Aaron Rodgers' or Eli Manning's career? 🤔 C.J. Stroud kept his answer simple | Get Up 

Why do people never mention that Eli didn’t just win two championships - he helped pull off one of biggest upsets in sports history

Everyone knows and agrees that Rodgers is better than Eli and everyone knows and agrees that 2 rings is better than 1. Both of those things can coexist perfectly. Why do people act like they can’t?

Superbowls are team awards. Mvps tell more about how good a qb was

Note: The question of "Who had the better career" is not the same as "Who was the better QB?" Career wise, the argument can be made that Eli had it better because he beat Brady twice in the Super Bowl to Rodgers' one total championship. However, if we're talking who was the better QB, there is no real debate that can be made. At their peaks, Rodgers was better. He was more physically gifted, was more consistent in terms of accuracy and getting his team to the playoffs and had far more accolades than Eli if you pooled them all together. Eli has more rings, but Rodgers has his ring and 4 MVPs. Eli doesn't have one, nor was he ever considered best at his position in his era. Often times, in the early 10's, people at least considered Rodgers #1 over even BRADY. I never once saw Eli in that discussion. I can't even remember his name mentioned in top-5 rankings. That's not to say Eli was bad, but at their best, he wasn't close to Rodgers. At their best, it's Rodgers by a mile.

This is NO QUESTION ELi. I get the MVPS but that award is skewed to just Qb's anyway. There have been several years that a non QB should have won over A rod. These guys beat themselves up and go through all of this not for the KIA MVP but for the Lombardi!

Eli had two Superbowl mvps too

Theres only 13 QBs with multiple rings, true, but there are only two QBs with 4 MVPs or more and Rodgers is one of them.

You extend Jordon Love and it’s not even close Tua and Dak are walking mediocrity. Jordon at least has the potential to be a top ten guy

So i guess Trent Dilfer's career means more than Marino's

Why people dont speak to the fact that GreenBay defense averaged allowing 35+points per game in those championship games. Rodgers in his career playoff games has over 40 TDs and less than 15 INTs with over 100 QBR. The disrespect is insane for Rodgers. This logic that the most superbowls means your career was better is absurd. With this logic taking Trent Dilfer & Rob Johnson (who contributed dogshit to their teams winning games) careers over Marino makes sense....its completely idiotic. Thank you Foxworth for keeping it 💯

It's also worth pointing out that since because Rodgers is more polarizing and as a result of his political stances and opinions being made more public to everyone else that the answers to this question by some are going to be skewed more towards the other guy. All of a sudden,, for some, the answer is going to be Eli BECAUSE they don't like Rodgers, either as a person and/or his opinions. They won't compare on the field resumes.

Eli made historic runs..my boy is my favorite..🎉🎉

Not just the superbowls but all those playoff games on the road to get there both times. I think Aaron is the better QB by the numbers but Eli seemed to be the opposite of a regular season QB. He was a post season QB. The bigger the games the better he played.

When will the media put pressure on Josh Allen to *actually* win something instead of placing his name next to Mahomes.

Easily Rodgers. More all pros More MVP’s Better career stats Better per game stats

1:43 Most at stake, Mahomes????😭🤣🤣🤣

If rodgers never won a super bowl then sure give me eli. But rodgers won 1. N he got 4 mvp to show for. Easy rodgers.

I think people are twisting the question as always.. The question was who’s career would you rather have, not who’s better..CJ simply answered Eli because he won more rings..unless I’m missing the entire sound bite

I’m def a Giants homer but if you go back to those two super bowl runs. Eli played out of his mind in clutch moments. In 2016 when the giants had the number one defense. Eli was throwing darts in the play offs. Obj and shep going to miami and dropping everything was the reason we lost; our defense with eli’s play would have secured us a third sb. Even Coach Belicheck said he was only afraid of our giants team.

Shoutout gillie and wallo for making it this far iykyk

Aaron Rodger’s 4 MVPs have the same energy as Rudy Gobert’s 4 DPOYs

You guys are finally asking some important questions (regarding legacy). We really gotta iron out the criteria points for all-timers (instead of solely focusing on who's the GOAT). As far as Rodgers' Career vs. Manning's Career... it's a very close call. One guy's much more productive than the other guy; while ' _the other guy_ ' found much more glory. I'm leaning towards the Eli Manning career. It seems more enjoyable & worthwhile.

Love some respect for ELI Giant's Legend 💯

Without disrespecting Rodgers at all, this is exactly the question you should ask yourself alongside the Eli HOF argument. 1st ballot for sure.

Everyone loves pointing out how Eli beat Tom Brady twice in the SuperBowl but forget that in order to get to Brady Eli went into Lambeau Field both times when the Packers were the #1 seed in the NFC beating both Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers. So why wouldn't you want to be Eli who's in more rarified air as a two time SuperBowl winner.

Eli had 2 good years and those are the SB years, saying you’d rather have Eli’s career is saying you’d want Jimmy G over Matt Stafforf

I’d pick Eli. Because I’d want a Stroudcast to retire to.

I’ll take Aaron Rodgers. More money, 4 Time MVP Super Bowl and the King of the NFC North. Nobody sighed a breath of relief when Eli retired. Eli was carried by that ferocious defense that Locked down Brady and Moss

I’d understand this convo more if A-Rod never won but he did win, has 4 MVPs, and universally known as at worst a top 5 QB ever

People must of forgot bro took out GB twice on his too 2 Super Bowls

A top 5 Qb all time or a borderline hofer?

😂😂😂😂😂😂 dak are you kidding me this guy needs to stay off the weed😂😂😂

Why didn’t they do the Aaron and Stafford one too? CJ is clearly not an Aaron fan lol smh

I would not have traded eli for rogers in the prime..big blue for life..eli fan 4 life🎉🎉

Eli>>>>>>>aaron can’t spell ELITE without ELI

Eli’s 2 SB run is legendary stuff. Story will be told forever

Bruh mahomes doesn’t have anything at stake. He could have a completely down season and his career resume is still amazing.

How is mahomes the guy with most at stake lol Brady won his 4th ring 10 years after the third at that didn’t harm his legacy stop the bs

Can't spell elite without Eli. That being said, he was clutch when it counted, which is what counts the most. As for me, Drew Brees was my favorite QB, and I'd take his career over most.

Most people look at thing stat wise and realistically winning championships is the biggest statistics a qb can have while a wr could have 1700yrd and be considered the goat without championships

Rodger’s is considered one of the greatest ever and he played for one of the greatest franchises with great players and yet he only managed to have like a 50% playoff record and one Lombardi. That’s the very definition of underachievement in a team sport. Please!! The answer is the overachieving very ordinary Eli with his playoff record & 2 wins against the GOAT coach and QB.

Mahomes in the words of Coach Prime.” you should have got me last year “ because now with Worthy/ Brown get ready for the 3 peat. 🏆 🏆 🏆 I'm here for it. 📺 🍺

Eli was a Giant after his draft trade til retirement, so it'd be nice to see CJ a forever Texan.

Obviously Rodgers is better but being an NFL QB you have to go Eli since the ultimate team goal is winning multiple superbowls

Not to mention Eli barely missed a game cause of injuries

I don’t count team accomplishments as an individuals career. Stand on your own merits.

He’s not catching Brady 💀😂 he’s still trying to catch like 5 other dudes 😂

Dominique is so bias with his answers it’s ridiculous 13 total QB’s have 2 rings and you rather be in the bottom 5 percent because he has better numbers lol

I just like the fact Eli is getting talked about because nobody ever brings him up he beat who ppl deemed the Goat and I feel that’s something

Extend the oldest of those 3 QB's? Makes no sense. He's the last one I'd extend, no playoff success and will probably cost the most.

Finally some respect for my homie

Why don’t people never bring up the fact the Eli is 0-4 outside of his D holding team under 20 points . In them games he has more picks then TDS and fumbles.

As a Jet fan hope A Rod is listening.

Perfect answer. Arron had the better career but i want the Rings. Only 13 people in the world with 2

Eli without a doubt. He beat the GOAT twice. Rodgers was all about HIM hence the MVP'S in the regular season. Talent can only get you so much and the lack of drive, leadership, will is the reason why he only had made the SB once and was lucky to beat my Steelers.

Rodgers great regular season 4 mvp. Eli manning Clutched 2 Super Bowl MVP

Why is 30 year old Dak "young?" He isn't.

When your two rings come against the GOAT, that's the ultimate trump card imo. Those giants defenses set the table but he took them across the finish line. As erratic (To put it kindly) as the guy could be, his best days solidified a career many would beg to have. Wasn't always pretty, but it's memorable.

Definitely Manning because the two Super Bowls were against Tom Brady. I would almost take a career of someone who won less Super Bowls as long as the ones were against Tom Brady.

Omg Dak?😭😭😭😭😭 cmon

Whose career would you rather have.. Brad Johnson, Trent Dilfer, Jeff Hostetler or Dan Marino?

Ah yes, the three time super bowl MVP and two time MVP has the most at stake, gimme a break

So we taking Dilver over Marino smh

They just have to talk about Dak for no reason!

Patrick is exactly what they wanted Jonny Manzel to be

Also Eli is beloved almost everywhere. Rodgers not so much.

People also forgetting that in both of those Giants Super Bowl runs, Eli took out Rodgers and the packers on his way to get to Brady

Eli is a front runner. Just look at his career record. How many times did Eli make the playoffs?

Aaron Rogers has not had a better career than Eli Manning.

Every player on Boston Celtics is like James harden

Eli has 2 superbowl mvps...and he should have 3 rings if Plaxico didn't shoot himself when we were 11-1 in 2009

Eli had a more enjoyable career and after his playing days his career is continuing. Of course I’d pick Eli.

Jim Plunkett has 2 super bowls but nobody is dying to be him. I don't think if EIi won any other playoffs games other than those two super bowl runs. I believe he is just a .500 QB over all. Aaron has a Chip and 4 MVPs. Eli is not in Aaron's league as a QB talent.

From a better quarterback perspective, Rodgers>Eli. But every player dreams of winning a championship growing up and only few get to do so. Even fewer still win more than one. So I get what CJ is saying and I would take winning titles because I feel like I've accomplished something and I did it again instead of being settled with just one and four MVP's. I'll also say that it's a travesty that the Packers in a 30-year window had two of the greatest quarterbacks ever, but went to three Super Bowls and won twice. That's like the 90's Atlanta Braves. You can't be consistently among the best for that long and not win more than two in that stretch.

C.J. Stroud either hates Rodgers or he just flat out slow. Either way Rodgers going to embarrass him on TNF just watch 😂

Didn't Eli beat Rodgers multiple times en route to SB?

1:25 Patrick Mahomes? No way! The answer is Justin Fields. Fields is a stud who was NEVER given a fair chance in Chicago with the chaos, and he still showed many flashes of brilliance. Does Fields have things to improve? Yes! But he also had new offensive coordinators every year, horrible play calling, lack of Oline, lack of offensive players, etc. Fields is the most athletic QB in the NFL and he needs a fair opportunity.

Most to prove is Daniel Jones

With one superbowl Eli is not even in the hall of fame, he barely is with 2

This is so stupid because Rodgers is clearly the better player statically. Then to top it off. He hasn't retired 🤣🤣🤣 So he still has a chance to surpass Eli or tie with him in Superbowl wins.

So does this mean Joe Flacco is better than Dan Marino?

Give me A-Rod Career. He might win a ring with the Jets this year.

Put some respect on Eli name most qb’s would kill to have my boy career

Eli won 2 Super Bowl champs, all against Tom Brady. Simple enough that eli career is better than aaron rodgers.

All in all, Aaron Rodgers is the better QB but he absolutely should of won more.

This fool loves Dak😂

Ahh guess Stroud rather have Dilfer's career over Marino's

Stop with the rodgers disrespect im not a huge fan but quit it

Is Nick Foles a better QB than Dan Marino?😂 Winning SBs is a feat that is suited for Game Manager type QBs. Which Rodgers is not!

In my opinion. Attacking SAS for lack of advocacy for anything is crazy. When it comes to the numbers He is up there with the best for literally lifting others to stronger platforms, stronger self love, stronger generational growth. He is wrong pn many points, but There are receipts of SAS covering and shining the light on womens sports including the WNBA. Not his fault NCAAW kills the WNBA in coverage and interest.

I respect Eli but Jesus Christ Aaron is 1000000x bettter ….. How many QBs or nfl players have had 4 or more MVPs ……. 2!!!! Just Peyton and Aaron , Aaron got his ring that’s it he doesn’t need another to be the better career the 4 mvps n 4 all pros speak more volume than a second ring when you already have one on the finger.

Rodgers career and it’s not even that close.

AAron in the regular season, ELI in tbe playoffs all day. To the people saying iTs a Team GaMe, in rodgers only SB appearance he was carried hard by his defense, if his defense doesnt carry he doesnt win in the playoffs, shouldn't an all time "elite qb" do a little more to win games instead of always putting it on his teamates to close out games for him? his safe playing style works in the regular season and leads to a good td/int ratio, but in the playoffs when its win or go home, that cowardly playstyle rarely works.

Stroud had to say Eli to make it seem like he’s a team first guy, if he would had said Rodgers, it would seem like he cares more about his individual success more than team success, Arod is by far better than Eli, but as a young player and leader of a team he chose the right answer,

Eli all day!

If I have to pick Eli/Giants 2 Superbowls over Brady/🐐 / Patriots.🏆 🏆 and beating an undefeated Patriots team is better than Rodgers's statistics 📊. And 18 years with the Packers with 1 Super Bowl win. CJ is right and will get pushback from Rodgers' homers.!!

Aaron Rodger’s the most overrated qb of all time

Eli Manning beat the GOAT twice in the closing moments. Rodgers was carried by a defense that luckily were able to do enough to beat the Bears in the NFC Championship game. Give me Eli's career and legacy over Rodgers.

The NFL game has a BUNCH OF POLE DANCER'S AFTER SCORING A TD. WHO GETS PAID THE MOST FOR POLE DANCER'S LEAGUE. RECEIVER AND QB. RB DON'T GET DANCERS MONEY ANYMORE

😂😂😂He has to be doing this for the views lmao, he says it so confidently this is too funny.