Тёмный

A Face In The Dark | RuskinBond | ICSE Class 9 & 10 English | The Best Explanation 

Study with Sudhir
Подписаться 371 тыс.
Просмотров 40 тыс.
50% 1

🔴Download Study with Sudhir app on Playstore : 1lzl.short.gy/...
Share the video link with your friends and juniors and subscribe to ‪@StudywithSudhir‬
A Face in the Dark by Ruskin Bond is a story about a school teacher in Simla (spelt as Shimla now) who has a fascinating experience with two persons in the dark. What happens in the story leaves the reader perplexed as it does Mr Oliver, the teacher. Which is why it is open to interesting interpretations.
We are on Telegram and Instagram.
#ICSEClass10 #AFaceintheDark #RuskinBond #TreasureTrove #StudywithSudhir #TSSudhir

Опубликовано:

 

18 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 221   
@biancasawant3829
@biancasawant3829 4 года назад
Thank you sir.....your explanation was extremely helpful and helped me widen my perspective on the topic further.Thank you oh so much!!!!
@harshghoshal2442
@harshghoshal2442 4 года назад
Sir now it's around 2:21am and I am listening to your explanation and it makes me fearful while reading this story now...😨😰
@chibisuki7151
@chibisuki7151 3 года назад
The fact that I'm dóing this late in the night while reading this comment is scary
@tamalichakraborty7760
@tamalichakraborty7760 3 года назад
I am starting the video at 2:19 a.m.
@adharmicindian491
@adharmicindian491 3 года назад
You feel scared? This story 'A Face in the Dark' is not at all scary.... It can be said a metaphor which Ruskin Bond used to explain the flaws of our English medium based (UK based) education system.
@shiprakothari8090
@shiprakothari8090 3 года назад
You are the torch that illuminates our path Thank you so much! The synonyms you suggest are indeed helpful!
@harkiratsandhu4283
@harkiratsandhu4283 4 года назад
Missing my school days . specially English Hindi Punjabi story classes😟
@ishitaarora3621
@ishitaarora3621 4 года назад
Thanks a lot sir for such detailed interpretations and explanation. I just had a doubt that why does the Life Magazine compare the school to such a prestigious institution like Eton if the education system practised is not good enough.
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
We are not saying the education system practised is bad. It is just that it seems to be creating a conveyor belt of similar products (boys). That is my interpretation of why Mr Oliver is unable to recognise his own student ... because all of them look alike, there is lack of individuality ...
@ishitaarora3621
@ishitaarora3621 4 года назад
Ok sir. Thank you.
@gits0807
@gits0807 4 года назад
thank you sir for so great an explanation... It was amazing and trust me none of our teachers had mentioned the points stated by you in this video...THANK YOU ONCE AGAIN SIR.
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
Having been a student of English Literature and a writer by profession helps :) You tend to look at every character and incident from a 360 degree perspective
@gits0807
@gits0807 4 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir Absolutely sir I accept👍♥️
@krishivraj6505
@krishivraj6505 3 года назад
Sir great to have you as a teacher but I have a question that if the watchman had no face and no mouth then how did he speak
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 3 года назад
In the horror story genre, writers usually take such creative liberties.
@krishivraj6505
@krishivraj6505 3 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir thank you sir for the quick reply
@kanishkadubey5048
@kanishkadubey5048 4 года назад
Sir what if at the end Mr. Oliver didn't actually reach the school but he felt like he was close to the school? Like hallucinating that he was close to the school but was just running into denser area of the forest? Or maybe, as he was coming from the bazaar where there are restaurants, he was drunk and just hallucinating all this.
@vedantlearns7516
@vedantlearns7516 3 года назад
could be...........the author has left it incomplete for us to make assumptions
@rishavvsharmaa
@rishavvsharmaa 3 года назад
It can also be that Mr Oliver was dreaming...
@priyanshubaidya76
@priyanshubaidya76 4 года назад
Great explanation. You told the points that I was not told by our teachers. But I have a question. It is- Why Mr. Oliver is referred as 'Sahib' by the watchman?
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
Sahib is the way europeans were referred to by Indians.
@priyanshubaidya76
@priyanshubaidya76 4 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir Thank you very much Sir.
@priyanshubaidya76
@priyanshubaidya76 4 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir Sir, then can we say that the watchman that later proved to be a ghost, was an Indian?
@tenzinyeshisherpa8149
@tenzinyeshisherpa8149 4 года назад
Thank you Sir😊😊this video helped a lot in understanding the story more 😆
@tanishqchaudhari9644
@tanishqchaudhari9644 4 года назад
Wonderful explanation. Thanks a lot Sir!!
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
Hi Archana, great to hear from you. Ruskin Bond stories have that character, extremely riveting they are. Glad you found the explanation useful. In fact, questions came in the 2019 exam class 10 boards, from this story. Have a look at it. My best wishes to you
@hellgaming3650
@hellgaming3650 3 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir 👍
@kanchansales5630
@kanchansales5630 4 года назад
Sir, you are doing a great explanation.🙏
@xander324
@xander324 4 года назад
Sudhir sir tomorrow is my Term 1 English exam and what mam is explaining i can't understand Sir but when u explained i understood everything that i did'nt understand so far what my mam was teaching, THANK U VERY MUCH SIR FOR U KIND EXPLANATION OF THIS STORY, I hope i can score better marks in exam sir. THANK U ONCE AGAIN SIR 😀😀❤
@ritwikkumar1-c726
@ritwikkumar1-c726 4 года назад
Sir your way of explanation knows no bounds !!! You explain complex topics with ease as if they are a piece of cake
@nayankolhe2498
@nayankolhe2498 3 года назад
sir seriously your perfect you deserve a million subs
@ShashiSingh-rh8ox
@ShashiSingh-rh8ox 3 года назад
Sir we were asked a question once that - comment briefly what you think about the watchman with no face? Do you think he actually had no face or was making so to make Mr. Oliver frightened because Mr. Oliver never trusted in ghost and all.. Plz help sir🙏🙏
@sanjanagandhi7328
@sanjanagandhi7328 3 года назад
Sir, what does the word *Factory* mean...you have mentioned it there in the white board?
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 3 года назад
I have explained why I have written it !!
@sanjanagandhi7328
@sanjanagandhi7328 3 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir ok sir
@shiprakothari8090
@shiprakothari8090 3 года назад
With regards to this chapter, I would like some help Question: Loneliness is the main reason for fear. Elaborate in the context of this story Kindly help me with the answer Thank you
@adarshkumar2569
@adarshkumar2569 3 года назад
SIR my boards are coming ur video helps me lot. For understanding I have also shared to my friends.thanks sir for helping me to study🙏🏻🙏🏻. MAY U GET MILLIONS OF SUBSCRIBERS IN FEW YEARS ...........ur explanation is very helpful
@adharmicindian491
@adharmicindian491 3 года назад
Thanks a lot sir...we have this story in Class 9 ICSE & your explanation & interpretations really help a lot in understand & widening my perspective about this topic. Thanks a lot sir !!!
@tesiccaarora02
@tesiccaarora02 3 года назад
Great explanation sir.
@sweksha5479
@sweksha5479 4 года назад
Tysm sir,Ur videos are wonderful..The explanations helps me a lot..I will be having my exams after few day..And your videos are helping me a lot...! Once again Thank you soo much sir...Its really very helpful to me...
@pratheekreddy1688
@pratheekreddy1688 3 года назад
lhsb xbx xb x xbx bx xbx xbx xbx hx xhx vxhvxhxvxhsvshvshsvshsbshssbbss h nsnkshhreply repltreplyh reply rew[ply
@babitagoyal9998
@babitagoyal9998 3 года назад
Thanks sir for making our path easy
@sagarguha5425
@sagarguha5425 4 года назад
Sir If the watchman had no feature then how did he speak?
@mitalisarkar6259
@mitalisarkar6259 4 года назад
even u can ask that the boy also had no features how is he crying as his sound is also audible.
@sagarguha5425
@sagarguha5425 4 года назад
@@mitalisarkar6259 Correct
@ahelibhattacherjee471
@ahelibhattacherjee471 4 года назад
@@mitalisarkar6259 ya and even how is the narrator understanding whether the boy is crying or not?
@PritishN26
@PritishN26 4 года назад
Well, if they don't have faces they could be ghost. Thus, they might possess some mysterious powers.
@pragyaghosh3643
@pragyaghosh3643 4 года назад
Mitali Sarkar The sound wasn’t audible...”soundless weeping” remember?
@patnaiktube
@patnaiktube 4 года назад
Sir Your videos have helped me a lot for understanding these poems and stories! In my workbook for this chapter, there is a question "How can you Explain the boy's 'strange, soundless weeping'?" Could this be mentioning to Mr.Oliver being alone and his psychological fears as he is in reality nervous and imaginative? If not could you tell me the actual answer
@seetaraghuveer9061
@seetaraghuveer9061 Год назад
Thankyou sir, your explanation is wonderful Please explain - 'From before Kipling's time'
@jojupulikken9478
@jojupulikken9478 3 года назад
Super sir loved it my real teachers can't beat.you thanks for the hardwork
@sukanshigarg6051
@sukanshigarg6051 4 года назад
Sir please plan out some time for CHIEF SEATTLE'S SPEECH too..🥺👩‍🏫👩‍🏫👩‍🎓👩‍🎓
@ninadpatil9894
@ninadpatil9894 4 года назад
Sir how is I possible for the watchman to speak to Mr. Oliver without having mouth as reffered in the story "without any features"🤔🤔🤔
@pragyaghosh3643
@pragyaghosh3643 4 года назад
Aiyana Jose that’s right. However, the boy wept *soundlessly*. He trembled while hiding his face in his hands-which led Mr. Oliver to believe that he was crying...
@yumibindal3390
@yumibindal3390 3 года назад
Amazing interpretation lovely hats off👍
@RoslineSheetal
@RoslineSheetal 4 года назад
Very nice explanation sir I understood the story very nicely
@arya.desai31
@arya.desai31 4 года назад
oh my god....sir gr8 interpretations
@hydendseekhelp
@hydendseekhelp 3 года назад
Why would he return back to school at late night? He should probably go to his home🤔
@mehakhora1805
@mehakhora1805 3 года назад
it was because he was a bachelor, and as the school was a residential school(boarding school) there is a probability that he would live back there in the school.
@chhuyalchannel4786
@chhuyalchannel4786 3 года назад
The study with sudhir got an prize for all the subjects best explanations
@abhigyanjain1948
@abhigyanjain1948 3 года назад
Thanks a lot sir......... Never imagined this chapter with so many possibilities.
@RahmanKhan-cz2bx
@RahmanKhan-cz2bx 3 года назад
Thank sir! For making this video. Your explanation is amazing
@ramanujsingh2113
@ramanujsingh2113 3 года назад
Thanks sir a lot good explanation
@vaishnavihshetty4764
@vaishnavihshetty4764 4 года назад
Thank you sir it helped me in my test
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
Glad
@BibhabNayak
@BibhabNayak 3 года назад
Very important story love it
@SanjuKumari-lq3ne
@SanjuKumari-lq3ne 3 года назад
Sir u are really fabulous ....i also reffer u instead of my eng subject teacher.. thanku sir a lot!!pls do keep uploading viedo for us .. may god bless u always
@aviraldwivedi
@aviraldwivedi 4 года назад
Hello sir, I am your new subscriber and I am in Class 9 ICSE school and I will be appearing for boards this year
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
All the best
@PritishN26
@PritishN26 4 года назад
Same, I'm also in 9th
@usharatnam4024
@usharatnam4024 3 года назад
Thank you very much sir. I am of class 8 and have this lesson . This helped me to attend my annual examination well. Thank you very very much. Your explanation is very nice . We need teachers like you😇😇😇😇
@pragyaghosh3643
@pragyaghosh3643 4 года назад
Thank you so much sir, especially for the interpretation 😊😊😊
@sumenpradhan8968
@sumenpradhan8968 4 года назад
Thank you sir wonderful explanation 🐱
@NiveditaM
@NiveditaM 3 года назад
Thank you sir.
@chhuyalchannel4786
@chhuyalchannel4786 3 года назад
Sir your explanation are like best English teacher of india
@dollyscookinghub9666
@dollyscookinghub9666 4 года назад
Sir thnku so much for this very esy explanation i will be thnkful for u .....
@Hope-ou3mv
@Hope-ou3mv 3 года назад
I think that the last line of this story 'thats when the wind blew the lamp out' is the proof that contradicts the theory that Mr. Oliver is imaginning things.....If he was imagining , then how is the lamp there mentioned?? btw Sir, the whole Explanation was Super Awesoome !! those hinting at the Education System part, its not even written in the Workbooks/Guidebooks MINDBLOWING🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
@kanchansales5630
@kanchansales5630 4 года назад
Thank you very very very much sir your video helps me a lot..... keep making
@rpom__realpowerofman
@rpom__realpowerofman 3 года назад
U r really very amazing teacher sir whatever u explain makes me imagine that whole thing and after listing to ur explanation I feel as if I no more need to read the book anymore for the chaptr explanation. Wndrful explanation sir ✌🏻✌🏻😁
@harshghoshal2442
@harshghoshal2442 4 года назад
Sir also thanks a lot for your explanation about this story 🙂😊👍
@jaychorghade669
@jaychorghade669 3 года назад
SIR THIS HELPED ME A LOT HOW TO THANK YOU THANK YOU SIR SO SO MUCH 😍😍🥰
@NoLagGamerZ2020
@NoLagGamerZ2020 Год назад
Sir I had a request for you, can you please make a video on English speaking skills, coz I observed that you have a very good communication skill.
@anshitasitesh5076
@anshitasitesh5076 3 года назад
Good morning sir. In the chapter "A Face in the Dark" I've got an assignment in which we gotta describe how the ending of the story creates an atmosphere to feeds man fascination with the dark. So, could you please tell some points and keywords to mention in it.
@abhik2972
@abhik2972 3 года назад
sir thank you so much, your videos of ICSE english has been great help for me during my term exams and my preboard 1
@kajalmakwana1844
@kajalmakwana1844 4 года назад
Superb helped me one day before my exam literally tysm sir☺️👍👍👏👏👏
@chaitalitalukder4865
@chaitalitalukder4865 4 года назад
Same here
@matechtips07
@matechtips07 4 года назад
Wonderful explanation thanks a lot sir!!!
@sharmilam8100
@sharmilam8100 4 года назад
Our teacher never mentioned anything about education system and how it was not good enough. They only stressed on the supernatural and horror element of this story.......
@pragyaghosh3643
@pragyaghosh3643 4 года назад
That’s one interpretation of the larger theme of the story.
@acousticcoverhub9756
@acousticcoverhub9756 3 года назад
This story reminds me of the Japanese Legend of "Noppera-Bo"(The Faceless Ghost) ..The interpretation was really awesome sir, thanks for guiding us for the ICSE... :)
@Vansh_The_Rover
@Vansh_The_Rover 3 года назад
Yah you right i also thought that the story is like the japanese legend
@seemonsingh20
@seemonsingh20 4 года назад
Sir, oliver teaches in the school "eton of the east" or the school which was in shimla?? Plz tell
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
Shimla school was called eton of the east
@seemonsingh20
@seemonsingh20 4 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir then the name of the shimla school is eton of the east in which oliver taught
@pragyaghosh3643
@pragyaghosh3643 4 года назад
SHOURYA Crunch Works No...the school in Shimla was *referred* to as the Eton of the East...
@pratyushjaiswal5251
@pratyushjaiswal5251 3 года назад
How strange it is sir! The story which pointed the deffect of education system is itself included in the education
@nalinraj872
@nalinraj872 3 года назад
Thankyou sir Watching this video made me confident about this chapter And I loved reading and watching this chapter altogether ❤️
@pranavjoshi2051
@pranavjoshi2051 4 года назад
I like the way you teach if i don't understand anything i just watch your videos and i understand
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
glad
@PritishN26
@PritishN26 4 года назад
Great explanation!! Sir, you really made me feel this story Edit: I think he saw a horror movie on a windy day, and his torch was low on batteries, but nothing happened. He went & slept and all of this was a dream, because your dreams are made off of your imagination. He probably saw a horror movie which was the reason for the horror aspect. And when going home, his torch probably was low on battery and eventually went our near the school and it was a windy day with trees making scary sounds because of which the thought of some paranormal activities stuck in his head which caused the dream.
@kartikgore7107
@kartikgore7107 3 года назад
This video helped me more than my teacher ever could
@IT-gq8ky
@IT-gq8ky 4 года назад
A lot of respect owed to you sir
@neetimaankaur2753
@neetimaankaur2753 4 года назад
thank you sir for the video
@nidhi.rathiii
@nidhi.rathiii 3 года назад
thank you so much sir!👍
@rockstarop1722
@rockstarop1722 4 года назад
Very impressively explained
@apoova_aph
@apoova_aph 3 года назад
Thanks for the explanation sir :)
@aritrachakraborty3883
@aritrachakraborty3883 3 года назад
You told some extraordinary points
@wizkid9050
@wizkid9050 4 года назад
I have a book of face in the dark... I got this gift on my Birthday... It's really exciting.... I read all the chapters....🤩🤩
@nandhamv8830
@nandhamv8830 3 года назад
its only a 2 pg story for that a whole book cannot be made
@AshoKSingh-vi7ij
@AshoKSingh-vi7ij 4 года назад
I always like the video at the start of it as I know it is worth of it
@rajbirkaur6578
@rajbirkaur6578 2 года назад
Very good explanation sir
@amerehustler
@amerehustler 3 года назад
Sir u explained it really very nicely. But sir I have a question that is it an imaginative story or a true life based story?? I guess it's an imaginative story but still can you pls say me this.
@adityanarayanpradhan8120
@adityanarayanpradhan8120 4 года назад
Why the school was known as the Eton of the east? Waiting for your reply sir
@kotajankari786
@kotajankari786 3 года назад
Very nice video
@zangmusherpa2138
@zangmusherpa2138 4 года назад
Thankyou Sir for the wonderful explanation.
@nidhi.rathiii
@nidhi.rathiii 3 года назад
which chapters are likely to come in exam for class 9 boards!?
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 3 года назад
there are no boards for class 9
@nidhi.rathiii
@nidhi.rathiii 3 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir our schools is conducting exams in a board pattern....prelims are already done....we have boards exams(final exams) starting from this Friday
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 3 года назад
@@nidhi.rathiii I meant schools will set the paper, not the icse council
@nidhi.rathiii
@nidhi.rathiii 3 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir yes sir!
@rahishah6379
@rahishah6379 3 года назад
woww awesome teaching....really very helpful
@ashokshing3938
@ashokshing3938 4 года назад
Thanku sir...
@subhikshashree4108
@subhikshashree4108 3 года назад
Awesome explanation sir No more doubts in this lesson 😀
@hi7621
@hi7621 3 года назад
Hi sir . Is this story really took place
@bhuminag3714
@bhuminag3714 3 года назад
If that old man is faceless just like that boy.... Then how did he asked Mr. Oliver, wt had happened.....????
@piyushchanderia5103
@piyushchanderia5103 3 года назад
19:00
@asiyakhan1656
@asiyakhan1656 4 года назад
Thankyou so much sir....really very helpful
@garvpathak3008
@garvpathak3008 3 года назад
best story ever
@upasnadarshani624
@upasnadarshani624 4 года назад
Sir please can u help us with the keywords of the stories to make our answers rich
@StudywithSudhir
@StudywithSudhir 4 года назад
this video may help. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_f2JDqO0b9o.html
@upasnadarshani624
@upasnadarshani624 4 года назад
@@StudywithSudhir thank you sir.....I am greatful for your kind response
@rishwabbhattacharya8183
@rishwabbhattacharya8183 3 года назад
So sir as you said that Mr Oliver was not an imaginative man so in my opinion that, is Mr Oliver doesn't believe in god or ghost and stuff like that like that that's my question it would be very helpful if you answer it
@4nawab950
@4nawab950 3 года назад
Sir theme aur settings to bata do😁
@anjistaahan7549
@anjistaahan7549 3 года назад
very good explanation, very useful
@yajanttripathi6571
@yajanttripathi6571 3 года назад
Congrats Sir on 2 lakh subscribers.
@toobasyed9972
@toobasyed9972 3 года назад
thank you so much you made my English prelim go well
@rachnabajpai7738
@rachnabajpai7738 3 года назад
Nicely explained
@bobbybobby-hs4jl
@bobbybobby-hs4jl 3 года назад
Sir is this story having any second part ..
@bobbybobby-hs4jl
@bobbybobby-hs4jl 3 года назад
Answer plz
@bobbybobby-hs4jl
@bobbybobby-hs4jl 3 года назад
..
@ortizyt3102
@ortizyt3102 3 года назад
Podeyy
@chhuyalchannel4786
@chhuyalchannel4786 3 года назад
It help me a lot in exam
@jasminearora9045
@jasminearora9045 4 года назад
Sir if watchman had no feature , no mouth, than how did he speak to mr oliver?
@ftglegend7476
@ftglegend7476 4 года назад
Thank you sir i are osme
@k.ddiwan7181
@k.ddiwan7181 3 года назад
So sir i have a doubt that is it a complete story Or a incomplete ( half story) should we will read it about later??
@k.ddiwan7181
@k.ddiwan7181 3 года назад
I am Aniruddh
@revabharol4425
@revabharol4425 3 года назад
How can you reach so awesome?😊😊