watching this video, no shia can argue anymore. Subhanallah, after I watched it, I'm even more confident in saying I'm shia.. Sadly, the Shia in this talk didn't had the knowledge to properly debate, which made it easy for the sunni Sheikh to 'win the argument', when all the things he said could have easily be disproved by someone with a little more knowledge. He probably couldn't make it 5mins in a debate with someone like Sayed Ammar.. Alhamdulillah I'm on the true path if Islam🤲

Those who follow them will be misguided ,,,,,,, Sura 49 AL-Hujurat V7 And know that Allah's Rasool is among you. If he were to follow you in most affairs, you would certainly be in trouble. Allah has endeared this faith to you and beautified it in your hearts, making unbelief, wrongdoing, and disobedience abhorrent to you. It is they who are rightly guided