A History of Hebrew Part 7: Old Hebrew to Greek and Aramaic

Подписаться 54 тыс.

Просмотров 202 тыс.

50% 1

A History of Hebrew DVD available through Amazon.Com - www.amazon.com/...
---------------------------
This is a segment of a much larger video production that I am working on and am looking for feedback (positive and negative) on the layout and content.
--------------------------
The old-Hebrew alphabet , also called paleo-Hebrew, was adopted by the Greeks around the 12th century BC. While Hebrew is written from right to left, Greek was written from left to right. For this reason, the letters were reversed in the Greek alphabet.
Over the centuries, these ancient Greek letters evolved into their modern Greek forms. Our English alphabet is Roman, and because the Romans adopted the Greek alphabet, we are able to see our own modern English alphabet in these ancient Hebrew turned Greek letters, the A, B, C, D and E.
As previously mentioned, the old Hebrew alphabet was used by all Semitic peoples including the Arameans (also called the Chaldeans), but evolved independently from the Hebrew. By the 5th century BC, the time of the Israelites captivity in Aramea (also called Babylon), it longer resembled the old Hebrew it came from and it is this Aramaic "square" script that Israel adopted during their captivity. With the Aramaic alphabet in use by the Israelites, it continued to evolve into the modern Hebrew letters we are familiar with today.
By the end of the 19th century, the translation of the Semitic alphabet was well established. The only mystery was the origin of this alphabet as mentioned in the 1922 "New Larned History for Ready Reference, Reading and Research" in its entry for the letter A. "A, the initial letter of the English and almost all other alphabets The Phoenicians called the letter "aleph" seemingly because of the resemblance of the character to the head of an ox. Although nothing is known with any degree of certainty concerning the ultimate origin of this letter." --The New Larned History for Ready Reference, Reading and Research, Pub. 1922, Page 1
What the editors of the "New Larned History" did not know, was that this mystery was solved just a few years earlier.
-------------------
Credits
Narration: Jeff A. Benner
Graphics: Jeff A. Benner
Music: Callen Clark
Photos: Henri Sivonen

Опубликовано:

7 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 620

@abryg8655 6 лет назад

Hebrew is the oldest phonetic language, spoken before the tower of Babel time. Hebrew words contain the internal essence of the subject spoken about. That's what makes it so strong and accurate. Deeper learning is needed to appreciate that.

@freeman7788 Год назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JEecFAJVRFU.html

@hweiktomeyto 10 месяцев назад

Hebrew is descended from Proto-Cannaanite, so that's not true

@Neesi392 Месяц назад

No it’s not

@celinesleiman6001 29 дней назад

😂😂😂 so funny even some modern xioNAZī say it is an Arabic. Accent

@TheDocumentary1234 10 лет назад

Just a note on the Greek "epsilon", which I hope you will find useful. It is actually pronounced very similarly to the original "hey", as it sounds like the "e" in the English word "egg". (Also, the name of the letter, the word "epsilon" itself, is pronounced in this way, too. The way you pronounce it sounds more like the 20th letter of the Greek alphabet, which is written "Y", it is called "ipsilon" and has the sound of the "i" in the word "infant"). Moreover, in ancient Greek, there were cases, when "epsilon", at the beginning of a word, would sound as "he", just like in "hello". In modern Greek, this variant pronunciation has been dropped, and "epsilon" is always pronounced as the "e" in the English word "egg". Shalom from Greece and thank you very much for your interesting studies, which you care to share with us, and help us appreciating even more the Word of the Lord.

@freeman7788 Год назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JEecFAJVRFU.html

@hweiktomeyto 10 месяцев назад

Epsilon is from Phoenician, not Hebrew, so it's from hē, not Hebrew hey, which is a cognate.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@microloverecords As I stated below to others who are also misinformed about the relationship between Hebrew and Phoenician, almost all people groups of the Near-East used the same alphabet, the phoenicians, the Hebrews, the Amorites, the Moabites, the Arameans, etc. So yes, this is Phoenician and yes this is Hebrew. By the way if you watched Part 5 of this sereis (Old Hebrew and Phoenician). So, before you start screaming, "Untrue!" Misinformation!" Please do your homework.

@paoleila 4 года назад

@ Jeff A. Benner The Phoenicians invented the Alphabet and the ten digit numerals, a system based on ten units with the zero called Sifr ( Cipher in English = a zero; a figure 0, nil) which derives its name from Sowfara as in to whistle; in Hebrew there is a similar word from the same root Shofar which is a famous word; because when you whistle nothing you can touch comes out = empty, so the number zero is an oval for the shape of the lips and not a circle. All the other Semitic languages follow in the Phoenician alphabet system including European languages as for the numeral system it has been adopted universally. No spin, we are not talking about cooking Hommos and who invented Hommos first! Qadmus the brother of Evropa invented the numbers first, then he invented the letters. These are historical facts. The Hebrews are originally from southern Iraq, from the city of Ur, their name derives from the word Abara = to cross as in Al Ebraniyoun because they crossed the Euphrates river. They used the Phoenician alphabet like other semitic tribes and Europeans, but they have nothing to do with inventing it. You say:"So yes, this is Phoenician and yes this is Hebrew". No don't play psychological games and tell people to do their homework! you do your homework first. I repeat the Phoenicians invented the numerals and the Alphabet. I hope this is clear! And so that you don't feel bad, Hebrew is a Semitic language, and has survived exile and descrimination. It is admirable that it has been preserved. Arabic has beome the lingua franca in the Middle East; scientifically speaking Hebrew is the closest language to Arabic and they are called sister languages but sometimes the words mean different things :) in Hebrew MARKABA is for car, in Arabic MARKABA is for a space ship! get it? enjoy and keep smiling.

@tFighterPilot 13 лет назад

Hebrew, Phoenician and the rest of the Canaanite languages were originally a single language, so these letters belong to all of them.

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

Yes, there will be a part 8, actually there are still at lease 10 more segments, this project is turning out to be a lot bigger than I originally intended LOL

@HoneySuckle123 3 года назад

I’m so grateful!

@bighairyfeet 2 года назад

How is that funny?

@mauricio201988 6 лет назад

One of Kabbalah’s explanations about this subject is that the aleph as the representation of an ox is the letter of potency (power) witch is the symbol of El, one of the faces of the Sacred, the Creator. It’s the creative silence that precedes power! Also represents Ruk’há - the spirit that created verbally all the worlds. Aleph or Alaph is the number 1, the legislative language. Following this storyline, for the ancient Semite to have an ox labouring in your lands means that you are a wealthy and powerful man because you mastered the beast and technology. Remember that the biggest sacrifice to YHWH - besides human life - was the ox and the first written Torah was made with ox pelt. As I said, it’s just a scratch of Kabbalah’s interpretation about Aleph. By the way, I study Kabbalah at Academia de Cabala - a branch of contemplative Kabbalah - Abraham Abulafia in Brazil - we study the Torah in Aramaic and some words and universe of meanings may differs from the Jewish Kabbalah. Shalom - Shalem - peace - paz.

@Seventh7Art 11 лет назад

I can read 2800 year old Greek inscriptions like I can read any modern text.... You can't re-write history. The Phoenician alphabet gave birth to the Paleo-Hebrew alphabet, not vice versa.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@microloverecords In part 5 of this series I explicitely point out that Phoenician and Hebrew use the same alphabet. The point of this video is to give an overview of the history of the Hebrew language, not to provide a deetailed analysis of all Near Eastern scripts. Yesterday I watched a show on the History channel about the Czar's of Russia. Continued...

@myrrhbear 11 лет назад

By the way, the names of the letters in Hebrew are the key to knowing what the original pictogram was of: Aleph = ox. Bet = house. Gimel = camel. etc.. These are also listed in the Sefer Yetzirah I believe. And interestingly while the modern English letters retain the shape of the ancient Hebrew, the Hebrew retains the names and meaning of the letters.

@valenrn8657 5 лет назад

Modern English letters are Roman Latin script.

@itzfili 11 лет назад

My personal belief (and I'm not an expert) is that the Phoenicians introduces writing to the Greeks, but not invented alphabetic writing. It was invented in Sinai by slaves. You can take it wherever you want from here.

@johnrhyne889 2 года назад

Any specific group of slaves? Also, around when?

@GODandGODDESS 7 лет назад

At 2:31, you introduce the Gamal (Gimmel) in Aramaic Square Script. It has 3 prongs, but the Wiki chart at the following link has 2 prongs that look like a mountain. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aramaic_alphabet The aforementioned Wiki chart lists Imperial Aramaic script. Can you explain the meaning of the difference between the 3-pronged Gamal at 2:31, and the 2-pronged Gamal on that Wiki chart ?

@ancienthebreworg 14 лет назад

@Sardonac I see your point and I you are correct. However, the Phoenician alphabet and the paleo-Hebrew alphabet are one and the same thing, it is just that most likely the Greeks adopted the alphabet from the Phoenicians rather than the Hebrews.

@RmMcclure 2 месяца назад

Stone Tablets have been found with the ancient Hebrew alphabet etched on them. Connecting dots, it appears Greek scholars needed an alphabet. The tablets were inked and copied onto Egyptian papyrus, which reversed the lettering. The ink alphabet on papaya was more easily transported back to Greece than the stone tablets, whereas the reversed alphabet on the papaya was adopted as their alphabet.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@istiiizzz In this video series I explain that Phoenician, Canaanite, Amorite, Aramaic, Hebrew, Moabite, etc. all used the same alphabet. In other words, the Phoenician alphabet is identical to the Hebrew alphabet.

@ajaxthree1 12 лет назад

To those who may feel that the video is incorrect, please consider that it is not incorrect but rather that it is a composite based on the authors/crea8tors perspectives/inputs, or from the knowledge they have. Others may have more inputs. Jeff, the Crea8tors crea8tion that is behind this crea8tion is an engineer by profession. He would not design/assemble a structure incorrectly as it is not in his nature. I've used his site for research for the past 5+ yrs and he goes deeper than many.

@Sardonac 14 лет назад

I think your only error may be one of terminology. Though (I think) the paleo-Hebrew alphabet is identical to the Pheonician alphabet, the Greeks adapted their alphabet from Phoenician traders. So, technically, it isn't the paleo-Hebrew script that was being adapted - even though it was in practice.

@freeman7788 Год назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JEecFAJVRFU.html

@Jeanelhaiby 8 лет назад

That's the Phoenician alphabet and not the hebrew

@NikkiJayArtistry 8 лет назад

isn't Phoenician ancient Hebrew?? and the modern Hebrew is a spin off from that?

@ancienthebreworg 8 лет назад

New Creature basically yes. That is fairly accurate.

@springbuiltitall 8 лет назад

Thanks so much for this

@siyamanci2596 7 лет назад

no it's Hebrew. Paleo Hebrew

@breenud39tv 7 лет назад

Siya Manci funny how you say "paleo" cause that word comes from the Greek word παλαιό pronounced the same spelt differently.

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

@MrWillieWester I never said the word "Hebrew" means language, culture or ethnicity. I never defined the word "Hebrew" in this series. But you are correct, it does mean to cross over.

@CarmineFragione 12 лет назад

One reason to explain how the language is inverted and reversed , between Hebrew and Greek ,is that the Cylinder was used as a rolling seal, and the Seal in manufacture, would show the writing in reverse, like seeing something in a mirror, but more so, in the rolling action of the cylinder, What was top to bottom left to right as engraved as inked and rolled out, would then be bottom to top, right to left, That is how it got this way, The Rolling Seal and the Result is opposite.

@brianfileman1281 3 года назад

There is so much Ill informed comment here that I don’t know where to begin. Ancient (paleo) Hebrew and Phoenician scripts are more or less identical, even if some of the words and pronunciations were not. As others have pointed out Phoenician is a Greek term initially denoting the independent city states along what is now the North Israel/Lebanon/South Syria coast. They were essentially Canaanites, and the script should be thus named. The proto-Sinaitic script is certainly based on Egyptian pictographic forms which were used to represent a Semitic language, most probably Canaanite. These ‘letters’ might have been the basis for the aleph bet of ancient Hebrew and Canaanite, but there is little evidence of any order (and in an alphabet). The first known alphabet (an abjad really) was Ugaritic. It had over 30 symbols to indicate sounds and used a simplified form of cuneiform, a far far older writing system that arose about the same time as Egyptian hieroglyphs. As for comments that refer to the Tower of Babel, it’s probably best to ignore them completely.

@Thericecakeman 7 лет назад

the Greeks took the phoenician alphabet not the Hebrew alphabet

@ancienthebreworg 7 лет назад

The Phoenician and Hebrew alphabets are identical. No matter what you call it, the Greeks borrowed it.

@yamgoyim8269 7 лет назад

It matters as much it matters that you present a syllabary as an alphabet.

@allmightlionthunder5515 6 лет назад

At first, they traded mainly with the Greeks, trading wood, slaves, glass and powdered Tyrian purple. Tyrian purple was a violet-purple dye used by the Greek elite to color garments. In fact, the word Phoenician derives from the ancient Greek word phoínios meaning "purple".

@VALDIGNE 5 лет назад

Phoenicians and Hebrews were relatives.

@servantofaeie1569 5 лет назад

@@robertjones6862 no, Canaanite was an abjad

@ItsameAlex 13 лет назад

@4anuvis4 read this: '' It is the first and oldest alphabet in the narrow sense that it notes each vowel and consonant with a separate symbol''-Greek alphabet. Go to wikipedia and search ''greek alphabet''.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@microloverecords I am not sure what you think is misguiding in this presentation. What I have presented "IS" the ancient Hebrew alphabet and language, hence the title of the video. In addition I do show in this presentation that the ancient Hebrew alphabet is identical to ancient Phoenician, Greek, Samaritan and Aramean.

@michaelsparks5736 6 лет назад

excellent for those wishing to learn Hebrew for the first time

@DavidSpivakartsstories 11 лет назад

So according to your video above, the "squared script" Hebrew wasn't adopted in Israel until 2500 years ago. Yet according to most Rabbinical scholars, Moses lived 3500 years ago. Does that mean that the Torah that Moses received was written in a completely different language than the Hebrew that we see in today's Torah.

@sue8536 5 месяцев назад

10 years and no one has replied to this lad? Now I want to know and I guess we will wait together

@mrtruthify 13 лет назад

The 1980 Jewish Almanac, p. 3, in the first chapter entitled, “Identity Crisis” said… “Strictly speaking, it is INCORRECT to call an ancient Israelite a ‘Jew’ or to call a contemporary Jew an ‘Israelite’ or a ‘Hebrew.’” “Here is a paradox . . . A most ingenious paradox: an ANTHROPOLOGICAL FACT, many [Caucasian] Christians may have MUCH MORE Hebrew-Israelite blood in their veins than most of their Jewish neighbors.” Jewish author, Alfred M. Lilienthal, What Price Israel, p. 223.

@GeorgePapageorgakis 8 лет назад

+Jeff A. Benner An interesting book to read: *Hebrew is Greek - Joseph Isaac Jahuda - Oxford 1982* Cheers.

@gracealmu6115 5 лет назад

Please where can I get the PDF version or cheaper version

@messianic_scam 4 года назад

😂😂😂 hebrew is greek because they sound so much alike🤔

@Gieszkanne 4 года назад

@@gracealmu6115 Google it I found two just on the first page

@paoleila 4 года назад

@Papageorgakis Yassou, your recommendation of Hebrew is Greek by Joseph Isaac Jahuda caught my attention. I'd love to get the book for I have a similar idea, but not that hebrew is Greek, my theory is that the origins of languages- (not all languages) but Semetic and Sanskrite derived/Indo-European- come from mainly two ancient languages one of them already dead, I read the reviews on Amazon about Hebrew is Greek - by Joseph Isaac Jahuda and found the comment regarding the word HOUSE-= BEY or beytu. In Arabic for example, there is another word for house but not in use anymore to mean house for humans except rarely!; In modern Arabic Kur means a house for a snake, rodents; in Pashto the word for house is KOR, in Greek XORIO is the word for village. They are definitely similar. "1.0 out of 5 stars beyth-beyt-beyt-oikia..one of these words is not like the others... Reviewed in the United States on June 30, 2014 I enjoyed this but just for the sharpening I derived from it.The oldest writing/language is,Akkadian a Semitic language that's related to modern languages Arabic and Hebrew. The Akkadian word for house is beyth or betu, which is the same as the Arabic beyt or the Hebrew beyt,the word for house in Greek is oikia,not similar at all. There is a natural progression in language changing.The man seems brilliant,but his claims are outlandish.Scientific proof? really....Really?" Languages don't have to be written, and words come in and out of languages and somerime words change meaning; there seems to be a common system based not just on words, but on grammar/syntax for semitic and indo-European languages.

@4420ish 9 лет назад

Paleohebrew is the oldest language...but people hating the Bible suggested that Sanskrit, a pagan language, was the oldest...

@roben2791 9 лет назад

4420ish paleohebrew, I know many languages that had been spoken before it

@ancienthebreworg 14 лет назад

@cobone1 Thank you for the insights and I did look this tablet up. However, the inscription on it is not Greek, not is it Phonecian. But what is interesting is the date of the writing - 5,000 BC, pretty impressive for a writing specimen.

@mazinga5159 3 года назад

That is pelasge writing nor greek(name Greek appears only in 18 century) , nor Jewish ,

@DarkFilmDirector 12 лет назад

I'm not a linguist but in simplest terms, Archaic Hebrew script was more cursive defined - for writing on paper. The Phoenician one tended to be more lapidary and refined for writing on stone. But the differences are minute. What's important to remember is that the Greeks based their alphabet directly off of the Phoenician one, since the Greeks had regular contact with them, not the Hebrews during the time period.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@istiiizzz Not at all. As I point out in this series the Phoenician/Hebrew alphabet is an evolved form of the proto-Semitic writing. The oldest examples of this writing were found in the Sinai penninsula and the nile region of Egypt. It was not until much later that the Phoenicians began using the evolved form of this script.

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

@ajaxthree1 Thank you ajax for the kind words and support, it is much appreciated.

@robbihuffine6626 7 лет назад

You showed the letter Khet instead of the Hey, as the Ezra Era Square Letter used today, towards the end of the video.

@messianicagejudaism 6 лет назад

Paleo Hebrew was a combination of Phoenician and ancient Egyptian writing. The only difference is the vowel system used to phonetically distinguish the two languages in the Paleo-Hebrew. Throughout history, the vowel system was replaced or interchangeably translated by different phonetic or translation variations, like the Samaritan, Syriac, Masoretic, text. This is how the new Hebrew modern language became to exist. However, the Paleo-Hebrew is the way to find out the true meaning of the Hebrew culture, roots, and the Holy writings.

@itzfili 11 лет назад

I agree, according to the oldest documents that can be related to the Hebrews. But the inscription in serabit-el-hadem written by slaves in the Sinai desert mines, the oldest Alphabetical inscription found (1500 BC), is using the word BALAT to name one god (this is Canaanite name|) and in other place EL, which is Hebrew.

@aliabdullahalhamo3641 6 лет назад

Oooh! That was Phoenician, which all Semites used one day...

@dachou55cs 5 лет назад

false , they were hellenised canaanites

@valenrn8657 3 года назад

Phoenicians are also sea traders, hence their alphabet system was spread across the Mediterranean sea. English's Latin alphabet continues the Phoenician tradition for today's international trade.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@liu408 The Gamma, which looks like a C, but pronounced like the G, evolved into both the C and G in the English Alphabet.

@TheGloriaDee 11 лет назад

Yahweh and tHEeS Native Tribes. Praise Yahweh!

@Q_reezy 3 года назад

Are you a Christian like me?

@glm6928 2 года назад

@@FirstInLastOut94 but Greek was not the original language. How can you take a translation more seriously than the original version?

@faraisithole3209 5 лет назад

Shalom . Thanks a lot for the enlightening video. It explained what has always puzzled me as astudent of Hebrew , Greek and latin . Todah

@edl3156 10 лет назад

RE:Yamgoyim's contention. Aleph actually is a consonant. Linguists call it a glottal stop.

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

If you compare Phoenician with Old Hebrew you will find that they are identical, there are of course slight differences between them, but there is also slight differences with the Phoenician writings as well as differences in the Old Hebrew writings. The idea that the Greeks based their alphabet on Phoenician is only speculation as there is no actual proof of this, but it is a reasonable assumption based on their contact with each other.

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

Modern Western religions see a deity as spiritual. Ancient Eastern peoples saw "Elohim" (incorrectly translated as "God")as physical.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@4anuvis4 The archeological record is very clear, the alphabet used by most all cultures today, including Roman, Greek, Semitic was developed and first used by the Semites in the ancient Near East.

@go_to_explore 4 года назад

What were the languages spoken in jesus time ?

@tonysoldan 4 года назад

Well, we Greeks borrowed Phoenician symbols, reversed them and then we invented vowels that were added into the mix. They called it an “alphabet.”

@zapplecore 15 лет назад

These vids are gold

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

@shaharmos That is partially correct, the Hebrew letters used today are in fact Aramaic, but the original Hebrew is different from Aramaic.

@joesneed5030 2 года назад

You keep saying that the Greeks got their alphabet from the "Old Hebrew Alphabet." I know that the old Hebrew and old Phoenician alphabets were pretty much identical. So, Wouldn't it be more accurate to say that the Greeks got their alphabet from the old Phoenician alphabet, since it was the Phoenician sailors who made contact with the Greeks? The Hebrews rarely sailed at all. Or am I missing something here?

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

@shaharmos Not exactly, Aramaic is a sister language to Hebrew and is very similar to it. But I should note that the Aramaic in the Old Testament, such as in the books of Ezra and Daniel, isn't exactly Aramaic, its more of an Aramaic that is heavily influenced by Hebrew. Similar to how Yiddish is German that is heavily influenced by Hebrew.

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

In the preceding segment of this video series I point out that "Old Hebrew" and Phoenician are one and the same alphabet. Therefore, to say they didn't copy the Old Hebrew but instead the Phoenician is a contradiction.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@Flickchaser Thank you very much for the suggestions.

@nurturingglobal2local473 3 года назад

א ב ג: Hebrew: א ב נ ד Ethiopia: አ ቡ ጊ ዳ Arabic : أ ب د Semitic/ Phoenicians etc original alphabet all of the above including Greek and Roman influence from the Ethiopian Coptic Alphabet called geez : አ ቡ ጊ ዳ /A Bu Gi Da

@genesisbustamante-durian 3 года назад

Let me guess you are ehtiopian you biased piece of shit. The scripts looks different, loser.

@nurturingglobal2local473 3 года назад

@@genesisbustamante-durian I can understand by the word you use, what kind person you are, ignorance is human beings worst enemy. Who are: the proto Semitic/ Phoenician/ Kemetic/ Egyptian/ Aramaic/ Coptic, when you pronounced the Ethiopian alphabet then you get the answer

@genesisbustamante-durian 3 года назад

@@nurturingglobal2local473 Tell me, where did you read that Phoenician alphabet came from Ge'ez alphabet?

@brotherebenezer449 3 года назад

May Yehovah expand your great teachings sir.

@freeman7788 Год назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JEecFAJVRFU.html

@savagedonut Год назад

Egyptian hieroglyphs -> Proto Sinai (Egypt writing system) -> Phoenician -> Greek alphabet ( vowels ) -> Latin -> Modern European languages but it started in Egypt it seems. Europe is linked to Egypt.

@ajaxthree1 12 лет назад

When one has more inputs, one gets closer to the Cre8tor. God is a puzzle - Prov 1.6. and puzzles are sometimes puzzling. I worked at 1 of the new FaceBook data centers during the construction phase, many engineers were puzzled as to how this building would operate and said "that's wrong". If all/more shared their perspectives with Jeff he would have more inputs and he could adjust his outputs accordingly. Consider that the origin of A is God "Hi-m (wE3) self" as He is/was the word...

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

The Hebrew and Phoenician alphabets are one and the same thing, some call this alphabet Phoenician and others call it Hebrew.

@ashzole Год назад

how is gamma the letter C???? you can get a c sound with s. if they can reverse letters turn them around . then gamma can be an L

@jbeil-byblosbaalback6850 8 лет назад

That's Phoenician/Canaanite, Hebrew came after so those letter are from Lebanon/Syria don't lie to your viewers. Hebrew can we after those Phoenician letters

@bloodbased 3 года назад

They are only different stylistically. If there weren’t so much potential for Biblical/Theological controversies, they wouldn’t be considered separate alphabets at all. By any other objective standard; so called Canaanite, Phoenician, and Paleo-Hebrew are all the same thing. They just have separate examples, from diverse locations, where the letters are just rendered _slightly_ different. Basically, they don’t want you to realize that what the Greek historians called “Phoenicians” were racially Israelites who had fallen to paganism; ie, they may have been worshiping Canaanite deities, but they weren’t necessarily Canaanites.

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

I don't think you understand how this works. Your approach is; I make statement X. You make statement Y. You expect me to research Y. You have it backwards, the way it is suppose to work is; I make statement X. You make statement Y. You supply hard evidence to support Y.

@MrBenalib 10 лет назад

Dude this is not hebrew alphabet this is the Phoenician-Canaanite Alphabet!! borrowed by Israelite tribes BTW their "language was Judean, a dialect of the Canaanite language as well as Moabite Ammonite and Phoenician dialects

@panosgkilis9263 6 лет назад

so if the Jews had not the first launguage then that means that the Torah aint divine? its not created by G.d?

@valenrn8657 6 лет назад

Kingdom of Israel is part of Canaanite tribe branch.

@ItsameAlex 13 лет назад

@ancienthebreworg nope, read this: '' It is the first and oldest alphabet in the narrow sense that it notes each vowel and consonant with a separate symbol''-Greek alphabet. Go to wikipedia and search ''greek alphabe''t.

@NearEastern 13 лет назад

These are Phoenician letters. And to be more precise, cadmus (a Phoenician) is known to have taught the Greeks to write Phoenician. But not to be mistaken that the Greeks did not know how to write before the arrival of Phoenicians. The Greeks went through a dark period where they simply lost the knowledge to write only to have it retaught to them by the Phoenician traders. Similar history can be applied to the Hebraic kingdoms. (cont)

@NearEastern 13 лет назад

And please let's not forget that the Hebrews lived in Egypt before invading Canaan.

@genesisbustamante-durian 3 года назад

And they also lived in Canaan before living in Egypt.

@catharperfect7036 2 года назад

On Wikipedia though it says that both Greek (via Old Italic) and Paleo-Hebrew are 'child systems' of Phoenician? In other words it couldn't be Paleo-Hebrew that gave rise to Greek, but rather Phoenician itself, no? Thoughts? What's the historicity behind it all? Great videos btw.

@ancienthebreworg 14 лет назад

I sure did din't I? LOL, thank you very much for the headsup and I have made a note to change this in the final draft.

@abcstan 11 лет назад

Greek ,Hebrew and Arabic developed from the Phoenician alphabet which is considered to be the first alphabet to use letters. Greek was original written from right to left for two hundred years then written in boustrophedon for a further three hundred years. All in all Greek was written and read in a right to left direction for over five hundred years .For more info go to abcstan or Omniglot seek and you will find.

@glorrifiedTorah 12 лет назад

Sorry this has nothing to do with this video, but to do with the main website. I have been looking at the work done on the Dead Sea Scrolls and the differences between them and the Masoretic texts. I know to many it would not seem like changing a letter to a vowel point would make much difference, but to me it does, since it changes the story in the word, since each letter has a meaning. It also matters to me because not one letter was to be changed by Elohim's order

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

I can understand your unpopularity :-), many of us have been there ourselves. Yes, I will be planning on making this series available as a DVD or two, depending on how big it gets LOL.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@notgodsemigod Can you name me the Israeli Archeologists that beleve that? Virtually all sources I have read agree that that paleo-Hebrew script developed from the earlier proto-Semitic script. This means that the Greek script had to have come from the later paleo-Hebrew script.

@ancienthebreworg 14 лет назад

Actually, at 2:55, for the modern Hebrew, I did use the chet instead of the hey.

@DihydrogenMonoxideGuy 3 года назад

2:55

@ancienthebreworg 14 лет назад

@Sardonac A correction is necessary and I have added an anotation to the video. Thanks for your help.

@OKandNOWwhat 12 лет назад

@shaharmos None. But if your statement were taken as a syllogism, the use of the same alphabet and a concurrent development do not equate two languages. If the words are different, the language is different. Hebrew & Aramaic share many words, as do French and English. But they sound different because they are. Bless you

@DarkFilmDirector 12 лет назад

The author actually isn't too far off. While the Greeks did not base their alphabet off Old Hebrew, they did actually copy the alphabet system of the Phoenicians, another Semitic language.

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@istiiizzz The origins of the Phoenicians is debated, but their origins is irrelevent to this debate.

@cyber.marshall Год назад

Why is there a ח instead of a ה at 2:55 in the video?

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

If they are not the same, can you tell what differences they have? Thanks.

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

@1robinsong The evidence for the adoption of the Aramaic script is found by following what script was used in the history of Israel. Prior to their Babylonian Captivity Israel always used the Old Hebrew script. It is not until the Babylonian captivity that we find Israel using the Aramaic square script. Aramea is another name for Babylon, so the Aramean captivity is the same thing as the Babylonian captivity.

@Seventh7Art 11 лет назад

The Greek alphabet exists since 800 BCE. The old Hebrew alphabet appeared LATER. The Phoenician alphabet was formed around 1050 BC. Greek does not derive from Old Hebrew.

@TURNKEYiNK Год назад

Wonder if the 9th letter: Tet, is used in scripture as a word, as I haven’t been able to find the proper spelling of Tet -which is (to me), one of the most fascinating and mysterious letters of the Aleph-Bet.

@freeman7788 Год назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JEecFAJVRFU.html

@TURNKEYiNK Год назад

@@freeman7788 Thanks for sharing. Very interesting video.

@freeman7788 Год назад

@@TURNKEYiNK Check out Alien jurisdiction Mary mother of the Sun And English is debt speak.... ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-btlNI4VblBQ.html

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@survivorproject There are many similarities between the Bible and Greek mythology. One of my favorites is Gen 6 which says that the "nephilim" were "heroes of Olam." Olam is the Hebrew word translated as "old," but what if it was a place name-Olam, which is very similar to Olympus.

@jamn928 14 лет назад

I think you have a chet instead of a he at 2:56 for the modern block script.

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

I looked up "Aris Poulianos" in wikipedia and read the whole article and there was nothing there on the origins of the Greek alphabet. I'm sorry, but if you want me to take your comments seriously, you are going to have to give me some proof.

@k344hxx6 4 года назад

greeks adopted phoenician alphabet, same as hebrews did, and those at the first of the video are phoenician alphabets :)

@anaggressiveroyalbengaltig1723 2 года назад

Ancient HEBREW to Greek and Aramaic. "GREEK" to etruscan, classic Greek. Etruscan to Latin, runic, Irish,German,modern Roman etc.. Classic Greek to Coptic, Gothic, Cyrillic, modern Cyrillic, modern Greek etc.. "ARAMAIC" to square Hebrew, modern Hebrew, Syrian, Brahmi, mangolian,Nabatean to modern Arabic etc.. Finally Hebrew is the grand mother of all modern languages.

@itzfili 11 лет назад

I'm not claiming that Hebrew is the source for Greek letters. what I say is that "Phoenician" relates to Hebrew just as old Greek relates to Greek. We both can read and understand texts written 3000 years ago in our mother language. And please, search Wikipedia for "Khirbet Qeiyafa" for the oldest text in Hebrew that is using biblical words and content. It looks like that the use of writing in Israel was earlier in 200 years than in Greece.

@espositogregory 4 года назад

At 2:55, the modern hebrew script show the Chet ח instead if hei ה

@dr.dougwilson2350 Год назад

2:55 and following--you have written a Hebrew heth for a "hey" as the fifth letter.

@user-ev6rs2ng4f 3 месяца назад

Oh my, backwards writings. What’s it say?

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

You're welcome and thank you.

@johnknoefler 15 лет назад

I eagerly await your next offering. My I give my most heart felt praise of your dedication to furthering the understanding of Hebrew origions and translation issues. Because of my interest in this topic I am not popular with my relatives and I left my family religion. The closest I can come to a congregation is Messianic Jewish since they don't get angry with me when I offer new things I have discovered. When you are finished I hope you offer the complete work as a video cd. Your site I faved.

@freeman7788 Год назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JEecFAJVRFU.html

@user-de6rn9uu3r 6 лет назад

that is phoenician alphabet even hebrew is a canaanite language you refer to as hebrew some refer to it as aramaic it depends on the region just like babylonian and assyrian but in reality these are the same language semite language as Arabic and Akkadian

@dachou55cs 5 лет назад

false

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

The Hebrew word for Hebrew is evriy (Eberite), which literally means one descended from ever (Eber). From Eber is descended the Ishmaelites, Israelites, Midianites, Amorites, Moabites, and more. So, technically, most of the Semitic people are "Hebrews."

@ancienthebreworg 13 лет назад

@hottiezol In this video series I present my sources to support the claims within this video. Do you have any contradictory evidence for saying this video segment is "wrong?' Or do you just say I'm wrong and everyone is suppose to believe you?

@Seventh7Art 11 лет назад

The Old Hebrew alphabet derives from Phoenician! Greek never derived from Old Hebrew alphabet, that is a lie! IT partly derived from Phoenician, and original Greek letters were added.

@valenrn8657 5 лет назад

Old Hebrew is a very close Phoenician derivative.

@genesisbustamante-durian 3 года назад

@@valenrn8657 Or what is more likely, the Jews wrote stuff with the Phoenician letters but in their sacred Language. They did not change the script enough to be considered a variation of Phoenician script.

@valenrn8657 3 года назад

@@genesisbustamante-durian Jews are just yet another Phoenician tribe.

@barthill9578 12 лет назад

that dont sound correct, why would they put at end and not in the word? plus they had no vowels

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

Yes, you are correct, but Roman is derived out of the Hebrew via the Greek.

@ancienthebreworg 12 лет назад

@MR1EAR We know the word eevriy (Hebrew) comes from the root avar, which means "to cross over." The "iy" suffix to eevriy means "one of," so eevriy means "one of Ever (Eber). Abram is called an eevriy because he was descended from Ever. Israelite (or Israeliy in Hebrew) is one descended from Israel (Jacob) and a Yehudiy (Jew) is one descended from Yehudah (Judah).

@ancienthebreworg 15 лет назад

If this is true, then the Greek alphabet can only be dated to about 1200 BC. You are saying that the Inear A and B are from 3,000 BCE, but I am still waiting for you to give any evidence to support that theiry. Since you can not provide any evidence, then I will assume that it is incorrect.

@DarkFilmDirector 12 лет назад

Nearly, but certainly not the same. That's why I said you aren't far off. But the Greeks most certainly did not base their alphabet off of an isolated Canaanite tribe like the Hebrews, but the sea-faring competitors of the Phoenicians.

@tFighterPilot 13 лет назад

@ZeusTelemaxos 600BC? Then how come the bible, some of which takes place before 600BC, is written in Hebrew? Also, which language was spoken in Canaan in Phoenicia if not Canaanite? Aramaic was spoken in Aram, that's why it's called Aramaic.