Тёмный

A Jewish-American activist says attacks on Palestine voices have "gone too far" | The Big Picture 

Middle East Eye
Подписаться 2,2 млн
Просмотров 14 тыс.
50% 1

“What could be more dangerous to Jewish people than lumping us in with this genocidal campaign?”
If Not Now co-founder Simone Zimmerman says the attacks against anyone speaking for Palestine have gotten so bad that even antisemitism experts and Jewish historians are being smeared and targeted on university campuses.
Zimmerman’s personal story from a pro-Israeli student to a pro-Palestinian organiser was documented in the acclaimed new film ‘Israelism’. She describes her activism as the best defence against real world antisemitism, and that wherever there are Jewish people, there will be a presence at Palestine rallies.
Catch the full interview on this week’s episode of The Big Picture Podcast.
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye

Опубликовано:

 

23 апр 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 185   
@bahidjamajiet5581
@bahidjamajiet5581 Месяц назад
the founder of Hamas made it clear and i quote him " We do not fight them because they are Jews...we fight them because they are Occupiers....."
@jrhartley4819
@jrhartley4819 Месяц назад
I think Sweden should rise up against their violent occupiers.
@TheJonh000
@TheJonh000 Месяц назад
@@jrhartley4819 nobody's occupying Sweden, even less violently
@jrhartley4819
@jrhartley4819 Месяц назад
The founder of Hamas should also tell you that they were founded on the pillars of radical Islam. Do a bit of research before you decide to be clever.
@jrhartley4819
@jrhartley4819 Месяц назад
@@TheJonh000 Perhaps you should ask the Swedes. How dare you dismiss it with your personal opinion. Typical pro-Hamas mob member.
@davidfine1341
@davidfine1341 Месяц назад
Hahahaha😂
@jimmyromano4525
@jimmyromano4525 Месяц назад
Such a sound, reasoned, humanitarian perspective. What does this say about the people who rabidly oppose it? It takes a lot of courage and principles for Jews to speak publicly about this and I truly respect them for it.
@StephenfromChch
@StephenfromChch Месяц назад
What an articulate comment.👍
@paddydalton2373
@paddydalton2373 Месяц назад
This Is Not About Jew's Or Even Arab's.. It's About Governing Policies That Fuel This Hatred
@yohanag3408
@yohanag3408 Месяц назад
it’s not about jews, it’s about zionism…
@mbronzeinfo7950
@mbronzeinfo7950 Месяц назад
Based on racism apartheid and segregation
@ingeborg3333
@ingeborg3333 Месяц назад
Thank you for your integrity. It's true, Gaza puts all of us in danger, whether Jews or Muslims or just anyone in this world. And your Jewish voices are the most important to open people's eyes.
@afifaamin6944
@afifaamin6944 Месяц назад
She said it so honestly.
@dlslythgoe666
@dlslythgoe666 Месяц назад
I grew up in SA during the dying days of apartheid. Even as a British kid we were exposed to cradle to grave indoctrination and history rewritten into propaganda while we were raised into a militarised state. The older generation grasped on harder as their world slipped from their fingers yet the youth began to fight back first in small numbers risking arrest, beatings and sometimes death from police and army. But the tighter the grip. The harder we fought until the inevitable was happening and the young moved into positions of wealth and power and began to dismantle the system from within. America’s geriatric leaders are not long for this world and the young will start to take on the mantle and no longer fun Israel’s cruelty or mass murder. Support in the UNSC will become a thing of the past. Evil cannot and will not be allowed to exist forever as young idealistic leaders that have morally sound judgement will dismantle the support that allowed the sadistic state of Isreal to exist for so long. Just like apartheid days were numbered in SA so are they in Israel. The zionists should pray to their gods of money and power and hope that the Palestinians will find it in their hearts to forgive the atrocities they committed against innocents just as the name Isreal will invoke a sense of disgust and shame for decades to come as the nazis are seen today
@esratasneem1113
@esratasneem1113 Месяц назад
Well said. Thank you.
@jrhartley4819
@jrhartley4819 Месяц назад
Yet now that blacks are attacking and stealing from whites, nobody says anything.
@ahmedramzy597
@ahmedramzy597 Месяц назад
Well said young lady. We all wish for the same things in life.
@europainvicta3907
@europainvicta3907 Месяц назад
In London, where I live, there has always been a large Jewish bloc at every Palestine march. London is very proud of them.
@da7me22
@da7me22 Месяц назад
She is gorgeous, beautiful inside and out.
@jimbojones101
@jimbojones101 Месяц назад
Were Palestinians, guards at the camps during WW2? . . .
@mega99999
@mega99999 Месяц назад
I don't think so... but expect israel to make up this claim soon😅
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
Most of the capos in German camps during WW2 were Jewish. But I think you knew that, right?
@reemsaif3105
@reemsaif3105 Месяц назад
Europe threw jews in palestine that was under British mandate after they created the holocaust, they also forced jewish arabs to go there as well.they killed the old people and took young families to create isreal. There was rape and genocide to create the city, they told them its a land without people for people without a land and so on. They use them in the army for American Interest but they don't know that. It goes against the torah. Before all of this they were going to put them in Uganda, check wiki.
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
Most of the capos in WW2 prison camps were ... [CENSORED] - sapienti sat...
@MTx485
@MTx485 Месяц назад
Google Hajj Amin Al-Husseini and read a few paragraphs about that alliance.
@Hesham_MK
@Hesham_MK Месяц назад
Jewish Americans are the ones that will bring about the liberation of Palestine. All respect 🫡
@candelariadelazar4390
@candelariadelazar4390 Месяц назад
I agree 200%
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
Just like America brought “liberation” to Afghanistan, Vietnam, Japan, etc., etc., etc.
@MyWissam
@MyWissam Месяц назад
​@@ernestolynch1926 You completely misunderstood, or chose to misinterpret, the comment.
@candelariadelazar4390
@candelariadelazar4390 Месяц назад
@ernestolynch1926 no, you are deliberately chosing thecwrong concepts, twice now
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
@@candelariadelazar4390 Are you high?
@Jim-nt7xy
@Jim-nt7xy Месяц назад
Thank you for speaking out against the atrocities.
@3rrlia661
@3rrlia661 Месяц назад
Zionism, israel and being jewish may have something in common but clearly they are 3 different things
@nch6807
@nch6807 Месяц назад
A safe world for all people NOT JUST FOR JEWS.
@MarianAMusse
@MarianAMusse Месяц назад
Young lady such wisdom than the so called leaders.
@dantyrrell3300
@dantyrrell3300 Месяц назад
You are wonderful Jewish person. Keep up the good work.
@The88Kings
@The88Kings Месяц назад
What a queen
@ayeshaali8131
@ayeshaali8131 Месяц назад
She needs more exposure...we need more like thinking people from both Jews and Palestinians to actually have a chance of coexistence, as neighbours, as equals, as friends...and a chance for peace
@tonenotrequired8626
@tonenotrequired8626 Месяц назад
What a brave brave woman. Thank you for your humanity.
@r00mq1
@r00mq1 Месяц назад
Courageous woman, my respect.
@user-cu2es6ok6j
@user-cu2es6ok6j Месяц назад
May God bless all these jewish people. Risking their livelihoods for the sake of the palestinians remind us of the germans who helped the jews against the NAZI
@abdelhamidboukabou840
@abdelhamidboukabou840 Месяц назад
Hopefully there are brave persons like this lady ❤
@hamodachichigo8029
@hamodachichigo8029 Месяц назад
Thank you very much !!
@Mahir-mf4cd
@Mahir-mf4cd Месяц назад
May god bless this woman Thank you
@ChefbyMistake
@ChefbyMistake Месяц назад
I agree with her. Let Palestine be free
@timbanks7344
@timbanks7344 Месяц назад
Thank you for speaking out, young lady.
@user-xx4bf7et5h
@user-xx4bf7et5h Месяц назад
Our battle is against genocide and occupation, not against jews or judaism
@Heavenlyrules
@Heavenlyrules Месяц назад
ANGEL
@rifasheriffdeen9513
@rifasheriffdeen9513 Месяц назад
Thank you for speaking truth to Evil power!
@user-xx4bf7et5h
@user-xx4bf7et5h Месяц назад
I loved Dr.Norman Finkelsteins genius response to that accusation: "lets say Einstein was a self-hating jew does that make y not = 2x squared"
@esratasneem1113
@esratasneem1113 Месяц назад
Thank you Simone. Beautifully said. 🇵🇸💞
@davidfine1341
@davidfine1341 Месяц назад
Yes they are. And also brainwashed. Disgraceful. 😢
@Ghandi12
@Ghandi12 Месяц назад
It's a war good against evil. The humankind gone win, the humanity gone loose a lot off beautiful souls. The win is there shall be peace for us all no matter your relegion, no matter your skin color, no matter your believes. We must go on for the full 100 %. Thank you Simone 🌍❤💚🤍🖤❤
@jamesdean4922
@jamesdean4922 Месяц назад
I believe these jewish people for peace are some of the bravest best people in the world.
@postwatch1377
@postwatch1377 Месяц назад
Well said. If only our leaders had a similar clarity of consciousness.
@azizdridah9467
@azizdridah9467 Месяц назад
God bless the honest jews that stand against injustice!
@brahimmandour9696
@brahimmandour9696 Месяц назад
Respect and appreciation for this lady. She is truly courageously, what a queen are you lady with a good heart ❤️ for humanity, i agree with her, hat 👒 off and God bless 🙌 you and your family. In God we trust 🙏 he will protect us all together. Love and much greetings from Moroccan citizens.
@kritisch614
@kritisch614 Месяц назад
Free Palästina.. Stop GC
@Shofargirl1
@Shofargirl1 Месяц назад
Yes, GOD help us all ! 😢
@jonathanblank2347
@jonathanblank2347 Месяц назад
Not bad children. Just bad parents.
@lulumozba
@lulumozba Месяц назад
❤❤❤
@mbronzeinfo7950
@mbronzeinfo7950 Месяц назад
THANK YOU SO MUCH JEWISH ✡️ 💙 ❤️ PEOPLE TOO WERE VICTIMS OF THE. NAKBA💕🙏🫂⚖️💯🇵🇸
@andrewnlarsen
@andrewnlarsen Месяц назад
When grieving for the hellish losses they suffered, they were taken advantage of by Jewish zionists.
@bpd9660
@bpd9660 Месяц назад
Jews against atrocities committed by Netanyahu... that is what we are protesting
@williamkauffman5745
@williamkauffman5745 Месяц назад
🙏
@kr902
@kr902 Месяц назад
Brilliantly stated, “how is this genocide keeping Jews safe’…..? To the contrary genocide is fuelling hatred.
@kelliephoenix
@kelliephoenix Месяц назад
💯
@michaelmcbride4930
@michaelmcbride4930 Месяц назад
These young Jewish people taking such a stance are the true “chosen people” ❤
@naymatunc-rc6vs
@naymatunc-rc6vs Месяц назад
RABBIM SEN UYUYAN GOZLERI GONULLERI UYANDIR BAKTIGINI GORMELERINI SAGLA RABBIM ☝️☝️☝️🇵🇸🤲🤲🤲
@pascalsolal
@pascalsolal Месяц назад
As always, politics make war against the will of people of both sides.
@TantraySirPhysicsClasses
@TantraySirPhysicsClasses Месяц назад
Beautiful Jewish lady with beautiful heart
@assalaamu-alaykum
@assalaamu-alaykum Месяц назад
@wiesaalabrahams7700
@wiesaalabrahams7700 Месяц назад
What an intelligent, rational young lady. Keep doing the good work, Islamophobia is ruining so many lives since the USA started their vigorous campaign against All Muslims in 2001!!!
@lystein1070
@lystein1070 Месяц назад
shes not self hating, just grossly misinformed
@StevenWolf275
@StevenWolf275 Месяц назад
Guards at ww2
@mahbubafidda620
@mahbubafidda620 Месяц назад
@nadiamouj3385
@nadiamouj3385 Месяц назад
🤲♥️
@ehmoudfahmy2332
@ehmoudfahmy2332 Месяц назад
الشر توراة عزرا توراة عزرا شر
@madjock-ig5bv
@madjock-ig5bv Месяц назад
Lovely interview with a kind compassionate person. I do not judge anyone on what religion they might be. That is actually not important to me. I judge a person on how they act towards others in society. There are good and bad people in all groups (whether religious, social, race, sexuality etc). I dislike the horrible or the cruel ones in each group whilst respecting everyone else and their right to be who they are.
@user-vy8mp5sv7b
@user-vy8mp5sv7b Месяц назад
SHE IS AN ANGEL! SHE IS A MODERN MESSIAH!
@IlyaRabinovich
@IlyaRabinovich Месяц назад
You are not Jewish, you are a person of a Jew ethical roots. And yes, you hates Jewish state, Jewish people and Jewish values. Calling yourself as a Jewish is blatant lies.
@sha1658
@sha1658 Месяц назад
To step out of "Jewishness' must be difficult-- but she is doing what Jesus would. All of them, speaking out, is what an objective/clear-headed and Godly thing to do = LOVE.
@WorkingMan234
@WorkingMan234 Месяц назад
Salt of the earth
@michaelslater3464
@michaelslater3464 Месяц назад
Lol salt ruins the earth … yes “ salt”
@Gary-sx5ox
@Gary-sx5ox Месяц назад
I have painfully listed to several clips about the American Jewish opinion. Let’s start with a simple question. What would you have wanted Israel to do after the Hamas attack????? Not one of these videos has the answer. What do you want Israel to do about all of the people that are still prisoners under Hamas? Hamas has figured out that if they fight, using children as shields, they will suck in the sympathy of Social Media. Why isn’t Hamas being protested against for using this cowardly way of fighting? Finally, at this point, what do you want Israel to do so this never happens again? Everyone has an opinion until they are asked these questions. It’s so hypocritical to not recognized the horrors of war. The side that is usually chosen are done from the cheap seats.
@Robert-mw5tp
@Robert-mw5tp Месяц назад
I am so glad to hear beautiful people like her so i don’t hate Jews
@KorenVeerz
@KorenVeerz Месяц назад
Is this your application to become a Sonderkommando? I don't think you have the muscle mass just saying
@AA-SOM
@AA-SOM Месяц назад
🫡🫡
@candelariadelazar4390
@candelariadelazar4390 Месяц назад
Well said. I am happy for these jews, and I wouldn't want to be a zionist nowadays. I don't think it's dangerous, but it can be uncomfortable.
@janiceshugantini14
@janiceshugantini14 Месяц назад
Why there is no protersers asking Hamas to stop the barbaric works to be stop shame on you student who paid for you?is that much you valued for the money Students are so cheap that They can just buy you just like that
@SirCamera
@SirCamera Месяц назад
Protests are meant to put pressure on your own institutions. In the USA, for example, our institutions have nothing to do with Hamas. Nothing. Zero. What we have influence over - what we are responsible for - is what *we* are doing. And what our institutions are doing with our labor, votes, and tax dollars is supporting Israel’s g3n0cidal agenda (one that has not rescued any hostages and has in fact killed a few of them by IDF fire). Let the Palestinians worry about Hamas. An American protesting Hamas is symbolic at best. Instead, protest what you have tangible, material leverage over.
@rozetkeribar4971
@rozetkeribar4971 Месяц назад
Stupidité
@moudzy1446
@moudzy1446 Месяц назад
I like M=E but disagree of the title of this video. We need to address people by their nationality first and then their religious beliefs. For example: sayin “Christian-American" emphasizes the person's Christian identity first, suggesting that their faith is a primary aspect of their identity, and then their American nationality. "American-Christian," on the other hand, emphasizes the person's American identity first, suggesting that their nationality is a primary aspect of their identity, and then their Christian faith. However, it's important to note that these terms are not commonly used. In the United States, it's more common to say "American" to refer to nationality and "Christian" to refer to religious belief, without combining the two.
@EggBastion
@EggBastion Месяц назад
!? consider the title of the video in relation to the video that its's the title of
@mickeydrennan1576
@mickeydrennan1576 Месяц назад
Blah, blah, blah...
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
"We need to address people by their nationality first and then their religious beliefs." - yeah... Then why do so many Americans identify as "Italian American", "French American", "African American", etc.? In the United States, the difference between nationality and citizenship is blurred. And how would you define the meaning of the term “Jew”? This is intentionally made very confusing. One may be Jewish by birth and still be secular, while another may become a "Jew" by converting to the religion of Judaism, regardless of his ethnic background. This is soooo fishy....
@moudzy1446
@moudzy1446 Месяц назад
@@ernestolynch1926 I think I agree with you if you mean that religion is not a nationality. Is that what you intended to say?
@mickeydrennan1576
@mickeydrennan1576 Месяц назад
@@ernestolynch1926 you're just ignorant. Nationality means nothing. "French" can be a nationality and ethnicity, as can "Italian". "African" isn't a nationality. Jewish people can be ethnically Jewish or religious Jews. Maybe go read a book or two on the matter. Or is that too much effort?
@RobertoSiffredi-xy1nc
@RobertoSiffredi-xy1nc Месяц назад
She says nothing and doesn't acknowledge the horrors of October 7th.
@thetaxiucla
@thetaxiucla Месяц назад
This rich wealthy woman may not have a care in the world and can dream about ivory tower future utopias, but many others are facing stark realities. Her tea and crumpet luxury routine is certainly not a one size fits all.
@TheSwissPoliticalSystem
@TheSwissPoliticalSystem Месяц назад
I wonder what triggers your negative view of what is obviously a sane, wise, young woman full of humanity
@rezrunnercl
@rezrunnercl Месяц назад
Guess we know who is who. Why would the world not like people who excuse a Halocaust? For every bit of good will she creates, you take it away. Just remember... people have the right to retaliate. What you support...never ends. You seal your own fate.
@Moscow8888
@Moscow8888 Месяц назад
How disgusting. She could not condemn the October 7th attack with a single word, and she even blames the victims of the attack. She justifies the attack by referring to the domestic political debate in Israel as its "context".
@amraboughazala5986
@amraboughazala5986 Месяц назад
you are not self hating jews, they are Jews by benefit not by religion.
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
Anything profitable goes, indeed.
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
I'm confused: she talks about "Jewish traditions", but are those traditions? Let's be clear: Zionism and Judaism are two sides of the same coin.
@mickeydrennan1576
@mickeydrennan1576 Месяц назад
No, they're not. Stop spreading nonsense.
@candelariadelazar4390
@candelariadelazar4390 Месяц назад
No. Please inform yourself. Christianity is good, crusaders or KKK are not, they are zionists. Jews can be beautiful, peaceful and peace-loving, generous, kind souls. Not all jews are zionists, and you don't have to be a jew to be a zionist (says Biden!).
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
@@mickeydrennan1576 The organized cri[CENSORED]me syndicate known as îᛋřāёł is built on a religion (jûɖāïᛋm̃) and a socio-political platform (ƶïøṅïᛋm̃). Read the original complete versions of the Torah, Shulchan Aruch and Tanya to learn the truth about ra[CENSORED]cism in jûɖāïᛋm̃. Read Shulchan Aruch and Tanya: followers of jûɖāïᛋm̃ can lie if the lie helps protect their property and if the lie saves them from righteous non-Jewish law. Weren't these the same Orthodox Jews who sp[CENSORED]at on Christians, and aren't they the same Orthodox Jews who want to de[CENSORED]stroy the Al-Aqsa Mosque to rebuild their temple? ƶïøṅïᛋm̃ = socio-political ra[CENSORED]cism; jûɖāïᛋm̃ = religious ra[CENSORED]cism. jûɖāïᛋm̃ and ƶïøṅïᛋm̃ are two sides of the same coin.
@captainmajed2078
@captainmajed2078 Месяц назад
No they're not, there have always been sub-groups that misinterpret ideologies, and try to hijack ethno or religious groups. Us Arabs have been protesting the Palestine conflict for decades, if it wasn't for Jews like her, our struggle right now would be much harder, so we should be appreciative and celebrate those voices. Also, of course a religion that started thousands of years ago, has traditions, so that's nonsense. Zionism is a separate issue and we should not conflate the two. The same voices that want to be anti-semitic will turn on other identities, and we shouldn't allow them to fester. The world is too small for us to entrench ourselves in tribes.
@ernestolynch1926
@ernestolynch1926 Месяц назад
@@candelariadelazar4390 "Jews can be beautiful, peaceful and peace-loving, generous, kind souls. Not all jews are zionists" - I completely agree with you. However, this woman spoke about some “Jewish traditions,” and I am completely unaware of any “Jewish traditions” that are not associated with either Judaism or Zionism. If you know anything please enlighten me.
@stupidvideo101
@stupidvideo101 Месяц назад
I bet the algorithm tries to bury this. Let’s share and comment. Powerful interview, thank you Miss Zimmerman 🙏
@nigeljoseph5472
@nigeljoseph5472 Месяц назад
Such a courageous and compassionate woman! These people will save the world, if anyone can.
@zakiriibs
@zakiriibs Месяц назад
How much you donate to Israeli government?
@TheSwissPoliticalSystem
@TheSwissPoliticalSystem Месяц назад
Irrational comment.
@oang...3264
@oang...3264 Месяц назад
....👶🍼...SISTER..! U R DEFINATELY KIND HEARTED AND MORE BEAUTIFULL THAN ' THE ZIONIST IDF WONDER WOMAN'...WE LUV U SIS..! MAY GOD BLESS AND PRTECT YOU AND YOUR FAMILY...🙏👼🕊️❤️....
@leeroy2966
@leeroy2966 Месяц назад
🫡
Далее
OMG🤪 #tiktok #shorts #potapova_blog
00:50
Просмотров 11 млн
ЛИПЕР ДЛЯ ТЕЛЕФОНА 🤯
00:59
Просмотров 623 тыс.
Noam Chomsky - Why Does the U.S. Support Israel?
7:41