Тёмный

ABBA-Shoulda been on THE VISITORS?- Review/Reaction 

Popcorn Philosopher
Подписаться 2,8 тыс.
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.
50% 1

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

 

3 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 72   
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Missed y’all❤! Here is my ABBA PARTy playlist! ru-vid.com/group/PLVaDWMlhe6SFje2D8LnNORUEyB2p0-VZ_ Including a Voulez-Vous Album deep dive, you might’ve missed ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-g4mVGwGIGmw.html si=bCepaioBNmAHV2ub
@robertschatz7781
@robertschatz7781 Месяц назад
I can never have enough of your reactions to ABBA. Please keep them coming!
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Thank you! I am the city is up next!
@robertschatz7781
@robertschatz7781 Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher I am looking forward to that one!
@alejandrosantanaborquez917
@alejandrosantanaborquez917 Месяц назад
Love ❤ Frida! Love ❤️🅰️🅱️🅱️🅰️! Great analysis and delivered in an entertaining way...doubly good 👌 Take care! Love ❤️ from Chile 🇨🇱🤗😘👍
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Thank you so much! I love Frida too, and this might be one of my favorite vocals from her! Also, I hope I get to go to Chile one day!
@carlosgarjon8340
@carlosgarjon8340 Месяц назад
This is one of my favourite ABBA songs, it's just perfection and it deserved a good place in The Visitors. Sometimes I don't understand Benny's perception of their songs.
@alexioverdo5225
@alexioverdo5225 Месяц назад
Neither do i.There were masterpieces that were 'left behind" such as 'One Man One woman" or even 'Move On" never been in any official ABBA GH collection neither in the MM films.Not to mention his objections on ''Just like That"....Hey Benny i won't forgive you but i'll love you forever.
@alexioverdo5225
@alexioverdo5225 Месяц назад
Side A had 4 songs.easily a fine A side closer right after 'Soldiers" simply ending the flow of the original tracklist order.
@christianoazzuro6711
@christianoazzuro6711 Месяц назад
@@alexioverdo5225 Since You've mentioned OMOW/MO.Let's not forget what happened to "If it wasn't for the nights".The single that never was.The track that never found some decent place in none of Abba's famous collections either.Could have easily been a double a sided single coupled with 'Chiquitita" at the time.Both excellent and diverse..
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
It’s super fascinating! I sort of see why he might think it is mismatching verse and chorus. But I think it works really well here!
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
@@alexioverdo5225 I’m thinking of doing the Elaine Paige demo possibly!
@Ianrob12
@Ianrob12 Месяц назад
This song deserved a single release in its own right. It's a more mature, adult pop ABBA. Definitely as worthy as the other A sides from The Visitors
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
If for no other reason, then I would’ve loved to see a MV of this!
@Ianrob12
@Ianrob12 Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher I concur! Frida's 'character' in the song is amazing, not to mention Frida's amazing vocals
@wayne_twentyfive
@wayne_twentyfive Месяц назад
Great to see you back, Io, and I totally enjoyed your analysis of this moody and thoughtful ABBA song .. Admittedly, it's one I haven't given much attention to in the past, but your breakdown of the various individual components shed some new light and appreciation of it for me .. Particularly how technically and emotionally powerful Frida's vocal is .. Thank you !
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Thank you I definitely missed doing this! Yeah, this is definitely shaping up to be one of my favorite Frida vocals. I think she was really feeling it when she recorded it. I wonder if she was disappointed it wasn’t on the album
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Oh, and I hope all is well with you!
@wayne_twentyfive
@wayne_twentyfive Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher Thanks, Io .. I'm going OK .. Could be a bit better in some areas, but overall I can't complain .. Definitely better for seeing your vids again.👍☺
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
@@wayne_twentyfive isn’t that just life though right! Me too! And Thank you!
@starmersbarber
@starmersbarber Месяц назад
Lovely to get some PP Abba angles again!
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Aw thank you! Good to be back!
@charliemctavishsmith9486
@charliemctavishsmith9486 Месяц назад
Love that you did this!!! Such an underrated song. Thanks for highlighting the musicians too :)
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
I totally agree. I can’t believe more people don’t talk about this song! The musicians particularly the rhythm section added so much!
@The_Jupiter2_Mission
@The_Jupiter2_Mission Месяц назад
Two For The Price Of One should have been ditched and Should I Laugh Or Cry should have replaced it on the album.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
I actually like Should I laugh, cry, better, but I sorta see why they put TFTPoO on instead.
@danielbaskins6601
@danielbaskins6601 Месяц назад
Always love when you do an ABBA vid. Pleeeeeease do a Super Trouper album vid I neeeeeed it
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Thank you! do really want to do that album! But I also kind of want to do something early on. Focus on stories earlier in their journey.IDK?
@danielbaskins6601
@danielbaskins6601 Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher hear me out. Both!!
@Lisa-M
@Lisa-M Месяц назад
Yaaay, finally 😃😍 Now you know why I wanted you to do a reaction to this one. 😁
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
@@Lisa-M you were right! Such a good song!
@Lisa-M
@Lisa-M Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher ☺👍
@petterhansson7312
@petterhansson7312 Месяц назад
Great reaction and analysis. Frida had done story-telling before: Fernando; Money, money, money; One man, one woman; I wonder (departure) to take a few. In her solo career before and during the ABBA period she did loads of songs that were stories and with very good narrative in the Swedish language (sorry not in English but none the less more than great!). You have to take my word for it, said the Swede! 😉
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
lol. I believe you! Yes her, storytelling is my favorite part of her vocal delivery after the texture of her voice. I’m working on a video about her solo album right now too:)
@kristianmapage9742
@kristianmapage9742 Месяц назад
Thx, The visitors album is one of the very first to be recorded, arranged and "transcribed" entirely digitally in their new studio. It is clean that benny and Michel tretow have experimented with the new capabilities of their equipment. Various effects are heard, vocoder without a dedicated device at the time via the mixer, we can hear it on "when all is said or done", a little more on, "Two for the price of one" and A lot present on, Under Attack. On some of the last tracks perhaps they also used an "autotune" effect, before its time.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Oh, maybe that’s the vocal thing I’m hearing ! I never thought about a vocoder. Their productions skills were so ahead of their time anyway!
@kristianmapage9742
@kristianmapage9742 Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher, If I understood you correctly, you are talking about resonance "echoes", as if they were singing it in a room with a high ceiling, a hall, a cathedral. without sound insulation materials
@JayneBangert
@JayneBangert Месяц назад
they are musicians unlike the crap that is churned out now
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
And this is really them at their absolute height of their greatness!
@carolhesterberg7526
@carolhesterberg7526 Месяц назад
I totally agree. Today's "music" is just plain annoying and not at all melodic IMHO.
@doomranger6047
@doomranger6047 Месяц назад
I really like how you broke down. I have an appreciation for this song now!
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
I know,, right! Thanks for watching!
@hovergrl
@hovergrl 23 дня назад
I liked your video very much. I think it’s a nice way to explain and deconstruct every aspect of the song.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher 23 дня назад
Thank you! I’m posting another song deconstruction today, actually. And an Abba one on the way!
@nielsulriksrensen9818
@nielsulriksrensen9818 Месяц назад
Another great reaction from you - thanks! I've always loved this song and felt so sad that it wasn't on the album. But you're right that it might have been too close to When All Is Said and Done in terms of structure, sound etc. And ABBA always made very heterogenous albums, a little of this and a little of that. They never stuck to one sound og concept. So even though each album had a certain ambience, they were always inconsistent in terms of style, themes etc. So, in that regard, it was a very ABBA thing to do to put Two for the Price of One on the Visitors in stead of Should I Laugh or Cry, which in my opinion is a far better song. Hearing Frida's vocals on this song isolated is a really wild and wonderful thing.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Thank you! I was hoping y’all were going to like me reacting to the stems isolated! I’m real curious about the other albums. The visitors fit together so well but yeah, each song was its own universe. Voulez-Vous was underrated, but definitely sounded more like a collection of songs.
@christopher3d475
@christopher3d475 Месяц назад
By the way, I love the Large Marge clip. When I was a teenager way back in the mid-80s when Big Adventure came out, I worked in a movie theater which played it. I used to love going in and watching the audience reaction during that part. Everything about Big Adventure is sheer 80s brilliance.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
That’s hilarious! I probably would’ve done that too! Kind of like how I like to watch people’s reaction to hereditary today. I might be a little sick lol. But I love. PW!BA!
@doomranger6047
@doomranger6047 Месяц назад
Ha I was in high school too when big adventure came out
@JamesGordon-ss8tm
@JamesGordon-ss8tm Месяц назад
😅
@certifiedquality6381
@certifiedquality6381 Месяц назад
Very nice video
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Hey certified thanks good to hear from you!
@6549Marci
@6549Marci Месяц назад
Love your ABBA videos. You're so creative and on point. I prefer this song on The Visitors album rather than Two For The Price Of One. It's not a bad song, but it's an unwanted distraction. Aside from Super Trouper, none of the 80s songs featuring Frida as lead vocalist were released as singles. Not even When All Is Said And Done. Just a little note: fix the names in the description before some fans call you ignorant. Unfortunately, there are plenty of those among us.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Thank you so much! I try, haha. Yeah, it really does seem half-and-half who prefer this song or not! Thanks for the name btw. I filled it out without my glasses on lol
@what-uc
@what-uc Месяц назад
11:38 Like the background brass in The Jacksons - Can you feel it?
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Oh I never thought of that!
@martinhumble
@martinhumble Месяц назад
It was only the picture disc edition One of Us where Should I laugh or cry that had the count in if I remember correctly. A great song, and well above You owe me one as a B side. And, the lyrics is typically ABBA grown up moodiness. Thanks
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Oh, I was wondering about that count in! I think it’s probably one of my favorite Frida vocal and Bjorn lyric!
@alexioverdo5225
@alexioverdo5225 Месяц назад
Well that's a rarity.This error exists only in a few copies pressed as far as i'm aware. Btw i also think that (at least lyricwise) SILOC's sequence was the Benny/Bjorn written song 'SLOWLY" that Frida recorded in 1984 but with Kristy Mc Coll instead of Agnetha since ABBA was over.Kristy did an excellent job in the backing vocals and her husband producer Steve Lillywhite did a fantastic production to the song made it sound like a respectful ABBA project.And ihmo far better than Gemini's version which i don't really connect despite being produced by B+B..Could have easily had a place in TV album if it was 3 years earlier.
@6549Marci
@6549Marci Месяц назад
@@alexioverdo5225 Although I love Frida, I prefer Gemini's version.
@alexioverdo5225
@alexioverdo5225 Месяц назад
@@6549Marci Hi Marci!So nice to hear from you! Well tastes can't always coincide,we all have our personal preferences,rightfully.It's human.😊Same goes for you....Gemini's i find it kinda 'cold" and "sharp-angled".Frida's feels warmer and more velvet to me. btw taking it a bit far from reality both 'Slowly" and 'Comfort Me" are tracks i fantasized being part/left out of 'TV" album.In my playlist to it i have excluded UOME and have stuck these 2some.(Just my twisted imagination,lol.)
@christopher3d475
@christopher3d475 Месяц назад
I'm in camp 'shoulda been on the album'. I've always felt that. I don't get Benny's assessment that it didn't have the same production values as the other Visitors songs. And yes, I think it could have easily replaced Two for the Price of One. Granted, that song kind of is a counter-balance to the darker tones of the Visitors, but it's also always been my least favorite of this collection. I think it's a brilliant song. It was eventually included as a 'bonus' track on a later remastered version of The Visitors which I think was a good idea. I also love You Owe Me One and I think that could have been included also.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
I think it’s a case of they had an embarrassment of riches. They were just so good at this later date. although it took a long time for people to realize.it it seems. You owe me one is one of my favorites too! It’s surprised me that so many people don’t like it
@Georgie_R
@Georgie_R Месяц назад
I absolutely adore the verses of this song.... but the 'chorus'/middle 8/whatever always feels quite misplaced (musically even more than lyrically) It takes a very abrupt turn from intriguingly melodic to somewhat cheesy, predictable and cliched. But that's just to my ears. Personally I feel 'Cassandra' is a much stronger B-Side track from that time frame.... although recorded after 'The Visitors' had been released possibly. And I'm really glad that Frida's vocals having been getting the recognition for so long now... after them being relegated to second to Agnetha's in many listeners during the 70's 80's and 1990s by mant people
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
So you agree with Benny ! I personally like Cassandra too ! Frida had gotten so good by this point! her vocals were so interesting
@Georgie_R
@Georgie_R Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher Erk... i suppose I do. But then I always felt Benny seemed more 'sonically involved' than Bjorn in creating the ABBA Sound. And while I adore Agnetha's voice, I always seem to appreciate the counter melodies that Frida provides in the A led tracks. The Difference in their voices is what makes ABBA.... (And to my ears some of the F led tracks still sound vocally 'fresh' and not defined to a particular decade performance technique/sound... god that makes me sound obsessive and pretentious!!!) I so respect that Frida was so lacking in ego that she never had a problem of Agnetha being favoured for the more 'Single Worthy' tracks... and actually preferred the freedom some more non conventional compositions gave in in finding new expressive ways to perform. Plus she never envied the OTT attention Agnetha got... and tried to be supportive when A felt low and depressed by how invasive it was At least from what I remember of Swedish Language interviews I read as a kid in the 80's when she was doing her solo stuff... (as well as older 70's magazines) which may be misremembered and sketchy after 4 decades!!!! 🤣 As you can guess-even as a Swede- becoming an ABBA fan in the 80's was seriously uncool!!!!
@mattias5157
@mattias5157 Месяц назад
This is the only downright bad ABBA-song that I know about.
@popcornphilosopher
@popcornphilosopher Месяц назад
Really you don’t like it? I was thinking it was very underrated.
@mattias5157
@mattias5157 Месяц назад
@@popcornphilosopher Yes. I think it´s a manhating song. I know it´s written by a man, but often when simping men supports feminists and a feminist agenda, it´s because they have stuff to hide. I guess that is the case. Imagine men sing like this about a woman!! Women would down right hang them, wouldn´t they? But I also think it´s a mess musically. It doesn´t go anywhere. t´s dressed up in a positve vibe, tut then the lyrics is a vomit. I think it´s a downright depressive song.
@mgbchoralmusic6443
@mgbchoralmusic6443 Месяц назад
I'm assuming you've never heard The King Kong song?
@mattias5157
@mattias5157 Месяц назад
@@mgbchoralmusic6443 That song is bad but at least not disgusting like this one. This one I can't even listen to. It's just bitter and hateful.
Далее
ABBA's FINAL Single For 40 YEARS *REACTION*
10:42
Просмотров 2,5 тыс.
Reaction To The Unknown World of Finnish Meme Music
19:53
У КОТЯТ ОТКРЫЛИСЬ ГЛАЗКИ#cat
00:26
КОГДА НАКРОШИЛ НА ПОЛ #shorts
00:19
Просмотров 855 тыс.
ABBA 45 Single "The Day Before You Came" REACTION
15:27
The Hidden Struggles Behind Carpenter's Iconic Album
31:55
A HIDDEN GEM! ABBA | I Let The Music Speak(REACTION)
11:50
ABBA Reaction! UNDER ATTACK!
16:28
Просмотров 903
ALL I CAN SAY IS WOW!!! ABBA | Visitors (REACTION)
14:03
Пикми
1:48
Просмотров 327 тыс.
Баяноммай (Svonedj Remix)
3:48
Просмотров 660 тыс.
Сигма Бой (Preview)
0:30
Просмотров 409 тыс.