Brothers and Sisters. Make sure to like and share this video with everyone who has any doubts about Hadith. Also make sure to watch the video for your own benefit as it has important information that every Muslim needs to hear. Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
Quran 4:80 / 5:92 / 24:54 / 4:59 / 47:33 / 64:12 / in all of those verses says follow ALLAH and his messenger ! if they say prophet mean all of them then > 48:29 answer this ! and if u ask them bring the teaching of All prophets which they mentioned in Quran while u say we're following them ! they cant because the Only teaching we have by detail is the teaching of prophet Muhammad (pbuh) in verse 7:157 ALLAH clearly say that Muhammad ﷺ gonna teach u what is right - wrong lawful or unlawful , and also 16:44 !! and also 33:59 says O prophet tell ur wives ! while ALLAH ﷻ could Simply say your wives and so on ! so ALLAH s.w.t clearly give option to prophet Muhammad pbuh that they may teach us .. and also 33:36 clearly say follow command from Muhammad ﷺ , also 59:7 / also 4:59 , and 5:38 ! says cut the hand of thief ! how they're cutting ? if they cut right they do injust left ? unjust ? fingers only ? unjust .. arm ? unjust ! 2:110 and many others says give Zakah ! how they give ? if we put 10 quranist in 10 Different rooms and say to them pray ! and record them ! at the end we realize non of them are prayed like another one ! what they say in Rku in Sujud ? how they take ablution(wdu) , in 53:3 says nor does he speak of his own whims ! so 23 years was he Only talking Quran !? of course not . So at the end Quranist people or 1- they're full ignorant or 2- pay by other groups and organizations to be against Islam ! while they realize they cant destroy islam by ( libralism - christianity and other believes ) .. STAY AWAY FROM THOSE IGNORANT AND LIERS .. barak ALLAH fikum
Honestly, I don't consider Hadith rejectors to even be Muslim. Ignorance can sometimes be forgiven, but if they persist even after they've been challenged, then they are fasiqun following desires.
assalamu alaikum akhi mohammed. tafseer seris 3 soon pls. i have benefitted a lot from it barakallahu feekum. looking forward. may Allah make your intentions pure and make you a source of guidance and means of bringing people to Allah. hayyaakumullah.
Brother barak Allah fik, I'm wondring if you can provide substitle in french and arabic, so I can share it with my friends, they won't listen to me because we can't have a proper conversation. May Allah aza wajjal Bless and reward you for this efforts to the muslim community.
MashaAllah brother, welcome to Islam. There's a hadith you reminded me of " Anas ibn Malik reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “I wish I could meet my brothers.” The companions of the Prophet said, “Are we not your brothers?” The Prophet said, “You are my companions, but my brothers are those who have faith in me yet they never saw me.”". You believed Islam and prophet pbuh, even though you only heard about him. MashaAllah. You weren't born muslim so it was harder for you and all who reverted back to Islam. May Allah swt keep us steadfast on Islam inshallah.
Hey another Cuban, MashAllah 🤲🏼 I’m originally from Miami but moved to Tampa, hit me up if you need some support. I know how those Cuban families operate😂✊🏼 SubhanAllah, I’m excited for you akhi✌🏼
Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatulah hermano, yo soy un Español Argentino, ya hace un año que revertí al Islam, Alhamdulillah. La fé de Abraham, y la religión de la fitrah! Que más podría uno pedir?
I learned this yesterday about Muhammad. Muhammad Sucked the Tongue of a Boy [Syrian Biography of Muhammad written by Al-Amin Al-Mamoun, Chapter Title: The first people to believe in the prophet]: For it was narrated by Fatimah Bint Asad, the mother of Ali who related that when she gave birth to her son, it was the prophet who named him Ali and the prophet spat in Ali’s mouth then allowed to suck on his tongue till he fell asleep. [Musnad Ahmad, Hadith number: 16245, Volume Title: The Sayings of the Syrians, Chapter Title: Hadith of Muawiya Ibn Abu Sufyan]: Narrated by Hisham Ibn Kasim, narrated by Huraiz, narrated by Abdul Rahman Ibn Abu Awf Al Jarashy, and narrated by Muawiya who said, “I saw the prophet (pbuh) sucking on the tongue or the lips of Al-Hassan son of Ali, may the prayers of Allah be upon him. For no tongue or lips that the prophet sucked on will be tormented (by hell fire) Muhammad Kissed a Boy’s Little Penis [Hadith number 16245 Volume title, the sayings of the Syrians Hadith of Mu’ awiya Ibn Abu Sufyan]: He (the prophet) put Husein’s legs apart and kissed his (little) penis ( I know your better than your prophet.)
Dear Mohammad You have made me to come back to Islam. I was so confused and have been agnostic/ atheist. Your logical approach and way of refuting arguments, helped me immensely. Picked up Quran and reading it regularly. Praying regularly and left all kinds of music and movies, haram things from my life. Trying to take care of my parents and give away as much as I can. Islam literally took my mind,body and soul at peace.Keep spreading the truth. May Allah protect you and your family in this life and akhira.
I always do critical thinking (but i dont tell it to anyone) about Islam and finding answer through most of our Muslim brothers channel on youtube. Sometimes i listen to Ustaz and ulama online. Can you see Allah works? whenever you think about something, we always find the answers right away (even though we arent looking for it at that time. Alhamdulillah Tq Allah
There was consensus among the scholars that whoever denies that the Sunnah constitutes shar‘i evidence in general terms, or rejects a hadith of the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him - knowing that it is the words of the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) - is a disbeliever, who has not attained even the lowest level of Islam and submission to Allah and His Messenger.
In the Holy Qur’an obedience of the Prophet peace be upon him) is considered as the same as obedience to Allah. Muslims are told to take the Holy Qur’an and sunnah as their guides.
Oh, boy! We have a big one today! I was just feeling a little down from some guy saying some ignorant things about Islam. May Allah (SWT) reward you for this video, for it has brought a smile to my face and will most likely increase my knowledge.
Jazakh Allah M.A. you are one of a few reasons why i started praying, i was so lazy to pray but your patience and knowledge is amazing so i had to start also i get a special feeling when you upload a video may allah reward you for your effort.
Try not to reject this hadith from the so called "most authentic hadith book in the world" Sahih Bukhari 7:67:393 . I have more because the book itself is full of it it's just and example. And these careless self made scholars hide it.
Thank you, thank you, thank you. I was guided to Islam right before Ramadan 2023 and I’ve been sometimes overwhelmed with the amount of learning I’ve gone through as a 34 year old American. Your videos have been crucial to my journey to the truth and I hope you can continue this much appreciated work that you are doing. May Allah bless you.
The religion is to make it easy not difficult and to lighten your heart not to burden you. Remember, only Allah's opinion matters not the opinion of others and Allah's default state is love for the believers, so take your time. Learning is a life long process.
Try not to reject this hadith from the so called "most authentic hadith book in the world" Sahih Bukhari 7:67:393 . I have more because the book itself is full of it it's just and example.
@@mohamedbel657 The point is Muslim world around the world don't keep dogs because it is written in the same book that angels won't come to a house where there is a dog and I heard someone saying dogs saliva is bad because a dog licked satan's saliva.
Not all people who haven't studied deep into their religion are like this Alhamdulillah. I've read only the first few books of Hadith and i've read the Quran from cover to cover only twice and ive been a revert to Islam for a year and a few months. I could never reject Hadith, it is history, regardless of whether there is something I don't agree with, and there has been but I got over myself and accepted that there are things that I will never be able to understand and that I shouldn't let my own opinions get in the way of what Allah has set in front of me. Especially considering Allah tells me in the Quran that I should follow Rasulullah saw, and the only way to do that is through Hadith. Allah said so, and that is enough for me.
you should never disagree with the hadith. It's from the messenger of Allah pbuh and Allah commanded you to obey him. Maybe you might not understand the wisdom but don't say you don't agree with it.
Indeed the hadiths provide historical and cultural context for the Qur'an making in particular those verses dealing the the life and times of the prophet peace be upon him clear. But did Allah rely on Muhammad peace be upon him to complete the revelation?
@@logicalmuslim1590 there is no way you're using the muddy pool argument. That's what the atheists and christians use to try to sway people into thinking islam is false.
@@logicalmuslim1590 You asked,has Allah relied on Mohammed peace be upon him to complete the revelation Two problems with the question the question indicates and is based on the following You are asking the question as if Allah sent Quran with a bird and went away then the prophet continued the journey from his own mind And the base is wrong so the question and this is the first problem that we will figure it out later after pointing to the second problem The second problem (just in case you mean rely as if the plants rely on the sun to live) is that you didn't have manners when asking it and you attributed false things to Allah Allah never rely on anyone but Allah uses his creation For example Allah used me to guide someone,he could just basically guide him himself and achieveed the wisdom behind me exactly doing this with his own but he choosed to bless me with this Another example Allah uses me to give someone food so that he can eat,he could basically gave him the food in any other way by his own but he choosed to bless me and look here is the mercy and the generosity of Allah,he gave me the money and and he uses me to give the money to benefit someone else which is Allah's money but even that it is Allah's money and Even he is the one who choosed and let me do it and used me to do it he reward me on giving his money that he gave to me to someone else that he used me for it and not only that he rewards me with good deeds which is the greatest thing he also returns this money back to me by multiple and not only that he also bless me and many other things that comes when you do sadaqa and all of this comes to you as a reward for something that is based on his actions not yours and subhana allah there can be wisdoms behind chosing you like for example the man you gave money loves you so he protect your sister from an accident or any other scenario like that which is again a bless for that man and if Allah wanted he could have do it his own but he choosed to bless the man and reward him on something based on Allah's actions in the first place that may have other wisdoms that Allah could have done alone but he chooses to bless and so on ,can you imagine ?this is his genoristy and mercy and wisdom and knowledge and justice that are absolute maximum perfect Second problem out Back to the first Allah used the prophet to reveal the Quran to us and he used him to reveal the ahadith to us it is that simple, whenever the prophet talks in the religion it is a revelation from Allah It is that simple,i don't know why you keep circling and lower your gaze from the facts just to create a nonsense argument which is a fallacy to attack Islam How weak? don't waste your energy you will find nothing wrong about Islam the only way to attack is through lies as you can see and do Oh and one more problem in your comment,you misrepresented ahadith All of the comment have mistakes , what are you doing with your life?and the funny things that you base your arguments on the presence of this mistakes making your argument another mistake,find something else that deserves attacking and attack as long as you want don't irritate us with nonsense and waste your time and energy and ours
Your first point was spot on for me. Being a revert from a Christian background I was very cautious about Hadiths. Learning about how the Hadiths of Sahih Bukahri/Muslim have been authenticated and ruled many times over as authentic really helped my understanding and increased my iman. Jazzakallah Khair
Alhamulillah bro , may Allah guide us , our lord do not deviate our hearts after you have guided us and gave rahma indeed you are Al-wahhaab ( one of the names of Allah , characteristics )
Assalamualaikum brother Muhammad Ali. I'm from Malaysia 🇲🇾 and currently studying Ulum Quran and Ulum Hadith, Seerah ect. Your videos helps me a lot. Its like being in class listening to a lecturer giving speech and as a student I note down all the important point and information. Thank you. May Allah grant you barakah fi dunia wal akhirat. Amin
Masalah orang kita nusantara ni suka dengar amalan tok nenek moyang, tok guru, claim macam² tanpa sandaran AL quran dan hadis. Belajar ulum hadith dan quran boleh beri gambaran yg baik memahami agama islam
@@Fearless...... Don't worry brother, they will have millons because they exactly say what we want to hear... 😊😊 There is absolutely nothing authorized except Quran in order to guide people. Do let you know properly, "What is actually obeying the prophet in the Quran. " Salam. From BD🇧🇩
Try not to reject this hadith from the so called "most authentic hadith book in the world" Sahih Bukhari 7:67:393 . I have more because the book itself is full of it it's just and example. And these careless self made scholars hide it.
For anyone who’s wondering, it’s about rules on hunting game and what’s permissible to eat. No issue with this, just silly people looking for imaginary problems. SAHIH BUKHARI VOLUME 7, BOOK 67, HADITH NUMBER 393. Narrated By Adi bin Hatim : The Prophet said, “If you let loose your hound after a game and mention Allah’s Name on sending it, and the hound catches the game and kills it, then you can eat of it. But if the hound eats of it, then you should not eat thereof, for the hound has caught it for itself. And if along with your hound, join other hounds, and Allah’s Name was not mentioned at the time of their sending, and they catch an animal and kill it, you should not ea: of it, for you will not know which of them has killed it. And if you have thrown an arrow at the game and then find it (dead) two or three days later and, it bears no mark other than the wound inflicted by your arrow, then you can eat of it. But if the game is found (dead) in water, then do not eat of it.” And it has also been narrated by ‘Adi bin Hatim that he asked the Prophet “If a hunter throws an arrow at the game and after tracing it for two or three days he finds it dead but still bearing his arrow, (can he eat of it)?” The Prophet replied, “He can eat if he wishes.”
@@hboi965 according to this hadith muslims can keep dogs and it's okay to eat what it brings meaning it's saliva is also not najs. So if there is nothing wrong in it I challenge you to tell your 30 muslim friends that its okay to keep dogs and we can eat what it brings.
@@Notrandomlikeyouthe hadith you mentioned has nothing to do with dogs Chapter 7 is about tayamum, rubbing of hands and feet Hadith 393 belongs to chapter 8 regarding salah Wallahi This is the hadith 393 Narrated Maimun bin Siyah that he asked Anas bin Malik, "O Abu Hamza! What makes the life and property of a person sacred?" He replied, "Whoever says, 'None has the right to be worshipped but Allah', faces our Qibla during the prayers, prays like us and eats our slaughtered animal, then he is a Muslim, and has got the same rights and obligations as other Muslims have."
learning about how the hadith were transmitted is actually so interesting and it is actually crazy how in depth they went to make sure its acurate, especially in comparison to western history
Thank you so much, as a new revert with a thirst for knowledge I find things that I know nothing about, like the "fabrication of hadiths" so glad you are here to guide me and strengthen my faith often! I had a similar issue with the "ex muslim" angle, again you proved some very solid points there
BY ALLAH THEY ARE A TOTAL FABRICATION BY 99%,HAVING READ THEM ALL OVER SIX YEARS AND MOST OF THEM CONTRADICT THE HOLY QU'RAN, FROM THE SECOND REVELATION, MADE UP WITH THE PARALLEL RELIGION BASED ON THE TEN OF THOUSANDS OF FAKE AND FALSE HADITHS AND ABROGATE THE HOLY QU'RAN
Maa Shaa Allah, May Allah bless your knowledge and hardwork, Brother. Jazak Allah Khair. Very useful🙏 I had to end a 7 year friendship bcuz of this matter. I had to stand up for my principles and our Prophet's (ﷺ) teachings ❣️ Please, make dua my friend realizes asap how silly it is to reject hadith and comes back to straight path🤲
Clearly THE FABRICATION OF HADITHS ARE HERE TO DEVIATE YOU AWAY FROM THE PATH OF ALLAH SOUBHANOUHOU WA TAÂLA READ THE HOLY QU'RAN AND YOU WILL FIND 212 VERSES THAT ISLAM IS FROM THE QU'RAN ONLY, THE WORD HADITHS MENTIONNED SEVERAL TIMES REFERING TO ALLAH, THE WORD SUNNAH OF GOES BACK TO ALLAH SOUBHANOUHOU WA TAÂLA ONLY AGAIN AND OUR PROPHET PEACE BE UPON HIM IS TOTALLY AND COMPLETELY INNOCENT WITH WHAT CONTRADICT THE HOLY QU'RAN و الله متم نوره و لو كارها الكافرون
أضن أنه من كثرة كذب والإدعاءات بأحاديث منسوبة كذبا لرسول عليه الصلاة والسلام خاصة في فيسبوك مثل ( ...أنشرها تدخل الجنة ) لهذا يجب أن نتأكد من صحة حديث جيدا
Because not All hadiths are the the same... They are written by many different people at different times in different lands.... Scholars of Islam classify them as weak and strong... What do think that means? Hmmm.... Also you seem to have added the words "Sunnah" to your claim.... Do you understand that Sunnah and Hadith are not the same thing?
Jazzakallah akhi appreciate all the knowledge you share as a revert the classes youve been starting are also beneficial keep up the hard work been looking forward to this video inshaAllah may Allah swt grant you jannah for the hardwork you put in and steadfastness threw any struggles you may have as well
Try not to reject this hadith from the so called "most authentic hadith book in the world" Sahih Bukhari 7:67:393 . I have more because the book itself is full of it it's just and example. And these careless self made scholars hide it.
Mashallah !! I've been waiting for this video , can't wait to share and spread this to so many. May Allah Reward You for all your hard work Brother Muhammed. JazakAllah
Try not to reject this hadith from the so called "most authentic hadith book in the world" Sahih Bukhari 7:67:393 . I have more because the book itself is full of it it's just an example. And these careless self made scholars hide it.
@@JTheMuslim Do you mean you will blindly believe what these people say but won't believe what honourable prophet peace be upon him said which is written in Quran.
this has to be one of the most well thought out and informative video i have ever watched from you, just simply amazing. Thank you for this, sincerely.
One of the reasons why Hadith rejectors reject Hadith is that they don't want to do prayers and a lot of the good teachings of the prophet Muhammad pbuh
@@abdullahalharbi9061 If I follow a religion that has 7 prayers a day and I say "you don't follow my religion because you don't want to pray 7 times". This is playing games. It's not a real argument.
Brother you are an inspiration. learn so much from your videos and how to deal and refute the Christians and be strong and firm in our faith. may Allah SWT reward you in this world and the here after AMEEN.
masha’Allah this is a great service to the ummah, may Allah accept it Small correction at 56:35; Muwatta is from Malik Ibn Anas not Anas bin Malik- I’ve made that mistake as well several times 😅 barakAllahu feek habibi
The final sermon of the Prophet ﷺ “O People, no prophet or apostle will come after me, and no new faith will be born. Reason well, therefore, O People, and understand words which I convey to you. I leave behind me two things, the Quran and my example, the Sunnah, and if you follow these, you will never go astray. All those who listen to me shall pass on my words to others and those to others again, and may the last ones understand my words better than those who listen to me directly. Be my witness, O Allah, that I have conveyed your message to your people”.
This was simply amazing to watch! The structure of explaining all the point and evidence brought up is top tier. Jazaka allah ! This video strengthened my iman further.
May ALLHA SWT reward you the highest in the Jannat al Firdous for making such a comprehensive explanation. I have been dealing with Hadith rejectors for some time and this video helped me a lot! Jazakallaho khair brother.
@@truehikma Says don't follow Hadith, goes on to mention Hadith, well done habibi. Also, no one worships Bukhari. I don't engage/reply here but your contradictory statement made me LOL so thanks love
@@truehikma mate, you literally said "BUKHRIAN HADITH WORSHIPPERS ARE THE ENEMY OF THE MESSENGER, CONDEMNED BY HIS WORDS, **HIS TRUE HADITH**." .... as I said, I do not engage/debate here, so you can do what you think is best, and I will follow the Quran and the sunnah
I have one problem why the RU-vid forbid me to like this video many times , May Allah reward you brother Muhammed I think you cover every general point in this subject this video will be my easy way with an English speaker who reject Hadith
Imagine that the idea of denying hadith reached the Arab Islamic countries. I met one of the sisters who lives in Mecca, and then the discussion began about this matter. I was surprised that she completely denied the Sunnah and said that the Qur’an alone is sufficient. I was shocked, as this girl has lived her entire life in Mecca. Then, after a long discussion, she mentioned that she follows people on Twitter who are always discussing the truth about the authenticity of hadiths. They mention many similarities and many hadiths which they attribute to Al-Bukhari and which contain some doubts. Until they reached the point of denying the entire Sunnah. She was giving them credit and thanking them. They had completely washed her mind. There's no strength except with Allah . I ask you, Brother Muhammad, to make videos in Arabic on this particular topic, because there are fierce campaigns operating secretly in groups and accounts targeting Arab youth. Thank you, God bless you.
I think this also explains how the Islamic civilization that was there disappeared and why the condition of Muslims who are supposed to follow the truth is so weak, and this is because they have turned away from their religion.
Don’t ask of me anything read 5827 bukhari and 4:18 closely think about it. If you accept there is a issue between this verse and Hadith then we can get into other topics about Quran alone. But if you don’t see a issue with this then your lost and blind
@quranaloneistruth , your obviously lacking simple brain cells as the hadīth say even if they commited it, it doesn't say committing it showing he is talking about people who slipped and repented , no where is this hadith talking in the context of people committing these sins persistently until they die. It goes to show your just another quranioon that doesn't have the ability to think rationally
@@Quranaloneistruth Seems like no issue to me Though I'm no scholar of deciphering either the hadith or the holy Quran It's a basic understanding It's like the pharoah of the time Moses pbuh When he saw death he wanted to be a believer and he was drowned by Allah.
بارك الله فيكم... اللهم اغفر لوالدينا و ارحمهما و اجمعنا معهما في الفردوس الأعلى مع الأنبياء و الشهداء و الصالحين و جميع موتى المسلمين.. اللهم احقن دماء المسلمين و انصرهم على من عاداهم.. رب إني مسني الضر و أنت أرحم الراحمين... لا إله إلا أنت سبحانك إني كنت من الظالمين..... .. ............... ............ ................................................................ . ...........................................
Every time I've had a question or there has been an attempt to make me doubt Islam as a new revert I come across a video of yours that quells the doubt and answers the questions. I appreciate all of the time you've taken not only to educate yourself but also to share what you've learned with the public so we can all be *fairly* knowledgeable about the Truth that we stand by.
Hadith is a necessary tool for us to know our Deen. How can one pray? How does one follow Allah in a sufficient enough manner that is better than how Christian’s or other pagans do? We need an instruction manual because otherwise we are lost.
Lol you’re telling me your learned prayer from hadith and that’s how your dad mom learned it and their dad/mom going generations back?? 😅 gosh you guys cannot think critically at all
What is the deep explanation of that? You see when a non muslim saw this, its not gonna make any sense. If you die on the right path you re already going to jannah. But what is that hadith you said meaning. When you don’t show the real meaning of it, its not logical.
@@gemici810 I think the hadith is clear, if you die under debris then you are considered a martyr. You dying to the right path without being a martyr and dying on the right path while being a martyr is not the same. You can learn about what rights Allah gives to a martyr on the day of judgement.
@@ednoc19 No still not clear or logical and does not comply with Qur’an. In Qur’an Allah says in the Qur’an when a person liveand complete his/her life with shirk, all the good deeds they do is gone. There are unforgivable things like this that Allah mentioned. While there are hadiths like this that exact opposite to what Allah revealed. So tell me again how is that hadith is “clear”.
@@gemici810 It's common sense that it's talking about muslims that didn't commit shirk, since if you commit shirk without asking forgiveness, you are out of religion, if you are out of religion, you are not entering heaven. So yeah hadith is clear. Martyr is a status for Muslims.
Brother may allah give you barakah in your life and all this that you are doing is better then the world and what it contains you inspire me and im sure you inspire alot more ❤ keep it up love you for the sake of allah
Salams, Muhamamd, like your work a lot, Mashallah! However on this topic I don’t understand, the stoning punishment was abrogated, and if the Hadith is sahih it goes against the the ayat of the Quran that stipulate the punishment for adultry, and what I know is if the Hadith goes against the Quran, then we take what the Quran says in the subject, so how come in this instance you are taking the Hadith over the Quran?
I had the same issue . I may be wrong but one time Prophet (pbuh) decided the adultery issue for a Jewish couple. He recommended stoning according to their belief ie the Jewish Law which allows stoning for adultery. Also Quran requires 4 witnesses who have actually witnessed the act, which is next to impossible . Allah knows best.
Allah Almighty Says (what means): "6. Verily, those who disbelieve, it is the same to them whether you (O Muhammad may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) warn them or do not warn them, they will not believe. 7. Allâh has set a seal on their hearts and on their hearing, (i.e. they are closed from accepting Allâh’s Guidance), and on their eyes there is a covering. Theirs will be a great torment." [Quran 2:6-7]. Simple Interpretation: 6) Those who reject what has been sent down to you from your Lord out of pride and transgression will never have eemaan. That is regardless of whether you attempt to strike fear in their hearts and warn them of Allah’s punishment or simply leave them as they are, due to their stubborn persistence in their falsehood. 7) Allah has placed a stamp over the hearts and hearing of these people and placed a cover over their vision. That is because of their disbelief and obstinacy after the truth has been made clear to them. So they will not come in line with the guidance, and they will have a severe punishment in the Hellfire.
Before trying to prove the Quranists/Hadith Rejectors wrong, you should have stated what in your view do the Quranists/Hadith Rejectors say about their position because it seems like you're making a strawman argument here. The Quranists I know don't say you should not believe and follow in what the Prophet said. What they doubt is the authenticity and reliability of the Hadith literature we have today. Let me give you an example to better explain myself. When Muslims say they don't believe in the Gospels, they don't mean to say they don't believe in the teachings of Isa/Jesus. Rather they say, the teachings attributed to Isa/Jesus in the Gospels we have today are unreliable because there is a lot of falsehood mixed in with the truth. For us at this present moment, there is no way to determine what is actually from Isa/Jesus and what is a fabrication attributed to Isa. As a result, Muslims do not rely on the Gospels as a source of divine knowledge. Similar is the case with the Hadiths attributed to Prophet Muhammad. Since "Hadith Rejectors" do not have a way to determine which hadiths are authentic and which are fabricated, they don't rely on hadith as a source of divine knowledge. So if you have anything to say in response to these types of Quranists, I'd be happy to hear you out. That said, I'm still half way through watching your video, so maybe you've already addressed this point in the remaining part of the video; in that case, no need to respond here.
It is not about rejecting hadiths, those who reject everything are wrong. But giving to hadith a legislation power is wrong. We will not be judged on hadiths, I know that for sure. Allah will never ask us the day of judgment about what others reported about Muhammed pbuh. Those who think that their errors can be put on the imam, or alem are in a dream. You will bear your own error.
@@canjeero Not nonsense. He knows this for sure because Allah (swt) told us in Surah Al-Jathiyah [45:6] as a warning against hadiths: تِلۡكَ ءَايَٰتُ ٱللَّهِ نَتۡلُوهَا عَلَيۡكَ بِٱلۡحَقِّۖ فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۢ بَعۡدَ ٱللَّهِ وَءَايَٰتِهِۦ يُؤۡمِنُونَ These are the verses of Allāh which We recite to you in truth. Then in what hadith after Allāh and His verses will they believe?
@@canjeero OMG that's so awesome!! It's like Allah (swt) is talking about you in real-time. It's just magical. Because I shared A VERY Relevant Verse above (that you ignored), but have a look at its next two verses (continued): *Woe to every sinful liar; Who hears the verses of Allāh recited to him, then persists arrogantly as if he had not heard them. So give him tidings of a painful punishment.* - [45:7,8] Amazing isn't?? 🤯 Good luck to you too! 👍🏻
iam going to say the truth here i was for some time a hadith rejector but when i read the Quran and it said that everything from the Prophet saw is revelation ive come to the realisation that id be a hypocrit /liar to myself to even start doubting Hadith even from basic logic how do you know how to do ablution? prayer ? Ive researched on how the ranking of hadith is done and there were so much variables that were taken into consideration that i didnt even imagine man icant say no to that because it would be me following my desires at that point if a hadith is authentic you accept and follow it no questions asked ,thats the whole point of Submission to Allah subhanou May Allah accept from me and all muslims tawbah . seriously these days its hard to stay steadfast on Islam and it gets scary very fast😰. and i was a muslim all my life الحمد لله icant even start imagining what new reverts can go through because of this this video gave me more insight into this subject so thank you Brother
Barik Allahu feek brother very nice and informative video. There’s just one concern which inshallah you Can fix in your video that I noticed. I just want to note out that there was a slight mistake at minute 9:56 when reciting 2:142 . You said “3an annas” when it’s “min annas”. And o believe it is verse 142 but you noted 143. It’s not a major mistake but still felt obligated to point it out. Other than that may Allah reward you for this beneficial video.
Thank you Muhammad for this. I had a roommate a few years ago that rejected Hadith and I had trouble refuting him. You have made it very clear the authenticity of Hadith. May Allah reward you.
You cannot call yourself Muslim if you rejected what allah Messenger has to say, because Allah order us to obey Allah and his Messenger, If You Reject Sunnah And Hadith, You Certainly Has Disobey Almighty Allah SWT, And In Hereafter You Will Be Among The Losers,
I feel like I'm literally about to cry. I had a conversation with a Quranist yesterday and he asked me a question about the age of Aisha, may God be pleased with her, when she got married. Then he talked about how the marriage of young girls is permissible in one of the verses of the Qur'an, which is interpreted like this in the authentic hadiths. I don't know yet about this topic, because I did not learn about it before, but I believe that the hadith is true and that I cannot interpret the Qur’an alone or take the interpretation from someone from the nineteenth century or from anyone other than the Prophet, and I know that the hadiths are the history of Islam. Without them, the Qur’an's verses have no events for them to be reveal. I cannot accept that all of those Adkar that I say after every prayer, and the morning and evening Adkar, are all baseless. Despite my conviction, I felt the whispers of Satan who wanted me to question the authenticity of the hadiths, but thank God I knew that brother Muhammad Ali at one time put up a video refuting the Qur’anists, and now I have watched it fully with a lot of deep feelings sweeping through me, as if I had successfully passed God’s test of me. Thank Allah first and thank you brother Muhammad Ali, may Allah grant you the highest level of paradise. I'll make dua for you in every prayer inshallah, you made it easy for me in many ways.
(59:7) "And whatever the Messenger has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty." "Say, [O Muhammad], 'If you should love Allah, then follow me, [so] Allah will love you and forgive you your sins. And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful’” (3:31).
I love seeing dawah being spread (your channel is my favorite) and Allah has given you something very special brother Muhammad, I hope you will continue to use what you have been given in His path. I want to support you personally so that you can do this full time and more videoes can come up and so that you don't have to work on the side to support yourself and your family. How can I supprt you the best? You have linked to options but what has the least fee - so that all the money goes to you and not some website fee.
Assalamu aleykum brother/sister, our brother Muhammed has a pinned comment on this video and most of his other videos. There you can choose to support through one of the avenues he has listed. May Allah bless you for finding it in your heart to support the dawah. I'm however in no way in contact with the brother so I can't help you help more than this.
doesn’t the entire concept of weak hadith vs strong hadith damage the requirement of following hadith? what if some of the weak hadiths were actually true or what if there are things that were never recorded as hadith in the first place but were important and followed by the companions, but was just missed somehow? please admit that the concept of hadiths are a human invention. I’m not rejecting hadith and I don’t doubt the effort that was put into compiling them, but I’m not understanding how they can be inseparable from Quran. There was no explicit verse in the Quran saying to follow hadith.
Its possible that weak hadiths are true and correct but we dont use them for the basis of faith and do not make them requirements on the muslims do to it not being comepletely verfied as the word of rasool. For example weak hadith can be used as supporting evidence to come to a certain conclusion or islamic ruling. Only sahih is used for aqeedah and strict rulings. Because they are verified words of the prophet saw
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "(There are) two words which are dear to the Beneficent (Allah) and very light (easy) for the tongue (to say), but very heavy in weight in the balance. They are: ''Subhan Allah wa-bi hamdihi'' and ''Subhan Allah Al-`Azim." Sahih al-Bukhari 7563
