And yes true words ❤❤ some fans just jeallus and somt believe theyre so talented BTW BTW BTW heard of the jin military nurse thingy? (Ik off topic but yeahh)
I dont think so anyone doubted their live performance. If you are unsure they sing live, maybe parts of it were and part weren’t the percentage can go up and down. But when you see a live one, it’s clear.
I didn't know that was a mistake. I thought they did it on purpose. They somehow made their mistake make the song even better. That's true professionalism.
@@gragalakaisel1477 there was no vibrato.. what are you guys talking about 😭 she’s doing a run that’s not the same thing as vibrato. she is an incredible singer who has a tendency to strain and that’s ok to acknowledge! she strains a bit at the end of the 2nd high note and it sounds more like a screech because she loses control in comparison to the first which sounds fine. it’s not hate to acknowledge a fave of urs or mine can make mistakes, especially given the circumstances.
@@kpop_k the instrumentals makes it obviously that wasnt a mistake, since they doesnt even started to play. Then, listen carefully to the vocals, the notes arent even i in the same rhythm/notes. It wasnt a mistake!
@@kpop_k it wasn't. If they didn't sing that part, it would be a total silence since the music stopped for a few seconds. It's a festival version, isnt it? That wouldn't match the theme, if they kept quiet lol
@@luvvliaa2914 rosé is an average vocalist..it would have been considerable if you wrote 3ning/wendy/solar or some other names, but rosé is not a very good vocalist and please don't take this comment as hate, rosé is my bias wrecker and i am a die hard blink, but a fact is a fact...
It’s not a mistake, it’s a plan. If you notice that sullyoon is not doing it coz she knows or the staff already told her what lily and haewon will do in that performance plus the background music suddenly went out meaning they did it on purpose and thats why you notice that the highnote its kinda different or re-arrange from the original coz they literally did it on purpose just to tell everyone that they’re always live live.
@@almagazzaniga3293 The instrumentals makes it obviously that wasnt a mistake, since they doesnt even started to play. Then, listen carefully to the vocals, the notes arent even in the same rhythm/notes. It wasnt a mistake!
@@shahadmerani3116its part of the peformance, if it was a mistake then why did lily still do it. Beside the instrumental will look bad or boring if theres no vocal for like 3 seconds
@@kaito6103 ok so, to answer the first question, Lily had to do smthng to fix the mistake, The instrumental didn't sound bad cuz Lily filled the void and gave chance to Haewon to start over in the right moment.
@@sabrinnor i'm not talking about the group or the song, they're both awesome. i'm talking about this comment.. the goddamn jellybean flashbacks.. makes my blood boil
if you ever wonder what those vocal coaches mean by saying "they're not only singing together, but also listening to each other". this is what that means
@@Chaotic_jeans I believe the song is “Dice” by NMIXX. Be warned, it has a ton of switch ups and tempo changes that made the song get a lot of hate, but I personally loved it
The mistake was not Haewon's, the mistake was made by the sound manager, since the music stopped earlier, so Haewon had to go ahead with the note and Lily followed her, the two fixed the mistake professionally, but it wasn't theirs mistake. And there is no doubt that it was the best mistake because it sounded even more incredible. Anyway, Nmixx vocal queens✨️.
@@jiouri yeah i think so too because usually their mic get on when sound manager pull up the volume and its like 2-3 sec before the highnote probably the sound manager got lazy and turn on all nmixx member mic
@@roseflxower I’m not hating on her tf, all I said was there other people in groups that have a higher voice range and the “Golden voice of Korea” was already a title to someone else
For everyone believing it was a mistake, it wasnt. Sullyoon hurt her vocal cords due to the high note, and lily and haewon had to do her high note part. That was an intentional warm up so they don’t hurt their vocal cords too. (guys thank you sm for pointing out what a warm up is, i had no idea. maybe you should search up sarcasm next and tell me what you know about that too 💀💀)
You do warm ups before going on stage and they were literally singing before this part, it's nearly the end of the song, none of them were jumping straight into high notes
I dont understand how some people are saying this was a mistake and not planned because when they started singing during what everyone is calling the "mistake" the beat would have started anyways. Is nobody paying attention to the beat? Like it didn't start until *after* Haewon and Lily did their little mini notes at the beginning of the beat drop. If it was really not planned the beat would have started *immediately*, not with the random pause at the beginning.
no literally. i was scrolling through comments and I'm amazed has some of these people don't understand that they literally stopped the music so that lily and haewon could warm up their voices before singing because those notes are really high and to not strain them, they wanted to warm up a little. i completely agree with what your saying.
No. Its just the music stopped and haewon didn't let it slip and started right away and lily continued it...and when the music was on they both continued singing with the music..(I think)...idk it maybe wrong tho
If it was planned, I think they would’ve both started at the same time, but even if it wasn’t we all know they don’t need to lip sync with those INCREDIBLE VOCALS!!!! :)
